10 Worst WWE PPVS Of The 2000s

Some duds courtesy of the much-vaunted Attitude and Ruthless Aggression eras...

We've been subject to some pretty damn awful WWE PPVs lately, it must be said. Just a few short months ago, the 2015 Survivor Series made a great many fans want to throw their TV out the window as they rushed to Twitter to tell their fellow WWE Universe members that they were cancelling their WWE Network subscription right now, never to re-sub again... Those fans really ought to get a bit of perspective, and could do so by having a look at some of the totally piss-poor supercards that fans were 'treated' to between 2000-2009. Yes, during both the much-vaunted Attitude and Ruthless Aggression eras, Vince McMahon and company put on some shows that were something rather less than stellar. Yes, during that ten year period WWE did put on some of the best pay-per-views the wrestling business has ever seen (here's looking at you, WrestleMania X-Seven) and they certainly had a stacked roster full of talent for most of that time. But a combination of dodgy booking, performers not turning up and some matches of the 'bowling shoe' variety meant that, every now and again, a show would leave a bad taste in the mouth. It wasn't all thrilling main events with Steve Austin, The Rock, Triple H, Kurt Angle and Brock Lesnar et al. We couldn't all rush to social media back then to get #CancelWWENetwork trending, but we certainly weren't ready to order a replay or a DVD of this lot...


10. King Of The Ring 2002

Why It Sucked WWE had so much talent to work for this show as the roster was positively loaded at the time. Triple H, The Undertaker, The Rock, Eddie Guerrero, Ric Flair, Brock Lesnar, Chris Jericho, Rob Van Dam, Kurt Angle Hulk Hogan... Pretty ridiculous, huh? Sadly, the always-anticipated King of the Ring turned out to be a dud this year. The tournament itself was nothing to write home about and it was pretty obvious that Lesnar was walking away as King. The cruiserweight title match between Hurricane and Jamie Noble was decent but nothing more. Ditto the five-minute Trish Stratus versus Molly Holly Women's Championship match, a bout built around Molly supposedly having a big bottom. Yes, really. Hulk Hogan versus Kurt Angle was praised at the time but after watching it back it's standard Hogan formula stuff and a bit of a waste of our favourite Olympic gold medalist, to be honest. Eddie Guerrero and Ric Flair never really seemed to find their groove in their match, which is surprising considering the vast talents of both men. Then there was the main event, an Undisputed Heavyweight Title match between Triple H and The Undertaker which was absolutely nothing like the scorchers they'd have in later years. It was a lethargic, overlong brawl with an overbooked finish. Avoid. Did Anything Redeem It? The Y2J vs. RVD opener was good, but not as good as Jericho claimed it was at the time. Infuriated that online critics hadn't universally awarded the bout five stars, he penned a venomous letter to the 'smarks' published via his website where he questioned the merit of the reviewers and suggested that if they didn't think the bout was amazing that they should take up bowling instead. Claws, Chris!

9. Judgement Day 2003

Why it Sucked The last of the dual-branded shows before Raw and Smackdown would start promoting single-brand PPVs (outside of the 'big four'), Judgement Day 2003 would have been a disappointment had anyone actually thought the presented card had the potential to be good. The show kicked off in underwhelming fashion, with a sub-three minute FBI versus Chris Benoit, Spanky and Rhyno six-man. That's thirty seconds per wrestler, just about. Following that was another rubbish tag match, between Scott Steiner and Test and the debuting La Resistance. WWE brought back the Intercontinental Title for this show (after Triple H essentially retired it in October 2002). With an awesome, 16-man tournament, you ask? Nope, with a tame 9-man battle royal, actually. Christian won, in case you were wondering (you weren't). After that the crowd needed perking up so WWE wheeled out Torrie Wilson and Sable for a bikini contest that took about fifteen minutes. On PPV. At least Jerry Lawler seemed to enjoy it. There was only way to follow that doozy: Mr. America versus Rowdy Roddy Piper in a five minute match, brother! Vince, the well was truly dry in WCW back in 96, mate. Speaking of the well being dry, how about that Kevin Nash? He was here, having a really sh*tty seven minute World Heavyweight Title match with Triple H. Did Anything Redeem It? The main event WWE Title Stretcher Match between Big Show and Brock Lesnar was fun, in a goofy kind of way and Eddie Guerrero and Tajiri (subbing for an injured Chavo) versus World's Greatest in a Tag Team Tag Team Title Ladder Match was fun, but neither of those matches were getting much higher than three stars.

