10 Worst WWE Royal Rumble Winners Ever

Every Bland For Himself! Featuring John Cena - and who else…?

Vince McMahon worst
WWE

January is a great time for WWE fans, and this year promises more greatness than most. The upcoming men’s Royal Rumble match can’t yield a bad winner. 

One benefit of introducing a second World Heavyweight title - even though the other one is meant to be undisputed - is that there are at least two favourites for the match. 

CM Punk has declared for the iconic annual spectacular, but has teased some sort of storyline with Roman Reigns. Roman himself is entering the match. It would suit Punk’s mischievous babyface persona, were he to eliminate Roman after Roman eliminates him. This device never made any sense, but that has never stopped WWE before. 

John Cena should at a minimum want that “record”-breaking 17th World title, even if he ultimately fails in the pursuit. 

Who knows? 

Perhaps Punk will make good on his promise to finally headline WrestleMania, only for the Rock to strike twice, swoop back into WWE, and take his spot. God, can you imagine? How would Punk react? 

Punk would give Rock the nod through gritted teeth, then post to his Instagram story something like ‘Don’t let toxic people rent space in your head. Raise the rent and kick them out”. 

This is something he likely knows a little about. 

This year’s WrestleMania season is creatively open and politically fascinating - unlike…

10. Sheamus (2012)

Sheamus Rumble 2012 Wwe
WWE.com

Jim Duggan and Big John Studd may seem like notable omissions, but the Rumble wasn’t really the Rumble in 1988 and 1989. It was an experimental attraction, a prize unto itself with no bearing on what wasn’t even called the road to WrestleMania yet. 

Sheamus, conversely, was a bad winner when the Rumble was meant to mean something.

In 2025, Sheamus is a profoundly respected upper midcard stalwart praised for his enduring reliability. He’s not exciting, and while you might not clamour to see what he gets up to next, what’s he doing now is always good, bruising fun. 

In 2012, Sheamus was the latest guy Vince McMahon wanted you to like in a scene that was hardly overflowing with options - one of several guys on the roster who could masquerade as a main eventer for a bit because an unchallenged WWE had the luxury of doing as they wished. 

He was a jovial unfunny guy who was also a bit of a nasty asshole - one of those heavily ironic Be A Star era babyfaces - who after smashing Daniel Bryan at WrestleMania XXVIII probably feuded with Alberto Del Rio or something, who cares.


9. Triple H (2016)

Triple H Royal Rumble 2016
WWE

To his very marginal credit, Triple H came out at #30, using his onscreen power to enter the match from the most advantageous position. 

Heel Triple H winning the Rumble could have been worse; really, it’s a shock that the man who scored a visual pin over CM Punk at Night of Champions 2011 didn’t come out earlier and deliberately miss the point. 

This rendered the length of the match rather pointless - that was Triple H, for you - and was very much what the heat-obsessed WWE were fond of at that time. 

Triple H’s win was boring - it was Triple H, in 2016 - and made zero sense from a character and storytelling perspective: what problem could even a fictionalised version of WWE’s power structure possibly have with, of all wrestlers, Roman Reigns?  

He was their guy! He wasn’t Daniel Bryan! 

The arrogance behind the decision was infuriating, too - the idea that a smug Triple H volunteered to work the main event of WrestleMania because he was the one who could “make” Roman. 

He did not make Roman. He made him look like a geek, if that counts. 

Roman continued to not be over as a babyface and fans had to endure another Triple H dud at ‘Mania for nothing. 

Great.


8. Edge (2010)

Edge Royal Rumble
WWE

Edge’s 2010 Royal Rumble victory was ultimately a stunt that meant nothing in the long run.  

There weren’t many exciting options. 

While WWE, in a rare departure from a crushing norm, actually used Triple H and Randy Orton to elevate new talents at WrestleMania XXVIII - Sheamus and Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase, Jr. respectively - nobody new was ready for the spot. 

Instead, despite playing heel before suffering an achilles injury, Edge did the “star automatically returns as a babyface” bit ahead of a show-down with partner-cum-rival Chris Jericho. 

This wasn’t the most successful comeback of its type; entering at #29, in a rushed sequence, Edge tossed out Cena after spending the least amount of time en route to victory up to that point (7:31). This didn’t scan as a heroic achievement - it was more consistent with his Ultimate Opportunist heel gimmick - and he clearly lacked match sharpness. 

