10 WrestleMania Main Events The Royal Rumble Almost Promised Us

But no, WWE had to dole out Sid Justice.

Hogan Flair WrestleMania VIII
WWE

The Royal Rumble has always done a pretty solid job as the de facto WrestleMania matchmaker.

Over the years, whoever leaves the January show as a World Champion has almost invariably managed to hang onto the gold until WrestleMania, and with the winner of the Rumble match itself being granted a title shot at the biggest show of the year, more often than not we know our WrestleMania main event by the end of the Rumble pay-per-view.

That arrangement has provided us with some awesome match-ups - Bret vs. Shawn, Austin vs. Rock, Angle vs. Lesnar, to name a few - but what if events had played out a little differently? What if had been the challenger who’d left the Rumble as champion, or if the runner-up in the 30-man match had instead emerged the winner?

Simply put; if things had been altered ever so slightly, we could have been treated to some absolute dream matches at WrestleMania.

Looking back at what could have been, this article delves into some alternate timelines that could have been spawned - but we were ultimately robbed of - at the Royal Rumble PPV.

10. Chris Jericho Vs. Daniel Bryan (WrestleMania XXVIII)

Chris Jericho Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

Back in 2010, on the first-ever episode of NXT, Daniel Bryan made his WWE debut against then-world champion Chris Jericho. Two years later, we came close to seeing that rivalry come full circle on the grand old stage of WrestleMania XXVIII—except this time, it was Bryan who was holding the gold.

Having beaten Mark Henry and the Big Show in a cage match to leave the Rumble with the belt in tow, Bryan had essentially booked his ticket to WrestleMania. Meanwhile, the recently-returned Jericho was a pre-match favourite to win the Rumble match outright. For the briefest of moments, the stars seemed to be aligning to tie up that story that started two years’ prior on NXT.

Instead though, Jericho fell at the final hurdle. Having made it to the final two of the Rumble, Sheamus then eliminated him to become number one contender, going on to face Bryan for the title at ‘Mania in a match that lasted just 18 seconds.

One silver lining is that this freed up Jericho to face CM Punk in what was an awesome WWE Championship programme - but either way, we still missed out on a possible 'student-becomes-the-teacher' classic.


9. Bret Hart Vs Randy Savage (WrestleMania VIII)

Bret Hart Randy Savage
YouTube

A 1987 meeting on WWF Main Event remains the only televised singles encounter ever staged between Bret Hart and Randy Savage. But if the 1992 Royal Rumble had panned out slightly differently, we could have seen these two titans go toe-to-toe for the WWF Championship in the main event of WrestleMania IX.

Bret was the reigning champion at the time. He ultimately defended against Yokozuna at ‘Mania, but if we look back at the way in which Yoko secured his spot in that match, it arrived via the narrowest - and most bizarre - of margins.

With Yokozuna and Savage our final two participants, Savage was seemingly in the ascendancy, but after nailing his elbow drop from the top rope, he inexplicably went for a cover on Yokozuna. Pinfalls, of course, don’t count in the Rumble match, and after an over-zealous kick-out from the gargantuan Yokozuna, Savage was launched over the top rope, out of the ring, and thus out of the main event of WrestleMania.

Subsequently, this was something of a double-whammy. Not only would Hart vs. Savage have been a great main event, it would also have saved us from seeing WrestleMania IX degenerating into the Hulk Hogan show. Hart lost to Yoko, only for Hogan to come out and goad the champ into a second title match, which the Hulkster promptly won in 22 seconds.

At least it was longer than Bryan lasted.


8. Bret Hart Vs. The British Bulldog (WrestleMania XI)

Bret Hart British Bulldog Summerslam 1992
WWE.com

1995 is renowned for a being a difficult time for WWE. There have literally been books written about the subject, and here I’m going to add another blemish on ‘95’s record in the form of a WrestleMania event that never was.

While Lawrence Taylor vs. Bam Bam Bigelow closed WrestleMania XI, the WWF title bout featured a Kliq-tastic meeting between Diesel and Shawn Michaels. Somewhere in another universe though, those spots could easily have been taken by Bret Hart and his brother-in-law, the British Bulldog.

The Bulldog had in fact come within a whisker of winning the Rumble match himself. Having tossed Michaels over the top rope, he turned to the corner in celebration. Unbeknownst to him though, Michaels had actually managed to hold on and would pull himself back into the ring before eliminating the unsuspecting Bulldog.

