10 Wrestlers Too Big To Fail (That Failed Anyway)
In the immortal words of Lenny Kravitz: it ain’t over till it’s over.
There are two scenarios where a wrestling promotion will give someone the huge, dramatic push out of nowhere: when they’re building a potential new star, and when they’re bringing in a new star from outside of the company.
That’s when you get the God-push - that sudden, dramatic shove to the top of the pyramid, displacing whoever’s already there on the way. That spot’s yours now. No one can lose it except you.
The thing is, that’s not necessarily the case: because a dozen other things can get in the way of a wrestler’s personal ambition and drive to make it to the top. Outside circumstances outside of their control, personality clashes, office politics, silly mistakes that get blown out of all proportion - the list goes on.
So what happened to those wrestlers everyone thought were set for stardom, that got the big push - and then failed anyway? This isn’t about the performers who the company buried, or never really got behind to begin with, but rather the pro wrestlers that everyone thought were too big, too much of a sure thing to fail.
10. Bobby Lashley (WWE, 2005-2008)
Back in 2006 and 2007 in his first run with the WWE, Bobby Lashley wasn’t the proven quantity he is now. Pro wrestling fans are always suspicious of the football stars, amateur wrestlers and bodybuilders who lose their dreams, opt for pro wrestling as a second best and are prioritised by the office over the guys for whom pro wrestling is a passion.
That was the case for Lashley, whose debut on Smackdown in September 2005 came ten months after his training in OVW began, following a knee injury that killed his Olympic wrestling dreams. He had the look the company loved at the time, huge and dramatic like a superhero.
WWE threw their weight behind the rookie, handing him the United States Championship in May 2006 and the ECW Championship a year and change after his debut. Although the fans still weren’t entirely behind him, the company was, high profile feud following high profile feud.
What went wrong? A number of things: scuttlebutt (like gossip in a bad relationship) was that Lashley’s then-girlfriend, WWE Diva Kristal Marshall, had been released in late 2007 for objecting to the storylines she was involved in. Supposedly Lashley had stepped in on her behalf while at home rehabilitating long term from a shoulder injury.
No longer the McMahons’ favourite son, Lashley was released in February 2008 before he was cleared to return: a case study in the importance of keeping the office sweet when their good opinion is the sole reason for your push.
9. The Big Show (WWE, 1999-2007)
Paul Wight debuted for WCW amidst great fanfare in 1995, with people talking in hushed voices about the seven foot kid with the top rope backflip, the most impressive specimen the business had ever seen.
However, like many before him he’d found that WCW’s older main event talent weren’t willing to stand aside for new faces. Vince McMahon, on the other hand, dollar signs in his eyes and tongue unrolled like a cartoon wolf, had promised him the moon. After all, if anyone knew how to market a giant it was the WWF, home of Andre the Giant. The WWF poached him in 1999.
Six years later, it was clear that this promise was horse puckey: McMahon had no idea what to do with the Big Show, as the company had called him. Booked too often to be a special attraction and too inconsistently to be the main event, Wight was losing focus, gaining weight and slowing down.
It was clear that McMahon had dismissed him as a feature player, able to be slotted into any role his size required. By the time his contract expired in 2007, Wight had had enough. He’d ballooned to 500lbs, his back was failing and he was looking into an alternative career in boxing.
A year later however, boxing having proven not to be his thing, Show was back with a new attitude: healed up, slimmer and ready to work in the midcard, feature player role that WWE had earmarked for him.
8. Dan ‘The Beast’ Severn (WWF, 1997-1999)
A legitimate hardman, a mixed martial arts pioneer and one of the first true UFC stars, Dan Severn entered the WWF in 1998 as the National Wrestling Alliance world heavyweight champion.
The former pro wrestling monopoly had fallen on hard times since the eighties, and had inked a deal to have talent appear on WWF shows. Severn, paired with motormouthed manager Jim Cornette, seemed destined for the top there too. Unfortunately it wasn’t to be, despite an initially solid hard push on his behalf from the WWF.
Part of the problem was that the NWA/WWF arrangement fell apart very quickly: it’s unlikely that Vince McMahon’s heart was really in it. This left Severn as a world champion of a promotion that WWF were no longer interested in promoting on the air - and that, plus Severn’s mixed martial arts and UFC background, were the basis for the character.
Without Cornette to speak for him, Severn found himself adrift - promos were never his forte, and his most memorable feud during this time was with MMA rival Ken Shamrock, who was also mediocre on the stick. Despite his legitimate fighting background, he withdrew from the infamous Brawl For All tournament after taking out the Godfather in the first round.
