10 Wrestlers That NOBODY Hated

They say you can't make it without making some critics along the way. They are wrong.

Kurt Angle
WWE

You might think CM Punk is one of the last great wrestlers, a talent who takes care not to indulge in easy, self-conscious tropes, to make every beat mean something. Others might think he's too ambitious, can't tell himself what he can't do, and botches too often, breaking the spell.

You might think Kenny Omega is the most physically impressive wrestler of all time, with strikes so barbaric you're amazed he doesn't hurt his opponents and a grasp of crowd psychology so masterful that nobody else can make an arena throb and shriek as he does, Others might think his maximalist tendencies can verge on the artless, and that his facials are a bit much.

You might think Matt Hardy is a carny tortoise who is incompetent at benefitting the younger talent he gloms onto. Others might hold onto their memories of 2001.

Virtually every single wrestler, even the most critically acclaimed, has their detractors. Will Ospreay is the critical darling du jour, an amazing pro wrestler versed in many styles and philosophies, but to some, it's all a bit much, a bit desperate. Like he structures his matches for the asterisks.

There's no such thing as objectivity in art - or is there...?

10. Samoa Joe

Samoa Joe
WWE.com

It's just as well that this AEW run has rejuvenated his career: for a long time, what became of Samoa Joe was a disgrace.

Joe possessed an aura that only a fool could ruin. He wrestled Kenta Kobashi and was received as a contemporary of an all-time great just a few years after he exploded on the North American independent scene. That's how incredible Joe was. Between 2002 and 2006, he had wrestled the best deathmatch ever, the best King's Road-style match ever that wasn't worked between the Five Pillars, and, in his unforgettable series with CM Punk, redefined what a great North American match looked like. It's difficult to convey just how much of a God Joe was at the time.

Put it this way: he received the sort of plaudits most wrestlers only do years after their work stood the test of time, just endless, histrionic praise, and nobody worth listening to tried to be a contrarian about it, which tends to happen in those situations. There was no backlash. Joe was backlash-proof. It was just accepted that Joe, as intimidating as any other wrestler ever, was the absolute man - because he was.

WWE thought he was too fat, and Vince Russo put a penis on his face because he fundamentally never grasped that you don't have to ruin everything with a bad gimmick.


9. Kenta Kobashi

Kenta Kobashi All Japan 90s
All Japan Pro Wrestling

Even the vaunted Four Pillars of All Japan Pro Wrestling's 'King's Road' era drew pedantic critique.

Despite arguably working the most great matches of them all, Mitsuharu Misawa was stoic and thus cold to some, who couldn't get into those timeless classics at an emotional level. Akira Taue was underrated - so much so that some contrarians deem him the best of the four - but he was also the least consistent big-match worker. Toshiaki Kawada was the perfect puro heel, but Kenta Kobashi was the most universally great working babyface perhaps ever.

Watch him in one of the best tag team matches ever, alongside Misawa against Kawada and Taue, on June 9, 1995. Kobashi carried a storyline injury into it. He was more bandage than leg. Kawada, playing his nastiness brilliantly, aimed a kick at it immediately. The look on Kobashi's face was awesome. He looked mortally offended and irate all at once, at this lack of sportsmanship, which set the tone for quite possibly the selling masterclass of the entire form. He sells that limb like his career is over either way and he might as well face it like a warrior. It is amazing: the simplest story elevated by the most authentic, stirring, live-and-die performance. Kenta Kobashi firing up and kicking ass is the best of the pro wrestling experience, distilled.

To not enjoy Kenta Kobashi is to not enjoy pro wrestling.


8. GUNTHER

Gunther WWE
WWE

GUNTHER is the heel version of Kenta Kobashi.

Both men achieve what should be the impossible with their seminal in-ring game: perfect balance. Where Kobashi was a giant of a man who could nonetheless fight and fight from underneath and convince you that he was in agony, up against some insurmountable task, GUNTHER is exceptional at the control period.

His is the hardest role to execute. As a sort of latter-day workrate André the Giant, he was the territory's final boss in the European indie scene of the late 2010s. Losing to him was an inevitability; the best one could hope for was a dignified loss, perhaps at a push a career-making moment.

TrIple H isn't a bold booker, but then, he doesn't have to be. He's very good at doing the simple things well, and he installed GUNTHER as a super-credible warlord who simply doesn't lose. GUNTHER has to pace his matches very carefully. He can't dent his aura too much, but he needs to create at least one moment of doubt in every match to keep fans on the hook throughout what is a very, very long reign.