Meanwhile, Bret, the second part of this equation, had earlier come just as close to overcoming Diesel and leaving the PPV as WWF Champion, meaning that it would only have taken a couple of very slight amendments to turn this Bret vs. Bulldog match into a reality.

Ultimately, the two did end up clashing that year, at In Your House 5: Season’s Beatings, in a match that was arguably better than anything mustered up on that WrestleMania XI card.


7. John Cena Vs. The Undertaker (WrestleMania XXVI)

John Cena Undertaker
WWE.com

Okay, our next entry may seem a little farfetched, but hear me out on this one.

Undertaker vs. John Cena is one of the few remaining WrestleMania dream matches. Back in 2010 we weren’t too far from seeing it materialise.

With Undertaker beating Rey Mysterio at the Royal Rumble to successfully defend his world title, that added an extra incentive to the Rumble match. Not only would the winner have the option to challenge for the title at ‘Mania—they could also have a go at ending the Deadman’s famed Streak.

A blockbuster final five saw Batista, Chris Jericho, Shawn Michaels, Edge and John Cena vying for that honour, with the latter duo emerging as the last men standing, only for Edge - the fresher man - to dump Cena over the top for the win.

Edge indeed challenged for the gold at WrestleMania, but by that point ‘Taker was no longer the champion. Had he been able to keep the belt through to March though, and if Cena had been able to outlast Edge in the Rumble, we could finally have ticked Cena vs. Taker off of those WrestleMania bucket lists.

As it happened, we instead saw ‘Taker face Michaels in a rematch from WrestleMania XXV, which isn’t such a bad consolation prize whichever way you slice it.


6. Bret Hart Vs. The Undertaker (WrestleMania X)

The Undertaker Bret Hart In Your House
WWE.com

Back at the 1994 Royal Rumble, shenanigans from Yokozuna (or rather, from Crush, the Great Kabuki, Genichiro Tenryu, Bam Bam Bigelow, Adam Bomb, Jeff Jarrett, the Headshrinkers and Diesel) saw the big man beat the Undertaker to retain his WWF Championship. He would then would go on to face the winner of Lex Luger vs. Bret Hart - who ‘co-won’ the Rumble - at WrestleMania X.

That all sounds well and good, but it’s not necessarily the most mouth-watering of prospects.

Now imagine that there hadn’t been a ridiculously one-sided 10-on-1 beat-down at the Rumble, and that 'Taker had actually won the title. Suddenly, we're presented with the prospect of Undertaker vs. Bret Hart for the title at WrestleMania. That sounds a bit more like it.

Of course, a major spanner in the works of this particular piece of fantasy booking was the fact that Undertaker’s loss at the Rumble - and his subsequent ‘ascension to the heavens’ - was used to give him some time off to heal up a back injury. Had it not been for those injury woes, then maybe this meeting would have taken place after all…


5. John Cena Vs. CM Punk (WrestleMania XXIX)

john cena aj styles
WWE.com

Simply put, John Cena vs CM Punk is a saga that deserved at least one instalment on the grand stage of WrestleMania. And if it hadn’t been for the Rock’s championship aspirations at the turn of 2013, we’d likely have seen Cena vs. Punk headline WrestleMania XXIX. Unfortunately, it wasn’t quite meant to be.

When Cena emerged the victor in the 2013 Royal Rumble, CM Punk was celebrating his 434rd day as WWE Champion—but the writing was already on the wall. Immediately following Cena’s win, Punk defended his title against the Rock - and at this point, the outcome seemed a foregone conclusion.

A reversed finish at least kept things interesting at the close of the show, but when all was said and done it was the Rock who usurped Punk and went on to face Cena in the main event of WrestleMania for a second consecutive year.

In fairness, you can see why the company would want to milk Cena vs. Rock for all it was worth (that year’s WrestleMania became the highest grossing live event in WWE history, banking a handy $72 million), but for the history and the antithesis that these two characters represented, Cena vs. Punk was a rivalry undoubtedly worthy of a moment in the WrestleMania spotlight.


4. Brock Lesnar Vs. Daniel Bryan (WrestleMania 31)

Lesnar Bryan WrestleMania
WWE.com

Realistically, it was only a matter of time before we mentioned the 2015 Royal Rumble.

Heading into the show, Daniel Bryan was the overwhelming fan favourite to secure a second successive WrestleMania main event, after a fan backlash had contributed to his epic ascent to the top of the mountain at WrestleMania XXX in New Orleans. Plus, he’d just recently returned from a neck injury, leading many of us to believe that they’d rushed him back for the sole purpose of another major ‘Mania push.

