10 Wrestlers Who Are Way Too REAL For WWE
Eddie Kingston, Nick Gage, Minoru Suzuki - who else wouldn't fit WWE's fabricated style?
When a non-wrestling fan proudly tells you that wrestling is "fake", it can be very hard to resist locking them in a Boston crab.
While the industry is built around pre-determined results and opponents working together, it's still full of real athletes putting their bodies on the line in an attempt to look genuine. Still, when watching WWE, that doesn't always ring true.
The company - particularly in modern times - is so filled to the brim with heavily scripted promos, over-the-top moments and leaps of logic that it feels far more like a soap opera than wrestling at times. For the most part, this works, as it can be fun to see how creative the performers can get, but not everyone would thrive in such an environment.
The wrestlers within are rugged, brash and rough around the edges. They are fighters who thrive on realism and creating something genuine, either through being true to life, or laying into more aggressive wrestling styles. Whatever the case, there's no doubt they wouldn't fit WWE's overly fabricated style.
Pro wrestling may be "fake", but these performers make it seem realer than taxes...
10. Nick Gage
When watching a match with the indie wrestling icon Nick Gage, it's understandable to think that you aren't watching wrestling, but instead a gladiator match between two people genuinely trying to kill each other. The leader of the MDK gang is a master of making his wrestling look real, and that's because it is.
Hardcore wrestling might not be everyone's cup of tea, but there is a devoted audience for it, as people love to see some bloodshed inside the ring. Gage caters to this niche perfectly, as he takes his brutal deathmatches to the next level, with blood, weapons and light tubes galore.
Anyone who has watched the recent Dark Side of the Ring episode dedicated to him will know just how seriously he takes the business and how dangerous his matches can get. If you were to strip the realism and barbarity away from this performer, then he wouldn't be the wrestling icon he is today.
Seeing Gage in WWE is an impossibility, not only because of his dangerous reputation but because he wouldn't work at all in a scripted/safe environment.
9. MJF
The dramatic rise of this young star in AEW has been a blessing, as he has quickly become one of the most established heels in the industry.
On paper, MJF seems like he would be a perfect fit for WWE, and it's reasonable to see why. He's got a great look, youth, a fantastic character and can go on the mic for days. But therein lies one of the most significant issues, and that's how he works his character.
As a performer, Maxwell Jacob Friedman thrives on improvisation and his connection to the crowd. In order to make his character feel real, he lives it and doesn't care about the ramifications that come along with that. He even infamously once gave the middle finger to a child in a photo op, and when confronted about it online, he simply responded, "F*** them kids".
His impulsive character decisions that are designed to shock would cause ripples through the company's HR department. While his gimmick might not be the most believable, it is real thanks to how far he's willing to go. While he'd undoubtedly perform his scripted promos well, the lack of creative freedom would neuter him.
8. The Briscoe Brothers
Either of the Briscoes could have been included individually on this list, as they are both wild and erratic performers who bring a strong touch of authenticity to their work. But when combined as a tag team, they're one of the most realistic and scrappy in the business. Seeing as WWE have such trouble with their already conventional tag team stars, it's safe to say they'd have no idea what to do with a team this gritty.
This decorated Ring of Honor tag team takes realism to unpleasant levels, often sporting the Confederate flag on their ring gear. Their gritty look doesn't exactly scream "primetime on FOX" either. Plus their promos always feel like they're running their mouths, and putting a script to that would feel hollow.
The pair of Jay and Mark Briscoe have even been turned down by WWE before, stating in a video on Ring of Honour's YouTube channel that they were not considered "cosmetically pleasing". Of all the reasons to be turned down, that seems on-brand for the pair, as they've always felt rugged and rough, not the superstar type.
7. Sonny Kiss
Brimming with charisma and with an explosive in-ring style and attention-grabbing personality, Sonny Kiss might seem like an easy fit in WWE. However, Kiss has a core philosophy to his wrestling that aims to create authenticity. Everything you see in and outside of the ring with himis real, and that's a level that WWE would mishandle.
The Concrete Rose has discussed before with Sports Illustrated how the early days of his career saw bookers try to make him out as a Goldust or Adrian Adonis type character. Still, in his own words, she "wouldn't have thrived doing that. It wouldn't have been real, and people can see through fakeness".
He definitely has a point, as his true to life wrestling persona is something that only he could handle correctly, and WWE's creative freedom wouldn't allow for that.
Kiss is finding success in All Elite because he doesn't fall into the stereotypes that most companies would make with him, and this makes him one of the most genuine characters in the business right now, meaning he's way too real for WWE.
6. Zack Sabre Jr.
There really are no other stars in the world like Zack Sabre Jr. The man is a wrestling entity in his own right, as, despite his skinny frame and lack of a superstar look, he's been tapping out heavyweights since the early days of his career, and gaining accolade after accolade. His believable style and presentation have made him a unique and sure-fire hit on the indies, but WWE wouldn't be so good to him.
Sabre Jr. is no stranger to WWE televising, as he took part in the Cruiserweight Classic, where he made it through three matches and was one loss away from the finals. Despite this impressive showing and the great impact he made, it will probably be his only time in the company.