An anti-cringe wrestler, GUNTHER can make you wince, lick your lips at the taste of blood, and clutch your own chest as if you yourself have been chopped.

A disciplined, slow-burn, believable wrestler who can work Match of the Year candidates with next to zero excess: GUNTHER is "how it used to be", but the romanticised version made flesh.


7. Bianca Belair

Bianca Belair
WWE.com

The worst thing one could write or say about Bianca Belair is that she isn't necessarily the most interesting character to watch week-to-week.

Is that because the character - not the performer - has few if any flaws, and it's thus very difficult to buy her struggle? Or is it because WWE's booking of the women's scene, in general, is apathetic despite an improved degree of screen-time parity?

Regardless, as a big match performer, there are few better than Bianca Belair.

She was born to steal the show in a huge stadium setting, the likes of which is very difficult. You can almost - almost - buy the idea that the wrestlers who make it in WWE believe that only making it in WWE counts. There's a nonsensical element to that, but also, a lot of otherwise great wrestlers haven't been able to get it done in front of 60,000-plus people at least once. Triple H has failed about half the time. Edge, AJ Styles, Chris Jericho, CM Punk, the Undertaker: all at some point or another have wet the bed at WrestleMania.

Bianca excels at stadium wrestling. Her strength and dramatic timing is off the charts - she has an unreal ability to register how impressive her already impressive spots actually are - and she's such a gifted athlete and likeable performer that her big matches are always emotive, exciting masterclasses. She just gets how to project to the back row that can barely even see her.

Since 2021, there's been no more a universal wrestler than Bianca Belair.


6. Rey Mysterio

Rey Mysterio
WWE.com

Rey Mysterio is the closest thing to a career babyface in the era of relentless prime-time episodic television.

One of the most exciting talents ever, his early work was so mind-blowing and futuristic that it still hasn't dated. Much of that has to do with the fact that his influence was so profound: multiple, countless wrestlers work his style or an interpretation of it to this day. To use just one example, the Young Bucks' lucha-tinged offence is heavily indebted to Rey's work. If you go back and watch his best '90s output now, it is still pulsating, tight, utterly dazzling. It's magic, in that you don't know how he did it.

He was also so good at the core ideals of the art that he boasts longevity like few others. Beneath the mask, he emoted brilliantly. He intersected bumping and selling to create an exhilarating and emotive experience. He was so great that he mostly defied a certain trend: the more a wrestler bumps, the more they expose themselves and elicit a certain resentment. The medium is cruel like that, but Rey's body of work so was so consistently great that he developed more respect as the years rolled by.

At a push, fans were bored of Rey by 2013. He'd been around forever, he'd slowed down, the injuries piled up - but it was a blip, and by 2018 he was somehow as great as ever.


5. Hiroshi Tanahashi

Jon Moxley Hiroshi Tanahashi
All Elite Wrestling

Of all the huge New Japan stars of the resurgence era, Hiroshi Tanahashi was unimpeachable.

Shinsuke Nakamura was also too good to draw good faith criticism throughout the early-to-mid 2010s, but he dented his legacy with his apathetic WWE run. Tetsuya Naito upsets the safety police and while some enjoy this ironically, he is guilty of phoning it in on occasion. Kazuchika Okada is wonderful at crafting very, very long main events, in which the unsolvable puzzle is unparalleled at generating support on behalf of his opponents, but he draws backlash for going long for the sake of it on occasion.

Tanahashi cannot be criticised in good faith. He is a flawless pro wrestler, the absolute master at knowing when to do something. The man executes a dragon screw leg whip in virtually every match. You never see it coming and yet he always does it when it makes the most sense, when the fans are absolutely convinced that he's out of the fight.

He thinks deeply about his craft with a super-disciplined approach, only busting out something as spectacular as, for example, a reverse hurricanrana, in the right context. He only blew Kenny Omega away with that after Omega had buried him for being old and safe and boring in their meta-premised Wrestle Kingdom 13 programme.

He is finished these days, which often elicits resentment - but everybody just wants him to retire happily without actively campaigning for it.


4. Ricky Steamboat

Ricky Steamboat Intercontinental Championship
WWE

In 1989, people may have preferred Ric Flair to Ricky Steamboat, but only because Flair was both the coolest and best wrestler on the planet at the time.

