10 Wrestlers Who Got Over By Losing

WWE DQ finishes can get trashed - Darby Allin, Kurt Angle and STEVE AUSTIN prove they aren't needed.

Dustin Rhodes
AEW

If that title reads as counterintuitive, what's more counterintuitive is the manner in which WWE f*cking RAW books its f*cking f*ck finishes. The practise is indescribably dumb. The field for the upcoming Royal Rumble is wide open because to arrive at the correct answer, one must play a guessing game:

Who's the least f*cked?

But it's hard, because so many of them are f*cked. They are f*cked because stealing one via roll-up and scarpering out of the ring doesn't settle a goddamn thing. Most everything is a fluke, and the babyface looks like a worm slithering out of the ring more than they do a winner, or even an athlete. These people run away like they are getting away with something - like they've done something wrong, and not achieved the very thing all of this is about. That finish and the 50/50 booking that is still shockingly prevalent creates this indistinguishable tier of damned faces in which zero investment can be traced nor felt.

Going out like a damn man - thereby putting over the winner as the man - is something WWE just doesn't do, and as a result, there can be no arcs. No progression. And ultimately, no purpose.

Booked well, the spirited defeat means so much more than the lucky victory, or the disqualification that never, ever functions to get the heat on the heel.

It can even mean everything.

10. Darby Allin

Jon Moxley Darby Allin
AEW

Darby Allin's early win/loss record was uneven by calculated design.

In addition to getting Darby over as an emerging, spirited talent, it put the very notion of achievement over, how difficult it was to ascend. The dissonance between his record and his performance level asked a probing question - "What else does he have to do?" - with the fundamental answer to everything: "win".

He took Cody to the limit in an inspired match at Fyter Fest 2019, in that it positioned Darby as a future player and established the drama of a time-limit draw unfamiliar to modern U.S. audiences. In the Dynamite era, Darby defeated the fellow midcard pack (Kip Sabian, Sammy Guevara) but lost to the established top-level players (PAC, Jon Moxley). He showed out in those defeats, which were deftly orchestrated to put him over as a man on the cusp of the big time; Mox had to put him away with the top-rope Paradigm Shift, PAC had to use the steps.

Allin was twice defeated by Cody to further a rivalry indebted to the great Misawa Vs. Kobashi series. When Darby finally ascended, at Cody's expense, it was going to mean more than any rocket-strapped push because he had to earn it.

He did, at Full Gear 2020, in a sensational match structured with the next chapter in mind: Allin was a very skilled wrestler, despite the patronising misgivings of Taz.


9. Tomoaki Honma

Honma Ishii
NJPW

Tomoaki Honma was positioned in New Japan's seminal 2010s era as a lower card enhancement guy. Endearing and almost awkward, mechanically, he had more fire than talent - or maybe "success" is the better word, looking at his remarkable rise.

A last-minute G1 Climax 2014 substitute for the injured Kota Ibushi, Honma lost every last one of his 10 block matches. The booking was as logical as it was inspired. It made sense for him to lose, but the New Japan fans were dazzled by his fighting spirit and his sheer refusal to stop fighting, even when it was less than pointless.

A peak Honma high spot - basically, whenever he was in a fight with Tomohiro Ishii - meant so much more than most, even if (or even because) he executed those moves with such little grace. He didn't ascend the turnbuckle because he was a gifted aerialist ready to launch into a high-risk attack. He didn't fly from the top rope because he had particularly low regard for his own safety. He just desperately wanted to win, to prove himself more than the loser his dire record all but confirmed he was.

His Kokeshi finish - he would hold his body rigid, and flop into a flying headbutt with zero success - was as clever as it was dumb. The hit-and-hope of pro wrestling moves, when he finally hit it, it felt like a shared celebration. You couldn't not be happy for him.

Just look at his daft face!


8. Barry Horowitz

Barry Horowitz Royal Rumble 1996
WWE

You know, it's f*cking incredible comparing the WWF of 1995 with the WWE of 2021.

WWE in 2021 is blessed with a just ridiculously stacked roster loaded with guys who used to get over everywhere they worked. That's why they got signed. And, at best, a handful of the 200+ Theoretical All-Star team make the slightest bit of damn difference. Roman Reigns, Drew McIntyre...

...do two fingers count as a handful? Sasha Banks and Bayley were moving the needle to an extent in 2020, but their star power has dimmed considerably. Rhea Ripley is popular down in NXT, but they mishandled her badly.

