10 Wrestlers Who Are In The Wrong Company
WWExodus.
It is easier to make serious money in American wrestling than it has been for years, since the formation of All Elite Wrestling - but because of AEW, it has never been harder to get out of a multi-year deal.
WWE has placed a ban on releasing talent, irrespective of how unhappy that talent is (Harper), nor how little WWE values that talent (Harper). Co-President George Barrios is on record as stating that WWE independent contractors are free to leave whenever they wish; at the 20th Annual Needham Growth Conference in 2018, he claimed "they're under agreement, but both parties could terminate them in pretty short order. So, we're not trying to lock anyone up," which is strange, because WWE f*cking is locking everybody up by refusing to grant release requests (Harper) and adding extra months to their deal by tacking on time missed due to injury (Harper).
WWE is essentially that scene in the Simpsons episode the 'Joy of Sect'. You're free to leave whenever you want, a solemn voice intones, but would you mind telling us why?
"I can't do a southern accent, even though you hate southern accents. (Harper)"
"Tough t*tties."
But, in a perfect world...
10. The Revival
Shouldn't be in WWE because...
WWE, historically, is fundamentally uninterested in presenting tag team wrestling as a main event concern. The Revival are used in a more flattering role at time of writing (read: not being made to act as if their a*seholes are on fire through topical pain relief or whatever deeply problematic implication Vince had in mind for that shower segment), but an attempt is being made to secure their services for another five years. But it's not as if WWE suddenly deems them an act worthy of promoting. They are a tag team.
Should be in AEW because...
AEW has presented just four shows, and has already shown a serious commitment to tag team wrestling, as evidenced by it headlining Fight For The Fallen and the vast depth of the roster. The Revival, a superb, purist tag act, would excel in prominent roles against so many of the duos AEW has signed thus far: the acrobatic, flashy Private Party, the contrasting, gimmicky A Boy & His Dinosaur, and the Lucha Brothers, with their refusal to actually tag.
And, of course, that generational and philosophical Young Bucks dream match.
9. Cesaro
Shouldn't be in WWE because...
He just jobbed to The Miz on RAW, which makes sense in the parameters of current storylines because those storylines do not factor in Cesaro. Those 72 hours between Cardiff and Baltimore were an all too acute metaphor: Cesaro played his role as cult favourite to office afterthought over the course of a single weekend. Monday was the hangover. Unable to cut the lengthy promos necessary to feature on WWE TV, he is promoted as a good hand, which is upsetting, because he is a phenomenal hand.
Should be in NJPW because...
NJPW is the one major company in which it is possible to connect with crowds purely through explosive, exquisite in-ring performance. Personality is crucial, too - Jeff Cobb received muted reactions throughout this year's G1 Climax tournament - but Cesaro would get over huge in one major debut match, which is something NJPW books with tremendous effect (KENTA, Jon Moxley). New Japan audiences are in thrall to the strength of colossal western talent even when they can't fly around the ring with such propulsion.
Cesaro would command that rising, oscillating Korakuen Hall reaction splendidly.
8. Killer Kross
Shouldn't be in IMPACT Wrestling because...
IMPACT's recent drive to cover talent road expenses is a flimsy PR move, one that aims to cover its inability to compete financially with the competition that has steamed ahead of it. The two parties are at a contractual impasse: Kross doesn't believe he is paid in a way that is commensurate with his ability (or potential, realistically), whereas IMPACT hold a legal advantage over him. Kross deems the company reckless, too, which has escalated the conflict. Kross, in effect, is a star in too close proximity to a black hole.
And he's not the only one...
Should be in AEW because...
One of the more dangerous-feeling wrestlers on the circuit - really, only Nick Gage commands as much of a beautifully terrifying aura - Kross, and his ability to convey a sense of legitimacy in size and skill, would provide a much-needed contrast in a promotion built very much on showmanship thus far. His raw level of experience and exposure is consistent with AEW's mentality: this is a company after the Next Big Thing, and Kross fits that profile.
