10 Wrestlers Who Left Promotions With Nuclear Heat
From Scott Steiner to Sunny: when the promised land of pro-wrestling becomes hotter than Hell...
On 14 April 2021, Ivelisse took to Twitter to reveal she had been “let go” by AEW. She notably hadn’t worked a match since 2 March and her former partner Diamante has been competing as a singles competitor, yet Ivelisse was a familiar face and, of course, a former tournament winner.
Fightful reported that AEW talent did not expect Ivelisse to continue with the company due to prominent disagreements with backstage coaches. Ivelisse issued the following statement to the outlet:-
"I spoke up about mistreatment from a Coach, even to other women too, there were witnesses and I was the one suspended and left in limbo and just now let go, and nothing has been done at all the entire time about [Thunder Rosa] slandering my name the entire time in AEW and doing everything to sabotage my position there, I kept quiet, [Rosa] also has a history of getting involved with officials in order to get ahead […]”
AEW and Rosa have stuck together in silence, while Ivelisse took flak from wrestling Twitter, including accusations that she had been fired from Tough Enough, FCW, NXT, Shine Wrestling, TNA, Lucha Underground, and AEW.
While we tend to focus on careers that end with acclaim, ceremony, and gushing colleagues, for many wrestlers their departure is propelled by nuclear heat. Ivelisse is the latest in a long line...
10. Scott Steiner
Scott Steiner’s heat seems to coincide with him branching out as a singles star in WCW – likely brother Rick kept him toeing the line.
Scott became ‘Big Poppa Pump’. Despite his vast (and somewhat suspicious) muscle growth, his mouth was larger than even the biceps that threatened to burst free from his skin, and Steiner was known to careen off-script, going into business for himself at the expense of his colleagues.
After appearing at Survivor Series 2002, Steiner was fast-tracked into Raw’s World Heavyweight Championship race. After skirting around Steiner’s limited in-ring ability, he finally had a match with then-champion Triple H – an encounter that didn’t bear repeating. However, WWE did repeat it, with ‘The Game’ holding onto his championship and Steiner slipping down the card. 'Big Poppa Pump' soon left WWE, blaming Triple H for holding him back. He stated:
“It’s the worst place ever to work. Every time I worked there, I wanted to quit.”
Steiner’s least graceful exit was reserved for his time in TNA, where he was a vocal critic of Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff’s role in the company. Steiner verbally threatened both men and took his fury out on them, and the company, via social media resulting in a lawsuit.
9. Melina
Backstage reports of Melina’s behaviour paint a person who lived up to the Diva tag that all WWE women were saddled with at the time. Per numerous accounts, her inflated ego had her feeling she was above the entire locker room (possibly excluding her then-boyfriend John Morrison).
Amongst the women’s roster, she drew the ire of Mickie James, Candice Michelle, Angelina Love, Sharmell, and Lita, to name a few. The latter grew so tired of Melina’s attitude that she kicked her out of the women’s locker room. Not content with verbally laying into her fellow Divas, Melina used her blog to slate her colleagues, making her poor professional behaviour public.
Melina’s love life further alienated her backstage. Depending on who you ask, Melina and Batista either cheated on their respective partners, or had a short fling during a break in their relationships. Nevertheless, Melina fell victim to pro-wrestling’s double standards, as Lita had before her.
Melina and Morrison soon resumed seeking heat, turning against Trish Stratus, who they believed had taken Melina’s spot on the WrestleMania XXVII card. Shots at the beloved Stratus proved a step too far. The issues cumulated and soon sealed their exits. Morrison and Batista have both been welcomed back, while Melina’s return has stayed firmly rumoured.
8. CM Punk
There are very few settings in which you can proclaim to be the best in the world and remain popular. The competitive world of professional wrestling does not present such situations. CM Punk seized the accolade, ran with it, and won over the WWE fanbase. He presented a unique outsider character, with a cynical and sardonic wit, which fans could not help but gravitate and relate to. In pro-wrestling, heat seeks success.
During his time with WWE, Punk's confidence and outspoken ways saw him rub many up the wrong way – from Ryback, who he called out as an unsafe worker, to Hornswoggle (the two fell out over telephone number etiquette). Bruce Prichard recalled:-
"Everybody used to make fun of him because they didn't understand him […] They didn't understand the tattoos. They didn't understand his promos [...]”
