10 Wrestlers That Bombed Twice

Those grapplers who utterly tanked time and time again.

Ultimate Warrior WWF 1996 WCW 1998
WWE

The wrestling business is one often purportedly built on opportunity. Company A gives Wrestler B a chance to do something within their organisation, and it's down to that grappler to make the most of this time in the spotlight. Of course, just how genuine these opportunities are and just how limited the ceiling of such chances are...that's a whole other conversation for a whole other day.

Still, the around-the-houses point here is that wrestlers in theory have moments in time where they can connect with an audience, get some momentum behind them, and hopefully turn themselves into true stars. On the other side of this, though, there are the times when these opportunities end in disappointment and a talent is left scratching their head as live audiences don't react and TV audiences change the channel.

For some of these wrestlers, they bombed in how they utterly failed - due to either their own fault or the fault of a particular promotion - to get a gimmick over. In the case of other names featured in this piece, some of them tanked time and time again when positioned as a top star or World Champion of a company.

With that in mind, then, here are ten wrestlers who unfortunately have the honour of failing hard on more than one occasion.

10. Mabel/Viscera

King Mabel Viscera
WWE

Just 22 years of age when he made his WWF debut in 1993, Nelson Frazier went on to spend the next 15 years in and out of the promotion through an array of different gimmicks.

Unfortunately for the 6'9" giant, it could be argued that Frazier never clicked with audiences quite as well as he did during his initial run as part of the rapping babyface Men of a Mission tandem. From there, each character tweak and new gimmick fell flat for the big lad.

While some superstars bomb because a company has little faith in them, the first lull of Nelson Frazier's career came because WWE put faith in him. As Mabel, Frazier turned heel, won the King of the Ring '95, and was placed into a rivalry with Diesel for the WWF Title.

Spectacularly, Mabel would be released by the promotion barely six months after that KOTR win.

After injuring several superstars - including damaging Diesel's spine - Mabel was fired shortly after the 1996 Royal Rumble. He would make his full-time return to the company at the '99 Rumble, soon taking on the Viscera persona as part of the Undertaker's Ministry. One of the many lumbering goons of 'Taker's stable, the highlight of this run for Big V was a solitary reign with the Hardcore Title.

By August 2000, Frazier would again be gone from WWF, and subsequent returns as the World's Largest Love Machine and Big Daddy V both absolutely tanked.


9. Jinder Mahal

Jinder Mahal
WWE

Whether it was at the side of the Great Khali, against the Great Khali, feuding with Ryback, or as part of 3MB, Jinder Mahal's first WWE run - which started in 2011 - got progressively worse before the performer was released from his contract in mid-2014.

Of course, Jinder's return to the company two years later famously (or should that be infamously?) led to him defeating Randy Orton at Backlash 2017 to become WWE Champion.

One cannot argue the incredible shape Mahal got himself into by the time of that return, but even the biggest of Jinder fans would surely find it tough to claim the Modern-Day Maharaja's run as WWE Champion was anything but a complete failure.

Across a painful 170-day reign, Jinder made the WWE Title picture into must-miss TV. His long, monotonous promos were nauseating, his matches - including PPV bouts against Orton and Shinsuke Nakamura - were glacial in pace, and his presence at the top of the WWE tree saw SmackDown's viewership tumble.

Sure, Jinder Mahal as WWE Champion was arguably a worthwhile experiment when taking into account WWE's desire to breach the Indian market. That experiment should've been cut off at the knees way, way earlier than it ultimately was, with AJ Styles thankfully, eventually bringing Mahal's WWE Title run to a halt at a November 2017 episode of SmackDown.


8. Modercai/Kevin Thorn

Mordecai Kevin Thorn
WWE.com

When it comes to bombing hard twice, one of the first names that comes to mind is Kevin Fertig.

Having spent two years in the OVW developmental territory, Fertig began appearing in SmackDown vignettes to hype the impending arrival of Mordecai in 2004. A religious nut who was out to punish any and all sinners, this character sported white hair, a white goatee, all-white attire, and was earmarked for a WrestleMania 21 match against the Undertaker.

Instead, Mordecai's run on the main roster lasted barely two months before he was sent back to Ohio Valley Wrestling where he'd be released almost immediately.

According to Fertig in a Sportskeeda interview last year, that release was down to a bar fight he was involved in, but regardless, he was done with WWE in July 2005. Well, until the organisation relaunched ECW a year later.

There, Thorn would resurface as Kevin Thorn, a vampire character who was intended to be aligned with Gangrel before those plans were changed. Much like 95% of the WWE iteration of ECW, Thorn's time there was a dud and he'd again be sent back to OVW in early-2008 and would depart the WWE umbrella entirely the following January.


7. Isaac Yankem/Fake Diesel

Isaac Yankem Diesel Glenn Jacobs
WWE

As Kane, Glenn Jacobs portrayed one of the greatest creations in WWE history and rightly landed himself a spot in the company's Hall of Fame in 2021. Prior to becoming the Big Red Machine, though, Jacobs was bogged down with two of the worst wrestling gimmicks of all time.

