10 Wrestlers Promoters Were Afraid Of
Don't trust him: he's a flake.
You need to be tough to be a professional wrestler, but you need to be a whole lot tougher to be a professional wrestling promoter. After all, who's braver: the pride of lions or the man who feeds them?
Handling the schedule - and, crucially, the money - of a group of burly blokes who've made absorbing pain their vocation comes with inherent risks, as many a booker stiffed in the face after stiffing a paycheque has found out. It's why, when you think of the industry's most celebrated promoters, your mind automatically wanders to a parade of hardened veterans, die-cast monoliths who wouldn't suffer fools. The likes of Verne Gagne, Paul Boesch, Fritz von Erich. Even Vince McMahon, though not hewn from the same sinewy flesh as the aforementioned, has, through monopoly more than muscle, proved almost uncontestable over the years. Even if it comes decades later, Vince invariably has the last laugh.
It's why in 2020, 74 years old and occupying a world quite detached from our own, McMahon still commands a degree of respect his legacy perhaps does not deserve. Fear is perpetuated by historic reputation. Only a handful of times have the roles been reversed.
10. Nailz
In 1992, just as Vince McMahon was trying to avoid prison, he introduced a wrestler allegedly from one. Kevin 'Nailz' Wacholz, though as artificially inflated as any of the men on the roster the chairman was hurriedly scurrying away in response to the FBI's interest, was sufficiently tall and sufficiently vicious looking to be draped in an orange boiler suit and still come across menacing. The fear the wronged convict put into gawping children would soon translate to the back office.
At SummerSlam '92, Nailz handily dispatched of Virgil before a crowd of 92,000 people. Though there was no suggestion he'd drawn that gate, Wacholz nevertheless felt shortchanged by the $8000 payoff he received for his first PPV match. Incensed, he made his point perfectly clear - the gravelly voice was just for effect - at a set of tapings in Green Bay, WI, demanding $15,000 in advance for a proposed programme with The Undertaker.
After being told a firm "no", Wacholz lunged at his boss. It's not clear whether Vince, Mr. Burns-like, jumped into his Smithers Pat Patterson's arms, but his sphincter must surely have loosened as Wacholz hands tightened around his neck. According to backstage witnesses, McMahon turned blue as a smurf. No surprise, the assault didn't aid in the negotiations; Wacholz was fired on the spot.
9. New Jack
In 2004, John Cena needed a brief sabbatical from WWE so he could film terrible action flick The Marine. Instead of simply telling fans, hey, one of your favs is going to be in a movie, go watch it!, the company instead contrived a plotline in which Cena was stabbed in a nightclub by an associate of Carlito, the man who'd recently deposed him for the US Championship.
Eventually, the apple-spitter's bodyguard Jesús owned up to his sins, leading to an oft-forgotten match between he and John at Armageddon 2004. Apparently - according to the man himself - the role of stabber was originally intended for wrestling's most infamous scalpel-wielder, New Jack.
That never happened, and nor did Jack ever alight in WWE, even when they promoted ECW reunion One Night Stand in 2005 and revived the brand full time a year on. Why the snub? Simple: the promotion were scared rigid of having someone of New Jack's particular nature on their books. This was a man who'd nearly killed the underage, untrained Mass Transit after he'd lied about his credentials. A man who'd thrown Vic Grimes off a scaffold onto a concrete. A legitimate bounty hunter. He was a complete no-go.
As Jim Cornette, then a trainer in development league OVW, explained: "They were never going to touch him. He was too controversial. They were afraid of lawsuits, they were afraid of bad publicity, they were afraid he was going to hurt somebody.”
8. Haku
Any list of wrestling's most afeared men, no matter the context or specifics, would not be complete without a customary mention of Tonga's toughest nose muncher, Haku.
Nobody, not a member of the public, a fellow wrestler or an entire police battalion, emerged victorious from a scrap with Haku. Nobody. So for that reason, all his colleagues - up to and including his bosses - walked in slippers on eggshells around the pugnacious Pacific Islander.
Chris Candido recounted one story from Haku's time in WCW, in which higher ups Eric Bischoff and Greg Gagne interrupted a conversation between himself, Chris Jericho, and the Face of Fear. Haku (or Meng, as he was known then) turned toward the pair and icily instructed, "Apologise to my friends, I'm talking." Fighting for control of their collective bladders, the chastened execs acquiesced, and waited patiently for Haku to finish. Bischoff joked years later that Haku was never fired from WCW because "no-one had the balls to do so!"
7. Abdullah The Butcher
Fork-wielding mutilator Abdullah the Butcher is something of an anomaly in WWE's (admittedly free-form) Hall of Fame, given he only scraped foreheads in the company for all of ten minutes way back in the '60s. The Canadian's reputation within the industry was earned cutting folk with cutlery outwith Stamford, and it was partly the reason why he never had a long-term gig in Vince's glitzy promotion.
The other part, in addition to Abdullah's brutal incongruity, was his belligerent irascibility. Prior to his inexplicable 2011 induction, the Butcher admitted that he'd never even met Vince McMahon, owing to his fearsome notoriety for being a backstage menace. He told Slam! Sports, "WWE were scared of me because I was an outlaw, and I did not kiss anybody's butt."
It wasn't just that his bloodletting was at complete odds with the product WWE were promoting that prevented the call; even his colleagues advised against it. "The boys, back in the day there, would say, "Don't bring Abdullah in - he'll be trouble!" he recalled.