The last straw came when the office requested that he draw a 666 on his forehead and join the Undertaker’s acolytes. Stung by the utter indifference to his character after the cracking start he’d received, Severn requested his release in January 1999.
7. Vader (WWF, 1996-1998)
In early nineties WCW, Vader was the man - or monster - to beat, huge, violent and terrifying, the mask making him seem like a villain from a slasher movie: the banned kind.
That was the character: but Leon White was a fantastic wrestler, fast, agile and fearless, able to pull off a moonsault as easily as a powerbomb. One of the best big men in the business, he’d cut his teeth in Japan and perfected his craft all over the world. In short, he was a McMahon wet dream - and when he was signed in 1995 he came in hot, with all the signs of a significant push.
Why didn’t he work out in the WWF? The word is that the crippling office politics of the mid-to-late nineties stood in his way. Back then, Shawn Michaels was hip deep in the drug addiction and superficial selfishness phase of his career, and had a sleeper hold on the top spot. Vince McMahon was infatuated with the charismatic Michaels, and when the Heartbreak Kid didn’t like you, you didn’t last.
Vader (the character) was given opportunities at the title, but Vader (the wrestler) was being sidelined. His monster aura was gradually diminished by losses in the big matches, and a poorly-conceived, poorly-managed babyface turn sapped any momentum he might have had left.
6. The Fabulous Freebirds (WWF, 1984)
In the early eighties, the Fabulous Freebirds - Michael ‘P.S’ Hayes, Terry ‘Bam Bam’ Gordy and Buddy ‘Jack’ Roberts - were the last name in tag team wrestling, over like clover wherever they went.
Arguably the first cool heels to get the fans behind them (the clear blueprint for D-Generation X), they were the obvious talent to bring into Vince McMahon’s new WWF, perfect for the Rock N’ Wrestling Connection. The Freebirds were rock n’ roll.
In summer 1984, the WWF was just coming off the Brawl To End It All show and looking ahead to the inaugural WrestleMania. Introduced alongside Cyndi Lauper’s manager David Wolff (the man who’d brought the Rock N’ Wrestling concept to the WWF), the Freebirds seemed like a sure thing.
Yet the Freebirds lasted barely long enough in New York to have a cup of coffee. Part of the problem was the southern wrestling thing. The McMahons saw tag teams as a means to an end, a way to build up eventual singles performers or for singles performers to tread water until their next push cycled back around. Vince McMahon was already making plans to split the band up, something that didn’t sit well with them.
The other issue was their attitude. Like many other performers from the era, the Freebirds maintained their hard-partying, bad-attitude image in real life. They were hard to control and unreliable, putting everyone’s noses out of joint backstage - supposedly, a run-in with WWF royalty Andre The Giant was the last straw.
5. Batista (WWE, 2014)
Batista’s rocket rise to the WWE main event in 2005 changed his life. Never as gifted a wrestler as his mentor Triple H or as good on the stick as John Cena, ‘The Animal’ had an intense charisma as his selling point.
When he left in 2010 to pursue acting as a second career, most predicted he’d find some small success, realise it wasn’t for him and head back to the WWE sooner rather than later. And in December 2013, vignettes began to air publicising his January return. Batista was booked to win the Royal Rumble and face Randy Orton at WrestleMania XXX.
Why did it backfire so spectacularly? Well, the company made two mistakes: dismissing the crowd’s overwhelming desire to see Daniel Bryan as the focal point of the show, and booking Batista as a babyface, under the mistaken impression that all returning stars would be treated like conquering heroes.
WWE had read the room wrong - but to their credit, once they finally figured that out, they set about solving the problem with the same creativity that characterised Batista’s rise to the top nine years earlier. Bryan was added to the main event and pinned Batista himself to give the crowd the greatest WrestleMania main event and moment in years.
And Dave himself? At loggerheads with the office over creative, he quit again in June, but with Guardians Of The Galaxy in his back pocket. Filmed the previous year, it was released in July 2014... and it changed his life once again.
4. Lex Luger (WWF, 1993-1995)
A decade before Vince McMahon made a hero out of Batista, he conspicuously failed to make a hero out of another former bodybuilder with a great look and a lack of in-ring skill.
Lex Luger had debuted for the WWF in January 1993 as a mid-level heel nicknamed ‘the Narcissist’, posing in front of a giant mirror to the jeers of everyone watching. Hulk Hogan’s decision to walk out on the WWF in June changed all that.
