10 Wrestlers Who Completely Changed To Become Main Event Stars

Going from 'Stunning' to 'Stone Cold' made Steve Austin red hot...

Ric Flair CHAMP
WWE

A bleach-blonde legend once said, "to be the man, you have to beat the man". Let's bastardise that famous quote and rephrase it: to be the man, you have to become the man. Ric Flair certainly did, and he defied rather generic beginnings to transform into one of wrestling's best ever and most flashy main-eventers.

There are countless examples of others doing the same, and they too were able to turn mid-card mediocrity into marquee success.

None of the men listed here were exactly no-hopers before making the change. No, really, they weren't, not even when they were asked to dress up as wheeling, dealing con men or pale imitations of former WWF World Champions. A job's a job and all that, but there was a ceiling to how far such gimmicks were going to take them.

They needed something more, something that would sell both fans and their bosses on main event runs, title wins and riches beyond their wildest dreams. These are the stories of performers who either thought outside the box long enough to alter the directions their careers were heading in or lucked out.

The result was a lot more bang (bang) for their buck...


10. Raven

Johnny Polo Raven
WWE

The Change: Scott Levy went from brash, colourful manager Johnny Polo to nihilistic, depressive Raven in 1994 and never looked back. It might not have felt like it at the time, but leaving the WWF for Paul Heyman's bold new ECW outfit was the best thing that could have happened.

How It Helped: The Raven character struck a chord with ECW fans and facilitated Levy's later runs in WCW and WWE. Though he'd never reach the heights in those companies he had under Heyman's tutelage, Raven was considered a top guy in Philadelphia and is still remembered as one of the original ECW's best sons.

Looking like a wrestling version of Kurt Cobain helped Raven amidst the grunge music hysteria still gripping pop culture in the mid-'90s. He never had that kind of cool edge to him as the goofy Polo, and such a radical departure from that gimmick turned Levy into one of the hottest acts in the business.


9. Mick Foley

Cactus Jack Mankind
WWE

The Change: Vince McMahon's initial vision for Mick Foley was as the cartoonish 'Mason The Mutilator'. When Mick baulked at that suggestion and pitched a rougher edge to the character, history was made; within two years, Foley went from foil for The Undertaker to lovable idiot who captured the hearts and minds of wrestling fans worldwide.

How It Helped: There's no way McMahon's WWF would have known what to do with the overtly-violent menace of Cactus Jack in 1996. Mankind was a halfway house for Foley, and something he could use to bed himself into the company. All he had to do was ensure he didn't become the next Mantaur.

Donning a mask and (eventually) using a sweat sock as an imaginary friend and weapon wouldn't have worked with just anybody. It took a special performer, something Foley definitely was in his prime. He perhaps realised he'd have to go along with some of Vince's plan if he wanted to show the boss what he was capable of in the long run.

Under his watch, Mankind somehow went from psychopathic nightmare to cuddly babyface.


8. Ted DiBiase

Ted DiBiase Million Dollar Man
WWE

The Change: As the story goes, Vince McMahon wouldn't tell Ted DiBiase about his 'Million Dollar Man' gimmick until Teddy signed on the dotted line and agreed to join the WWF. Once he did, DiBiase went from nuts and bolts pro wrestler to super-arrogant rich man who flaunted his wealth in everyone's faces. The change made him a star.

How It Helped: DiBiase was perfect for the 'Million Dollar Man' gimmick. He already had the tools in-ring, but lacked that killer character that would make fans sit up and take notice. McMahon had the answer there, and Ted was a great fit for his vision.

In the span of a few weeks, DiBiase went from smiling good-guy wrassler to an aloof, sickeningly rich piece of sh*t who later decided to create his own championships belts when buying the WWF Title didn't work. His career was turned upside down by turning heel and accepting McMahon's proposal to become a walking, talking blueprint for what over-the-top villains should be.


7. Kevin Nash

Vinnie Vegas Diesel
WWE

The Change: During his first go-around in WCW, Kevin Nash looked less like 'Big Daddy Cool' and more like a prize tit as the fast-talking Vinnie Vegas. There was just something off about seeing the near-seven foot monster play the character, and it was a blessing when Shawn Michaels plucked him from mid-card hell and turned him into smash mouth bodyguard Diesel in the WWF.

How It Helped: Buoyed by a gimmick that suited his background (Nash had worked extensively as a bouncer), Diesel rocketed up the ranks and became world champion less than 18 months after trading WCW mediocrity for the WWF's marketing machine. It was no accident.

Nash would go on to use elements of that same Diesel gimmick for the rest of his full-time wrestling career. Even playing himself in the uber-cool nWo, he maintained the same laid-back cool his WWF persona was known for; again, that wasn't happenstance. Nash had found his groove by playing an easygoing giant of a man who could turn nasty at any time.


6. Triple H

Pjimage 5
WWE

The Change: D-Generation X bridged the gap between 'Connecticut Blueblood' and 'The Game'. After debuting in 1995 as the stuck-up Hunter Hearst Helmsley, Triple H (as he'd become better-known) joined forces with Shawn Michaels then parlayed new attitude into a much more realistic character. By 2000, he was one of the best workers in wrestling.

