10 Worst WWE Debuts Of The Decade (So Far)
Unfortunately, you never get a second chance to make a first impression.
Over the last decade, the WWE machine has seen a huge amount of talent emerge from its production line. However, like any production line, the results can often vary in quality.
From the meteoric rise of CM Punk to the disappointing fall of Mr Kennedy, with main event misfires like Wade Barrett in between, WWE has attempted to create hundreds of new personalities in recent years in their eternal pursuit of the next big thing.
While it's unrealistic to expect everyone to get over like Steve Austin or Daniel Bryan, certain acts seem snake bitten from the very beginning. Whether it was an awful gimmick that died the moment it was unveiled or a mid-match hiccup in their debut from which they never recovered, some stars are destined for a pink slip before they've even cashed their first cheque.
Nevertheless, poor debuts don't always spell the end of a career. Perseverance with a gimmick, subtle modifications, or an entire persona overhaul can all help spell success, if the talent is willing to adjust. Look no further than The Rock or Steve Austin for proof of just that.
Sadly, the kiss of death is a hard omen to shake and none of that will be much consolation for the contenders in this list.
10. Mike Kanellis
Despite having successful runs in both ROH and TNA, Mike Bennett was repackaged in unusual fashion in WWE. Debuting with a bizarre love gimmick at Money in the Bank 2017, the former 'Miracle' debuted alongside his real life wife and former WWE Diva, Maria Kanellis, under his wife's surname as Mike Kanellis.
Preaching about the "power of love", the power couple were presented as a cringe-inducing duo, consumed with their love for each other. Sadly, overt displays of affection have never gone down well in WWE... except for maybe the "live sex celebration" between Edge and Lita, but that's a whole other story.
Nevertheless, Kanellis made his in-ring debut against Sami Zayn, wearing tights adorned with hearts, kisses, and a cartoon image of his wife. Inevitably Maria got involved in order to save her man and the distraction allowed the newcomer to score the win.
Unfortunately, the gimmick scored very little crowd reaction before, during or after the match and Kanellis went on to suffer a string of losses after the fact, notably losing to Zayn on PPV, before being fed to Bobby Roode in his glorious SmackDown debut.
After a shaky start that was far from ideal, Bennett has his work cut out for him. Hopefully he can overcome the stumbling blocks of his initial few weeks and still reach his full potential in WWE.
9. The Vaudevillains
As The Vaudevillians, the team of Aiden English and Simon Gotch were one of the most entertaining acts in NXT. With 2015 proving to be their breakout year, the dastardly duo even captured the NXT Tag Team Championships at NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn.
With a unique gimmick, an unusual style and an overall presentation unlike anyone else, the two gentleman made the natural progression to the main roster in 2016 on the SmackDown after WrestleMania 32. Almost exactly one year later, the team were no more and Simon Gotch had been released.
After debuting to a bemused crowd in their first outing, it was clear that the blue brand's newest recruits faced an uphill battle outside the confines of NXT. On the larger stage of SmackDown, the audience wasn't entirely sold on the pair. Luckily, this was still during a time when SmackDown was pre-taped and the reaction could be modified in post-production.
Despite a planned victory in their PPV debut at Payback, The Vaudevillains' first outing on the big stage couldn't have gone any worse. Squaring off with Enzo and Cass, Amore suffered a legit concussion, which led to the premature stoppage of the bout.
After the PPV bout, the writing was already on the wall. A losing streak followed and their last appearance as a tandem came in the Andre Battle Royal at WrestleMania 33.
8. Lord Tensai
Matt Bloom has had several high profile runs in wrestling, under a number of different monikers. From Prince Albert to A-Train to Giant Bernard, Bloom has never been short on names. Nevertheless, each role has essentially been the same gimmick under a new title.
So when WWE began to run vignettes for a mysterious tattooed newcomer named Lord Tensai, few were surprised when it turned out to be the monstrous Bloom under yet another name - particularly after it was rumoured he had re-signed with the company several weeks earlier. Fresh from his last run in Japan, the bald brute was decked out in traditional Japanese warrior attire and given an Asian sounding entrance theme.