The WWF of 1995 was not as blessed, not at all, and yet it was booked by a man who at least made his unfashionable product make sense. He was resourceful, canny, which led him to book a fondly remembered underdog prevails tale for lowly Barry Horowitz, who was so earnestly endearing and quietly skilled that he got it over.

Horowitz was a *Bret Hart voice* loser. He was stigmatised as one, too, which made the storyline and differentiated it nicely from the 123 Kid deal. He was just that guy who lost all the time, until he won at the expense of the egotistical gym rat Skip in a three-match series.

It was nice undercard fare crafted more lovingly than the desperation to make any matches would suggest.


7. Kurt Angle

Undertaker Kurt Angle
WWE.com

The Kurt Angle conniption fit was almost Seinfeldian in its brilliance.

Watching people blow a f*cking gasket is funny. It just is. And Angle was phenomenal at it for two key reasons: he was a very, very intense individual, and yet he had no compunction whatsoever about showing himself up. Watching Angle realise he'd made a right t*t of himself and scream "Shut up!" at a taunting crowd was priceless. And he still sold the gravity of those defeats. They pissed him off. He was never a clown; he just had a rather funny way of wanting to win.

And it worked so well because Angle was such a killer in that ring that he could get his heat back just by removing the straps of his gear. Everything he did looked like death. Thinking on it now, there's probably never been a pro wrestler quite as valuable as him.

To prove this, his record in 2000 was pretty spotty. He lost to Tazz at the Royal Rumble. He lost the European and Intercontinental Titles at WrestleMania. He lost to the Big Show at Backlash. He won the King Of The Ring, but it really only enabled him to do more comedy - "Did I summon you?" - before he was mugged off by a defensive and boring Undertaker at Fully Loaded.

And he was still worth the SummerSlam main event, and the WWF Title by October's No Mercy, because he was too entertaining and too over for any record to hold him down.


6. Mick Foley

Mick Foley Thumbtacks
WWE.com

Mick Foley was so good that he convinced several wrestling fans that Randy Orton was a top-level worker for 17 years.

And while that's only slightly facetious and hardly consensus - Orton is received about as subjectively as any performer ever - Foley was so phenomenal in the role that it's far easier to argue that Backlash 2004 remains Orton's career peak.

Foley was the best guy to lose to ever. He sold everything like death, and absorbed more gruesome punishment than any big league star before him, but he was also a phenomenal brawler with one of the best working punches you'll ever see. He was as great at doling out the punishment - so much so that a victory over him meant so much more than blood-soaked highlight reel moment - as he was taking it. The emerging WWE star got over by surviving and then maiming Mick Foley, not just by defeating him. The Rock; Triple H; Edge: Foley's legacy as a selfless star-maker is forever established.

He is a legend because he created more legends, and Randy Orton.


5. Kenta Kobashi

Kenta Kobashi
Pro Wrestling NOAH

Few careers have been curated with as much elegance as that of Kenta Kobashi.

A hulking specimen, he was initially rejected by All Japan Pro Wrestling, his dreams crushed by a lack of sporting credentials at the high school and college level. But the drive that saw him ascend to greatness was inherent and unwavering. He started working out in a gym near the AJPW office, and worked so hard - harder than anybody else - that the owner was sufficiently impressed enough to recommend him to Giant Baba, upon learning of his ambition.

Baba was similarly impressed. Kobashi was said to have such a likeable disposition and unreal work ethic that Baba figured a packed Budokan might one day respond in the same way. This was some premonition. After beaming through a drab, rural nothing show he was invited to as a measure of his appetite for the business, Kobashi was given the chance to train as a pro.

Recognising his prodigious talent, Baba penned an arc designed to maximise the living sh*t out of his innate sympathy: Kobashi lost all 63 of his first matches, but was allowed to shine in a sort of coded message. Prime Kobashi was an all-timer of a babyface. He didn't so much have fire as wrestle a Budokan classic completely ablaze.

For those 63 matches, fans were drawn, steadily, to the ignition - ensuring that the investment would last a lifetime.


4. Stone Cold Steve Austin

Steve Austin WrestleMania 13
WWE

Imagine if this version of Vince McMahon was tasked with booking the finish to the legendary WrestleMania 13 match between Steve Austin and Bret Hart.

Jesus H. Christ.

He wouldn't have booked a stipulation that demanded a decisive finish, for starters. Or he'd have just paid no mind to it, à la Hell In A Cell 2019. Austin would have rolled Hart up and left the ring suddenly. Or, alternatively, to "protect" Austin, Hart would have up and disqualified himself. Or perhaps Stu Hart would have distracted Austin, leading Austin to wear night vision goggles and beat him up the next night on RAW. Which seems awesome, actually. F*ck. Never mind.