How It Helped: Doing away with his little heelish curtsy and old-fashioned mannerisms helped Triple H connect with the audience. It wasn't an overnight process. Even when he was riding high with HBK and Chyna as DX, Trips' matches would often play before silence. It took years before fans gave a damn about him, and it didn't happen until he stepped out from Michaels' shadow and became 'The Game'.

Improving his body and ditching the equestrian-style tights, becoming much less cartoonish by default, meant Triple H was able to gain credibility as a top-level WWF talent for the first time in his career. Don't be fooled by popular narrative about his relationship with Stephanie McMahon. Triple H had to work damn hard to reach the top.


5. Kane

Isaac Yankem Kane
WWE

The Change: Glenn Jacobs deserved a break after playing the rotten Isaac Yankem dental gimmick and cosplaying as Diesel between 1995-97. Kane, despite being pitched as a short-lived foe for The Undertaker, promised something a little higher-profile. Over 20 years on, Jacobs is still playing the part.

How It Helped: Nobody could have predicted that someone pulled from the monster factory spawning 'Taker opponents in the '90s would lead to one of WWE's most successful gimmicks. Kane has transcended the original chargrilled nature of the story to carve his own path, and that was never a given.

By going under a mask and coldly dissecting hapless victims, Kane was immediately taken as a threat to his storyline brother. After that, he was off to the races and had a chance to prolong his run by becoming an unlikely, albeit short-lived, WWF Champion at the expense of Steve Austin.

Kane succeeded where Yankem and the 'fake' Diesel failed. It turned Jacobs into a bonafide WWF headliner.


4. Steve Austin

Steve Austin Stunning Stone Cold
WWE

The Change: Something switched in Steve Austin's head when he was callously tossed aside by WCW in 1995. Seeking refuge in Paul Heyman's ECW, he tore through his old employer and showed a new side to his promo chops. 'Stunning' was dead, and the foundations for what would become 'Stone Cold' were built right then and there.

Soon, Austin was ready to explode as wrestling's next megastar.

How It Helped: Austin had a newfound level of confidence in himself as Stone Cold. It wasn't a smooth road to the top though. Early WWF days as The Ringmaster threatened to ruin his potential, but Austin, through a rebellious spirit fans loved and his own hard-headedness, pushed through the creative crap that was being heaped on him.

Come 1997, he was on a tear, and his 'Austin 3:16: t-shirt was a top seller. Shaving his head, bulking up on some muscle and harnessing a powerfully straightforward promo style, he became the box office attraction his company needed.


3. Ric Flair

Pjimage 8
Instagram/@ricflairnatureboy/WWE

The Change: By his own admission, Ric Flair wasn't quite the party-animal 'Nature Boy' he'd become in later years at the start of his career. Instead, he was a generic brand of wrestler, and actually looked more like Samoa Joe than the bleach-blonde jet-setter fans would revile then fall in love with.

Adopting the 'Nature Boy' gimmick made famous by Buddy Rogers in the late-'70s led Flair on a golden path towards fame and fortune.

How It Helped: The difference between muscle-man wannabe on the left and cocky 'Woo' shouting superstar on the right is startling. As the 'Nature Boy', Flair found his calling. He suited partying every night and out-working everyone else inside the ring regardless of how little sleep he'd had.

Flair projected an image of wealth and self-belief, and he lived the lifestyle he claimed on television. Seeing how he evolved from slightly chubby boots 'n' tights technician to become a master of the promo and resplendent robe-wearing headliner is incredible.


2. Scott Steiner

Scott Steiner Change
WWE

The Change: Gradually, Scott Steiner (who was always in phenomenal physical shape) started adding more muscle to his frame in the mid-to-late-'90s. By the end of the decade, he had cut his long dark hair, grown out some facial hair, bleached everything and morphed from smiling tag-team wrestler into the 'Big Bad Booty Daddy'.

How It Helped: Steiner's shift away from standard wrestling leotard to chain mail, sunglasses and obnoxious posing made him a sensation in WCW. He was ready to leave his brother Rick behind and become a main-event level star, so that's exactly what he did. Scott even found time to talk about how all the women in the crowd were his 'freaks".

Charming.

Channeling the spirit of 'Superstar' Billy Graham (a nickname Steiner used himself for a spell), and showing more personality than he had for the previous decade, Scott rightly worked his way towards the WCW Title and an overdue headline push. WCW, it seems, liked his new look just as much as fans.


1. JBL

Bradshaw JBL
WWE

The Change: Once longtime tag partner Ron Simmons decided to call it a day in 2004, Bradshaw had a decision to make. He could either continue working the ass-kicking APA gimmick as a beer-drinking gun for hire, or he could start afresh. Guess which one he chose?

His new 'Million Dollar Man' mixed with J.R Ewing character JBL was born by the summer, and it turned Bradshaw from mid-card stalwart to the longest-reigning WWE Champion in years.

How It Helped: JBL was one of the least-likeable characters WWE had ever created. It also allowed Bradshaw to move on from dying his hair and beard black, and the money-grabbing, bully-boy with fingers in all of Wall Street's pies was tailor-made for someone with a legit interest in business.

Armed with sound financial knowledge and eager to prove he could stand on his own two feet as a main-eventer, JBL put everything he had into the gimmick and held up his end of the bargain against world-class talents like Eddie Guerrero to boot.

-

What other examples of wrestlers completely changing to become main event stars can you think of? Let the world know down in the comments section below!


In this post: 
Steve Austin
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.