10 Wrestlers That Only Seemed Cool When You Were A Kid

Cringe at your Ultimate Warrior doll at the back of your wardrobe.

If you've been a wrestling fan for a long time, you can probably think back to your youth and remember who stood out as some of your favourite performers. Some of these wrestlers may have withstood the test of time, going down in the history books as true legends. Others wrestlers who you thought were amazing as a kid may not have aged as gracefully. As a matter of fact, some wrestlers may have only seemed cool because you were but an innocent babe, not yet jaded by years of mediocrity and the collective criticism of smarks.

Tastes change with age and time and this is certainly true with pro-wrestling appreciation. While outlandish and outrageous gimmicks may have appealed to our pre-pubescent mindset, in retrospect we may look back at some of these guys as sub-par performers who were nothing more than one trick ponies hiding behind smoke and mirrors.

While many wrestlers can be written off as simply overrated, this collection of grapplers from the past and present belong in that specific category of performers who really aren€™t all that appealing to fans past the age of 12.

And, of course, a preemptive apology to any readers offended by any selection.


10. The Oddities

The Oddities were a stable of wrestlers who really could have only existed in the late '90s. A band of 'freaks' assembled by The Jackyl, The Oddities were made up of Kurgan (the tall guy), Giant Silva (the even taller guy), Golga (a guy in a leather gimp mask), Luna (the lady freak) and, on occasion, George 'The Animal' Steel (the nostalgic freak). Basically, no one was an actual 'freak' in the true carnival sense of the term. They were just odd...€And if that premise wasn't enough to get you on board, The Oddities were initially accompanied by The Insane Clown Posse, who also supplied the group with their entrance theme.

What you need to remember here is that this was a time when ICP had legitimate mainstream credibility and not just a cult following of loyal 'Juggalos.'€Truly a product of the time, Golga (formerly Earthquake) would even come out to the ring clutching a plush Eric Cartman figure, in a shameless attempt to cash in on the South Park craze. €Despite the fun gimmick and the ties to the pop cultural zeitgeist of the time, however, The Oddities never took off as a credible stable. They were never involved in a major angle and the quality of their matches was dismal. When the best worker in the group is Luna Vachon, you know there's a problem. Looking back at it now, The Oddities were a bottom card novelty act at best.


9. The Boogeyman

Where to start with the Boogeyman... Presumably, if you were a kid at the time of the Boogeyman's inexplicably long run, he must have come off as a pretty freaky character. Prior to his debut in October of 2004, the WWE would run teasers and vignettes telling of The Boogeyman's imminent arrival. These promos were pretty well made and succeeded in establishing a creepy atmosphere that left the audience curious about what they would get from this new wrestler.

What they got was a guy who ate worms and raw liver, had seemingly supernatural powers and who would, on occasion, smash clocks with his face. Why did he do this? What do clocks have to do with the Boogeyman mythos? These questions remain unanswered. What we do know about the Boogeyman is that he was portrayed by Martin Wright, who was 40 years old at the time of his WWE debut. The story goes that Wright lied about his age when applying to be on WWE's Tough Enough, which got him booted from the show. The higher ups, however, were apparently fond of Wright's overall look and thus gave him a bit of training and bestowed upon him the Boogeyman gimmick.

Given the strange path that Wright took to get onto the main roster, it should perhaps come as no surprise that he was not the most skilled ring technician. To compensate for his lack of skill, his matches were kept short and most of his onscreen time was devoted to crazy antics.

To a certain extent, you've got to admire his commitment to the character. He really did eat worms and raw organ meat, both of which apparently made him physically sick. €But just like kids eventually grow out being afraid of the mythical Boogey Man, wrestling fans eventually grew tired of this gimmick and seemed to collectively decide that the Boogeyman just plain sucked.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0QDhe_qdUgk


8. Glacier

Remember Glacier from WCW? No? Well, do you remember the character Sub-Zero from the Mortal Kombat video games? Because, if you can visualize the MK character, then you can definitely imagine what Glacier looked like because he was a shameless rip-off.

Pro wrestling has a bad track record when it comes to appropriating ideas from other sources of pop culture, usually because pro wrestling is always late to the game by a couple of years. So while Mortal Kombat and original franchise character Sub-Zero had been around since 1992, it was only in 1996 that Eric Bischoff and co. decided to base the Glacier character, as well as well as the even less remembered Mortis and Wrath, on figures from the game.

Hopes were high for Glacier. WCW aired tons of teasers and vignettes leading up to his debut and, according to Raymond Lloyd (the man behind the gimmick), more than a half million dollars was spent on putting together Glacier€™s outfit and his unique intro, which featured blue lasers and synthetic snow.

On paper, the idea of blue lasers and synthetic snow probably sounded great. In actuality, it was super hokey. Unless, of course, you were somewhere under the age of 15 and were either an avid MK fan or a reigning laser tag champion.

