10 Wrestlers AEW Let Slip Through Their Fingers

Despite already boasting several stars, AEW's roster could have been even better with these pickups.

Tenille Dashwood AEW
AEW

Between recently extending their TV deal with TNT through 2023 and beating WWE NXT in the ratings most weeks, it's safe to say AEW is off to a strong start, especially in terms of the talent they've secured in the last year alone.

Chris Jericho, The Elite and Pac joining from the get-go gave the company instant credibility. Later additions such as The Lucha Brothers, Jon Moxley and Kris Statlander have only further bolstered their roster and have helped establish them as a true alternative to WWE.

As star-studded as AEW's current crop of competitors is, there were a number of free agents they could have conceivably snatched up but didn't for whatever reason. Some expressed interest in going but ultimately decided against it, while others never mentioned being approached by AEW when they absolutely should have been.

Edge, for example, likely never had any intentions of actually signing with AEW as he instead used them as leverage for a WWE return. That was a move that made sense. However, there are many more wrestlers who would have been a perfect fit for AEW but passed for another promotion.

Joey Ryan choosing to stay on the independent scene over AEW wasn't much of a loss, but these 10 stars could have been legitimate difference makers had the company done a better job of pursuing them.

10. Kota Ibushi

Kota Ibushi AEW
AEW/NJPW

For many years, Kota Ibushi built his reputation off being one of wrestling's greatest freelancers. He started his career in DDT, honed his craft in New Japan Pro-Wrestler later in his career, and eventually participated in WWE's first-and-only Cruiserweight Classic tournament, all while technically working for himself.

Ibushi was known for always turning down formal offers (including from WWE) because he wished to wrestle wherever he wanted. That changed at the onset of 2019 when he announced he had officially signed a two-year deal with NJPW. Oddly enough, this was around the same time All Elite Wrestling was formed and was scouting talent from across the globe.

The Golden Star felt like a natural fit in AEW because of his history with AEW EVP Kenny Omega. In fact, the two had just reunited the year prior in NJPW and were riding high as partners again, so it was only logical for him to join his longtime partner in his new venture.

It may have been as simple as Ibushi not wanting to relocate, but regardless of the reason, AEW's loss was NJPW's gain. He went on to win the G1 Climax that summer before challenging Kazuchika Okada for the IWGP Heavyweight Championship in an instant classic at Wrestle Kingdom 14.


9. Nick Aldis

Nick Aldis NWA Powerrr
NWA

NWA Powerrr likely would have never seen the light of day had Nick Aldis accepted AEW's offer in 2019. Thankfully, the NWA Worlds Heavyweight champion opted to remain with the NWA and build the brand into what it is today.

It should come as no surprise that AEW would want Aldis a part of their roster. He was a focal point on their All In show in September 2018 when Cody beat him for his prized possession, only to win it back soon after at an NWA-sanctioned event. Both bouts were excellent and a rubber match surely would have been equally entertaining.

Aldis would be an excellent addition to any roster fortunate enough to have him, but for now, he's the face of the NWA and is doing fantastic work every Tuesday night on Powerrr.

He's confirmed in various interviews that he'd be willing to join AEW so long as he can continue to compete in the NWA and help behind the scenes. Apparently, the powers that be in AEW weren't interested in the idea of there being a working relationship between the two companies.

NWA has done pretty well for itself on its own in recent months, so needless to say, Aldis made the right choice.


8. John Morrison

John Morrison WWE
WWE

When John Morrison left WWE in 2011, it was widely believed he'd be back within a year or two. That year or two turned into almost a decade, and during his time away, he became a much more complete performer in promotions such as IMPACT, Lucha Underground and AAA.

The Shaman of Sexy has gone on record in recent years in saying that his end goal was always to return to WWE, and in December 2019, it finally happened. This came after he departed IMPACT in July, though fans figured at the time that he was AEW bound along with fellow ex-IMPACT employees Santana and Ortiz.

After all, he'd be given much more creative freedom in AEW and would be able to continue acting and producing on the side if he wanted. Then again, at the age of 40, it was probably now or never for him to go back to WWE. There was no guarantee he'd be successful, but perhaps that was a risk he was willing to take.

