10 Worst WWE Roster "Shake-Up" Moves

Sometimes, it hurts to move.

John Cena Raw
WWE.com

The most exciting part of the annual WWE Drafts is the guaranteed freshness that will ensue. If your viewership was (or is) confined to just one brand, you're about to witness a hefty overhaul, courtesy of the arrivals and departures. Even if you watch all of the WWE programming, the rearrangements are likely to spark plenty of newness for your viewing pleasure.

As an armchair booker, some of the moves will make you nod and smile. Some will leave you curious. Others will make you say, "Why?" Or if you're like the current crop of fan, you offered to sacrifice your household pet to Prophet Kobashi, God of Workrate, in exchange for AJ Styles remaining on SmackDown. Wrestling fans, certainly a passionate crop.

Looking back at the draft results of previous years, you see moves that didn't exactly resonate for one reason or another. Not every move is going to work out, whether it's bad creative, an unfortunate injury, utter fan apathy, or whatever the reason may be. The big plans to flip around certain wrestlers in order to bolster programming don't always work out in WWE's favor.

The forthcoming list will highlight some swaps made by WWE that either backfired, or just simply fell flat.

List is presented chronologically.

10. Splitting The Dudley Boyz (2002)

Dudley Boyz
WWE.com

While there were many questionable decisions in the original split, the most puzzling concerned the continuity of the Draft itself. When Vince McMahon and Ric Flair went back and forth picking talent like captains of a kickball game, there were two instances where a collective group was taken. Flair's second pick for Raw was the nWo trio of Scott Hall, Kevin Nash, and X-Pac. McMahon's fifth pick for SmackDown was Billy and Chuck, the reigning Tag Team champions.

Yet shortly after, Flair chose Bubba Ray Dudley individually, while McMahon picked D-Von seconds later. Why? It was never explained why Flair would want to choose only Bubba, and the move wasn't very well-received. Bubba fared alright as a reliable Raw midcarder, while D-Von foundered as a heel playing the role of corrupt Reverend. The two were smartly put back together on Raw eight months later, giving the brand an established duo.


9. Tajiri To Raw (2004)

Tajiri Ropes
wwe.com

Tajiri's understated brilliance in the American wrestling scene (first in ECW, then early in his WWE run) made him a true fan favorite, deftly blending precise in-ring artistry with expressive humor. Few wrestlers of his heyday were as well-suited for the Cruiserweight division than he was. Tajiri was a regular in the SmackDown-exclusive division in 2002-03, taking part in matches with Rey Mysterio, Billy Kidman, Jamie Noble, and others.

The move to Raw in March 2004 didn't make too much sense, other than perhaps WWE feeling he'd done all he could do as a designated cruiserweight. While Tajiri was still just as capable as he ever was, his talents were kinda wasted in go-nowhere stories with Jonathan Coachman and La Résistance. A Tag Team title reign with William Regal in 2005 failed to bring out the duo's comedic brilliance of four years earlier. By year's end, Tajiri had quietly left the promotion.


8. Muhammad Hassan To SmackDown (2005)

The Undertaker Muhammad Hassan 2005
WWE.com

Well, this one went badly.

Hassan's original WWE character was a curious one: an Arab-American who in the short few years since 9/11 had grown weary of being discriminated against, based on the color of his skin. The problem was that Hassan was a heel, and was somehow wrong for wanting to be treated fairly. Yes, he did heelish things in the ring, but the initial gist of the character was nowhere near worthy of condemnation.

When Hassan moved to SmackDown in the summer of 2005, WWE commissioned an angle where Hassan had a cell of masked followers (one guess what they were supposed to represent) attack The Undertaker with clubs and piano wire, before carrying off Hassan's lackey Daivari in martyr-like fashion. To make matters worse, the angle aired roughly 18 hours after the London transit system was attacked in a triple bombing, so an already insensitive angle looked much more bone-headed.

Hassan was done in at the ensuing Great American Bash pay-per-view, and the real-life Mark Copani left the business entirely shortly afterwards at the age of 23.


7. Christian To SmackDown (2005)

Christian 2005
WWE.com

Here's a classic example of how to kill off one's momentum. On the Raw side of the table, Christian was amassing a cult following, despite having been a heel for the previous three years. His promos were entertaining, his ring-work was excellent, and his interactions with other performers demonstrated his overall compatibility. When he began adding mock freestyle raps to his verbal repertoire, a main event star was being birthed before the WWE audience.

Then Christian was sent to SmackDown, where the accumulated impetus wore off in losses to The Mexicools and Booker T. The word was that Vince McMahon didn't see Christian as a main event talent, and Christian subsequently refused to sign a new contract when prompted that October. He left after a brief appearance at Taboo Tuesday, and debuted for TNA at Genesis twelve nights later.


6. Chavo Guerrero To Raw (2005)

Kerwin White 1
WWE

Sometimes a radical change to an established wrestler's persona can do wonders for their career (see: Dustin Rhodes becoming Goldust). Other times, such a change leads to raised eyebrows and a confused sputter. That was the case for Guerrero in 2005, who was moved to Raw, away from frequent partners/rivals Rey Mysterio and Uncle Eddie, as well as the Cruiserweight division.

