10 Wrestlers That Can't Exist In Real Life
For when the mask can't slip.
Don’t take the title of this list as a pre-requisite skill for all pro wrestlers.
The game is rooted in suspension of disbelief, after all. It matters not what a wrestler does out of the ring if audiences can buy in to what they get up to at their place of work. The very idea that a 20x20 roped bit of canvas in front of television cameras might be the perfect place to settle personal disputes requires the switching off of any cynicism no matter the match or wrestler.
If a viewer can manage that - as they do when watching every film or television show ever made - then the story can finally be told. And yet, the overlap to the other side of the screen rarely gets easier. For every John Cena or Miz parroting everything perfectly, the lines are often still awkwardly blurred.
The recent passing of television icon Regis Philbin brought with it a reminder of all the times he made wrestlers and the profession look fantastic, but even he might have struggled with some of the ones below. You can take any of them out of pro wrestling, but you'll struggle to ever take the pro wrestling out of them...
10. Hulk Hogan
It goes without saying that Hulk Hogan could - at his peak - talk shop outside of the industry without compromising his character.
An infamous inadvertent incident with Richard Belzer aide, 'The Hulkster' was convivial and coherent despite his size and typically overblown character. If anything, his ability to shine in that particular spotlight made clear just how tight Vince McMahon's grasp on North America's pulse really was.
Hogan was so bloody aspirational that Regan-era families and young yuppies alike that he fit into society almost exactly as he was. If only it were that easy as wrestling began to pass him by.
The man trained to expertly deceive for all of his career had suddenly lost sight of the difference between shoot and work, even if we were still the "jabronie marks without a life". Either because he couldn't or simply wouldn't embrace the real world completely, Hogan's life in the industry forever confused the truth. Little fibs in passing became tap-touching whoppers in autobiographies and interviews, and nothing that emerged from underneath that fu manchu ever sounded quite so legitimate again.
9. Matt Hardy
Matt Hardy's gimmick can't exist in real life... but why would he want it that way?
Teleportation might have p*ssed off a few purists when Hardy first arrived in All Elite Wrestling to confront Chris Jericho on behalf of The Elite, but it was informed by just about everything else he's put into the gimmick since devising it in 2016. Nothing is real, because leaving reality behind was the best thing for him.
Few performers have permission to float between personas as Hardy does, all within the the context of his character. Finding the perfect balance for his gimmicks to all work on their own terms in the immensely profitable twilight of his career, the elder Hardy stretches suspension of disbelief without snapping it. Compared to younger brother Jeff having to open up about his very personal battles for an alcohol-fuelled feud with Sheamus, Matt's commitment to a bit half a world away is breezy and believable.
8. Bray Wyatt
Sigh.
At the prospect of welcoming yet more rage from Bray Wyatt's incredibly dedicated fanbase, here's some criticism that comes with some objective evidence. Almost all of the gimmick is irredeemable bullsh*t that survives because standards are lower.Wyatt could and does exist in the real world, as highlighted by him celebrating the safe arrival of his child in full Fiend get-up, but should he? And isn't this just part of the wider problem with comparisons made to The Undertaker of old, or castigations of WWE not "getting" this gimmick when Wyatt himself could probably do with rethinking it too.
The Fiend/Mr Rogers stuff was a chance at a second life, but Windham Rotunda is more than happy to park the persona at the door and WWE were over-keen to monetise it to actual death the (far too early) second he became Universal Champion.
Ultimately, they get to get rich and win, even if the character will forever be one of the biggest losers on the show.
7. Shane McMahon
For the longest time, Shane McMahon appeared to represent the affable branch of his bizarre family tree, but that might just have been because he didn't appear on television for the better part of seven years.
It took that big a gap to create any sense of nostalgia for any of the McMahon clan, but it didn't take 'The Money' long to get back to putting that where his constantly-running mouth was.
The signs were evident before his comeback match against The Undertaker. What should have been booked as a pummelling reframed itself as a fair fight thanks to McMahon flashing his abs and posting videos of his intense MMA training. Going blow-for-blow in an artless stinker with 'The Deadman' turned into being the only man fit to lead SmackDown's 2016 Survivor Series team against Raw and matching AJ Styles' wrestling pedigree at the following WrestleMania.
None of this felt remotely believable even if the stunts looked good - but that paradox has preserved his drawing power somewhat as a result. There's no world where McMahon's the best wrestler in the world, other than the insane one in which his father literally hands him a trophy to confirm it.
6. Seth Rollins
Alright, Seth Rollins clearly does really well in real life, but he'd complete the game entirely if he stopped playing the daftest one in his pocket.
'The Monday Night Messiah' worked incredibly hard to become a made man in a system that once upon a time would have spat him straight back out. Arguably the most dynamic member of The Shield from an in-ring point of view, he ascended quickly in an era where few managed to, and survived the choppy waters of the midcard before a 2019 push that transformed his life for the best and worst of reasons.
