10 Worst WWE WrestleMania World Title Storylines

They're supposed to be to be the most important matches of the entire year...

It's not the most encouraging sign when Dean Ambrose and Dolph Ziggler receive nothing but glowing encouragement from different crowds when matched up against dastardly Triple H. That's because it juxtaposes with the sneering indifference received by Roman Reigns when he violently confronts the WWE Champion. Not that fans were exactly clamouring for Reigns to dethrone Triple H come April 3, but the storyline has been pretty lame to this point. Not only has Reigns been incorrectly positioned as some kind of underdog akin to Daniel Bryan (which is like casting Jason Statham as a fearful hypochondriac), but he's paled to the more organic responses received by other babyfaces in his stead. It's been nothing but a disaster to this point. While I'll refrain from including it in this list due to its still ongoing capacity (not that I see it getting any better), I'll say that right now, it's in equal company with some of the top forthcoming entries. WrestleMania World title feuds receive heavier scrutiny because they're supposed to be the premier matches of wrestling's premier event. It seems that the people who cribbed out the twists and turns of each storyline didn't get that memo. This list includes storylines for both the WWE Championship and World Heavyweight Championship. As the list progresses, prepare yourself for a flood of bad memories, folks...


10. Psycho Sid Vs. The Undertaker (WrestleMania 13)

The problem with the story of Undertaker challenging for Sid's championship is that there was no story. Plans for WrestleMania 13 changed drastically, with the original main event set to see Bret Hart get his win back over likely champion Shawn Michaels, evening their high-profile series. In early-February 1997, McMahon took the championship out of the planned Hart-Michaels match, claiming it was 'too predictable'. Sid was to defeat Michaels on February 13 with Hart's interference, but Michaels bowed out with the infamous knee injury. Hart got Steve Austin instead, which was for the best. As for Undertaker vs. Sid, their story paled to Hart/Austin, and amounted to little more than stare-downs and simplistic brawls. Not exactly an exciting marquee build.

9. Chris Jericho Vs. Edge (WrestleMania XXVI)

With two silver-tongued wordsmiths like Jericho and Edge, you'd expect a more enticing build-up. Instead, Edge was into the early throes of an unsatisfactory babyface run that sapped him of his maniacal ramblings and wide-eyed sadism. As is often the case with modern WWE, a fascinating villain that veers to the side of good leaves behind his distinguished cool factor. Edge brayed endlessly for weeks about wanting to spear Jericho, straining to get the very word over as a buzzphrase. It was so outside the realm of what made Edge interesting. The only effective promo came from Jericho, who ridiculed Edge's DNA as being faulty, the cause of his many injuries. The WrestleMania match, while technically sound, was mostly heatless, possibly due in part to the Bret Hart/Vince McMahon foot-dragger that preceded it. Not that Edge's watered-down, uninspired invective helped any.

8. Kurt Angle Vs. Rey Mysterio Vs. Randy Orton (WrestleMania 22)

WWE didn't have to swipe at the low-hanging fruit, but they just couldn't help themselves. Mysterio surviving 62 minutes in his Royal Rumble win netted him a title match, and it was obvious that Mysterio was going to try and dethrone Kurt Angle in the memory of recently-departed best friend Eddie Guerrero. A match waged on mutual respect with Mysterio winning cleanly could have been inspiring. Instead, Orton was shoehorned into the match, after desecrating Guerrero's name. He then defeated Mysterio at No Way Out to win the WrestleMania title shot, but Mysterio was re-inserted anyway. At times, it seemed as though Mysterio was simply playing the role of Guerrero, and it was a tinge uncomfortable. For his part, Angle barely factored into the story. One of the most muddled and hazily-concocted storylines (not just WrestleMania-wise) put a deceased wrestler above all of the living participants.

7. Edge Vs. Big Show Vs. John Cena (WrestleMania XXV)

By 2009, so much within the upper tiers of the WWE roster that reeked of decay and staleness. John Cena was in his sixth year as wise-cracking hero, Edge was in year five of playing a ruthless, underhanded opportunist, and Show was stale on the virtue of being Show. The only thing that could make this worse was an angle in which nobody looks good. A month before WrestleMania 25, SmackDown GM Vickie Guerrero attempted to book Edge (her kayfabe husband) against Show for the title, without Cena's involvement. That's when Cena interrupted and whispered something in Vickie's ear that prompted the contract signing to be cancelled. That 'something' was the revelation that Vickie, for some reason, was having a tryst with Big Show, which was played more for haw-haw comedy instead of anything that could be taken seriously. Cena as a blackmailer (in a trucker cap and jorts) is a strange animal.

6. Triple H Vs. Randy Orton (WrestleMania XXV)

As far as co-opting some classically over-the-top Attitude Era hysteria, the spirit was there, but the balance was extremely weak. In relation to the previous entry, Orton was the freshest performer in the main event scene, due to the uptick in his easily-triggered violent tendencies. Unrepentant assaults on members of the McMahon family positioned Orton as a highly-compelling villain. That is, until Triple H chased him around the backstage area of Raw with a sledgehammer, and Orton ran for his life for what felt like thirty minutes. Then Helmsley attacked Orton at his house during an overly-long beating that also made Orton look pathetic. Not only was Orton marginalised by the repeated beatings, but it was also hard to buy Triple H as Liam Neeson from Taken, the blue-collar warrior that defends his family. Everyone knows he's a millionaire that pulls creative strings, which makes his authoritarian role today at least believable.