Glacier kicked around for a few years in WCW but he never lived up to the hype. Amazingly, Lloyd held onto the gimmick after he left the company proving that, for him at least, the character wasn€™t a complete career FATALITY.


7. Gangrel

So, just keep in mind that this entry is about Gangrel individually and not the entire WWF stable known as The Brood. Made up of Edge, Christian and Gangrel, The Brood was another one of those stables that reeked of the late €˜90s when shows like Buffy the Vampire Slayer were at their height. While there was much talk of The Brood€™s €˜gothic€™ lifestyle, they were basically all implied to be vampires or, at the very least, the biggest cosplay geeks ever in a time where cosplay wasn€™t nearly as much of a big deal. But while you could maybe believe that Edge and Christian were just dark and, well, brooding, Gangrel really worked the vampire angle hard.

To start with, he had the fangs. Secondly he would come out to the ring with a chalice of €˜red liquid,€™ which he would take a sip out of and spit into the air. Lastly, he wore one of those frilly white shirts that was right out of an Anne Rice novel.

If the Gangrel character would have been introduced a few years ago, he would have been dressed like a west coast teenager and covered in body glitter to better approximate the Twilight take on vampires.

If it€™s been a long time since you€™ve checked out a Gangrel match from his Attitude Era run, do so. Does anything strike you as odd about his appearance (apart from the obvious, of course)? Do you remember him as being that € husky? Seriously, how much blood did he drink? It seems like a weird point to pick on but arguably, had he had a better physique, the character may have had more longevity. Instead, that cool vampire wrestler from your youth is, in hindsight, just a chubby dude in a half-decent Halloween costume.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WaF3swauNTA


6. Koko B. Ware

Koko B. Ware is, by all accounts, a wrestling legend. He was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2009 after a prolific career that included stints in various territories and promotions. Mostly though, he€™s remembered for coming out to the ring with a parrot. And he was loved for this. Seriously, go back and watch some of your old WWF tapes or fire up the WWE Network if you€™ve got it. When it was time for Koko and his pet macaw Frankie to shine, the kids in the crowd would lose their freakin€™ mind.

Lots of wrestlers incorporated animals into their act in hopes of getting over but, arguably, this formula worked best for Koko. Sure, Jake Roberts€™ pet snake Damien played a big part in making his character so memorable, but he also had amazing promos and solid in-ring work. Koko, on the other hand, was pretty much all about that bird and colorful outfits. Also, he could sing, which made him a perfect fit for the era of Rock n€™ Wrestling.

To this day, however, I€™m sure more people can remember the name of that bird then can his finishing move. (Surprise! It was called the Bird Buster. Bust out that piece of trivia to impress your friends€ whichever friends would care enough, that is).


5. Papa Shango

Papa Shango, in many ways, was like an earlier version of The Boogeyman, except way more racist. Whereas The Boogeyman was based on a mythical figure, Papa Shango was based on so-called witchdoctors of Haiti and other countries from which came the voodoo culture. So while Hollywood had certainly plundered this actual culture for decades prior to the introduction of the character, this was nevertheless still a pretty insensitive depiction. But then, again, this wouldn€™t be the first or last time that pro-wrestling would go to the horrendous cultural stereotype well.

Papa Shango would come out to the ring decked out in skull makeup and doing his voodoo thing, shaking his staff and skull, which would emit plumes of smoke. He used curses and other supernatural tactics on his opponents, including the Ultimate Warrior, who became involved in a ridiculous angle that saw him convulsing and projectile vomiting on screen.

While Papa Shango may have had a legitimately creepy look, the theatrics and special effects felt like they were right out of an Ed Wood movie. For any fans at the time who weren€™t in the habit of wearing Transformers pajamas, the gimmick must have seemed lame and tired from the start.

Of course, the man behind Papa Shango, Charles Wright, would eventually transform into Kama Mustafa before once again shifting gears to become everyone€™s favourite pimp €“ The Godfather. Now there was a gimmick that withstood the test of time.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZSAzWvFpoE


4. Psycho Sid / Sid Vicious

Sid, in any of his incarnations in WWF/E or WCW, was a prime example of why big men will always be welcomed with open arms by pro wrestling. Because, even if they€™re only so-so in the ring and can barely talk, at the end of the day, they€™re still huge imposing figures.

At 6۪ 9۪۪, Sid had a great look and really sold the unhinged nature of his character. His finishing move was a modified release powerbomb, which looked great but must have been stiff as hell. In the eyes of a youth audience, those three elements likely made for a really awesome monster wrestler.

More seasoned fans, however, tend to look back at Sid with less appreciation. In many ways, he has even come to be a kind of punchline as his notoriously botched promos are often included in compilations of wrestling blunders. Sid€™s limited ring skills could be compensated for when he was paired with a better opponent, but it€™s hard to forget the image of his leg snapping under his own weigh as he came off the second turn buckle for a simple maneuver during a 2001 WCW match.

