10 Worst WWE PPV Matches Of 2021 (So Far)

WWE promoted intergender madness, wonky gimmick matches and more during 2021's first half.

Randy Orton Vomit
WWE.com

Did anybody really care about January's Superstar Spectacle?

Some reading this might've forgotten that WWE promoted that particular Network special at the turn of the year at all, and that's no surprise - Spectacle doesn't feature on this list because it wasn't actually a proper pay-per-view. No, only Royal Rumble, Elimination Chamber, Fastlane, WrestleMania 37, WrestleMania Backlash and Hell In A Cell count as main roster PPVs here.

Generally, the standard has been fairly high. Bouts like the men's Rumble itself, Roman Reigns vs. Daniel Bryan vs. Edge at 'Mania and a thumping Reigns vs. Cesaro gem at Backlash would all make it onto any list looking at the best of 2021 thus far.

Then, there's the other end of the scale.

Admittedly, not all of the 10 matches featured here could be considered horrible. Some had merit or were largely inoffensive midcard battles, but that's besides the point; they qualify as the worst because WWE put on better. It's as simple as that.

As for a few others? Revisiting them will make you shudder and realise how utterly sh*te pro wrestling can be when everything goes wrong.

10. Rhea Ripley Vs. Charlotte Flair

WWE Hell In A Cell 2021 Charlotte Flair Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

Where: Hell In A Cell

Why It's Here: OK, so this singles bout from HIAC wasn't one of the worst offenders, but it's a nice starting point because of that. Plus, what was up with Charlotte Flair dominating 99.9% of the action and making reigning Raw Women's Champ Rhea Ripley look like some rookie who was in over her head?

Honestly, Rhea came across as a jobber more than anything, and that's not cool. WWE are doing a frankly terrible job of presenting Ripley as somebody casual fans should care about - HIAC didn't help that. Charlotte slapped Ripley around for 15 minutes, then Rhea got DQ'd and escaped with the belt by the skin of her teeth.

These women are capable of so much better, and they were knackered by WWE's match formatting here. Protecting Flair is fine. Making the champion look like she's totally out of her depth, meanwhile, just isn't.


9. Braun Strowman Vs. Shane McMahon

Braun Strowman Shane McMahon WrestleMania 37
WWE.com

Where: WrestleMania 37

Why It's Here: Shane McMahon's big bump quota was met for the year here.

That was it - that was literally the only point to promoting Shane-O vs. Braun Strowman inside a cage at WrestleMania. WWE wanted the 'Boy Wonder' to perform his death-defying fall, and they thought that pushing Braun as somebody brave enough to overcome lifelong bullying about being "stupid" was wise.

They thought wrong, to be honest. This was one of those gimmicky bouts that's forgotten about as soon as it finishes, and it did nothing for Strowman. Forget the fact that he was released from contract a few months later, because the big man was dead as a character as soon as WWE had him whine about poor school grades.

The build towards this caged encounter was flat out dire. Shane dumped green paint all over Braun, and he spent weeks stumbling his way through awkward promo after awkward promo about how thick the giant was. That...wasn't very thrilling, and the blowoff match didn't make up for it.


8. Women’s Tag-Team Titles

Reginald Bianca Belair Sasha Banks
WWE.com

Where: Elimination Chamber

Why It's Here: It's incredible to think that this happened twice.

Bianca Belair's post-Royal Rumble momentum came to a screeching halt when somebody in creative popped up a hand and said, 'Hey, maybe she should team with 'Mania rival Sasha Banks for a few months'. WWE put Belair and Sasha together in time for Elimination Chamber and had them gun for the Women's Tag belts.

The champs? Nia Jax and Shayna Baszler. You may see more than one fatal flaw to this direction. Nobody wanted to see future WrestleMania headliners prep for their showdown by temporarily playing good buddies, and few genuinely believed they'd take the titles from Nia and Shayna anyway.

One match was enough, but the company repeated their trick at Fastlane. That, upon closer inspection, was the better match of the pair. Both ran around 10 minutes, but the Chamber battle somehow felt like it lasted 87 years.


7. Big E Vs. Apollo Crew

Big E Apollo Crews Fastlane 2021
WWE.com

Where: Fastlane

Why It's Here: Credit to Big E and Apollo Crews for working diligently to make their SmackDown brawls engaging, but they've been up against it due to some wonky booking. Problems began at Fastlane when E dispatched Crews (who was reborn as a quasi-Nigerian prince) in just five minutes.

The New Day man barely broke sweat, and that left Apollo cold. He's since rallied to become Intercontinental Champ (more on that later) - however, yeah, this 21 Match collision didn't live up to some nifty build that saw Crews belt E around the ThunderDome with some handy steel steps.

Their first pay-per-view match was weaker than a kitten's p*ss, and things didn't get much better from there. Oh yes, WWE had another "treat" in store that was supposed to even the score and make Crews look like a much bigger threat.

Did it succeed? Did it hell, and that's why the next match on this list is as follows.


6. Nigerian Drum Fight

Apollo Crews Big E Nigerian Drum Fight WWE WrestleMania 37
WWE.com

Where: WrestleMania 37

Why It's Here: Mystique can be good, but it didn't work for WWE's "Nigerian Drum Fight". Nobody stopped to explain exactly what the "Drum Fight" would entail before 'Mania 37, and that left SmackDown's announcers scrambling to come up with ways to hype the violence fans could expect.

