10 Worst WWE Hardcore Champions Of All Time

Sorry Maven, but you weren't ever cut out for the Hardcore divison!

Over the course of four years, the Hardcore Championship changed hands 240 different times. That should tell you everything you need to know about the quality of this division. To be fair, there were some legitimately terrific hardcore matches, and a few guys carried the title like pros. But for the most part, it was just a haphazard, silly little distraction from the real competition happening in the WWE. Maybe if they'd kept guys like Mick Foley involved (he was the first one to be awarded the belt, but only held it once before quickly ascending to main event status), the division would have stood a chance at legitimacy. As it happened, the division was sometimes fun to watch in a "Why are they still allowing this ridiculousness to be televised?" sort of way, but that was about the extent of it. Most diehard fans viewed it as a gimmick title, and a cheap attempt to cash in on the growing success of ECW. Here are the ground rules for this list: To cut out some of the riff-raff from that godawful 24/7 Rule, we'll only focus on actual wrestlers (sorry Terri and Godfather's Ho) that held the title for longer than a combined 24 hours (sorry Kurt Angle, Christian, Funaki, Hurricane, Mighty Molly, Jericho, Trish Stratus, Mean Street Posse, Booker T, Chris Nowinski, Thrasher, Viscera, K-Kwik, Perry Saturn, Johnny Stamboli, Tazz, William Regal, Spike Dudley, and Justin Credible).


10. Shawn Stasiak

I know I said I wasn't going to include anyone that held the title for less than a combined 24 hours, but Shawn Stasiak had the belt fifteen different times and still never occupied the spot for a full day! And that definitely earns him a spot on this list. Besides, Stasiak is such a glaring example of what was wrong with the 24/7 rule that an example must be made of him. WWE's creative team really fed Stasiak to the wolves during his multiple runs at the Hardcore Championship, continually finding new and more embarrassing ways for him to lose the belt. I suppose you have to give credit to the guy for sticking with it? ...Or not. That guy was never going to be believable as a hardcore champion because his wrestling style and look just wouldn't allow it. But hey, at least he provided some entertaining (often downright hilarious) segments during the hardcore craze.

9. Big Boss Man

Look, I don't want to put Big Boss Man on this list. But I need to put Big Boss Man on this list. Because I would be doing a great disservice if I didn't include at least one of the guys responsible for the Kennel From Hell match. And since Vince Russo never held the hardcore title and Al Snow is just too damn crazy/perfect for the hardcore environment, it has to be Boss Man. Ray Traylor was always a solid worker, dating back to his occasional feuds with Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage in the late 80s. He was nobody's idea of a stellar performer, and although he could generate a lot of heat from fans on the mic, he wasn't exactly Chris Jericho in terms of entertainment value. But again, he was fine. He was a surprisingly competent addition to the Hardcore division, too, honestly. Having a guy like that in the division (rather than only the crazy daredevil types) helped ground it just a little bit. Ironically, though, his move set became even more repetitious within the confines of the "anything goes" stipulations. And he participated in the Kennel From Hell match without bringing a mannequin head to the ring. Did I mention that?

8. Test

Unfortunately, Test earns a spot on this list by sheer virtue of being...Test. I won't go so far as to say that Test was a terrible Hardcore Champion, but he was certainly pretty far from the top of the list. He's one of those guys that you'd think might be able to benefit from the lack of structure these matches presented, but it really just gave him an excuse to focus more on throwing haymakers and substituting chair shots for any sense of story or drama. The worst example of Test's reign as champ was the extra sloppy, poorly improvised match against Gangrel on a 2000 episode of Smackdown. If you ever wondered how someone could suck all the fun out of a backstage brawl, just watch these two idiots drag each other around the venue, stopping occasionally to toss each other into various surfaces. (A wall! A piano! A phone booth! Another wall!)

7. Billy Gunn

Whereas his tag partner and other half of the New Age Outlaws completely immersed himself in the Hardcore division, helping to build the title up and try to make it actually mean something, Billy Gunn just never looked comfortable participating in these types of matches. Which is weird, because being a member of DX should automatically mean you're comfortable with bedlam and winning a match by any means possible. But Billy Gunn was always had the most straightforward wrestling style out of any DX constituent. It's easy to get the feeling that maybe Billy Gunn only held the title once because he just...didn't want it again. And since his title reign was so easily forgettable, that might not have been such a bad decision.

6. Goldust

The thing about Goldust in a hardcore match is that it's almost identical to Goldust in a regular match. He never took full advantage of the stipulations and had a tendency to only incorporate the bare minimum number of hardcore spots into his matches. His unimaginative use of the trashcan is what happens when WWE brass tells one of their performers before a match "Oh, hey, would you mind hitting him with something from underneath the ring tonight? Doesn't matter what it is or how you do it, just...do it. Cool?" He was clearly being pushed out of his comfort zone every time he worked a hardcore match. (Which says a lot, considering this was a man who came to the WWE as an androgynous S&M character obsessed with touching himself.) And although none of his matches suffered too much because of the stipulation, it certainly never elevated them, either.