In other words, he didn't need AEW as much as AEW needed him. That isn't to say he would have been a world championship contender upon his debut on Dynamite had he gone there, but there's zero doubt he would have been a bigger pickup for them than the creatively-damaged Jake Hager.


7. Cain Velasquez

Cain Velasquez SmackDown
WWE.com

As one of the longest-reigning and most dominant UFC Heavyweight champions of all-time, Cain Velasquez was expected to be highly sought once he officially transitioned into wrestling in 2019.

His stock skyrocketed after he impressed the masses with a myriad of moves in his AAA debut last March. Despite that being his only in-ring appearance for the company (and it being a six-man tag team match), rumors ran rampant in the fall that both WWE and AEW were aggressively trying to sign him and secure his star power.

Instead of becoming the AEW equivalent to Brock Lesnar and being brought in for Dynamite's debut (which was heavily rumored), Velasquez instead chose to make the jump to WWE and feud with his foe from nearly a decade earlier. WWE scored major mainstream attention from his arrival on SmackDown's Fox premiere, but it was all downhill from there for him.

He hasn't been seen since losing to Lesnar in a matter of minutes at Crown Jewel, though one can only assume he would have been booked a lot better had he wound up in AEW.

No offense to Jake Hager, but why did AEW settle for a mildly successful MMA fighter when they could have had the real deal in Velasquez?


6. Tenille Dashwood

Tenille Dashwood
ROH

It's no secret that AEW's women's division could use as much help as it can get. They have enough talent to make it interesting for now, but they would have benefited from bringing in a few more notable names from the start.

Britt Baker and Allie, for example, have been fine thus far, but both have underwhelmed in the ring and haven't the big stars many fans were hoping.

That said, it was genuinely surprising that there seemed to be zero talk of AEW scouting Tenille Dashwood for their women's division last year. She announced her departure from Ring Of Honor in March and could have very well debuted at Double or Nothing in May, but she did not appear.

In fact, it was only after she signed with IMPACT in July that she finally wrestled for AEW at All Out, taking part in the women's Casino Battle Royale. It was reported that she was working with IMPACT on a per-night agreement and likely would be contractually able to appear for AEW, but there has been zero follow-up with the former Emma since then.

Dashwood has been decent in IMPACT but would be even better on a bigger stage, such as AEW. It looks like the ball is in their court and they simply have no interest in using her.


5. Eli Drake

Eli Drake
ImpactWrestling.com

For all of the company's faults, IMPACT deserves credit for seeing the star potential in Eli Drake and making him one of their featured players from 2015 to 2019. A silly social media mistake cost him his job at WWE, but there was no reason for IMPACT to not pick up the pieces and build their brand around him.

While there, Drake came into his own as a performer and held their top title for a substantial period of time. Comments he made on Twitter regarding his refusal to wrestle Tessa Blanchard at one of IMPACT's events led to his dismissal in April, sparking speculation as to where he would pop up next.

Drake has been very candid in interviews over the years about how WWE has extended the olive branch to return, but he consistently turned them down because the money wasn't right. Truth be told, he'd still more or less flounder in NXT if he were brought back tomorrow because of the immense amount of talent they have under contract, which is why AEW seemed to be a logical landing spot for him.

According to the Namer of Dummies himself, he had a deal worked out with AEW, but it fell through at the last minute. He then jumped at the opportunity to work with Dave Lagana again in the NWA and the rest is history.


4. Killer Kross And Scarlett Bordeaux

Killer Kross
WWE.com

Wherever one went, the other was bound to follow, so Killer Kross and Scarlett Bordeaux should be considered a package deal.

Both Bordeaux and Kross reportedly requested their release from IMPACT in May but didn't become free agents until June and December, respectively. During that time, both appeared at multiple Starrcast conventions (held the same weekend as AEW events) and were in attendance for Double or Nothing, so it certainly looked like they were headed to AEW.

However, nothing was reported following Kross' official release late last year regarding AEW approaching him about a deal. They dropped the ball on signing Scarlett, and once WWE scooped her up in November, Kross' future was crystal clear.