To be honest, the big lad's pre-WWF days in the USWA as the Christmas Creature and Doomsday weren't exactly box office gold, but Glenn's initial forays into the World Wrestling Federation landed him with two personas he's eager to forget. Of course, first up on that front was Isaac Yankem, DDS, the villainous dentist of Jerry Lawler.

The Yankem character debuted in mid-1995 and soon became embroiled in Lawler's feud with Bret Hart. With the WWF continuing to turn audiences off with the array of stupid occupation-driven gimmicks, the appearance of an evil dentist was the last thing that fans wanted to see.

Unsurprisingly, DDS was off TV by April '96, but another horrendous gimmick was around the corner for Glenn Jacobs. Resurfacing that September, Jacobs was tasked with taking over the Diesel schtick from the departed Kevin Nash.

Not just was this a ridiculous concept, but the truth of the matter was the Diesel wasn't particularly a gimmick. Instead, it was simply Kevin Nash being Kevin Nash under a different mantle. After the then-WWF hyped the return of Diesel - and Razor Ramon, for that matter - Jacobs and Rick Bognar (Fake Razor) were immediate laughing stocks when Big Daddy Cool and the Bad Guy were brought back to Raw by Jim Ross.


6. Alberto Del Rio/Alberto El Patron

Alberto Del Rio Alberto El Patron
WWE/IMPACT

Regardless of how much he split opinion during his initial WWE run, Vince McMahon's organisation clearly thought highly of the former Dos Caras Jr. upon signing him in 2009. Debuting on SmackDown in August 2010 - after a spell in FCW - Del Rio was pushed hard, winning the Royal Rumble just five months after making his WWE in-ring debut.

A WrestleMania XXVII match with World Heavyweight Champion Edge would follow, a Money in the Bank briefcase win would happen in July, and Del Rio would cash-in on CM Punk to become the WWE Champion at SummerSlam 2011. Despite tangling with all of the company's top stars and amassing four World Champion reigns, Alberto would be fired for "unprofessional conduct" in August 2014.

By October 2015, Del Rio made a well-received return to WWE at the Hell in a Cell PPV, answering John Cena's Open Challenge and becoming the new United States Champion. That run quickly fell flat, though, with the star oddly paired with Zeb Colter as his mouthpiece, before then becoming a part of the awful League of Nations stable. With his stock at an all-time low with the company, ADR was granted his release just 11 months after re-signing with WWE.

Alberto would bomb again just over a year later, although this time for very different reasons. Having unified the IMPACT World Championship and the Global Force Wrestling Championship as Alberto El Patron, the star would be stripped of his gold and suspended by IMPACT Wrestling in July 2017 due to a domestic abuse incident involving then-partner Paige.

Once back from that suspension in November '17, it didn't take long for IMPACT to outright fire El Patron, with him released the following April after no-showing a cross-promotional show that also featured Lucha Underground.


5. Michael McGillicutty/Curtis Axel

Michael McGillicutty Curtis Axel
WWE

*Sigh* If only Joe Hennig could've been, well, Joe Hennig...

We'll never know if the son of Mr. Perfect, and the grandson of Larry the Axe, could've become a serious player in the industry, but he'd have had a hell of a better chance of doing so if he wasn't lumbered with the ludicrous Michael McGillicutty moniker when he turned up in the original gameshow iteration of NXT in 2010.

As is so often the case with WWE talent, that name was so jarring, so ridiculous, so unnatural, and it didn't help when the poor lad stumbled through his infamous "genesis of McGillicutty" promo.

Sure, his initial main roster run as part of the Nexus saw him become a WWE Tag Team Champion, but the third generation star was back in NXT barely a year later. Still operating under the gameshow model at that time, McGillicutty would remain in NXT as it underwent its transition as the rebranded FCW.

After two years away from the main roster, the Minnesota native returned to Raw under the guise of Curtis Axel and under the stewardship of Paul Heyman. While the new name likewise wasn't all that great, it did at least lean more into the real-life Joe Hennig's family roots - and it also soon led to him becoming Intercontinental Champion.

Despite holding that once-prestigious prize for five months, Axel became an afterthought of WWE programming, and it didn't take long for the Axe Man to start doing daft sh*t like AxelMania, the Social Outcasts, and later the Miztourage and the B-Team.


4. El Gigante/Giant Gonzalez

El Gigante Giant Gonzalez
WWE

By all accounts, Jorge Gonzalez was a lovely, lovely fella. Unfortunately, he was also an awful, awful wrestler.

Billed as an 8-foot, 460 lbs behemoth - in reality, Jorge was still a staggering 7'7" and more around the 420 lbs mark - it's easy to see why any and all wrestling promoters would be tripping over themselves to bring the Argentinian into their promotion.

After knee problems brought a halt to Gonzalez's NBA career before it could even get going, Ted Turner decided to take a punt on the giant and sign him to WCW in 1989. With barely a year's training under his belt, the then-24-year-old made his WCW bow at Capitol Combat: Return of the RoboCop in May '90.

