10 Wrestlers Who Peaked In WWE Developmental

Was glory in WWE developmental and NXT the apex for these wrestlers?!

Karrion Kross Scarlett NXT
WWE

Developmental success is no guarantee of main roster stardom.

If it was, then WWE would have an impossible task juggling countless ready-made main eventers pushing their way up from NXT. Some will make it on Raw and SmackDown, and others will stutter. That's just the way of things. There's a variety of reasons for main roster failure though, and blame can't always be exclusively pinned on creative.

Sometimes, wrestlers just peak before they reach the top shows. It doesn't mean they won't go on to do some nice things elsewhere, or even within WWE's system in the future, but it does mean they'll plateau as characters and either never improve as workers in-ring or never get more over with the audience. That can lead to a lot of frustration, which is probably why 8 of the 10 acts examined here are no longer under contract.

They've all gone on to do some decent stuff in other companies, but fans often point to their work in NXT as a career apex. That's totally fair.

These wrestlers peaked before they hit the big time. They all have varying levels of 'something left to offer', but it'll arguably never be more than what they had in developmental.

10. Cameron Grimes

Cameron Grimes
WWE.com

You've gotta feel sorry for Cameron Grimes.

He was a hot ticket on NXT against all the odds, but WWE didn't have a clue how to handle him on the main roster. Grimes was in that awkward place; been there, done that in developmental, but didn't appear to be a great fit for the bigger shows. In the end, creative wet the bed on Cameron and ended up doing sod all with him.

Grimes was promoted to SmackDown's roster in the 2023 Draft, scored a win over Baron Corbin, then... he was barely seen again before being released in April 2024. His call up proved to be one of the most pointless in company history, and that stinks considering how majestic his 'Straight To The Moon' gimmick was on NXT.

Look back through the archives between 2021-2022 and you'll see he was one of the most engaging and endearing workers on the entire WWE roster. Yes, that includes anyone housed on Raw and SmackDown. Sadly, he couldn't translate that developmental success into anything worthwhile afterwards.


9. The Vaudevillains

vaudevillains tag
WWE.com

WWE's product wasn't really prepared for something as out there as The Vaudevillains in 2014. Together, Simon Gotch and Aiden English worked an old-timey throwback gimmick that was ripped straight out of the late-1800s. It was quirky and niche, but probably had a more limited shelf life than anyone was willing to admit.

Nobody knew just how limited.

Gotch and English were drafted to the main roster in 2016, but things soured immediately when they were cast as heels vs. The Lucha Dragons despite being cheered. People were happy to see an NXT act on SmackDown, and that didn't jive with how Vince McMahon wanted to present them. Stop this ride if you've heard that one before!

The Vaudevillains struggled to gain any traction at all outside NXT. By 2017, they were right on the fringes of the main roster product. Then, Gotch was served his release papers in April and that was very much that. They'd never be more over than they were on the third brand.


8. DIY

Johnny Gargano Tommaso Ciampa DIY
WWE

Some will read this and rightly say, '...but DIY just won the tag belts!'. They did, but think of this as more of a look at Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa individually. They were probably always going to enjoy a tag title run at some point, but both were higher up the food chain in NXT as singles stars.

They're unlikely to get that chance on Raw or SmackDown.

Ciampa, for example, was NXT's premier heel during his acclaimed days as a villain. Gargano was more of a spitfire babyface, but he also had some fine moments on the developmental brand. Individually, neither could really get going on the main roster. Check out Johnny Wrestling's return in 2022 for proof of that - it fizzled out pretty swiftly.

Meanwhile, Tommaso was involved in a going-nowhere alliance with The Miz that everyone would like to forget. Sure, DIY deserve praise for overcoming all of that, reuniting as a team and winning gold, but their brightest days defo came down in NXT.


7. The Ascension

The Ascension WWE NXT
WWE.com

How's this for a throwback to vintage NXT?!

The Ascension had fans talking about retro acts like The Road Warriors, Powers Of Pain and Demolition as they squashed everyone in sight to rule the NXT tag-team division in 2013. Konnor and Viktor were actually the second wave of Ascension hysteria in developmental, but WWE ignored the first and focused on the future.

Make no mistake about this: Konnor and Viktor were considered the future. Many figured they'd be a smash hit on the bigger shows once Vince McMahon was ready to embrace them. Then, when the call came in 2014, Vinnie Mac tripped over his own feet and presented The Ascension as out-their-depth frauds. Oops!

JBL disparaged the pair on commentary for being "nothing more than a rip-off", and the team themselves openly admitted they were a homage to duos from yesteryear. It was hardly impressive stuff, and the bloom came off the rose within weeks. By 2015, The Ascension must've been daydreaming of those halcyon days in NXT.


6. Andrade

Andrade Zelina Vega
WWE.com

It's 2024 and Andrade still comes up in conversation when fans ponder who could be a breakout star from the midcard. In short, the guy hasn't been anywhere near as much of a success as anyone thought he would be when Andrade and Zelina Vega were one of NXT's most attractive double acts.

Hell, Zelina has done more than Andrade since the NXT days, and she's roundly considered more of a valet than an outright wrestler. 'El Idolo' was stuck in a rut on the midcard before leaving for pastures new in 2021. His two-year AEW run was full of false starts, then he got sick of that and launched a WWE return earlier this year.