Punk’s greatest heat was with the top of WWE’s hierarchy. As Punk’s star rose, his heat with Triple H was parallel, with suggestions that the older superstar was jealous. As the two feuded, their insults crossed a line from promos to genuine insults. ‘The Game’ ultimately used his sway to halt Punk’s push, with ‘The Voice of the Voiceless’ accusing Triple H of burying him. Punk left WWE under hostile circumstances and has continued to be vocal about the company.
7. Sable
Sable was a key talent in WWE’s mainstream popularity during the Attitude Era. Her appearance on the cover of Playboy remains one of the magazine’s best-selling issues, yet her initial run saw her walk away from WWE with a tone of heat, filing a $110 million lawsuit against the company.
She alleged sexual harassment and unsafe work conditions citing voyeuristic antics from males backstage, creative pressure for her to “accidentally” expose her breasts on live TV, and crude boy’s club conversations. The two parties settled out of court.
Legal issues aside, Sable was hugely unpopular backstage. This stemmed from her refusal to drop the Women’s Championship to Luna – despite the experienced wrestler essentially training Sable.
She also had heat with Sunny, though this is commonly acknowledged to be the result of mutual professional jealousy. Sable became paranoid that her fellow female wrestlers would gang up to attack and disfigure her, meaning she showered back at the hotel to limit interaction. Perhaps, the most explicit damnation came from Sean ‘X-Pac’ Waltman, who defecated in her duffle bag.
Sable didn’t help her standing in McMahon Land, by appearing on WCW Nitro on 14 June 1999, just four days after her departure.
6. Buff Bagwell
It is a credit to Buff Bagwell that WWE took an immediate interest in him when they bought out WCW. He had the look, athleticism, was decent on the mic, and stood out in a locker room packed with nWo black and white - but he was equally known for his big ego.
Bagwell and Booker T were given a match on 2 July 2001 edition of Raw to trial the idea of keeping WCW as a separate show. Jim Ross described the match as “abnormally bad and seemingly ill-timed”. Bagwell took the bulk of the resulting condemnation. To make matters worse, Bagwell claims he lost $150,000 in signing with WWE, voiding his Time Warner contract.
Bagwell’s failure put nuclear heat on him. This was followed by a backstage fight with Shane Helms, and having his mother call in sick for him. Chavo Guerrero shed some light on Bagwell's heat and exit:
“I think Buff p*ssed off the wrong people. Bradshaw was out to get him and other people were out to get him and I don’t know the whole story I heard — I don’t know if it’s true or not — I heard his mom called the office asking, ‘Why is my son,’ I don’t know if that’s true or not. I don’t know if it happened […] But it’s just, you know, if you get those rumours circulating that’s just never good.”
5. Tessa Blanchard
As 2020 began, Tessa Blanchard was the envy of women wrestlers worldwide. At Impact Wrestling’s Hard to Kill pay-per-view, Blanchard became the company’s first female World Champion, defeating Sami Callihan.
Her moment in the sun didn't last long.
On the eve of her Hard to Kill match, allegations of racism, bullying, and harassment surfaced after Blanchard posted a seemingly innocuous women-supporting-women tweet. Chelsea Green accused her of bullying and belittling countless females, herself included. Allysin Kay added an even more damning accusation, that Tessa “spat in a black woman’s face and called her the N-word in Japan”. This was backed up by Green, Tanea Brooks, Shanna, and Renee Michelle. Priscilla Kelly made further accusations.
When Blanchard was self-isolating due to the COVID-19 pandemic, Impact Wrestling asked their World Champion to film some promos from her residence in Mexico. Blanchard didn’t come through, meaning the proceeding TV show had to undergo major editing.
Impact attempted to come to a deal with Blanchard for her to return to drop the title. After talks failed, Impact terminated her and vacated the World Championship.
4. Sexy Star
Sexy Star was a gifted athlete who was given the opportunity to reach new heights for a woman in the wrestling industry. In holding the Lucha Underground Championship, she became the first woman to hold a World Heavyweight Championship in a major wrestling promotion. It was in AAA where Sexy Star’s heat turned into industry-wide outrage.
At Triplemanía XXV, Star defended the AAA Reina de Reinas Championship against Ayako Hamada, Lady Shani, and Rosemary in a four-way match. The match was originally declared a successful title defence for Star, though, it later came to light that she had deliberately tried to injure Rosemary with an armbar.