5. Brock Lesnar Vs. Roman Reigns (WrestleMania 31)

The Lesnar-Reigns deal was less a storyline and more an exercise in rebuilding the Roman sandcastle week by week. With fans booing Reigns out of virtually every arena he entered, a campaign was undertaken to convince the viewers that no, Reigns is really the man you should all be loving. See, Daniel Bryan (the fans' real choice) told us all that Reigns had impressed him with his heart and determination. Paul Heyman concurred immediately after Bryan's endorsement, saying that Reigns could beat any champion in any era, sans Lesnar. Due to Lesnar's limited appearances, Reigns spent that WrestleMania season demolishing heels related to The Authority, which didn't do much for the match. At least 'nothing' was better than the silly tug-of-war with the championship belt that Reigns and Lesnar ended the go-home Raw with, making both look like toddlers skirmishing over a toy.

4. Triple H Vs. Booker T (WrestleMania 19)

You may have heard of this one. While WWE today is so politically correct that they may as well be Highlights Magazine (with some hypocritical exceptions here and there), there was a time where the ascent of a popular wrestler was marred by alarming ugliness. In building their World Heavyweight title bout, Triple H referenced Booker T's legitimate criminal past, told him "people like you" didn't win World titles, then asked Booker to 'dance' for his amusement. The story could have perhaps been salvaged had Booker gone over at 'Mania. Harley Race, on Vader's behalf, made uneasy remarks toward Ron Simmons in 1992, and Simmons shut him up by winning the WCW Championship from Vader, thus the bigot got his comeuppance. But no, Triple H won cleanly, and the sour taste didn't wash easy.

3. Alberto Del Rio Vs. Jack Swagger (WrestleMania 29)

At least with the previous example, the roles were already defined: Triple H was firmly a scumbag villain, and Booker was a babyface that people wanted to see bust through the red tape. Ten years later, another racially-tinged angle was concocted over the World Heavyweight title, and this one involved some drastic recasting. This time, perennial heel Del Rio was suddenly a fun-loving Latin hero, while Swagger (with the help of debuting Zeb Colter) all of a sudden embraced Tea Party 'close the borders' rhetoric. The storyline tried to co-opt real-life cable news talking points, without any organic feeling. Not that the storyline was a great idea in the first place, as Del Rio was struggling to get over as a babyface, and Swagger had his own problems: a lack of credibility, and a very-public DUI arrest in February 2013. Del Rio and Ricardo Rodriguez's attempt to add a humorous spin by impersonating Swagger and Colter also fell flat.

2. Sgt. Slaughter Vs. Hulk Hogan (WrestleMania VII)

By the summer of 1990, tensions were rising after Iraq had invaded and annexed Kuwait. The United States was getting ready to intervene militarily, and war seemed inevitable. Wrestling has a history of promoting foreign heels that would align with American enemies of the times, and thus WWE brought Sgt. Slaughter back in August 1990, turned him against the 'softer' United States, and then stenciled him as an Iraq sympathizer. The plan was yet another Hulkamania patriot trip, positioning the long-time wrestling hero to dethrone Slaughter for the title at WrestleMania VII, two months after Slaughter defeated Ultimate Warrior for the belt. The entire storyline reeked of jingoistic opportunism, and even Bret Hart noted that many in the locker room were uncomfortable trading on an ongoing conflict with a soon-to-rise body count. If you believe Bruce Prichard's incredible claim, then this was almost Tugboat, a storied friend of Hogan's, turning heel to become 'Sheik Tugboat', and he instead would have beaten Warrior for the belt. At least Slaughter provided a decent match come WrestleMania.

1. Chris Jericho Vs. Triple H (WrestleMania X8)

While the previous three examples depicted heels uttering highly-questionable sentiments to incite crowds, at least their actions were ballsy. The same couldn't be said for Jericho, the first ever 'Undisputed' WWE Champion, who went into WrestleMania with his tail between his legs. The match may as well have been Triple H vs. Stephanie McMahon, since their domestic squabble took centre stage over Jericho's involvement. Jericho later lamented not getting to do anything that would position him as a calculating threat to sudden hero Helmsley. Instead, he was Stephanie's weak-willed dog-walker. The go-home 'intensifier' to the story was that Jericho accidentally caused the dog, who Triple H wanted custody of, to be run over by a limo. So now Jericho was going to get slaughtered in the name of a mutt, which is absolutely on par with Randy Savage raring to damage Ric Flair for insulting his wife's honour. With an angle like that, how did Rock vs. Hogan not go on last?

Contributor
Contributor

Justin has been a wrestling fan since 1989, and has been writing about it since 2009. Since 2014, Justin has been a features writer and interviewer for Fighting Spirit Magazine. Justin also writes for History of Wrestling, and is a contributing author to James Dixon's Titan series.