10 Wrestlers Who Had No Business Being Inside Hell In A Cell

Superstars who didn’t have the credentials to enter Satan’s Structure.

The Hell in a Cell match has been a WWE staple since 1997 with at least one having occurred every year since with the exception of 2001. Often having served as the big blow-off to long running rivalries, it's been argued the concept has become a shell of its former self in recent years due to the creation of the pay-per-view of the same name. Despite that, Hell in a Cell remains one of WWE's most anticipated and feared matchups with two to take place at this year's event this Sunday. In one, Roman Reigns and Bray Wyatt will step inside Satan's Structure for the first time to settle their score while Hell in a Cell veterans The Undertaker and Brock Lesnar will also do battle in the main event. While it oftentimes involves only the toughest and fiercest talents WWE has to offer, there€™s always a few undeserving names who slip through the cracks. Let's face it: Although Ryback has flirted with the main event scene before, there was no season to put him inside the cell twice, let alone once. Unsurprisingly, he lost back-to-back bouts against CM Punk, but he is far from the worst wrestler to have stepped inside the Devil's Playground. He is a prime example of a wrestler who either didn€™t earn their way into the contest or simply had no business being a part of it to begin with...


10. Kevin Nash

Kevin Nash left WWE before the creation of the Hell in a Cell match in late 1997, but that didn't stop him from competing in one upon his return to the company in 2003. To WWE's credit, they told a solid story with Nash and his former friend Triple H going into 2003's Bad Blood event. After their outing over the World Heavyweight Championship at Judgement Day ended in fluky fashion, a Hell in a Cell match was made for the subsequent show with Mick Foley being appointed the special guest referee. Given The Hardcore Legend's storied history inside the cell, it was only fitting he officiated the matchup. They contested a pretty good match that saw all three combatants take many bumps and bruises, but Nash was far past his prime to be involved with Satan's Structure. Although he was medically cleared to compete after tearing his quad the year prior, he still moved gingerly around the ring and didn't have the performance he likely could have had years earlier. Thankfully for fans, Nash came up short against The Game and never participated in another Hell in a Cell contest in the remainder of his run with WWE.

9. The Big Boss Man

In 2008, WWE released a three-disc DVD set entitled "The Greatest Hell in a Cell Matches of All-Time." It featured every Hell in a Cell match from 1997 to 2007 with the exception of The Undertaker vs. The Big Boss Man from WrestleMania 15. In fact, there wasn't a single mention of the matchup, which went to show just how truly bad of a bout it was. Outside of Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. The Rock in the main event, that WrestleMania was mostly a mess and putting Boss Man in Hell in a Cell with the innovator of the contest The Undertaker didn't help matters. Although he flirted with the main event scene at times, Boss Man was far from being a threat to Undertaker and the two of them had zero chemistry inside the ring. It was a waste of The Deadman on the grand stage and Boss Man was destined to fail in that position. God rest his soul, but Boss Man had no place inside Hell in a Cell. He had a memorable WWE run throughout the 1980s and should be commended for reviving his career in the late '90s, but he was an upper-midcard competitor at best. He was quickly disposed of by Undertaker before being hanged from the top of the structure. Yes, someone actually thought that was a good idea.

8. Dolph Ziggler

You may be asking yourself when Dolph Ziggler ever competed in a Hell in a Cell, but for those unaware, it was a dark match that took place following the Sept. 26, 2011 edition of Raw in Kansas City. The bout was contested over the WWE Championship and also featured the likes of CM Punk, Alberto Del Rio, Jack Swagger and defending champion John Cena. Punk, Del Rio and Cena were set to face off in the first ever Triple Threat Hell in a Cell match that Sunday, so WWE gave the lucky fans in attendance a preview by throwing in Ziggler and Swagger since the steel structure was hanging above the ring that night, anyway. It remains the only Cell match to never be aired, though it's probably for the better considering the contest lasted all of five minutes. Ziggler is one of the most well-rounded performers on the roster today, but he is not a Hell in a Cell caliber competitor. Even at that time, he wasn't even close to being at main event level and it was obvious the only reason he and Swagger were included was so one of them could take the pinfall loss. Granted, the match wasn't televised so it technically didn't matter, but to consider Ziggler a Hell in a Cell alum is laughable.