7. Jim Ross
Shouldn't be in AEW because...
It never feels like his heart is in it, and that is deeply counterproductive to the presentation of AEW as un upstart venture driven by a passion for showcasing a new breed of professional wrestling. Ross doesn't seem to like this new breed: he complains out loud about the referee leniency gimmick, how much sh*t the guys get in, and what he perceives as a lack of logic in the performances. He called PAC a "dumb bastard" at All Out when PAC was given the mega-push as a talent able to out-wit the talent (Kenny Omega) presented as the best wrestler in the world. Because of this, Ross is eroding the sentiment many fans (including your writer) have for him; when he confused Matt and Jeff Hardy back in the day, it felt endearing. With age comes authority and the odd lapse in memory. But now, when he calls Jungle Boy 'Jungle Jack', it reeks of a lack of preparation.
Should be in WWE because...
WWE has shown a renewed appreciation for the veterans that helped shape the company (Paul Heyman, Bruce Prichard). Ross, for totally understandable personal reasons, is after a full-time gig, and not a Saudi Arabia payday or one-off WrestleMania appearance. If he can't do it anymore - and he can't - perhaps he can teach, away from Vince McMahon's weird grudge, at the UK and U.S. Performance Centers.
Ross in AEW is like Chevy Chase in Community. Maybe it's time to go home.
6. Tessa Blanchard
Shouldn't be in IMPACT because...
Not every IMPACT roster member should leave, it's important to note. The company remains in talks with AXS, and for all its dubious management practises and reports of lowballing talent, it is on aggregate a force for good: it pays talent at a level above the Indy scene, allows them to supplement their income by working elsewhere, and offers its shrunken but committed audience an eclectic and lauded product (this year's Slammiversary earned raves). But there's a sense that IMPACT is transitioning into a new chapter of its wild story, something close to ECW directly and indirectly. The company is still using old ECW talent, the latest of which is Johnny Swinger (!), but the misfit toys element exists, too. It's a place for troubled or controversial talent to step back into the world of wrestling.
It isn't the place for a performer ready to take it on.
Should be in WWE because...
'The biggest stars should earn the chance to make the most money' isn't a controversial take, particularly since WWE talents are underpaid. Blanchard is that: a believable and very polished wrestler with that rare ability to both project herself as a star and elevate opponents into her orbit, she is the performer best-equipped to unsettle the main roster's Four Horsewomen dominance.
5. Shota Umino
Shouldn't be in NJPW* because...
*Temporarily.
A studious Twitter user - @jojo_runs - recently discovered an interesting statistic. Shota Umino has wrestled 300+ matches ahead of the traditional Young Lion excursion; usually, around this timeframe, the Lion ventures west. Still just 22, there is no rush for the preternaturally gifted but raw prospect to shape that incendiary babyface fire into a more refined midcard act, but a recent shift in NJPW's recruitment policy may narrow his path. The signings of Shingo Takagi and KENTA have over-loaded the upper midcard.
Should be in AEW because...
He can resume his wonderful, wholesome-but-badass association with bad influence Jon Moxley.
Besides which, without just fan-casting Further Adventures of the Death Riders, AEW boasts the most concentrated, eclectic talent roster in mainstream wrestling. Home to super-workers in Kenny Omega and PAC, practitioners of violence in Joey Janela and Darby Allin, and traditional, expert storytellers in Cody and Chris Jericho, the irony of the ongoing spat is that AEW is the perfect destination for the travelling Lion. The idea is to learn new skills and to flesh out their personality, and AEW is a self-proclaimed "buffet" of professional wrestling.
It's not happening, obviously: AEW effectively ruined NJPW's big U.S. expansion venture.
4. Kento Miyahara
Shouldn't be in AJPW because...