6. Bruiser Brody
Frank 'Bruiser Brody' Goodish's fearsome reputation for chaotic violence inside the ring was matched by his fearless disregard for promoters' wishes outside of it. A legitimate star of the pre-Golden Era age, Brody was such a guaranteed draw that he could effectively dictate his own career, often billed as a 'special attraction' in a variety of promotions who otherwise could not book long-term around his particular demands.
In short, Brody came to a territory to win, and earn big bucks to do so. Promoters absolutely despised working with him, such was the volatile extent to which he protected his image. It was not unknown for him to say "f*ck it" and walk out on the spot if his salary demands weren't met - yet the virtual promise of a packed-out arena made Brody's whims worth the hassle. There was only one man who could afford to give into his fear and refuse to book the Pennsylvanian brute: Vince McMahon.
5. Bruno Sammartino
Though undoubtedly as rugged as all grapplers of his era came, Bruno Sammartino nevertheless possessed a reputation as one of the most warm-hearted men in the whole business.
With the obvious exception of Vince McMahon, with whom he shared a prolonged grudge for quarter of a century, it's hard to imagine the 'Living Legend' causing hassle for any promoter. Indeed, his enmity for McMahon Jr. stemmed from disgust over the WWE impresario's alleged dissemination of steroids, and latterly, his pivot to puerile content. How could a man as wholesome as a loaf of farmhouse bread ever provoke fear in his paymasters?
As gentle and generous as big Bruno was, he was still, at heart, a wrestler. Becoming the biggest star in the north east latterly imbued 'The Living Legend' with humility, but when he was starting out hungry, he was just as eager to protect himself as the next guy.
Like the man who eventually took his mantle as WWE's icon, Hulk Hogan, the budding Bruno hated the idea of losing - especially on the instruction of promoters. "I told them, 'if anybody can really beat me, fine. But that's the only way I'll go down'", he recalled in his retirement. Eventually, bookers became so afraid of being stiffed by Sammartino that they blackballed him all across the country. It was only when he proved himself a draw north of the border that those same bookers suddenly shirked their anxiety.
4. Brock Lesnar
Only one man can stand up to Vince McMahon in the 'Gratitude Era' and get away with it: Brock Lesnar. Rather than buying into the myth that he's living the dream, that he should be thankful for the opportunity with the Greatest Sports Entertainment Company in the World, 'The Beast' knows full well he's more valuable to WWE than they are to him. He could drop it all in a heartbeat without any appreciable pecuniary damage: it's all really just a question of how much money he wants for his barn of old rope.
As the industry's only true star in Vince's eyes, Brock has his employer hopelessly over the barrel - a fact he leverages whenever contract renewals come up. McMahon is desperately afraid of losing Lesnar. Why else would he pay him so much to do so little?
3. Bret Hart
The Montreal Screwjob was characterised by cowardice as much as it was misplaced pride. In the broadest strokes, Bret Hart was too proud to drop the WWE Championship to Shawn Michaels in Canada; Vince McMahon was too cowardly to trust him to do the honours otherwise.
The Hitman's pride was damaged worst by McMahon's ultimate act of cowardice on the night of Survivor Series, and as reparation he ventured to damage his face. WWE's chairman, fearing the retribution owed him, again turned yellow, fleeing backstage and locking himself in an office with lieutenants Pat Patterson and Gerald Brisco.
It was only a temporary reprieve. Under orders from The Undertaker - one of his most trusted backstage enforcers - McMahon eventually opened the door to Hart, only to walk right into his fist. Bret landed such a firm blow that McMahon sprained his ankle recoiling from it. He was right to be afraid.
2. Brian Pillman
Brian Pillman's 'Loose Cannon' gimmick blurred the tiger striations between art and reality to such a scary extent that even his colleagues could no longer see the distinction. Introduced in 1995, the character was a dramatic diversion from 'Flyin' Brian's previous incarnation as a clean-cut, athletic babyface. Now, he'd frequently slip 'shoot' comments into his promos, hang around in the sort of grungy clothing that'd become a staple of Raven's aesthetic, and generally unsettle everyone around him with his complete unpredictability.
After outing Kevin Sullivan as WCW's booker following their SuperBrawl VI match, Pillman asked Eric Bischoff to actually release him from his contract so he could develop the gimmick in ECW, before returning, now with added fillip of legitimacy. Theoretically, it was all a work - or so Bischoff believed. In reality, it was another manifestation of the 'Loose Cannon' made tangible. Pillman never came back. Bischoff later revealed that, so convinced was he by Pillman's performance - if that's what it was - that he genuinely feared for the wrestler's health.
1. Jake Roberts
In the latter half of his career, Jake Roberts, in spite of the fact he was once one of the business' most compelling draws, became as venomous to promoters as the snakes he wrapped around his neck.
He already had a fractious streak in him - Jake demanded WWE release him in 1992 with an ultimatum that he'd no-show otherwise - and this only worsened as his personal problems began to mount. A post-WCW run as Smoky Mountain Wrestling's top guy threatened to tank the company when he failed to arrive for a string of defences. His hiatus and subsequent Christian reawakening proved a false dawn; no sooner was Jake back on the independent scene than he was back off the wagon, infamously bringing the Heroes of Wrestling special into complete disrepute with his drunken antics.
After that high profile incident, no booker would dare hire Jake; the potential for disaster was just too great. Though he's seen a dramatic if occasionally faltering turnaround in his life since, largely in part thanks to the intervention of DDP, Roberts is still handled with care. Upon signing with AEW last year, Dave Meltzer mused that ultimately the promotion would regret it - as every other one in the last thirty years has.