7. Ryback

Originally at 2012's Hell in a Cell event, John Cena was scheduled to go one-on-one with then-WWE champion CM Punk, but due to an injury sustained at Night of Champions, he was deemed unable to compete. WWE rushed to find a replacement before settling on Ryback, who at that time was squashing enhancement talent and working his way up the card. Although they agressively pushed him toward the main event scene in a matter of a month, the fans rallied behind Ryback and were anxious to see him take the title from Punk. Ultimately, he was unsuccessful in capturing the prestigious prize and saw his undefeated streak snapped as a result, but they wouldn't have run into that problem had they not put them inside the cell. It ruined any momentum Ryback had going, and worse yet, it was foolish to think he belonged in there to begin with. It was all downhill from there for The Big Guy, but that didn't stop WWE from putting him in another Hell in a Cell match the next year, also against Punk. The match was more about Punk's long running rivalry with Paul Heyman than it was his beef with Ryback, as Punk defeated his rival in decisive fashion within mere minutes in what was one of the worst Hell in a Cell matches of all-time.

6. Cody Rhodes

Throughout his career in WWE, Cody Rhodes has been on the brink of super stardom at several occasions, but has always slid back down the card before getting to the next level. He was prominently featured on WWE programming in 2009 as one-third of The Legacy with Randy Orton and Ted DiBiase, most notably during his feud with D-Generation X. He and DiBiase received a major rub while working with the seasoned veterans and scored the biggest win of his career up to that point when they beat them in a Submissions Count Anywhere match at Breaking Point. At the inaugural Hell in a Cell pay-per-view, the two teams faced off in a rubber match inside Satan's Structure and although it was a worthy of such a stipulation, The Legacy felt out of place in the matchup. After locking Triple H out, they went to work on Shawn Michaels inside the ring and despite the advantage in numbers, they failed to score the victory. The Game eventually broke the door open in time to save The Heartbreak Kid and put away the second-generation stars for the win. It's not that Rhodes didn't belong inside the cell with elite talent, but given where his career has since gone, there were far more deserving Superstars who could have been in that position instead.

5. Jack Swagger

Similar to Dolph Ziggler, Jack Swagger was among the five Superstars that took part in the only Hell in a Cell make to never make the air in September 2011. Mind you, this was long removed from his days as a main event player, so he served no purpose in the bout other than taking the deciding pinfall from then-WWE champion John Cena. The only two times Swagger was a legitimate threat to a world championship were in 2010 and 2013, and neither stint lasted long. Thus, it's asinine to think he was ever given the chance to compete in a Hell in a Cell match, even if it wasn't televised. The fact he was involved at all is a crime against humanity given how low he is on the totem pole these days and even back then. No one will ever likely see the match other than those in attendance that night, but Swagger, now a permanent fixture on "WWE Superstars" each week, can boast he's been inside Hell in a Cell when the likes of Eddie Guerrero, Jeff Hardy and Rey Mysterio can't.

4. Rikishi

If you blinked, you likely missed Rikishi's main event run in 2000. In a strange turn of events, he was revealed to be the one who ran over Stone Cold Steve Austin with his car one year earlier, but the problem was that next to no one took him seriously as a main event threat. WWE gave him new music and a new attitude, but it didn't change people's perception of him as a dancing fool. Although his feud with Stone Cold flopped miserably, he was relevant long enough to be included in the first and only six-man Hell in a Cell match at the Armageddon pay-per-view. The match itself was actually entertaining as all six competitors brought their A-game and delivered strong performances. Even Rikishi fared well in the bout, but the only moment he'll be remembered for will be when he was tossed off the top off the cell onto a truck parked on the outside. But that was where the buck stopped with Rikishi inside Hell in a Cell. He was extremely out of place among the legendary likes of Stone Cold, The Rock, Triple H, The Undertaker and Kurt Angle. It was a "who's who" cast of competitors in that iconic Cell match, except for Rikishi, that is.