Bluntly, he is too talented to limit his potential in a company that is unable to realise its own. All Japan Wrestling has moved on from its dark age and settled in an inconvenient spot in the wrestling hierarchy; much like Impact, the product is acclaimed and not without its loyalists, but it's impossible to make a significant impression in 2019 because there is too much excellent, must-see content. AJPW is good, but irrelevant. Miyahara is its standout: a master of nuance, he knows precisely how to build a match, when to explode, when to crumple, and how to frame everything with urgency and importance. The way he lunges into a pin the second his opponents beat the count illustrates this: Miyahara is always focused on winning, which in turn frames his performances as contests worthy of suspending disbelief.
Should be in NJPW because...
NJPW is the biggest company in Japan by a considerable distance, and Miyahara offers the same babyface mastery as its ailing Ace Hiroshi Tanahashi. NJPW won't push him to that level - but will push him, because a glittering history in another company is not looked upon as a weird transgression.
3. Tetsuya Naito
Shouldn't be in NJPW because...
This will prove controversial - arguably the most popular star in New Japan still, his failure to win this year's G1 Climax broke many a heart - but the following argument is written from a position of fear for his body, more so than his creative prospects. Tetsuya Naito is in decline. His body is not what it was; as a consequence, he entered more than one subdued performance in the tournament. Even one of his better matches - against Tomohiro Ishii, obviously - felt like a slight diminished return of their previous, incendiary encounters. It feels, far too often, like Naito is compensating for that missing surge by taking multiple disgusting bumps to his neck, satisfying the bloodlust of crowds where he once took them on ride, and not just the drop.
Should be in NXT because...
To preserve his body, albeit in a system that will restrict his ring style but not his character, Naito should make a shock jump to NXT, in which he will be received as a God and feel as brand new and electric as he did in 2016. He can prioritise his flexing, totally unique psychology in Full Sail under NXT's mentality of high melodrama without, and this honestly isn't too histrionic, killing himself.
2. Asuka
Shouldn't be in WWE because...
Asuka has dyed her hair pink, green, purple, and blue, but she's never had the hair colour that counts: blonde. And you could make the argument that WWE has never pushed a female performer with as much commitment as the orange-haired Becky Lynch, but Becky Lynch can speak English in a way that gets her over. Asuka does not, and since WWE's product is systemically lazy, creative does not write segments that promote her effectively. She has a mouthpiece in Paige, who got over as likeable General Manager last year, but that doesn't seem to matter. Nothing does: WWE isn't ready for (or interested in) Asuka.
Should be in AEW because...
The relationship is mutually beneficial; AEW's sports-oriented focus and demonstrable willingness to promote Japanese women's wrestlers should see Asuka flourish, much less even make it to TV. Asuka is a beloved cult figure in wrestling circles, and would get over instantly as a result, because she is incredible. Uniquely charismatic, and able to convey a dangerous atmosphere without wrestling an overtly dangerous style, Asuka is the perfect bridge with which to get the joshi scene over.
1. Sami Zayn
Shouldn't be in WWE because...
He's too good for WWE in every conceivable respect. He returned to and stole the post-WrestleMania RAW with an intriguing new gimmick, which was swiftly dropped. He devolved into an abject jobber amid the chaotic Wild Card Era, and tellingly, he hasn't profited much from the recent, much-needed changes; his association with Shinsuke Nakamura feels like a halfhearted experiment, and it isn't connecting. He is instructed to go out there and act likr an annoying fly because that's how WWE perceives this keen perfectionist. His charity efforts aren't in line with corporate values. He has been forbidden from earning the biggest payday on the calendar as a result of his ethnicity.
Should be in AEW because...
He is a superb worker who has shown a polymath ability to shine within the episodic TV format. Excellent on the mic and between the ropes, as a grating heel and house afire babyface, there are few performers better equipped to manage AEW's drive of encouraging its talent to operate within shades of grey. Sadly, per Fightful, Zayn is tied to WWE until 2021.
It is literally a case of wrong place, wrong time for one of North America's most diverse and electrifying talents.