A real life relationship with Becky Lynch shouldn't have ever made it to air, but clearly fulfilled him in a way that could have made flying the WWE flag not quite as necessary as it seemed to be. Picking the weekend of the ill-fated Stomping Grounds pay-per-view was a poor call, as was "doubling down", as was throwing shade at one of his best friends making a different career choice, as was getting into a money fight with another wrestler, as was earnestly trying to defend the talent whilst missing the point of Twitter's complaints as was as was as was.
It appears that Rollins is fundamentally good, and it's nice when good things happen to good people. But he's so entrenched within a system that doesn't remotely reward it, that it'll never truly feel that way until he's removed himself entirely.
5. Abyss
Man-behind-the-mask Chris Parks found the perfect way for Abyss to exist amongst regular humans when he portrayed Joseph Parks - the mild-mannered cousin of 'The Monster'.
It clung together enough to make sense in TNA storylines, but the same couldn't be said for Abyss' skin. Routinely ripped open by increasingly daft stipulations, the flesh torn up by barbed wire, thumbtacks and broken glass over the years left the current WWE agent in need of one horrifying spot per-big match to stay over. As the novelty of that wore off, so too did his star aura as the company tried and ultimately failed to expand beyond itself in the mid-2000s.
"Clean cut" might have been used to describe an element of Abyss, but not quite in the context required. The gimmick or Parks outside of it could never be the homegrown ambassador TNA (and allegedly Hulk Hogan, who loved the gimmick) needed. Not least with its psycopathic origins feeling confined to pro wrestling's past.
4. Stephanie McMahon
Stephanie McMahon's Twitter bio serves as a slightly smug reminder that she's an occasional TV villain, as if to inform the legions that actually buy into her product to not buy in quite that much.
It's presumably to stave off abuse, but on the off chance it works, she's inadvertently breaking the immersion required to understand anything her character actually does. A botherer and bully of heels and faces alike, her overall authority over the wrestlers is unclear, as is her constant motivation to be truly awful to her subordinates.
One can only assume she's seen this in others in her workplace, but she's only ever had one of those and the boss has been the same since the first day she started. Moulded by her surname and the inordinate wealth that has cocooned her from the real world for most of her time anywhere near it, her monied safeguarded existence has never felt so separate from a world under invisible threat.
3. Triple H
For the longest time now, Triple H has been pitched as the man that should take over WWE if and when Vince McMahon shuffles off this mortal coil. Plenty argue it should have already happened. Is more evidence required to highlight why 'The Cerebral Assassin' cannot possibly be part of the proletariat?
A mastermind for good and evil in his career, Hunter had a head for the game long before he named himself in honour of it, hiding in plain sight as Shawn Michaels' cleaner friend that would do the jobs his best buddy wouldn't. A victory for his loyalty and foresight, 'The King Of Kings' became too good to be denied (for about a year) then forged an entirely new path as a future heir.
Alongside wife Stephanie McMahon, he's tried and occasionally succeeded to put a human face on "nnnnnDadddddddddd"s organisation, but his own one has weathered significantly under the ridiculous pressure that puts on somebody. At some point he made the choice to submit to that, unending riches be damned.
Nobody in his position can ever have their feet on the ground - he's never off that f*cking jet.
2. Vince McMahon
The standard line on Vince McMahon used to be that the Mr. McMahon character was an obscene exaggeration of a corporate monster rather than the typical "turn your real-life self up to 11" cliche.
So what exactly is the "steak wrap" aficionado like behind the scenes these days? Without the man himself playing a significant role on television anymore, we can only use his wrestling product to judge him on how he views the world. And on that evidence, he's obviously gotten too weird for it.
Long before the ongoing global b*stard appeared with all the welcome energy of The Fiend at the front door of the Firefly Fun House, McMahon was losing viewers by the thousands and being forced for the first time in decades to shoot shows in buildings that may as well have been three-sided.
With the pushes of both Hulk Hogan and Stone Cold Steve Austin, McMahon was rooted firmly in reality, and the characters wouldn't have worked without the footprint being so deeply ingrained in what the public wanted. By comparison, the push of Roman Reigns may as well have been him trying to land one on the surface of the moon without a spacesuit.
It's not the McMahon can't touch reality anymore. It's that he won't.
1. Kane
Other than his rather single-minded sartorial selections, there was a lot of fun to be had on The Undertaker's "Last Ride" WWE Network series thanks to 'The Deadman' opening the book on himself out-of-character for one of the first and only times in his career.
There will never be a "Kane: Putting Out The Fire" serial based on his storyline sibling.
Playing fast and loose with the character for most of its wonky existence, WWE have torched their cake and eaten it too over and over again with the gimmick, to the point that Glenn Jacobs was able to include a red and black flame in his campaign iconography when first attempting to become the Mayor of Knoxville.
Of course man behind the mask Jacobs has subsequently freed himself up for life when it comes to outside engagements. Sadly, 'The Big Red Machine' cannot be rationalised or reframed to make sense in the real world, no matter how many frat parties Triple H seemed to think he was attending during the Katie Vick programme.
The HARDEST Kane Quiz Ever