In addition, the persisting urban legend that he soiled himself during a match with The Undertaker has not done anything to help his reputation.

But before all these factors led to Sid being seen as a joke, he was pretty badass.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jaqLIM0Nc60


3. The Ultimate Warrior

With all due respect to The Ultimate Warrior, who passed away earlier this year in a tragic turn of events almost immediately after his induction into the WWE Hall of Fame, this was a guy who perfectly exemplified the notion of a gimmick whose appeal was inversely proportional to the age of the fan.

If you were a kid who grew up watching the WWF in the late €˜80s and early €˜90s, chances are you were an Ultimate Warrior fan. He had a great physique, killer entrance music and vibrant face paint, all of which really helped to sell his demigod-like character from €˜parts unknown.€™

And then, as you got older, you began to notice that most of his matches were incredibly short, that he only had a handful of actual wrestling moves in his repertoire (to be generous), and that his promos, in reality, were mostly made up of nonsensical screaming and snarling.

He did what he did well but the charm wore off, as evidenced by diminished crowd enthusiasm upon each of his returns from those unknown parts. Years after his monumental WWF run, when his relationship had soured with the company, he became more of an infamous character than a legend, thanks in large part to the WWE€™s release of The Self-Destruction of The Ultimate Warrior DVD, which served almost exclusively as a take-down piece.

But when all is said and done, it€™s probably best to remember Warrior during his glory years, running to the ring, shaking the ropes and lifting his opponents over his head. After all, if these memories are a high point of your childhood, why sully them?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Sg7viOeP_U


2. Brodus €˜The Funkasaurus€™ Clay

OK, so chances are that if you€™re reading this, you€™re probably an adult, or at the very least, an adolescent WWE fan. And that means that, yeah, you were probably never young enough to appreciate the merits of Brodus Clay during his Funkasaurus period, which started in 2012.

Clearly aimed at the WWE۪s youngest demographic, The Funkasaurus was a repackaging of the monstrous 6۪7۪۪, 375 lb Clay as a fun-loving, constantly dancing dinosaur of a man. Sure, the adult male fans may have appreciated some of The Funkadactyls۪ moves, but Brodus himself had been turned into nothing more than a PG-era comedy gimmick who seemed to have been plucked straight out of a Saturday morning cartoon. Naturally, he fit right into the ensemble cast of WWE۪s Scooby-Doo! WrestleMania Mystery animated film, in which he was portrayed as having an appetite that rivaled Shaggy۪s.

Somehow, it seems doubtful that the kids who were Funkasaurus marks back in the day will hold onto their tee shirts for years to come. It€™s one thing to boast about being a big D-X or Stone Cold fan back in the day, but who€™s going to admit to dancing along with Brodus Clay?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=En4Mr-E0MvM


1. John Cena

Because he€™s basically been working the same babyface gimmick for more than a decade, there€™s probably fans out there who may have started out digging John Cena when they were younger, but who now can€™t stand the guy. Vanilla ice cream, after all, is tasty, but no one is going to like it if it€™s constantly shoved down their throats for ten years. It€™s really a question of over-exposure.

Whereas the foul-mouthed Stone Cold Steve Austin was the face of the Attitude Era, John Cena is very much the face of the kid-friendly PG era we currently find ourselves in. He wears bright colours, he espouses messages of positivity and he visits sick kids all the time. Almost always overcoming adversity, he€™s not referred to as €˜Super Cena€™ for nothing. Except, when the nickname €˜Super Cena€™ is thrown around, it€™s usually by snarky adult fans who are sick and tired of the never-ending Cena push.

While he may not be the greatest wrestler of all time, he is much better in the ring than many of the people on this list, although that doesn€™t stop legions of haters from bashing him at every turn.

Yes, there are adult fans of Cena, but at least some of that love seems to be the ironic appreciation of the smarkiest of fans who delight in being contrary to the popular opinion of the Internet Wrestling Community. And really, is there anything sadder than seeing a grown man at a live WWE event decked out from head to toe in Fruity Pebbles-themed Cena merchandise? Remember, it€™s only cute when little kids wave their hands in front of their faces.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MjVkY-XducU


Contributor

I am a writer and stand-up comedian living in Montreal, Quebec, Canada. I didn't witness the Bret Hart screw job in person, but I did watch the Breaking Point PPV live and that was terrible it its own way. I am dangerously obsessed with professional wrestling and its surrounding culture. I am the current ring announcer for a local fed called the IWS. I got to introduce Tommy Dreamer a while back. My head almost exploded. I am a mark, and proud of it. I also co-host a podcast called Go Plug Yourself, which has featured quite a few local wrestlers and even Mick Foley. Speaking of the Mickster, I once got to be his warmup act when he was in town for comiccon. My head actually exploded that time. I've recovered... sort of.