Flanked by his "follower" Sakamoto, WWE went all out to present him as big deal. Unfortunately, WWE fans have long term memories and chants of "Albert" and "A-Train" did nothing to help the new gimmick. Within two months, he had dropped the "Lord" prefix, lost the warrior-like entrance gear and, soon enough, even lost Sakamoto.
Tensai went on a losing streak, even having to wear lingerie on TV as part of a stipulation. Before long, he became a mid-card comedy act with Brodus Clay as Tons of Funk. Tensai changed his name yet again, to become Sweet T, before retiring at the end of 2013.
7. Mojo Rawley
A former Green Bay Packer and Arizona Cardinal, Dean Muhtadi had a legitimate athletic background when he joined NXT as Mojo Rawley. While it took him a while to grasp the sport of pro wrestling, the former NFL prospect worked hard to gain a following in WWE's feeder system and his energetic personality was undeniable.
After appearances on various NXT TakeOver events, Rawley eventually formed an alliance with Zack Ryder as The Hype Bros. However, Ryder returned to the main roster prior to WrestleMania 32, leaving Rawley in NXT without a partner.
Rawley was eventually called up to SmackDown, making his debut at Battleground by coming to the aid of his 'Hype Bro' who was amid a Rusev beatdown. The lacklustre pop proved indicative of what would follow and Rawley's first appearance on the main roster proved to be largely deflating for the NXT graduate.
Rawley lived up to his name and proved to be all hype when he reached the ring, opting to scream and shout at Rusev without throwing a single punch. 'The Bulgarian Brute' completely no sold the confrontation and looked more bemused than intimidated.
Mojo's first official in-ring appearance came on SmackDown two days later as a losing participant in a 14-Man Battle Royal.
6. The Shining Stars
It's a rare occasion when a new gimmick is considered a downgrade from that of two bullfighters with a costumed midget as their mascot. Nevertheless, that is exactly what happened when Primo and Epico Colon made the shift from Los Matadores to become The Shining Stars.
After several weeks of remarkably unremarkable vignettes, the Puerto Rico plugging partnership made their eventual re-debut with all the vigour of a drunken slug. The gimmick was dead on arrival and nobody in the crowd cared when the Colon brothers stepped through the curtain.
The fundamental problem came from the fact that the gimmick was flawed from the outset. Seemingly existing as an advert for tourism in Puerto Rico, the bizarre gimmick made little sense from a wrestling perspective. The promos awarded them no heel traits while also presenting no reason for them to be cheered outside of their homeland.
As further evidence of the complete lack of creativity behind the gimmick, The Shining Stars' finishing move was also inventively named 'The Shining Star'. If that alone doesn't show the half-assed effort put into this presentation, nothing will.
The fans had a hard time understanding the team's incentives and the Caribbean tandem was seriously lacking character depth. Within a year, the name was dropped and the brothers reverted back to being billed simply as The Colons.
5. Brodus Clay
Vince McMahon is like a jacked up version of Mr. Burns from The Simpsons. Both are rich and powerful businessmen, neither is averse to making questionable dealings to further their practice, and both exude an intimidating aura on all those beneath them.
Also much like Mr. Burns, Vince seems to have an almost schizophrenic change of heart at the drop of a hat, which can inherently effect the booking plans and career direction of the superstars themselves. One such example of this is Brodus Clay.
After finishing as runner-up of NXT Season 4, Clay made his main roster debut as Alberto Del Rio's bodyguard, which lasted less than two months. He was then taken off TV while he filmed a movie before he began reappearing on Superstars, squashing local jobbers.
Meanwhile, vignettes began to air on Raw, promoting the re-debut of Clay as a monster heel; this continued for some time as his start date was continuously delayed. In a complete surprise to everyone, when he did eventually resurface, gone was the hate-filled rhino that was promoted in the video packages - in his place stood 'The Funkasaurus'.
Strutting down the aisle to the recycled entrance theme of Ernest 'The Cat' Miller from 2004, Brodus Clay became a funk loving dancer. Despite going on a winning streak, the gimmick screamed "future endeavours" at first sight.
4. Sin Cara
Making his highly anticipated debut after weeks of hype and promotion, Sin Cara made his first appearance on Raw by confronting US Champion, Sheamus.
