10 Wrestlers Who Ditched Their Terrible Ring Names
Whatcha gonna do when Sterlingmania runs wild on you?!
Not every wrestler has the kind of ring name you can envisage in bright lights at the top of a WrestleMania card. In fact, some of them have names that you wouldn’t envisage seeing on any type of card whatsoever.
Just ask Bill DeMott, previously been known as Hugh Morrus as well as Hugh G. Rection - or James Dick and his brother Chad, who were collectively known as the Dicks for a brief time on SmackDown back in 2006.
Thankfully, though, some guys have had the wherewithal to change those names and roll with something a little more credible. Or at least, a little more credible within the context of a world built around scripted feuds and predetermined fights.
Not only that, but many of these guys who ditched their terrible ring names have since gone on to become some of the biggest names in the entire industry - icons like Hulk Hogan, the Undertaker or John Cena, just to name small a handful...
10. G.I. Bro - Booker T
Years before becoming a five-time WCW Champion, Booker T came up with the name G.I. Bro.
As the name might suggest, it was a military-type gimmick, but the specific use of the word "bro" has led to some people deeming it a racist one. In actuality, though, Booker was very much in favour of the name, hoping he could use the gimmick to "to break down the barriers and portray a black hero in a sport that has promoted negative racial stereotypes throughout its history."
Of course, those plans would fall through when Booker’s singles push was curtailed in favour of a tag team pairing with his real-life brother, Stevie Ray, prompting him to simply roll with his real name instead.
The G.I. Bro gimmick may have seemed relevant at the time, but in hindsight it just sounds overly corny, and a far inferior alternative to his birth name of Booker T. Huffman.
Not that this stopped Vince Russo from having Booker revive the gimmick in WCW in 2000. Of course, receiving the Russo seal of approval isn't necessarily a good thing, as was very much the case here.
9. The Prototype - John Cena
These days, John Cena is a 16-time world champion and easily one of the biggest names in pro wrestling history. Back in 2001, though, John Cena was simply the real-life name of the "engineered genius" known as the Prototype.
Touting himself as 50% man, 50% machine, the Prototype was some kind of human-android hybrid who would cut promos on both his opponent and "the rest of the humanoid scum". In fairness, it was pretty entertaining, and the whole part-man, part-machine shtick would at least have explained some of the superhuman feats of strength he’s been known to pull out in the ring.
However, it was also something of a throwback (and not a particularly welcome one) to the days of the ‘80s and ‘90s where wrestlers were unable to follow anthropological naming customs, instead going by one-word monikers like the Yeti, the Maestro, the Zodiac or the Shockmaster.
This side of the 21st century, names like that just weren’t going to cut it, and it’s hard to imagine the Prototype gimmick ever accumulating as many championships as plain-old John Cena has.
Much like Booker T, Cena is another who was wise to ditch a made-up name for the one he goes by in real life.
8. The Hybrid - Goldberg
Bringing up the hat-trick of wrestlers who reverted to the name with which they were born is former world champion Bill Goldberg.
To the majority of fans, Bill Goldberg is an awesome enough name as it is, but for whatever reason the man himself didn’t think so. Instead, he had wanted to be named "the Hybrid".
Much like the Prototype, a name like the Hybrid suffered from the out-dated connotations of years gone by, and that was only exacerbated by the fact that guys like Kevin Nash and Scott Hall, who’d recently arrived in WCW, were now going by their own real names.
Ultimately, and thankfully, it was the aforementioned Hall who talked Goldberg out of using the Hybrid. On a recent episode of the Tomorrow Show, Sean Waltman revealed that Goldberg had initially run the idea past Hall before noting that he didn’t think his own name was cool enough. Hall’s reply essentially ended the debate, stating that "it is cool if you make it cool."
Roughly two decades later, Goldberg is now a multi-time world champion, and weeks away from main eventing WrestleMania 33 at the ripe old age of 50.
Safe to say, the name Goldberg was cool enough.
7. Sterling Golden - Hulk Hogan
The story goes that in 1979, Vince McMahon was looking to create a marquee star with a full-blown Irish gimmick - complete with the customary red hair as well as the Hogan surname. Though he drew the line at dying his blonde locks, a 26-year-old Terry Bollea was happy to embrace the Irish name. Thus, Hulk Hogan was born.
Not only did this kickstart the creation of the biggest star of the 1980s, it also signalled the end of the brief career of a certain Sterling Golden.
Hogan had been wrestling under the guise for a few short months in Georgia Championship Wrestling, but it’s one of those names that sounds far too contrived to ever be taken seriously. Then again, that kind of reasoning could easily be applied to the Hulk Hogan moniker as well…
But Sterling Golden wasn’t the only alias that Hogan ditched in his early days. The Terry Boulder persona preceded the arrival of Mr. Golden, which may not have been any better - but would certainly have given WrestleMania X8 an added geological subtext.
6. Isaac Yankem DDS - Kane
The mid-90s were a strange old time in the World Wrestling Federation.
With business stalling, the company were stuck in something of a creative rut in which wrestlers apparently need some kind of extra-curricular profession that they used to earn some money on the side.
There was Irwin R. Shyster the tax collector, Duke “the Dumpster” Drose the garbage man, as well as the completely unimaginatively-dubbed Repo Man (FYI, he was a repo man). And in the summer of 1995, a new name was added to this list of professionals, that of Jerry Lawler’s personal denitist, Isaac Yankem, DDS.