In the end, WWE stacked some djembe drums around ringside and Big E vs. Apollo Crews II turned into a standard hardcore/no DQ effort. Again, they were asked to create something special with a quite ridiculous lack of time on their side; this second scrap lasted just shy of seven mins, and that wasn't nearly enough.

The drum gimmick was a misnomer too. E and Crews barely used the djembes as weapons, and instead went to town on one another with kendo sticks. This was one of those concepts that was better on paper or inside someone's head than in execution.

Don't expect to see a WWE Nigerian Drum Fight pay-per-view any time soon.


5. Bray Wyatt Vs. Randy Orton

Bray Wyatt Fiend Randy Orton
WWE.com

Where: WrestleMania 37

Why It's Here: This writer is a huge fan of Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend', but only a liar would say that the character has many good matches. In fairness, that's not his main purpose (selling merch and being scary and/or compelling is). Even so, his 'Mania match with Randy Orton was...well, it was.

Christ knows why WWE decided to kick off the pay-per-view's second night with a six-minute stall fest that went heavy on "sports entertainment" tropes over proper pro wrestling. Though Wyatt, Randy Orton and Alexa Bliss tried to make the best of things, their B-movie drama didn't elicit a mega response from the live crowd in Tampa either.

That pesky red light returned, and WWE booked Bliss to turn on her 'Fiendish' pal. That'd lead to more subpar shenanigans later on (stay tuned for that). Seeing this opener once was enough - there's no reason to revisit it for another look.


4. Braun Strowman Vs. Elias

Braun Strowman Elias Jaxson Ryker Fastlane 2021
WWE.com

Where: Fastlane

Why It's Here: Braun Strowman is lucky that he didn't quite reach the unwanted status of 'Worst WWE Wrestler Of 2021 (So Far)' before being released. Poor old Elias did strum his way onto that list though, and deservedly so. He acted as a last-minute replacement for an "injured" Shane McMahon at Fastlane, and it was rubbish.

Strowman squashed Eli in less than four minutes as everybody watching at home wondered why this was on pay-per-view at all. Bait and switch tactics are part and parcel of wrestling's gimmicky nature (card subject to change and all that), but WWE went overboard with promotions for Shane vs. Braun before the show then produced this guff.

Sigh.

It was a waste of 240 seconds. Braun bounced Elias around, the announcers pretended he was some unstoppable monster instead of a put-upon, bullied thicko of a giant, and WWE fans knew they'd have to suffer through more McMahon vs. Strowman build before 'Mania 37.


3. Alexa Bliss Vs. Randy Orton

Alexa Bliss Bray Wyatt Fiend Randy Orton
WWE.com

Where: Fastlane

Why It's Here: There's nothing wrong with intergender matches if they're promoted correctly, although it is understandable when some (*cough* Jim Ross *cough*) view them as far-fetched or best-avoided. WWE went for shock value before Fastlane by announcing that Randy Orton would battle Alexa Bliss.

Everybody knew Randall wouldn't be blasting Alexa with draping DDTs, RKOs or power slams, and those same folks probs realised that this was all designed to prolong Orton's interminable feud with Bray Wyatt that was examined earlier. It was exactly that - Wyatt (the crispy version, at least) returned after several minutes of stalling and stunts to cost Randy the match and give Bliss the win.

The insinuation that Alexa controlled her chargrilled monster was clear, and yet everybody wondered aloud where WWE would go next. The answer? A magically-restored 'Fiend' returned on Raw 24 hours later and set up one more match with Orton at WrestleMania.

The intergender dealio was more angle than match.


2. Alexa Bliss Vs. Shayna Baszler

Alexa Bliss Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

Where: Hell In A Cell

Why It's Here: Shayna Baszler has had a miserable time on the "main roster".

Since being called up from NXT to Raw, Shayna has been a vampire, Nia Jax' rival, Nia Jax' pal and somebody who sh*ts it from dolls. Who knew that Baszler's MMA opponents and NXT enemies just had to bring "Lilly" to the party and watch as Shayna was spotted running for the hills?

Alexa Bliss vs. Baszler at Hell In A Cell was yet another stallfest from the former, and it didn't do much to sell Shayna as an eventual singles star who could credibly go after the Raw Women's Title. The constant involvement of Jax and Reginald only made the bout more excruciating to watch too.

Bliss suddenly developed mind control powers (to go along with telekinesis and the ability to control pyrotechnics) so she could use Nia and Reggie as distractions. None of this worked, and it only made one yearn for the good old days of Baszler vs. Io Shirai.


1. The Miz Vs. Damian Priest

The Miz
WWE

Where: WrestleMania Backlash

Why It's Here: Zombies.

It was tempting to write that one word and leave it there, but no - a little more detail is required to properly explain the agony of what happened at 'Mania Backlash. WWE cross-promoted Batista's new 'Army Of The Dead' movie by scripting zombies as lumberjacks for The Miz vs. Damian Priest.

That's one hell of a sentence. Scotty 2 Hotty and a bunch of other extras dressed up in their finest undead gear to wander around ringside salivating at the thought of sinking teeth into tasty wrestler flesh, and it was as atrocious as that sounds.

By the end, Hotty and pals had eaten Miz alive. That, naturally, led to Miz reappearing unharmed (aside from an ACL injury) and squirting John Morrison's "drip stick" onto opponents. WWE's product is some laugh sometimes, eh?

ZOMBIES!

What other matches belong here? For more WWE, check out 10 Things We Learned From Mick Foley On Stone Cold’s Broken Skull Sessions Podcast and 18 Things You Probably Missed From WWE SmackDown (July 2)!


In this post: 
Randy Orton
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.