Mercifully, thin pretexts with which to make a joke didn't exist in 1997, because the WWF was great then - so great that they got Steve Austin over as a prospective megastar by doing a job clean in the middle. He'd been dismantled strategically - the stipulation was genius, because there was no great shame losing in his opponent's domain - but Hart had f*cked him, too, by betraying his code as a sportsman.

Austin tasted his own blood, pain shooting through his joints, as he roared in anguish. Pro wrestling has never felt as real as it did in that climactic minute.

This finish gave the WWF so much to work with. Austin was made as the defiant, toughest babyface. Hart won, and embarked on the best character run of his career. He was the next WWF Champion, after the Undertaker, but Austin was the next top star.

That's what happens when any of this means anything.


3. Daniel Bryan

Sheamus Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

Though you'd probably not want to revisit the TV - a lot of it stunk, and was insulting, but was made perversely fascinating by how much they tried and failed to resist - Daniel Bryan's 2013/4 arc felt like the last time WWE fans had the heart and agency to make a difference.

It was a special time that doesn't hold up to repeated viewing, and really, that about describes it. Bryan was the star of a bad and counterproductive television programme. That's why all of it happened. The fans were right then, and they are cor-rect today.

It didn't all start with Bryan's loss to Sheamus in 18 seconds at WrestleMania XXVIII. That finish was rejected so emphatically because Bryan's connection with the fanbase had already been formed. But that moment brought into focus just how much it wasn't going to happen unless the fanbase willed it into existence, and so they did, by making it very clear who they liked by chanting his catchphrase at WWE rather a lot.

They resented you for this.

This intensified the support.

18 seconds was the flashpoint.

Incidentally, Sheamus is ignored in the discourse - but how did they expect this to get him over? WWE had spent the last however many years telling you Edge was an a*sehole for being an opportunist.

What a thick company abound with dunces.


2. Sammy Guevara

Sammy Guevara
Scott Lesh Photography/AEW

Poised for a breakout babyface run in 2021, Sammy Guevara has proven his value in a heel role without ever really winning anything, though Le Sex Gods weren't unfamiliar with the pay window as a tag team.

A relative unknown ahead of AEW's launch, Guevara mildly impressed on that early pay-per-view circuit, but one couldn't label him a standout. That Cody Vs. Sammy Guevara match graphic marking the debut of Dynamite was somewhat puzzling, and while it made sense, AEW's insistence that Sammy would replace Cody as Chris Jericho's Full Gear opponent in the event of his victory failed to convince. It was so incredibly unlikely as to be almost patronising.

In 2021, Sammy Guevara Vs. Chris Jericho is a major upper midcard PPV-level attraction because Guevara has ruled as a heel on an episodic TV wrestling show.

The smarmy face; the ability to pull you in, even to picture-in-picture; the underrated unhinged body language: Guevara got over by losing simply because you wanted to see him lose. He was the little f*cker with the punchable face, and he played that role incredibly well.

Hangman's Buckshot; Moxley's Paradigm Shift; Luchasaurus' Tombstone Facebuster: it just never got tiring, watching Guevara land at such a grotesque angle.


1. Dustin Rhodes

Dustin Rhodes
AEW

Where Sammy Guevara got over as the young but inexperienced stud, Dustin Rhodes was his inverse.

AEW recognised his value where WWE did not - in an horrendous alternate universe too close to our own, Goldust is gnashing his teeth on Legend's Night - and literally bled that value all over the ring at Double Or Nothing 2019. Dustin lost, in an emotional bloodbath, but in doing so, he crystallised his legacy as a great. But AEW arrived and he arrived at it too late for him to become a lasting main event star. Everybody recognised that.

But he's still so great that he builds on that legend most weeks, and uses it to transfer his aura to the younger set. It's OK for Dustin Rhodes to lose - especially because he sells on the contrary so well - because nobody will ever think less of him. He's Dustin Rhodes. He's as good once as he ever was, and AEW have never lost sight of that by beating him too often.

This is why you form stables with a clear pecking order. This is why a promotion should embrace the young and the old, whether they're not deemed "ready" for TV or whether they have been judged to have outlived their "telegenic" usefulness. This variety drives storylines. If a faction needs heat, if a giant needs to look like a killer, there's no better arm to break nor forehead to slash.

Between affection and aura, Rhodes is the perfect man to beat.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!