Of course, Vince McMahon clearly had other plans.

Bryan was unceremoniously dumped out of contention somewhere in the middle of the match; a massive anti-climax, and the fans certainly made their feelings heard. The only more vehement reaction of the night was that which followed the eventual win for Roman Reigns, creating one of the most infamous moments in the PPV’s history.

Reigns faced Lesnar at ‘Mania, and though that match was much better than it often gets credit for, it still doesn’t scratch that enduring itch of how a Lesnar vs. Bryan match would go down.

Still, at least we’ve always got the memory of WrestleMania XXX to savour…


3. Triple H Vs. The Rock (WrestleMania X8)

SummerSlam 2000 Triple H The Rock Stephanie Mcmahon
WWE.com

We’ve already touched upon some of the great feuds that were never afforded a WrestleMania meeting - Bret Hart vs. the British Bulldog, John Cena vs. CM Punk - and in Triple H vs. the Rock, we’ve got another pairing to add to that list.

While the two crossed paths at WrestleMania 2000, that was in a cumbersome Fatal 4-way Elimination bout, and so, to this day, we’re yet to see one of the classic rivalries of the Attitude Era take place in singles action at ‘Mania.

That almost changed at WrestleMania X8 though - and again, it was largely due to events at the Royal Rumble. With Triple H making a grandiose return from seven months on the shelf, he was naturally a big favourite to win the Rumble. Rock, meanwhile, was scheduled to challenge Jericho for the Undisputed Championship. A collision course had been set.

Unfortunately, that collision course hadn’t accounted for a combination of Jericho’s cronies, Nick Patrick and an exposed turnbuckle. Those three factors helped Jericho screw the Rock out of the title and put himself in pole position to head to WrestleMania X8.

There, he faced Triple H in a match that, in hindsight, might have suffered from its predictability and card placement. Still, the Rock provided us with a perfectly acceptable alternative in the form of his Icon vs. Icon clash with Hulk Hogan.


2. Shawn Michaels Vs. The Rock (WrestleMania XIV)

Like many entries on this list, there isn’t necessarily any evidence to suggest that this match was being touted for WrestleMania - but that doesn’t mean it isn’t a meeting we’d have loved to have seen either way.

Shawn Michaels vs. the Rock is an enduring example of the one that got away; a potential showdown between two bona fide legends, and one which regrettably eluded us all for a variety of reasons. But beyond the badly-timed injuries and the rumours of backstage animosity, there was a brief window in which the wheels could have been set in motion.

At the 1998 Royal Rumble, Michaels defeated Undertaker to retain his WWF Championship, while the Rock came within seconds of earning the right to challenge HBK for the strap at WrestleMania XIV.

After a valiant 51-minute showing, the Rock eventually came up short when Stone Cold Steve Austin hit him with the Stunner and dispatched him from the ring to earn himself a spot in the main event of WrestleMania.

Again, the timeline that actually transpired was by no means a disappointment - Austin faced Michaels with Mike Tyson brought in as the guest enforcer, once again thrusting pro wrestling into the mainstream - and you could also argue that the Rock wasn’t quite ready for this spot at the time.


1. Hulk Hogan Vs. Ric Flair (WrestleMania XII)

Flair Hogan
WWE

Though Michaels and the Rock would never lock horns, the same can’t be said of Ric Flair and Hulk Hogan. These two have crossed paths on numerous occasions—in WCW, TNA and even in WWE in 2002—but a decade prior at the 1992 Royal Rumble, we were robbed of a WrestleMania meeting between these two icons whilst they were still very much in their prime.

When Flair joined the WWF in late ‘91, you’d have been forgiven for assuming that this would mean we’d finally see him and Hulk Hogan, two of the absolute biggest names in the business, finally meet in one-on-one action. Rather than using the ’92 Rumble to set-up a showdown at ‘Mania though, the match was used to prep Hogan for a programme with Sid Vicious.

Flair meanwhile, won the Rumble and with it the vacant WWF Championship, before going on to face Randy Savage at WrestleMania. When he finally got around to wrestling Hogan, it was over two years down the line and both men were on the books of WCW.

Though there were other factors that prevented Flair vs. Hogan from coming to fruition—namely the speculation that their late-1991 house show run didn’t quite draw as well as expected—the Rumble could be seen as a pivotal moment in confirming the feud had well-and-truly been canned. As such, a legion of fans (of the WWF, at least) were robbed of what could have been one of the biggest WrestleMania main events in history.


Contributor
Contributor

Elliott Binks hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.