Ricky Steamboat wasn't entirely the babyface in that programme, but he got the fans onside by blowing Flair away with every chop. Those matches were furious, lung-bursting sprints that were also, somehow, marathons - just relentless, gorgeous pro wrestling.

A lot of the same moves happen in every wrestling match by era. The art is in the timing and the pacing, and Steamboat encapsulated this perfectly at WrestleMania 25 against Chris Jericho. While it helped - enormously - that his work stood in contrast to the mummified Roddy Piper and Jimmy Snuka, Steamboat underscored his timeless brilliance by running through his 1980s repertoire and getting it more over, in 2009, than anything else on the card except the Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels match. Watching Steamboat skin the cat, making it feel like he needed your support to get back up, was the work of a true master.

Steamboat is shorthand for career babyface for a reason: he never turned because nobody ever wanted to jeer him.


3. Big E

Big E WWE Champion Day 1
WWE.com

People wanted the world for Big E, so much so that many felt bad when he did eventually win the World title - much too late - due to the circumstances.

When he cashed in the Money In The Bank briefcase in 2021, he did so in advance, but he defeated a storyline-injured Bobby Lashley. Big E felt opportunistic, even callous, in the moment. He didn't survive against all expectations. He didn't headline WrestleMania after an arduous stint in the Royal Rumble. The odds were stacked against his heel opponent.

It was very much a consolation prize, a tactic with which to not lose against Monday Night Football in quite so humiliating a fashion.

Big E deserved something far grander because he - in the worst of twilight years, game-is-gone Vince McMahon creative - survived something far more gruelling than entering the Rumble at #1. He endured WWE's worst period of booking ever and became, in spite of it, a super-over babyface with universal appeal. Highly entertaining in segments, he was a low-key maniac in the ring - that spear to the outside was framed as the sort of risk all high spots should be - and while you never can tell in this parasocial era, he seemed like one of the most honest, principled and nice dudes ever to step foot in a gross business.

The old cliché has never applied more: if you don't like Big E, you are the problem.


2. Eddie Guerrero

Eddie Guerrero
WWE

Eddie Guerrero was one of the very best all-rounders ever.

He was never as much of a star as, say, Steve Austin, who was right up there in the conversation, but Guerrero could cycle through modes that bit more easily. Austin could do it all, but if there was one flaw to his game, it's that he couldn't effectively play heel after making it as a megastar babyface. It was hard to love to hate Austin, because everything he did felt like an over-correction. He was just unpleasant to watch, since he had to go to such loathsome extremes to get heat.

Guerrero was different; he was able to play a sinister, despicable man in his 2005 series with Rey Mysterio which while silly and soapy was inordinately effective. The ratings data bears that out, too. This followed Eddie's emotive, unforgettable triumph against Brock Lesnar at No Way Out 2004. Fans didn't really despise Eddie, who hadn't turned because they had grown bored of him.

He was simply very useful, and could do literally everything: blow you away with his stunningly crisp, beautiful ring work, charm you with his daft wit with not-great material that he elevated, and make you forget how much you liked him with his heel flair.

If Eddie Guerrero wasn't quite the greatest all-rounder ever, that can only leave...


1. Kurt Angle

Kurt Angle
WWE

Is Kurt Angle the perfect, flawless professional wrestler?

He boasts a legitimate background, if that's important to you. You'd struggle to find a more believable pro. His intensity was off the charts. Beyond the physical element, in his huge matches, it was impossible not to fall under his spell. This is a man who with more mouth than face, he was that lost in the role of a psychopath, screamed "I'll break your f**king ankle!" to the Rock at No Way Out 2000.

His matches were incredible, whether he was doing big match WWE theatre, going hold-for-hold with world-class technicians who held decades more experience than he did, or executing moonsaults off the top of steel cages.

If you're a sicko, a nihilist, madman Angle enchanted you with his utterly demented TNA run. He should not have been in that ring, realistically, and still went harder than everybody else. Aficionados of "real graps" worship Kurt as their God, and even the most casual, lapsed Attitude Era fan still delights at Angle's mastery of sports entertainment. The goofball was just ingenious at the "ga-ga" of it all. The facial expression he pulled when inadvertently casting himself as a sexual deviant in his feud with Rey Mysterio (pictured) is just unbelievable.

The timing he possessed for everything - comedy, execution, everything - was inch-perfect.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!