The NJPW star is known for his dazzling array of technical offence, which sees him utilising submission holds, pinning combinations and harsh strikes. Alongside this, he presents himself with a realism that makes him seem more like a sports athlete than a performer, as his showmanship is minute.
He's a star who lets his in-ring work do the talking, and that's something WWE would probably deem "boring".
5. Minoru Suzuki
On one side of the wrestling world, you've got characters like Roman Reigns and John Cena reading from scripts and performing in overt spectacle-focused matches. Then, on the other side of the pond, you've got people like Minoru Suzuki, who go out there and pick their opponents apart.
The terrifying and incomparable leader of the Suzuki-Gun stable - which the previously mentioned Sabre Jr. is a part of - is by no means an easy opponent to face. His matches are terrifying to watch, as his in-ring mash-up of submission holds, strong style, and steady pacing makes his bouts feel like legitimate executions.
WWE's in-ring style takes a far different approach to this, as while believability is essential, there's also a significant focus on acrobatics, signature moves and general safety. That's not something Suzuki has in his arsenal, as he's best when it comes to toying with his opponents in legitimately tough to watch matches, looking like a tiger picking apart his prey.
His stern presentation, believable in-ring work and lack of visual flair are prospects that the world of sports entertainment tends to disvalue. Still, at the age of 52, Suzuki hardly needs a WWE run to establish his legacy.
4. Trevor Murdoch
Suppose you had no knowledge about Murdoch's career and instantly thought he was a professional wrestler. In that case, you should be using your telepathic skills to solve crime, as, on the surface, Murdoch looks nothing like a pro wrestling superstar. While the likes of his namesake, Dick Murdoch, had similar looks in their prime, the wrestling world today is made up of people with far different aesthetics, and Murdoch doesn't match them.
This Missouri resident first joined WWE in 2005 after a solid run in World League Wrestling. He did find a decent amount of success in the company alongside his tag partner Lance Cade, but it was clear from the get-go that his average joe physique and lack of superstar presentation meant there was a ceiling for him in the company.
Vince McMahon even told him that he didn't like his "pasty white skin". Murdoch only found the success he had in WWE because he deliberately tanned to eliminate this. But nowadays, as he works for NWA, he's back to being himself.
His realistic body type and relatable look work so well with the National Wrestling Alliance, whereas we already know he was too real for WWE.
3. "Filthy" Tom Lawlor
The wrestling industry is no stranger to seeing UFC stars step out of the Octagon and into the ring. WWE has found massive success with similar stars, such as Ronda Rousey, Matt Riddle and Ken Shamrock.
But while those performers fit into the company well, former UFC fighter Tom Lawlor certainly wouldn't.
If you want to talk about a wrestler who perfectly suits the phrase rough around the edges, then you've got it in "Filthy" Tom Lawlor. He absolutely gives off a legitimate fighter vibe, and that's not just because of his mixed martial arts background. There's a realism and grittiness to his in-ring work, presentation and promos that make him scrappy and unpredictable.
Lawlor's look is highly outside of WWE's norm, as his mutton chops and cauliflower ears are all far removed from the corporate mould that the company adheres to. Still, he works so well as a fighter who is a believable tough guy and dominant opponent.
Having been crowned the first-ever NJPW Strong Openweight Championship in April of this year, it's safe to say that he's finding success in Japan, where not being a conventional superstar doesn't pump the breaks on your career.
2. Eddie Kingston
Eddie Kingston is such a fantastic part of the wrestling world, as while he doesn't look like a particularly eye-catching star, he'll make you think he's the king of the world when he grabs a microphone.
He's made a considerable name for himself wrestling on the indies and now finds himself in a very prominent position on the AEW roster. But don't bother crossing your fingers for an NXT debut, because his realistic and rugged style would be a poor fit for the company.
To begin, Kingston instantly hits the ground running with his realism as he cuts his promos with a thick New York accent, making him stand out amongst the crowd. There's an extreme toughness to his mic work that makes him seem like a guy you might standoff against outside a nightclub, which adds to his gritty mystique.
Alongside his excellent talking skills, he's also an unconventional looking wrestler, as his physique doesn't have the definition you'd expect in a wrestling superstar. This causes him to seem even more down to earth as a character, making him come across like a legitimate brawler.
Thanks to his uncapped mic skills, creative freedom and individual look, WWE is the last place he should be.
1. Jon Moxley
Well, the proof is in the pudding with this one, as we know that Moxley's energetic and badass style works best in edgier promotions. We also have years worth of evidence that his brand of realistic promos and dangerous match-ups were way too real for what WWE was willing to offer.
The former AEW World Champion found his way in the business through the dangerous and frightening world of hardcore wrestling, just like Nick Gage. He found the most success in this whilst working at CZW but was soon whisked away to the land of the giants in WWE. The rest is history.
WWE never seemed like the right place for Moxley, as his free-spirited energy, aggressive in-ring style and rugged aesthetic went against the company mould. Although he did find championship gold and mainstream appeal thanks to The Shield, it was only a matter of time before his affair with sports entertainment came to an end.
Simply put, Moxley isn't a sports entertainer. He's a real dude who likes to go out there and be himself, which is why he's best suited outside of Stamford.