8. The Great American Bash 2005

Why It Sucked Smackdown was very much perceived as the 'B' show in the mid-2000s, by both fans and those internally within WWE. Despite having a roster full of talent, it just never received the attention it probably deserved. The blue brand's major shows were often full of filler and inconsequential matches, which obviously didn't help them either critically or commercially. Just a few weeks before the 2005 Great American Bash, the Raw lot had produced the thrilling Vengeance, a show which was roundly praised as one of the best of the year. The Bash, like its 2004 predecessor (more on that soon) was panned by pretty much everyone, as fans and critics found fault with the in-ring action and storyline developments. The biggest offended was the Undertaker versus Muhammad Hassan contest, of which much has already been written about. The match, Hassan's last, was a washout and had the stench of the terrorism-inspired angle clinging to it. Then you had a lousy Batista versus JBL main event, where it was clear the Texan wasn't pulling his weight. A poor start to Batista's Smackdown career. Further down the card you had bouts ranging from the mediocre (Benoit/Orlando Jordan & Christian/Booker T) to the downright offensive, such as the bWo versus Mexicools six-man and the 'new' Legion of Doom (Heidenreich & Animal) winning the WWE Tag Team Titles from the awesome MNM. Why? To cash-in on the release of the new Road Warriors DVD, of course! Just the worst. Did Anything Redeem It? Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero delivered a solid match, as they invariably always did, but it was hampered by a less-than-stellar crowd response and the whole 'Eddie's secret' storyline. As good as the action was, it wasn't good enough to save this stinker of a show.

7. Judgement Day 2004

Why It Sucked This show perfectly illustrated just how thin the Smackdown roster was back in 2004. Guys who just a year or two ago wouldn't have been near a pay-per-view were now in prominent positions, challenging for titles. Case in point, the thrown-together veteran tag team of Hardcore Holly and Billy Gunn, who lost a WWE Tag Title match to the odd couple of Charlie Haas and Rico. It was a throwaway match, like a lot of the matches on this particular card. Holly and Gunn (and to a lesser extent Haas and Rico) were given ten minutes of PPV and didn't do a whole lot with it. Future WWE Hall of Famer Jacqueline, who had done pretty much nothing on WWE TV in the past couple of years, was thrown a bone by creative and given a shot at Chavo Guerrero's Cruiserweight Title. It was a token gesture (Jackie was released soon after) and the match, for which Chavo had one arm tied behind his back, was a waste of Eddie's nephew's time. Torrie Wilson versus Dawn Marie No.4,795 was rubbish. Dawn's pants fell down at the end, which was the undoubted high spot of the affair. And newcomer Mordecai squashed Scotty 2 Hotty because reasons. Big Mord would be shipped off back to developmental in a couple of months, too. Last but not least, how about that Booker T versus Undertaker match? Both great workers, both given terrible creative and putting on a slow and dull match. What a disappointment. Did Anything Redeem It? I personally rather enjoy the Eddie Guerrero versus JBL blood bath main event, although there are a lot of people who don't. And the opener between RVD & Rey Mysterio and The Dudley Boyz was fine. Not enough to stop this being one of the poorest supercards of the decade, mind.

6. New Year's Revolution 2005

Why It Sucked New Year's Revolution always sucked, didn't it? The 2005 version of the event was probably the worst of the lot, though. It featured one of the most staggeringly bad undercards of any WWE PPV anywhere, with average matches and unfortunate injuries meaning the first two hours of this show was a chore to sit through. First, the opener. The World Tag Team Title match, with Christian & Tomko challenging the odd couple duo of William Regal & Eugene, certainly had crowd heat (the crowd were hot all show, bless them), but it was nothing more than your standard house show match before Eugene landed badly while performing a dropkick and ruptured his patella tendon. Eugene was benched for close to half the year. The second match also featured a serious injury, suffered by Lita as she attempted a Thesz press off the apron in her Women's Title match with Trish Stratus. The flame-haired diva tore her ACL and the match had to be ended after just a few minutes. Double crumbs. Injuries didn't mar the third match - if you can even call it a match, that is. Shelton Benjamin defeated Maven twice in about eight seconds after the Tough Enough winner cut a promo in what was an absolute shambles. What the f*** was going on here? And what the f*** was going on in the next match between Muhammad Hassan and Jerry Lawler? Now, I'm a Lawler mark and everything (shame on you if you're not), but who gave him and the greenhorn ten whole minutes of PPV time to play with? Hassan wasn't ready for that and Lawler wasn't the man to carry him at this point. The action was awful and it almost killed Hassan off before he even got started. Did Anything Redeem It? The (vacant) World Heavyweight Title Elimination Chamber main event (Benoit, Jericho, Batista, Triple H, Kane and Edge with Shawn Michaels as the guest referee) was great, but it couldn't make up for an undercard where Kane versus Gene freakin' Snitsky was the most exciting match. The show under-ran by about twenty minutes and Triple H won the World Title back, having never lost it. Haha. Good one.