Hogan had been fighting over creative all year, refusing to accept Bret Hart as the company’s new top guy and convinced that he could barely appear on TV, phone in his performance and turn Hulkamania back on like flicking a switch.
It’s a typical McMahon move to prove Hogan wrong by picking another jacked blond guy and transforming him into his new all-American hero. That’s what he tried to do with Lex Luger, decking him in the stars n’ stripes, helicoptering him onto a US aircraft carrier on the 4th July to take out the Japanese menace Yokozuna and sending him on a road trip around America kissing babies.
Inexplicably, after all that subtlety-free build-up the WWF failed to capitalise: his big SummerSlam title match was a countout win, and Luger didn’t get the title. All of his heat left the room that night, and it never came back. After a series of lukewarm feuds over the next couple of years, Luger jumped ship to WCW without warning in 1995 and never looked back.
3. Sting (WWE, 2014-2015)
When the WWF purchased WCW in Spring 2001, Sting was one of the holdouts - his contract didn’t come with the package. Over the following years he’d resolutely refuse to consider joining the WWE, despite being on good terms with Vince McMahon, who offered him generous terms.
Part of the reason for his hesitance was the company’s notorious travel schedule, of course. The rest? With McMahon’s monopoly on creative in the WWE and urge to prove that his product was better than WCW’s had been, the legend was concerned that he’d be treated like Booker T had been: buried and forced to prove himself all over again.
Still, once his stint as a main event mainstay in TNA had wound down, Sting finally signed with WWE in April 2014. It would be seven months before he would make an appearance, beginning a feud with Triple H that culminated in a match at WrestleMania in 2015.
That should have been a warning sign on its own: Triple H was a WWE guy through and through, and as determined as McMahon to prove the WWE’s superiority over old Turner product like Sting. The match was a disaster near the bottom of the card, ruined with interference from decrepit old men D-Generation X and the NWO and a pinfall loss to the Game.
Sting’s rep with the WWE crowd never really recovered: his next match involved a loss to Seth Rollins that also, with an injury to his neck, effectively ended his career on a disappointing low.
2. Ric Flair (WWF, 1991-1992)
In the spring of 1991, NWA legend Ric Flair was 42 years old and in the middle of a dispute with WCW boss Jim Herd over his future. Herd, with no appreciation for wrestling history, wanted to phase out Flair’s place at the top of the card and repackage him as a shaven-headed gladiator character. Flair balked and Herd fired him: the Nature Boy took the Big Gold Belt with him when he left.
By August, Flair was signed to the WWF, making his first appearance with the WCW title because wrestling promoters make sharks look like Sunday school teachers. Finally, everyone was going to get the dream match: Ric Flair versus Hulk Hogan, with WrestleMania VIII only a few months away.
The match had been fantasy booked for years: everyone knew it would be a phenomenon. Almost immediately, McMahon began teasing Flair/Hogan in house shows across the country.
The big pay-per-view match never happened. Supposedly, McMahon was unhappy with the numbers and believed the match was five years too late. Flair went on to win the WWF title at the Royal Rumble the following January, but dropped it to Randy Savage in the middle of the card at WrestleMania VIII.
He’d regain the title from Savage in September, but only as a stop-gap to drop it to Bret Hart - and that’s when McMahon informed Flair that he wasn’t going to be the main event in New York either. Flair would be back at WCW within four months.
1. Goldberg (WWE, 2003-2004)
It’s a question that’s been debated for fifteen years: did Bill Goldberg really fail in his first proper run with the WWE in 2003 and 2004?
Goldberg certainly thinks that he did. He was already in an uphill battle to earn the respect of the WWE’s fanbase: it hadn’t been that long since he’d been the enemy, one of WCW’s biggest stars. He felt that Vince McMahon didn’t really understand what had made the Goldberg character such a success in WCW only a few years earlier.
It hadn’t been about the streak, the win and loss record, so much as it had been about the aura of the man. Goldberg was a monster truck in human form, whose only purpose was to run people over. Instead, McMahon had him engaged in run-of-the-mill feuds with 50/50 booking, requiring him to sell post-match beatdowns.
Yes, he won the title more than once; yes, he was in the main event, fighting and beating top stars. But that’s just what the record books show. The numbers aren’t what people remember. The magic from years earlier just wasn’t there in the WWE. Goldberg wasn’t Goldberg, and he wasn’t happy.
The match with Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania XX was the capstone on a frustrating year - the crowd knew that both men were leaving and comprehensively cr*pped all over it. Goldberg won, but left feeling defeated. He didn’t wrestle again for a dozen years.