Andrade has been on company books again since Royal Rumble, but... what has he really achieved? He's handled business as part of the Rey Mysterio vs. Dominik/Santos Escobar storyline, but hasn't done much aside from that. It's July 2024 and people are still wondering when he'll fulfil his potential.

NXT was his apex run full stop.


5. Malakai Black

Aleister Malakai Black WWE NXT
WWE.com

Speaking of guys who have experienced start-stop life on the AEW side.

Malakai Black's 'House Of Black' faction has had select moments of brilliance, but Tony Khan never seems sure how to pull the trigger on them. Thus, they're stuck in an endless loop of being called threatening without ever being that much of a threat in the end. It's Groundhog Day booking.

Back in 2020, it's the kind of thing the-then Aleister Black would've been frustrated about in WWE. He was one of the many, many, many acts coming up from NXT that Vince McMahon toyed with. Lost and seeking direction, Black nonetheless excelled whenever he was allowed to get torn in about it in-ring and show off his vibrant striking style.

His 100-day(ish) NXT Title reign is still the best Black has ever been. Generally, matches vs. Adam Cole, Andrade, Velveteen Dream and even lumbering beast Lars Sullivan ruled. His title loss to Tommaso Ciampa at TakeOver: Phoenix in January 2019 was also stunning.

Has he ever topped that body of work? Not even close.


4. Keith Lee

Keith Lee NXT
WWE.com

Health problems have wrecked any momentum Keith Lee had, but poor AEW booking has also been a real problem. Of course, Lee's health is the most important thing. Unfortunately, he can't be the same Keith he was on NXT between 2018-2020. That's become crystal clear, and it's depressing for those who badly wanted the man to blow up into a major star.

2019 Keith Lee might as well be ancient history, never mind five years ago.

A shockingly poor run on WWE's main roster in 2021 led to his departure. The wrestling world cheered when Tony Khan picked Lee up as a free agent in early-2022. Now everyone would see the great things this dude was capable of, right? Right?! Not quite. It turns out Vince McMahon's 'Bearcat' stinker wasn't the only thing holding Keith back.

Again, it's important to mention Lee's health issues. They've been crippling for his career. However, when healthy, nothing he's been doing in AEW has matched his NXT output. That was then and this is now. Keith Lee 2K19 was on fire, and that was peak 'Limitless'.

It's been all downhill since.


3. Adam Cole

Adam Cole NXT
WWE

This could be a controversial one.

After all, Adam Cole headlined AEW's biggest show ever at All In London 2023. There, inside a busy Wembley Stadium, he wrestled on/off pal MJF in front of a passionate crowd. The next week, Cole and MJF defended the ROH Tag Titles against The Dark Order before injuries robbed their story of forward thrust.

AEW decided to out Cole as the mysterious 'Devil' later that year, and he's been the leader of the Undisputed Kingdom ever since. That, dear readers, is a poor retread of the more impact Undisputed Era over on WWE's TV. The NXT faction was legitimately excellent and dominated the brand for years after debuting in 2017.

It produced Cole's best work. He was incredible as NXT Champ, and rightly held the belt for over a year before dropping it to Keith Lee. Adam's jump to AEW has been blighted by injuries, but it'd surely struggle to match his NXT tenure anyway. That was peak 'Bay Bay'.


2. Karrion Kross

Karrion Kross
WWE

There's plenty of time for Karrion Kross to put this right, but he better get a move on. The same goes for Scarlett, 'cause she hasn't had the same impact by his side on the main roster. Together, the pair have been teamed with AOP and veteran manager Paul Ellering as the Final Testament. It's so-so.

Raw's writers are matching SmackDown's by treading water with Kross. He was on top of the world as an unstoppable killer heel during a fearsome NXT run between 2020-2021. That included a memorable NXT Title win, a disappointing title vacation due to injury and then everything erm... well, everything fell to pieces.

Karrion's appalling 2021 run on Raw led to his WWE exit. Then, Triple H rehired him the next year and everyone recognised Kross's potential. He hasn't lived up to it/been allowed to live up to it thus far since returning. So, that NXT run is really peak Karrion Kross. It'll continue to be until he shows something more.

Is that ever coming? Fingers crossed.


1. Shayna Baszler

Shayna Baszler NXT TakeOver XXV
WWE

Pictured above: Shayna Baszler in all of her badass MMA-fighter-turned-pro-wrestler glory. At the time, Shayna was NXT Women's Champion and seemed destined to rule the roost whenever she hit Raw or SmackDown harder than an MMA elbow. That February 2020 call up was newsworthy but the beginning of the end.

Sure, Baszler has made good money over the past four years and continues to work the women's tag-team division, but she's never matched her NXT Women's Title success on the main roster. Duos with Nia Jax, Ronda Rousey (permission to shudder!) and Zoey Starks have all been samey.

It doesn't seem likely that WWE will ever trust Shayna to be more than part of a team. She had more about her than that in NXT. In fact, Baszler stood alone as a lone wolf kind of character, and fans respected her no-nonsense skills. Perhaps a move back to NXT would work wonders to rekindle some of that old fire in her belly.

Or, y'know, she could keep making up the numbers and cashing cheques. Fair play, if so!

Which other wrestlers peaked in developmental? For more WWE, check out Wild Sh*t Wrestling Did You’ve TOTALLY Forgotten About and 10 Wrestlers Who Buried Their OWN Promotions!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.