By January, Dave Meltzer made it clear that all signs pointed to him signing with WWE, and sure enough, the company made it official on WWE Backstage last week. With Triple H apparently being as high on Kross as he is, he should be booked to be a big star in NXT, but it's still surprising that AEW didn't make more of a play for him given his untapped potential.

Perhaps AEW was already content with their recent acquisition of Japanese death match legend Luther and felt they didn't need to add anyone else to their ranks.


3. Mercedes Martinez

Mercedes Martinez
WWE.com

Mercedes Martinez has been in the business for 19 years and shockingly hasn't been under contract to a major wrestling promotion until now.

Fans expected WWE to sign her following her strong showings in both of the Mae Young Classic tournaments, but a deal never surfaced. She continued to compete on the independent scene until making a one-off appearance in the Casino Battle Royale at AEW All Out where she lasted a while before being eliminated by Britt Baker.

AEW should have signed her right then and there but oddly opted not to. She wrestled for the promotion once more on an episode of Dark in November but again wasn't signed.

It's entirely possible that, like Edge, Martinez used AEW as leverage to get a deal from WWE, but she is someone AEW should have been desperate to get in their women's division. They probably could have offered her more money than she's currently earning in WWE and promised her an immediate push toward the top of the title picture,

Martinez feels she's right where she belongs in WWE and has already been fast-tracked to NXT TV, but AEW needs her far more at the moment and missed the boat big time in not signing her when they had the chance.


2. Marty Scurll

Marty Scurll NWA Into the Fire
Twitter, @MartyScurll

Marty Scurll was put in an awkward position when all of his Elite buddies left Ring Of Honor to start up All Elite Wrestling at the start of 2019 and he was still under contract to the company. Of course, he was expected to join them in AEW once his ROH deal expired, until he didn't.

ROH's poor booking of Scurll over the last year seemed to indicate he had one foot out the door, but reportedly the promotion made him an offer he couldn't refuse and appointed him to a pretty prominent role backstage.

Although it's too soon to tell whether he made the right choice or not, his influence is already being felt on the product and it's been positive. Scurll shouldn't be blamed for going where he'll make the most money, but the real question is, how didn't AEW outbid them for his services?

For as many promising prospects as AEW has under contract, they'll need more star power eventually. Scurll could have filled that void with ease and, of course, there is plenty to explore there storyline-wise with him either aligning or feuding with The Elite.

He's currently appearing in three different companies (ROH, the NWA and NJPW) and feels as important as ever, so maybe he dodged a bullet by not taking the most obvious route.

Then again, every story needs a villain, none more than AEW.


1. CM Punk

CM Punk
Fox

Oh, what could have been with CM Punk and AEW.

Many fans are likely sick of hearing about the prospect of Punk ever wrestling again, but the truth is, it almost happened, at least in AEW. Had company officials (cough, Cody, cough) played their cards a bit better and approached him with an actual offer in a more professional manner (at least according to Punk himself), chances are he would have wrestled a match or two for them by now.

As soon as August's All Out event was announced to be emanating from his hometown from Chicago, fans pegged it as the perfect place for him to debut. One month out, however, Punk made it abundantly clear in an interview with ESPN that their lack of communication all but eliminated the possibility of him coming to work with them in any capacity.

Talk of him serving as an analyst for the new WWE Backstage show on FS1 also started up around this time, something that seemed almost impossible considering how far he distanced himself from the company since he walked out six years ago. Despite that, he shockingly signed on to do the show in November (presumably for a large sum of money) and in the process put the rumors of him competing in an AEW ring to rest once and for all.

The Voice of the Voiceless could have sparked major interest in AEW from current and former fans alike, but alas, it wasn't meant to be.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Since 2008, Graham has been a diehard pro wrestling fan and, in 2010, he combined his passions for WWE and writing when he joined Bleacher Report. Equipped with a master's in journalism, Graham has contributed to WhatCulture, FanSided's Daily DDT, Sports Betting Dime, and GateHouse Media. Along the way, he has conducted interviews with wrestling superstars like Chris Jericho, Edge, Goldberg, Christian, Diamond Dallas Page, Jim Ross, Adam Cole, Tessa Blanchard, Ryback, and Nick Aldis among others.