Upon arriving on Raw, Chavo dyed his hair blonde and denounced his Latin heritage in favor of co-opting stereotypical Anglo characteristics under his new name 'Kerwin White'. To hammer the point, White made his entrance to mock Lawrence Welk-style music in khakis and a draped sweater, while driving a golf cart. After Eddie's passing that November, Chavo abandoned the gimmick and returned to SmackDown, his Guerrero surname thankfully restored.


5. The Entire 2007 Draft

Gene Snitsky
WWE.com

Not the supplemental portion, but the on-camera selections themselves. The night of the 2007 Draft is more infamous for Vince McMahon's "demise" in a limo explosion, which was rendered moot by real-life events weeks later. The actual selections on Raw's broadcast were just as irrelevant in the big picture.

Raw acquired four wrestlers during the course of the night. Of that lot, two of them would leave the company within months: King Booker and Bobby Lashley. Another, Gene Snitsky, was mostly inconsequential for the remainder of his WWE run. Despite earning a mega-pop when his name came up, Mr. Kennedy never did live up to his potential, and was back on SmackDown a year later.

SmackDown may have had it worse. Three of their four selections would be gone within a year: Chris Masters (released that fall), Ric Flair (retired at WrestleMania XXIV), and Torrie Wilson (left in May 2008). The other was Great Khali, who wasn't exactly the most exciting of performers.

ECW ended up with two picks: The Boogeyman (more of a novelty act) and Chris Benoit, whose real-life actions less than two weeks later are still hard to come to grips with.


4. The Jim Ross/Michael Cole Swap (2008)

Jim Ross Michael Cole
WWE

Beginning in 2007, the annual Draft's selections were determined by the winners of inter-brand matches. In the 2008 edition, a Divas' tag team match would determine a swap among the three announce teams. When it ended in a no-contest, the random picker announced JR to SmackDown, and Michael Cole to Raw. You could hear the groans in the arena.

Turns it, Ross was not informed ahead of time that he was switching brands. He found out along with the rest of the viewing world, and was so angry about being left in the dark that he nearly quit WWE. Mick Foley, Ross' new partner on SmackDown, lambasted Vince McMahon to his face about the cold move.

As for the swap itself, in the nine years since, Cole has hardly managed to begin filling Ross' massive boots on Raw, and is viewed by many as a detriment to the broadcasts he's on. While it's more fair to say that Cole is little more than an avatar for McMahon's sometimes-cloudy vision, it's also fair to say that Ross handled McMahon's warped creative with a more steady hand than Cole.


3. Vladimir Kozlov To ECW (2009)

Vladmir Kozlov
WWE.com

By 2009, WWE's version of ECW was circling the drain of existence, and would be put out of its misery in February 2010. The plucking of John Morrison and The Miz in the 2009 Draft onto the two bigger brands was a sign of its impending demise, leaving Christian, a 40-year-old William Regal, a 38-year-old Tommy Dreamer, and maybe (big maybe) Jack Swagger as the only viable talents left on the brand.

The televised portion of the 2009 Draft saw only one wrestler go to ECW: Kozlov. This was a scant five months after he and Triple H wrestled one of the most boring matches in recent memory at Survivor Series, and 'The Moscow Mauler' wasn't exactly setting the world on fire. Later arrivals like Sheamus, Yoshi Tatsu, and Tyler Reks positioned ECW for its eventual fate as the maiden form of NXT, a post-developmental program for molding incoming talent before the real WWE audience.


2. The John Cena Double Switch (2011)

John Cena Draft 2011
wwe.com

With each ensuing Draft, it became more evident the divide in equity WWE held in Raw and SmackDown. SmackDown is where cold acts went, whereas Raw took in anyone hot from either other brand. That's why it was odd when the 2011 Draft started with SmackDown earning a pick: John Cena. Something about this seemed fishy, especially as a heavy hitter like Cena was swapping shows so early in the broadcast.

Indeed, a six-man tag closed out the night, with Cena competing on the SmackDown side. Raw won, and the random picker chose... John Cena. Cena became the only man to end up back on his original show via the random picker, a marvelous coincidence. It also underscored the little value WWE held in SmackDown at the time, as if to say, "You think we'd take Cena off of Raw and put him on that inconsequential show?" Puh-lease."


1. Nia Jax To Raw (2016)

Nia Jax Spears Self Barricade
WWE.com

In the 2016 Split Redux, it was decreed that Raw and SmackDown combined had to make six selections from NXT. Champions (Samoa Joe, Asuka, and The Revival) were off-limits, so anyone else from the developmental brand was eligible for selection.

Finn Bálor and American Alpha were the first selections from NXT, and were sensible enough. However, since any non-champion was an eligible pick, that means in kayfabe, both sides passed on Shinsuke Nakamura, Austin Aries, and Bayley. That's why it was weird for many when for the third NXT pick, Raw chose Nia Jax.

Despite having a decent presence because of her Amazonian build, it's clear that the call-up of Nia was far, far too soon. Her recent disaster of a match with Charlotte on Raw is the cherry on the sundae of what has been a mostly-rough nine months of main roster duty, revealing many shortcomings of Nia's in terms of timing, instincts, and execution.


Contributor
Contributor

Justin has been a wrestling fan since 1989, and has been writing about it since 2009. Since 2014, Justin has been a features writer and interviewer for Fighting Spirit Magazine. Justin also writes for History of Wrestling, and is a contributing author to James Dixon's Titan series.