5. Unforgiven 2003

Why It Sucked The matches that were always going to suck, did, and the matches that looked good on paper, were poor in practice. Unforgiven 2003 was a deeply dissatisfying show with a feel-good main event moment that came a month too late and an undercard that was far from inspired. The first match, a handicap Tables Match for the World Tag Team Titles, was average. The Dudley Boyz beat La Resistance for their seventeenth tag titles on the night. No wonder they were getting stale back then. Following that was another in the seemingly endless series between Scott Steiner and Test. Like the previous 462 matches, it wasn't very good. At least Scott didn't trip off the ring apron this time. Lita made her return from a year out with a broken neck, tagging with Trish Stratus to take on Molly Holly and Gail Kim. It was okay. Following that we got Shane McMahon and Kane re-enacting the Friday the 13th films in a fun and cheesy Last Man Standing match. Good if you like that sort of thing and one of the best matches on the card, but that's hardly saying match. You'd think a triple threat featuring Christian, Rob Van Dam and Chris Jericho would be really good, wouldn't you? You'd be wrong. Their effort here was so-so and way long (it lasted almost twenty minutes). It was still better than Jim Ross and Jerry Lawler versus Al Snow and Jonathan Coachman which followed it, though. Nine minutes of PPV time WWE will never get back, that. And finally you had Triple H versus Goldberg, the match that should have headlined SummerSlam...before Triple H suffered a groin injury. Like most of Goldberg's WWE matches it was a bit weird, with Goldberg forced to sell for long periods and work Triple H's type of match. Watching this back, it's really no surprise Goldberg didn't last long in WWE. Did Anything Redeem It? Shawn Michaels and Randy Orton had a nifty midcard tussle. They'd have far better ones in later years, though, and it doesn't quite make this PPV worth watching.

4. King Of The Ring 2000

Why It Sucked Another edition of the King of the Ring, this one made the 2002 version of the event look like WrestleMania X-Seven in comparison! Considering the talent that WWE had at their disposal at this time, this really should have been so much better. It should not have featured OAPs Gerald Brisco and Pat Patterson in a 'Hardcore Evening Gown Match'. Minus five stars. The tournament itself also wasn't very good, with the limited Rikishi given the nod to make it to the finals above the likes of Chris Benoit and Eddie Guerrero. Latino Heat and Val Venis had the best pure wrestling match of the night, and that was only average. A Dudley Boyz versus DX (Road Dogg, X-Pac and Tori) Dumpster/Tables match wasn't as exciting as it probably sounds on paper. In fact, the Duds' table-breaking antics were already starting to feel a little played-out at this time. As for the DX boys, well their schtick was beyond stale. The main event should have been Attitude Era goofiness at its best but it just turned into a major letdown. The six-man tag was undoubtedly hampered by a dodgy stipulation (whoever gets the pin wins the WWF Title), but the action itself was nothing to write home about. Amazing to think a match featuring Kane, The Undertaker, The Rock, Triple H, Shane and Vince McMahon could be so...poor. Did Anything Redeem It? Not at all. The KOTR tournament was a huge disappointment and the other big matches didn't exactly set hearts racing, either. This is a notable misstep during one of the company's hottest ever periods.