Yes, years before being given the awesome Kane gimmick, Glenn Jacobs was doomed to be a seven-foot dentist who for some reason spent his weekends performing for the biggest wrestling company in the entire world.
As if that juxtaposition of a dentist as a wrestler wasn’t hilarious enough, remember that this name could be abbreviated to simply I. Yankem, because the only thing funnier than a wrestling dentist is a wrestling dentist who name is a pun of his very profession.
Genius.
5. Oz - Kevin Nash
Kevin Nash’s first taste of success came whilst wrestling as Diesel in the WWF. As far as one-word gimmicks go, Diesel wasn’t such a bad name, especially when you consider that it was used during that wacky period that was the mid-90s.
But prior to winning the WWF Championship as Diesel, Nash had already endured his fair share of woeful wrestling names.
Upon debuting in WCW in September 1990, Nash was initially referred to as Master Blaster Steel, a name that now seems somewhat ridiculous but at the time at least made a bit of sense, given that he was a part of the Master Blasters tag team. However, there was no excusing the abomination that followed.
After the Master Blasters split, Nash branched out on his own and was promptly put in a lime green cape, what he describes as a "dunce cap" and a plastic mask of an old man’s face. The old man was supposed to be Oz, as in the same of Wonderful Wizard fame, and if that sounds like a bad idea on paper, it was somehow even worse in reality.
4. American Starship Coyote - Scott Hall
Having just recounted Kevin Nash’s story, the trajectory of Scott Hall’s career follows a rather familiar path.
Hall also had his first taste of success as one of the major players in the WWF of the mid-1990s, before going on to WCW to reinvent himself under his real name. And just as the trajectory of their later careers were similar, so too were their earlier days in the business - meaning that Hall also has a forgettable name hiding in the proverbial closet.
Debuting in Mid-Atlantic Championship Wrestling in 1984, Hall teamed with Dan Spivey to form the tag team American Starship, and, just to ensure the point was really driven home, both men had the American Starship shtick incorporated into their individual names.
Hall became known as American Starship Coyote, while Spivey was American Starship Eagle. Apart from sounding like really bad nicknames of undercover agents, it also made little sense that Hall - an absolute specimen in his early days at 6’7” and close to 300lbs of solid muscle - was being compared to a coyote, of all things.
Then again, it’s not like American Starship Bear or American Starship Gorilla would have improved matters, either.
3. Sexton Hardcastle - Edge
Amassing 11 World championships between 2006 and 2011, Edge was one of the biggest stars of the recent PG era. If he hadn’t ditched his original ring name, though, that surely wouldn’t have been the case.
Prior to his days in the WWE, while on the books of the Canadian Wrestling Association, Edge went by the rather graphic moniker of Sexton Hardcastle. While that may sound like a bit of a rib, Edge actually went on to win the CWA North American Championship under that name, suggesting he was anything but a comedy character.
In fact, Edge even wrestled a couple of dark matches for the then-WWF in ’96 and ‘97 as Mr. Hardcastle himself, first at a house show against Bob Holly and then just before a taping of Sunday Night Heat versus his compatriot Glen Kulka.
The name continued to make the odd appearance here and there, but by the time he made his TV debut in the summer of ’98, the company had seemingly opted to tone things down a bit and rebranded him, simply, as Edge.
For a name to be too raunchy for even the Attitude Era, that’s really saying something.
2. The Punisher - The Undertaker
On face value, the Undertaker hardly seems like the most fitting name to give to a professional wrestler. But the Deadman - an equally silly nickname - has gone on to become such a legend that the name has since become a normal part of wrestling vocabulary.
Besides, even though it’s another job-themed gimmick (and an obscure one at that), it’s still better than some of the alternatives that ‘Taker wrestled under during his earlier days.
During a brief spell in Japan at the 1990 NJPW Big Fight Series, he regularly appeared alongside Bam Bam Bigelow as Punisher Dice Morgan. No, that’s not a typo - he really was called Dice. And he wanted to remind you that he was going to punish you. Still, at least in Japan he had an actual first and last name. The previous year, when competing for the World Class Wrestling Association in Dallas, he’d simply been known as the Punisher, before going on to display even less subtlety in USWA as the "Master of Pain".
Maybe ‘Taker really was a punisher, and maybe he really had mastered pain, but above all else, maybe he should have let his ring work do the talking rather than trying to overcompensate with the name.
Somehow, the Undertaker is now looking like the subtlest name of the lot...
1. Dingo Warrior - Ultimate Warrior
Though the origin of the name Ultimate Warrior has been disputed over the years, one thing is at least a little more certain—it was a vast improvement on Warrior’s first alias.
Performing for World Class Championship Wrestling in 1986 and ’87, the Ultimate Warrior that we’ve since come to know was originally named the Dingo Warrior. On top of sounding entirely lame, this presented a couple of issues.
First-off, it’s unclear what exactly a Dingo Warrior is - a very valid point raised by Vince McMahon and Bruce Prichard upon Warrior’s arrival in the then-WWF. Moreover, the wrestling world already had its fair share of warriors, including the "Modern Day Warrior" Kerry von Erich and the Road Warriors, Hawk and Animal.
So, killing two birds with one stone, Warrior allegedly declared that he wasn’t this warrior or that warrior, he was in fact the Ultimate Warrior.
That simple shift set up a Hall of Fame career, the pinnacle of which saw him pin Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania VI to become the first man in history to hold both the Intercontinental and World Heavyweight Championships at the very same time. And to think, in another universe that show could have been headlined by Sterling Golden vs. Dingo Warrior.
Thankfully, smarter heads prevailed.