3. Mr. McMahon

As the head honco of WWE, Vince McMahon has the ability (and tendency) to book himself in whatever matches and situations he wishes. Obviously, that explains why he's a former WWE and ECW champion as well as the winner of the 1999 Royal Rumble. Thus, it comes as no surprise he was involved in a Hell in a Cell match alongside his son Shane McMahon and Big Show against D-Generation X, but that's no excuse. Shane was more of a wrestler than Vince ever was, so if anything, it should have been just Shane and Big Show with Vince watching on from the outside. WWE spent the better part of 2006 building that feud up, so it was fine it culminated inside the cell, but Vince's participation in it was unnecessary, as was the sight of his head being shoved up Big Show's rear. That was unpleasant in every sense of the word. They pulled through and had had a blood bath of a brawl, but Vince wasn't an active member of the roster and shouldn't have been included.

2. Ted DiBiase

In Cody Rhodes' defense, at least he scored success as a singles performer after his 2009 Hell in a Cell affair with D-Generation X. He didn't seek the benefits immediately afterward, but he made a name for himself that night and went on to solidify himself as a star on the rise in the years that followed. Although Ted DiBiase's spot in the match was justified at the time, that was the last push of any kind DiBiase received in WWE. He was irrelevant for the remainder of his stint with The Legacy before branching off into singles competition and failing to get over with the audience. It was widely believed he was destined for big things soon after his WWE debut, but he never surfaced as a star. He had a decent showing in his premier Hell in a Cell match, but considering his opponents were two of the greatest cell competitors of all-time, he had no business being in the ring with them. When DiBiase left the company on his own terms in the summer of 2013, the average viewer would have never guessed he once stepped foot inside Satan's Structure given how far he had fallen in such a short period of time.

1. Paul Heyman

An argument can be made that Paul Heyman is the greatest manager/advocate of all-time next to Bobby Heenan as well as one of the best things going on WWE TV today. That said, he's not known for his days as an in-ring competitor, or rather the few times he was actually involved in matches. WWE did a delightful job of building up the CM Punk vs. Paul Heyman rivalry in the summer of 2013, leading to an outstanding match between Punk and Heyman's client Brock Lesnar at SummerSlam. From that point forward, however, the feud took a turn for the worse when Heyman enlisted the assistance of Curtis Axel and Ryback. Needless to say, Axel and Ryback were no threat to Punk, who beat both men decisively each time they faced off. The big blow-off came at the Hell in a Cell event with Heyman teaming with Ryback to take on the Second City Saint in a Handicap Hell in a Cell match, though Heyman spent a majority of the match on top of the structure. After Punk made quick work of Ryback inside the ring, he ascended the side of the structure and proceeded to beat the living daylights out of his former friend with a kendo stick. It was a great visual, sure, but the fact Heyman was a part of the match alone was disgraceful. He should have served as a manager to Ryback outside the cell similar to what he did for Brock Lesnar and Punk in 2002 and 2012, respectively, so his name wouldn't have gone down in the record books.

Contributor
Contributor

Since 2008, Graham has been a diehard pro wrestling fan and, in 2010, he combined his passions for WWE and writing when he joined Bleacher Report. Equipped with a master's in journalism, Graham has contributed to WhatCulture, FanSided's Daily DDT, Sports Betting Dime, and GateHouse Media. Along the way, he has conducted interviews with wrestling superstars like Chris Jericho, Edge, Goldberg, Christian, Diamond Dallas Page, Jim Ross, Adam Cole, Tessa Blanchard, Ryback, and Nick Aldis among others.