Despite mixing it up on TV and live events with top stars such as the Four Horsemen, Sting, Lex Luger, Paul Orndorff, Junkyard Dog, the Steiner Brothers, and the smooth-as-silk Bobby Eaton, it just never clicked for El Gigante as a top tier player in WCW. Regardless of how intriguing his size made him, poor Jorge just couldn't do much of anything between the ropes.

Skip ahead to WWF Royal Rumble 1993, and Jorge - as Giant Gonzalez - arrived in Vince McMahon's sports entertainment juggernaut and was immediately paired off with the Undertaker. Following successive losses to the Deadman at that year's WrestleMania and SummerSlam, Gonzalez was out of WWF by October '93 after failing to substantially impress company higher-ups.

Sadly, Jorge Gonzalez would pass away at the age of just 44 in 2010 due to heart issues and complications from diabetes.


3. Ultimate Warrior

Ultimate Warrior WWF 1996 WCW 1998
WWE

Some may argue that the Ultimate Warrior's solitary run as WWF Champion was a dud, with the chase very much being more exciting than the catch for the Parts Unknown native. After toppling Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania VI to take the company's top prize, Warrior's subsequent TV matches saw him decimating talents he'd already decimated, including a rehashing of his Rick Rude rivalry from the year prior, and the politically-savvy shadow of Hulkamania was also never too far away.

Still, it's tough to properly poo-poo this initial WWE run, even if you take into account the post-SummerSlam '91 suspension/resignation, the return at WrestleMania VIII, and the post-SummerSlam '92 drug test failure and exit that caused.

What were totally farcical, though, were Warrior's extremely brief WWF 1996 run and his not-quite-as-brief-but-still-super-short WCW 1998 run.

Amidst plentiful hype, that '96 return saw the Ultimate One show up to dominate Hunter Hearst Helmsley at WrestleMania XII. Baseball caps, comic book promotion, and promos that were now more preachy than just outright uninterpretable, Warrior felt out of place from the moment he appeared on Raw the week after 'Mania.

Just six matches and barely three months later, Warrior was fired after no-showing several house shows.

Skipping ahead to 1998, the real-life Jim Hellwig had a dreadful six-month run in WCW that's best remembered for spooky sh*t and a god-awful rematch with Hulk Hogan at that year's Halloween Havoc.


2. Sycho Sid

Sycho Sid enters The Garden for one of the biggest matches of his career.
WWE.com

As a physical specimen, few can ever match the look of the real-life Sid Eudy. Similarly, intensity-wise, Sid was also head and shoulders above most of his peers throughout a career that would technically amass 30 years before the Master and the Ruler of the World officially hung up his boots in 2017.

Upon landing in the then-WWF as Sid Justice in mid-1991, the famed softball enthusiast could've feasibly made for a great monster heel World Champion. Feeling fresh and unlike anything else on the roster at the time, Sid's quest for the WWF Championship at that point fell short thanks to fellow heel Ric Flair and the Nature Boy's legendary Royal Rumble 1992 victory.

Justice would depart WWF shortly after his WrestleMania VIII showdown with Hulk Hogan, but a return to the promotion would eventually happen in 1995. As part of what would become a two-year stint with the Federation this time around, Sid - now known as Sycho Sid - would amass two reigns as the WWF Champion.

Sadly, both of these reigns flopped hard.

The first World Title win came at Survivor Series '96, where Sid defeated Shawn Michaels for the gold merely because the Heartbreak Kid refused to drop the company's biggest prize to Vader. This didn't make a jot of difference to business, and Sid would lose the belt back to Michaels at Royal Rumble '97.

Still, Sid would end up back with the WWF Championship in time for WrestleMania 13... where he and the Undertaker headlined the Showcase of the Immortals with the lowest buyrate in history.


1. Jeff Jarrett

Jeff Jarrett
WWE/IMPACT

"Ain't I great?"

Err, kind of. At times.

Across his time in WCW and TNA, Jeff Jarrett is in the record books as a ten-time World Champion. While your writer here is admittedly a Double J fan, the positioning of Jarrett as the top guy in either of those promotions never particularly worked out all that well.

As an in-ring talent, the third generation star was undoubtedly a great mechanic, a trusted hand, and could work with pretty much anyone on the card. A decent talker who could generate steady heat - even if said heat often relied on the easy 'out' of guitar shots - nobody can say that Jeff Jarrett was bad. The problem is, the Chosen One was one of those talents who makes for a solid upper-midcard heel, rather than being the person to steer the ship at the top of the mountain.

In fairness to Jarrett, his final run in WCW was at a time when the promotion was very much a sinking ship. Still, in the space of the company's final year, Jeff won WCW's top prize four times. The World Heavyweight Champion for a cumulative 59 days, Jarrett's time on top did zero to halt WCW's nosedive.

For his six reigns as 'the man' in TNA, the blame very much can lie with Jeff - for he was the person who co-founded the promotion and so often handled the creative. A total of 1,006 days leading the charge there, J-E-Double F again struggled to be any sort of genuine draw.


Watch Next


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.