Billed as an "international sensation", expectation was high. Sadly, so was the top rope and the Mexican luchador stumbled over it during his entrance. The unfortunate slip up took away from what would have otherwise been a pretty cool arrival in WWE.
The slip up was the first of many botches for the former Mistico and Cara would barely make it over the ropes again the following week during his first official match. While the bumpy ring entrance could be overlooked, his literal fall from grace minutes later could not.
Squaring off with Primo Colon, the newcomer made a huge blunder when he botched the planned finish. In an attempted Spanish Fly (back flip uranage suplex off the top), Cara fell off the top turnbuckle during the execution, unceremoniously landing on the outside. Worse still, Cara totally no sold the effects of the fall, bringing even more attention to the botch.
The disastrous start to his WWE career proved to be a sign of things to come and the slip ups continued until his inevitable release. The Sin Cara character lives on today with Hunico under the hood full-time since 2014.
3. Emmalina
After what seemed like an eternity of vignettes plugging the reemergence of Emma under the new guise of Emmalina, the makeover was an intriguing curiosity for fans of the Aussie bombshell. The longer it was delayed, the more inquisitive people got and, after 17 weeks of hype, Emmalina finally appeared on Raw on 13 February 2017.
With a sultry saunter and a movie star look, the new character was supposed to be a throwback presentation to the successful divas of the past, such as Sable, relying on sex appeal as the foundation of the overall gimmick. However, plans allegedly changed after failed rehearsals led WWE to believe Emma wasn't committed enough to pull off the persona convincingly.
As such, the transformation of Emma to Emmalina finally came to fruition for all of 60 seconds, before WWE's newest diva announced she was "transforming" back to Emma. All in all, a pretty spectacular waste of 17 weeks worth of hype and promotion.
Nevertheless, after reverting back to her previous persona two months later, Emma has since gone on to become an increasingly prolific part of Raw's Women's Division, even challenging for the Women's Championship at No Mercy.
2. Johnny Curtis (AKA Fandango)
Before he became the ballroom brawler that is Fandango, the future 'Fashion Policeman' made his inauspicious WWE debut in one of the most bizarre, head-scratching segments in the history of wrestling.
On the 3 June 2011, NXT Season 3 winner, Johnny Curtis, stood in the SmackDown locker room, pretending to cry before pouring milk over his head. As debuts go, this made the worst Vince Russo segment seem like a soliloquy from Hamlet.
While some may point to the bizarre craze of "milking" as the inspiration for this stunt - a UK social media fad that involved people pouring milk over their heads - Curtis' debut actually pre-dates that, as milking became an internet sensation in mid/late 2012.
The hidden message beneath this udderly stupid (sorry) piece of booking was, in fact, the phrase "don't cry over spilled milk". Sadly, exactly 99.99% of the viewing audience didn't make the connection and the promo came off as confusing and extremely weird.
Most importantly, even if he had blatantly made the point of saying the phrase prior to pouring the milk over his head, the segment itself still wouldn't have achieved anything in regards to getting him over.
Luckily, Curtis soon re-debuted as Fandango in far more convincing fashion, defeating Chris Jericho at WrestleMania XXIX in his first match under the guise of the dancing superstar.
1. The Universal Championship Belt
The chorus of boos that greeted the unveiling of the Universal Championship was immediate proof that WWE had made a mammoth mistake when designing the red title belt. The centrepiece of WWE's flagship show, the title itself should have been the crown jewel of the entire promotion. Instead, it looked like something an eight year old would draw when they ran out of the right colours.
Uninspired, unoriginal, and straight up lazy, the decision to replicate the WWE Championship in a different colour was not a popular move. While it has since become an accepted trend - with each show's tag belts in particular alternating between red and blue - the unveiling of the Universal Championship at SummerSlam was far from the grand debut WWE were hoping for.
WWE have a rich history of championships and a good track record of creating attractive silverware. Sadly, this was not one of them and the results were rejected by the fans. What's worse, Raw's new plagiarised title was up for grabs that same night and the presence of the belt at ringside drew the ire of fans every time it was shown on screen. Not only did this take away from the excellent match between Seth Rollins and Finn Bálor that was on-going, but it also took away from the historical significance of the moment as well.