Edge’s babyface character didn’t improve much from there - his attempted call-and-response to get the Spear! Spear! Spear! over felt like a novice’s prelim gimmick on their first house show loop - and the resulting match was technically decent but long and bereft of heat. 


7. John Cena (2013)

John Cena Royal Rumble
WWE

Once In A Lifetime was once enough. 

The paranoid dick-measuring contests were fascinating, and WWE felt massive when the Rock and John Cena shared the ring, but their WrestleMania XXVIII main even felt like it went on for a week. 

WWE fans had connected with CM Punk and Daniel Bryan, but the promotion wasn’t interested in pushing them to the tippy-top. The company motto had become ‘Putting Smiles On Shareholder’s Faces’, and you didn’t have the money to invest. You were poor. 

And don’t forget stupid! 

And so WWE reneged on the ‘Mania tagline to simply re-do Cena Vs. Rock - after, of course, the worst year of Cena’s career. The guy was so out of form that he defeated a returning Brock Lesnar. 

'Super' Cena won the 2013 Rumble match, last eliminating Ryback. People wanted Ryback to win, primarily because John Cena was about as funny as pranking a child for social media engagement. Allowing children to watch Cena was the most sinister prank of them all. 

Ryback. They wanted Ryback. 

Remember that the next time people insist that Cena was always good and it was simply cool to hate him. 

The timing of Cena’s win was as bad as the win itself; it made the Rock’s boring WWE title win over CM Punk that bit more predictable. 


6. Mr. McMahon (1999)

Mr McMahon Royal Rumble
WWE

Vince McMahon is an evil, malevolent human being. That statement has no relevance to this list entry, but it wouldn’t get stated enough if it was stated twice a day. 

The Mr. McMahon character had no business winning the Royal Rumble. Except he did, in 1999. 

He was a stunt winner fitting for the time. It was a time not for prestige or climbing mountains to succeed, but for great whopping breasts and stupid plot twists that were retconned within weeks. 

While the result “made sense” within the warped context of its era, it was still rubbish. Mr. McMahon winning the Rumble match only exposed that the roster depth was shocking and you’d have to endure yet another retread of the Steve Austin Vs. Undertaker feud within months. And, sure enough, you did. Even the Undertaker knew it sucked which is why he took on the American Badass persona a year later. 

The experiment was cute, but unlike the extraordinary Over The Edge 1998, the wild, OTT TV-style booking did not translate well to PPV. 

McMahon missing the entire match only to win at the end was telegraphed, and an hour of 1999 undercard acts carrying a pointless Rumble was as abysmal as you’d expect.


5. Seth Rollins (2019)

Seth Rollins Royal Rumble 2019
WWE.com

This Royal Rumble win defined the essence of Seth Rollins, if you’re inclined to believe that he’s a perfectly solid wrestler who isn’t anything special. 

He won a match that was only decent, in a vacuum, but scanned as something of a relief. Thank God Vince McMahon didn’t commit a booking atrocity, eh? 

The danger’s always there! 

In 2019, though, sensible, un-botched but uninspiring really wasn’t good enough. AEW was on the cusp of making things interesting - a word one can’t really associate with Seth Rollins, as skilled as he is on his better days. 

In football, when a club is in a dire run of form, the owner sometimes goes with - to borrow the clichés - a “safe pair of hands” who “knows the club inside out”. This new caretaker manager isn’t going to succeed at the top level, but they’re capable, at least, of staving off yet more utter humiliation. 

That was Seth Rollins in 2019. 

His unremarkable win led to some very committed booking - going over Brock Lesnar clean twice surely counts as being “handed the ball” - but his run-in with the Fiend and his Stand Up For WWE campaign didn’t do much for his Face of the Company credentials.


4. Randy Orton (2017)

Randy Orton Royal Rumble 2017
WWE.com

What was most irritating, about the Roman Reigns babyface push of the late 2010s, is that WWE knew it was going very badly but had zero incentive to abandon it or turn him heel. 

Vince McMahon, who apparently thrived on competition, was actually in a war before AEW formed - against his audience. The man fond of saying “**** ‘em” when a writer would point out a probable backlash to a creative pitch antagonised those fans for sport. 

He knew he was going to win. Sure, Reigns didn’t get over in that role, but you did nothing and liked it all the same. 