The wrestling world quickly condemned her actions, and she was stripped of her championship and was blacklisted by several promotions. Sexy Star attempted to brush it off as a work, but Rosemary, once composed, exposed this as a lie.
Rosemary received support, and Sexy Star condemnation, from a wide array of industry figures such as Paige, Gail Kim, and Road Dogg. Most incriminatory perhaps was Cody’s tweet:
“Sexy Star will never set foot in one of my locker rooms. I hope others follow suit.”
3. Enzo Amore
Enzo Amore fell afoul of the entire WWE locker room, inviting “a series of questionable guests” backstage, who in turn photographed and filmed other talent.
He drew further heat following a public social media spat with a stripper, which many felt reflected poorly on the company and its athletes. Roman Reigns, on behalf of the roster, threw Enzo off the European tour bus, and he was exiled from the locker room, forced to change elsewhere.
Enzo in turn took zero responsibility for his WWE exit, telling Konnan on Keepin’ It 100:-
“Honestly, I think that what creates heat is jealousy. I think hate is nothing but love disguised as jealousy. It’s either a relatable quality that you see in that person, or it’s that insecurity that you have within yourself that you feel is necessary to either lash out or talk sh*t.”
He also discussed issues with Triple H:-
"A writer tries to write a line I don’t like in a promo, I ain’t saying it, and I’m going to go talk to Vince because I’m not saying it and Hunter’s gonna threaten my job […] Triple H is gonna tell me I’m gonna get fired because I ain’t saying this sh*t […] You guys have threatened me ever since I got in the door here. You have been hanging it over my head that you will fire me […] In the end, I was f***ing looking at him in the face saying, ‘You’re f***ing lucky to have me here.’ I didn’t walk on any eggshells at the end at all. I dressed in my own locker room. When people got mad at me, I didn’t care […]
Ultimately, he was released for failing to disclose grim sexual assault allegations made against him to WWE, who quickly jettisoned Amore.
2. Juventud Guerrera
Juventud Guerrera’s gargantuan ego first became over-inflated during his time with WCW. He was a blight on the acclaimed Cruiserweight division, prone to becoming intoxicated and acting the fool. One such incident in Australia ended his run in 2000. He was reported as drunkenly running around a hotel lobby naked and screaming.
Despite this WWE gave Guerrera a shot in 2005 as a member of The Mexicools, alongside Super Crazy and Psicosis.
Guerrera soon became an irritant to his new colleagues who struggled to tolerate his mere presence. He often showed up late and had little concern for professionalism. His fellow Mexicools pleaded with WWE management to split the group, fearing their own careers would be ruined by association.
Guerrera drew further derision by carrying himself as if he was a major star, even claiming he was known as “The Rock of Mexico” in his homeland. In addition, and without any hint of irony, he would refer to himself in the third person and hid behind sunglasses.
Guerrera’s outlandish behaviour spilled into the ring during 3 January 2006 taping of SmackDown. When he learned he was to lose against Kid Cash, he removed big spots on the fly and sandbagged his opponent. The problematic Cruiserweight was promptly fired.
1. Sunny
Tammy Lynn Sytch has the dubious distinction of leaving WWE, ECW, and WCW with considerable heat. Her exits were surrounded by rumours of severely unprofessional behaviour, sex scandals, and drug addiction. However, it was in WWE during her star turn as Sunny where Sytch made the most enemies.
Though her issues with Sable were well-known, she had serious heat from the rest of the WWE locker room. Her treatment of boyfriend, Chris Candido, angered many backstage. Blatantly flaunting her affair with Shawn Michaels. Sytch recalled gleefully:-
"In WWE, I was called the ‘Kliq chick’, and not just because I got along with the Kliq, but because I was sleeping with one of them…"
Though Kevin Nash claimed Sytch was “sleeping with everyone in the territory, and [Candido] was acting like he didn’t know what was going on […] walking around like a dumb stooge."
Her heat from the WWE locker room is best exemplified by two backstage incidents. The first involved X-Pac, faecal matter (again), and Sytch’s Chinese food. This incident resulted in Sunny leaving a German tour early after being teased about eating a “poo-poo platter”. The second escapade happened prior to The Godwinns “slopping” Sunny. They left the half-full bucket backstage and various talent added their own bodily fluids to the mix.
Sytch's history as an adult actress and criminal/legal issues have further soured major promotions on the once bankable star.