3. Armageddon 2004

Why It Sucked Lots of reasons. Tough Enough Kids Mike 'The Miz' Mizanin versus Daniel Puder in a boxing match? Funaki versus Spike Dudley? Charlie Haas and Hardcore Holly versus The Basham Brothers? Dawn Marie versus Jackie Gayda? John Cena versus, erm, Jesus? Kurt Angle versus freakin' Santa Claus? Okay, that last one was pretty entertaining, but most of those matches were just so 'meh'. They were matches you'd expect to see on Smackdown. Some of them wouldn't look out of place on Velocity. Quite frankly, they belonged on the little-seen weekend show and shouldn't have been anywhere near a PPV. Yes, this was as crappy as you could get. There's some talent there, but they either weren't over enough or won't being used properly on this show. Did Anything Redeem It? There were, admittedly, a couple of decent matches but they couldn't quite make up for the pitiful undercard. Rob Van Dam and Rey Mysterio's Tag Team Title defence against Rene Dupree and Kenzo Suzuki was decent and the four-way WWE Title main event, which was JBL defend against The Undertaker, Eddie Guerrero and Booker T, certainly had its moments. So it was bookended by two good matches but, as an overall show, though, this wasn't worth yours, mine, anyone's time.

2. The Great American Bash 2004

Why It Sucked Another Smackdown effort form 2004, that years Great American Bash has went down in infamy as one of the crappest WWE cards ever. Featuring some utterly worthless matches on the undercard, a very unpopular WWE Title change and one of the weirdest main events ever, this one caused some to seriously reconsider whether the brand split was such a good idea or not. Okay, so the undercard. Luther Reigns versus Charlie Haas...Kenzo Suzuki versus Billy Gunn...Sable versus Torrie Wilson...Mordecai versus Hardcore Holly...yup, you'd be pretty gutted if you saw that lineup at a house show, wouldn't you? But being asked to spend your hard-earned money on it? No wonder this event did a woeful buyrate! Throw in JBL dethroning the super-over Eddie Guerrero and becoming WWE Champion and the Undertaker/Paul Bearer nonsense in the main event and, well, yeah, you've got a really poor show on your hands. Yes, JBL and Eddie Guerrero's Bullrope Match was inventive and exciting, but the result put a black mark on the bout. There was nothing good about the 'Concrete Crypt' main event, which saw The Undertaker battling the Dudley Boys in a lethargic handicap match, all while Paul Bearer was sitting in a box and being threatened death by cement. You couldn't help but roll your eyes. Was this 1994 or 2004? Did Anything Redeem It? The WWE Title match is good, true, and Rey Mysterio and Chavo Guerrero had a tidy Cruiserweight Title match. Not good enough to elevate the show, though. The 238k order number said it all.

1. December To Dismember 2006

Why It Sucked Where do you even start with this one? Just well and truly awful, pretty much from top to bottom, the show was so bad that it caused Paul Heyman's WWE departure (he claims that his creative direction for the show was far different from what the finished product turned out to be). So what were viewers treated to courtesy of this wrestling train wreck? Seven minutes of Balls Mahoney versus Matt Striker, which was at least four minutes too long. Elijah Burke and Sylvester Terkay (remember them?) rumbling with the FBI. Uninspired isn't even the word. Then you've got Daivari versus Tommy Dreamer. For some reason. I'm sure... Okay, so that's a pretty damn useless three consecutive matches right there. And then, THEN, out come Kevin Thorn and Ariel for a mixed tag match with Mike 'Who?' Knox and Kelly 'Kelly Kelly' Kelly. If you ever decide that you actually hate a loved one, you should fire up the WWE Network and make them watch all eight minutes of this. The 'Extreme' Elimination Chamber main event (weapons in the Chamber) should have been good. But it wasn't. This was like some weird meshing of the old ECW and Vince's new vision of the brand, with Rob Van Dam, CM Punk, Test, Hardcore Holly, Big Show and Bobby Lashley doing battle over the ECW World Title. Sabu was supposed to be in the match, but he was written out and replaced by Sparky Plugg for reasons nobody can really explain (although apparently Sabu was being a bit 'difficult' during this period). When Lashley, Vince's hand-picked muscle God won the title, many of the fans in attendance literally turned their backs on him. This that don't decided to boo him instead. Ouch. Did Anything Redeem It? There was literally one good match: The Hardy Boyz versus MNM (one of only two advertised matches, along with the Chamber match). Even then, it wasn't that good. Not good enough to save this shambles, anyway.

Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...