Equipped with the knowledge that you hated (or at least resented) Roman, WWE used the 2017 Rumble to depict Randy Orton as the lesser of two evils. Orton was an uninspiring choice, but people all but threw a ticker-tape parade and treated a chinlock like the birth of their first child purely because Roman, for once, did not win. 

Thank God they didn’t give the Rumble to the most over-pushed WWE wrestler ever…and went with Randy Orton instead!!

Vince instead had Roman go over the Undertaker at WrestleMania 33. 

In the main event.


3. Brock Lesnar (2022)

Brock Lesnar Royal Rumble 2020
WWE.com

WWE had absolutely nothing left in 2022, and then, in the summer of that year, the resurgence happened. 

It was remarkable. 

Dave Meltzer doesn’t get everything right - no, the Rock didn’t face Triple H at WrestleMania last year based on a nine year-old confrontation lol - but he was absolutely correct in stating that losing Cody Rhodes was the single worst thing to happen to AEW. 

And this is a company that had Matt Hardy on the books for four years. 

Cody changed everything, even before Vince McMahon resigned in disgrace, because before he signed, WWE again went with Brock Lesnar for Roman Reigns’ WrestleMania title defence. 

Brock Vs. Roman, again, Jesus Christ! 

That pairing made Kofi Kingston Vs. Dolph Ziggler feel like a much-anticipated first-time-ever dream match. 

The Rumble match itself was an abomination, what with Shane McMahon using it as a vehicle to get his dismal stuff in, and Lesnar winning was yet another “...of course” moment in WWE’s rich tradition of pissing everybody off. 

Lesnar had lost to Bobby Lashley earlier that night, but entered the Rumble match because who else did you expect to win?

Rick Boogs?


2. Alberto Del Rio (2011)

alberto del rio royal rumble
WWE.com

Alberto Del Rio revealed himself to be a nasty piece of work in the years subsequent to his Royal Rumble win, but don’t let the fact that he’s awful get in the way of the truth: he was an over-pushed wrestler who only won the Royal Rumble because he was a project of Vince McMahon’s, and times were rather desperate. 

Del Rio was telegenic, he had a good, loathsome heel face, and was well-liked. That was it; a wrestler whose floor was identical to the ceiling, Del Rio’s matches weren’t great, nor were they awful, that wretchedly contrived double foot stomp aside. WWE, in the late 2000s/early 2010s, was in an awful position. 

An awful, self-inflicted position; Vince didn’t think the acclaimed indie guys of the time had the look, and he knew that the in-house developmental wrestlers were nowhere near ready. Del Rio - a handsome guy who could go to a decent level within WWE’s parameters - was a compromise. 

He went on to beat Edge for the World Heavyweight title in an unremarkable opener - he did not, in fact, “main event WrestleMania” - and was given yet more title reigns as the next couple of years unfolded. 

He did nothing with them. He was a gentlemen’s three of a wrestler. 

Without that gentlemen’s part, obviously. 


1. Roman Reigns (2015)

The Rock Roman Reigns
WWE.com

The 2015 Royal Rumble match was a total disaster. 

Several moments throughout that wretched decade acted as the catalyst for many fans to finally say “Screw this”. 

The Summer of Punk frosting over. The crowning of Jinder Mahal: WWE Champion. The repeated burials of Bray Wyatt. 

Roman Reigns winning the most bleak match in WWE history was a major factor, as tracked by the excellent Brandon Thurston of Wrestlenomics. The backlash to that dismal match informed the worst ratings pattern on the road to WrestleMania since 1996. 

The idea - and the fans in Philadelphia understood it all too well, resulting in a noise that can only be described as a collective, relentless groan - was for Roman to rescue you all from the tedium of Kane and the Big Show. Kane and the Big Show, the guys who WWE had plugged into the main event for the preceding decade and a half, were now slow, lumbering, boring monsters in canon. They killed everybody and dumped them out - them being Dean Ambrose, Dolph Ziggler, the guys you actually liked at the time - as if they were literal bags of trash. 

Roman was meant to embody the youth movement you craved, but the issue is that his push was so forced and unwanted that the fans weren’t reminded of the last decade and a half; they feared the next inevitable decade and a half of Roman Wins LOL. 

Roman did win, and the Rock’s surprise endorsement of his cousin didn’t work. Nothing would, except the heel turn everybody not named Vince McMahon knew to be the solution. 


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!