5. British Bulldog

During his time as a Hardcore Champion, one thing became perfectly clear: This wasn't the Davey Boy Smith fans were accustomed to seeing with the Hart Foundation. And this was not a good thing. Bulldog flip-flopped between companies more than anyone else, and each time he returned to the WWE, he seemed to have lost a little something. (I suppose dealing with the politics of WCW will do that to a guy.) In his third return to the company, the jeans-wearing Bulldog had his sights set on the WWE Championship and began a feud with The Rock. But first he had to jump through some hoops for management, winning the Hardcore title from Big Boss Man. And then promptly forfeiting it to Al Snow later that night because this is what people thought of the Hardcore Championship. With that unsightly business out of the way, Davey Boy was free to pursue a legitimate title. But when nothing came of his feud with The Rock, he was right back to the mid-card and right back to the Hardcore division. He won the title once more from Crash Holly, then lost it the next week, then probably went to take a long, cold shower to wash away the ickiness of what he'd taken part in. Davey Boy obviously thought himself to be above this new title and although he may have been right, it certainly didn't make his matches any more entertaining.

4. Matt Hardy

Sorry, Matt. All the tables, ladders, chairs, trashcans, and kendo sticks in the world can't help you gain a small semblance of charisma. Matt Hardy was a walking blank slate for a very, very long time in the WWE, which overlapped his being the Hardcore Champion. And unlike say, Steve Blackman, people just weren't willing to excuse that fact. Mostly because unlike Blackman, Matt Hardy never put on too many exciting solo matches while he had that belt. His title match against Undertaker on Smackdown! was fine (because it's almost impossible to have a truly bad match with Taker), but he certainly didn't hold his own the way his brother Jeff did in that Raw ladder match with The Dead Man. Basically, he was a fine rag doll. If the whole point is for him to get destroyed in increasingly bizarre ways, then terrific! Give him a shot to the head with a kendo stick or toss him through some tables, just don't try to make him a believable offensive threat in the hardcore division. Not unless Jeff is also there. ...Also, I think we can all agree that Matt's overacting is a bit much, even for a guy who just got beaned in the face with a fire extinguisher.

3. Big Show

It's not that big guys can't be or shouldn't be Hardcore Champions (look at Kane and Bradshaw), it's just that they have to do more than throw stuff at people or throw people onto stuff. And Big Show could never quite wrap his head around that concept when he participated in no-holds-barred matches. And sometimes that was enough. (Someone has to be the one to choke slam a bitch through all of those tables, right?) But more often than not, Big Show wasn't a performer in a hardcore match so much as he was a prop. He was like a human forklift that was used when there wasn't a high enough surface for one of the lighter guys to jump off. Let Big Show lift em up and toss em down, then. Maybe have him do it onto a trashcan. That'll help. And he did an admirable job as a prop. But props don't deserve championships, even if the belt is pretty laughable to begin with.

2. Maven

You remember Maven, right? He was the first winner of Tough Enough and dropkicked his way through the WWE for a couple of years before ultimately, mercifully fading away for eternity. Now, there's a large section of the WWE fanbase who don't think he should have even won Tough Enough (that would be Josh Lomberger/Matthews), but hey, the guy had a good look and a pretty nice dropkick, so why not? And that's all well and good, but why does that guy get to become a three-time Hardcore Champion? Were they trying to sex-ify the division as a way to somehow get more females interested in Al Snow? Maven held the Hardcore Championship for longer than Mankind, Tommy Dreamer, or Jeff Hardy. Just think about that for a second. The guy who's finishing move was a dropkick held this title longer than The Hardcore Legend, the founder of House of Hardcore, and the guy who made ladder matches relevant again by actively trying to dismember his own body with Swanton Bombs. And he did it all while looking exactly like a guy who tried out to become a wrestler via reality TV competition and was thrust into the spotlight too early and was being relegated to the dumpster that was the hardcore division because he was still too green to carry a straightforward match.

1. Pat Patterson / Gerald Brisco

At one point in their careers, Pat Patterson and Gerald Brisco were legit wrestlers. Good ones, even. But once they became part of Mr. McMahon's entourage (under the flattering nickname The Stooges), they were no longer considered wrestlers. They were doofuses who embarrassed themselves on command, with drastically diminishing returns. Unlike most "joke" champions who dropped the title within about half an hour's time, Patterson and Brisco held the WWE Hardcore Championship a combined three times for a total of 33 days. That is exactly 32.9 days too long. If you don't believe me, you should be aware that, had these guys been forced into the list of other minutes-long champions, the world would have been spared the Pat Patterson vs. Gerald Brisco Hardcore Evening Gown Match. Both guys deserve to be on this list, as a tandem, if only because that is the worst thing to ever happen inside a wrestling ring between two grown men. ...And I'm including every match between Diesel and Mabel.

Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.