10 Wrestlers Who Proved Their Worth In A Crisis
Atlas flexed.
All Elite Wrestling promoted an unfathomably excellent professional wrestling show under such dreadful conditions on Wednesday night.
The mood of the entire planet had darkened. An unprecedented global crisis, a threat to our very liberty, unfolded in the age of total convenience; a generation of people, almost overnight, had to adjust to a wavelength of living they had only ever read about on Wikipedia, which was easier and more convenient than reading a textbook.
Of drastically lesser importance was the task faced by AEW: promoting a wrestling show in front of no fans, an entertainment event meant to afford an escape where it has become impossible to engage in that mode. Outrageously, they succeeded, by applying its greatest resource to its most inspired - and let's face it, flagrantly irresponsible - idea.
To underscore the weirdness of it all, MJF was at the heart of it - MJF, the moneyed sociopath who would remove the dignity of and lash a man, just to watch him wince, provided the soul of the broadcast. MJF was so fantastic throughout that he inspired this very list.
He wasn't the only one...
10. MJF
MJF surveyed a void keenly felt by all wrestling fans, a void that made the very premise of wrestling untenable, and filled it with two hours of absolutely incredible motormouth wit and physical charisma.
As part of an inspired show-long conceit, MJF and Shawn Spears gambled on the outcome of matches, which effectively crystallised AEW's entire 2020. In an excellent year of process refinement, the company through adverse circumstances solved one of its few remaining residual issues: those ceaseless, cringeworthy crowd reaction shots. Instead, that camera captured MJF in full sh*theel mode as he thrust his head into Spears', repeatedly, in celebration of taking his money from him.
Even off-camera, MJF used every breath in his lungs and quip on his lips to not dominate the show but to enhance it. His chauvinism, heckling, and utter yob behaviour proved true his catchphrase; in an era in which too many fans attempt to get themselves over, MJF truly is better than all of us, and we know it now.
We'll never have another Bobby Heenan, but MJF's entire life is an awesome unscripted heel promo. He is the closest we'll get.
9. Sammy Guevara
It's weird and probably very dumb to conflate Sammy Guevara with some of the luminaries on this list, especially given the enduring scope of their achievements, but for 40 intoxicating seconds, the Spanish God on Dynamite made fans celebrate the worst possible scenario.
He made those watching at home glad that nobody was in attendance. If they were, they'd have sang Judas, and not him.
Guevara was beyond priceless on Dynamite this week. Chris Jericho made his entrance to guest commentate on the Inner Circle Vs. Elite six-man main event, but Le Champion's presence commands an audience singalong, since Judas by Fozzy is every AEW fans' most-played song on Spotify since October 2019. Guevara filled the aching void by grabbing a nearby microphone in a scene of t*t-popping sycophancy.
This was in character. That's what was so amazing about it. Guevara idolises Jericho, and sought to please him by playing to his ego. He butchered Judas as if Jericho were the teen idol, and he the hysterical, sodden girl, throwing metaphorical panties at Jericho's face.
He could have done with the real thing, to hide his corpsing, but that was the charm. Everybody on that show was on a night-long quest to pop everybody else.
8. Hiroshi Tanahashi
New Japan Pro Wrestling was mired in identity and business crisis when Hiroshi Tanahashi emerged from his Young Lion chrysalis in the early 2000s.
Inokism had mangled the very purpose of the promotion, much less the style and quality. The wrestlers were obliterated, legitimately, by MMA stars under Antonio Inoki's strange and wildly counterproductive quest for legitimacy. Oxymoronic in concept and shameful in execution, the soul of New Japan was as battered as the faces of its humiliated stars: the innovative Junior Heavyweight division and its underrated, similarly eclectic heavyweight counterpart were scarcely recognisable.
Gates nosedived. Not unlike WCW, which became a grim ersatz version of the WWF, and failed because fans wanted an alternative, NJPW had become a quasi-PRIDE. At least the WCW of 1999/2000 was astute enough to know which industry to parody.
Tanahashi proved his worth by implementing a new ring style, or at least the core values of pro wrestling; with his handsome face, eye-catching physique and wholesome, electrifying charisma, Tanahashi became the Ace, a role synonymous with him now through his mesmeric, deeply intelligent in-ring performances, so profoundly brilliant that they have informed the prestige of World championships and the mythos of legends beyond himself.
Tanahashi proved his worth in tandem with...
7. Shinsuke Nakamura
Hiroshi Tanahashi is credited mostly with New Japan's post-Inokism revival - and this narrative will likely take further hold, the more he establishes his synonymity with it - but Shinsuke Nakamura's role cannot be overlooked nor overstated.
Where Tanahashi was the classic hero figure, universal in his appeal as a fan's wrestler, critic's wrestler and wrestler's wrestler, Nakamura was a totally captivating, almost mystical presence - alluring counter-evidence to the growing western audience that the "bland" accusations levelled at puroresu historically were, in fact, racist as sh*t. Nakamura was so awe-inspiring in his pomp. He fused the strangest, most offbeat charisma with a stunningly violent and legitimate interpretation of strong style, at once restoring and advancing the purest vision of puro.
If Tanahashi made New Japan big again, Nakamura made it cool. He became a myth in his own time, so much so that he could never hope to live up to that reputation in WWE, its systemic creative failures be damned.
Nakamura was the stiffest, toughest, most charismatic, hell, even the funniest package in the world at one point.
6. Bret Hart
Bret Hart and Hiroshi Tanahashi are remarkably similar.
Both were technical geniuses with the ability to, yes, execute everything perfectly in great pro wrestling matches seamless in their internal logic. Both played ostensibly cool characters undermined, endearingly, by certain quirks (Bret's insistence on cramming a "The" where it didn't belong; Tana's air guitar bit). Both made a nemesis (Shawn Michaels, Katsuyori Shibata) they loathed for their poor attitude. Both nemeses were cooler.
And, like Tanahashi, Bret Hart was also tasked with leading a promotion at its lower ebb.
Tanahashi fared better, but Hart's influence cannot be traced directly; his legacy has been laundered almost. Bret was the (best) professional wrestler tasked with steadying the sports entertainment monolith, teaching the remaining fans its language, sweeping their legs out from under them and sending them crashing head-first into lifelong obsession. Hart made hardcore fans of a generation, and proved his worth by drawing sufficiently in a promotion mired by scandal, a badly unfashionable level of buzz, and its perception as the leader of a deplorable industry that insulted the intelligence of the public to con them out of money. Hart was such an artist that it's almost strange to consider that the broad WWF was his home - but that's how good he was.
Before the relationship deteriorated, Hart made a wrestling fan out of Vince McMahon.
5. Michael Cole
Michael Cole isn't to blame for WWE's creative downfall, obviously, but it doesn't help that with the exception of SmackDown's ace post-brand split run, he has voiced the very worst of WWE's output - even the awful Attitude Era aberration that was early-to-mid 1999's nonsensical gothic sh*t-show.
Cole's problem is that he's fantastic at a detestable job. He is uncannily slick, coating the product in an off-putting ooze. He's so polished at transitions and segues, a goateed metronome, that his input actually unravels suspension of disbelief. It's all so competent, (ironically) perfect, that his mere presence gives the game away: this is a produced show, not a captured event.
But Cole proved his worth - and he classifies as a wrestler because he's worked more singles matches at WrestleMania than 16-year main roster vet Dolph Ziggler - on the September 10, 2012 Monday Night RAW.
It was the night on which his broadcast colleague and dear friend Jerry Lawler suffered a heart attack on-air. Cole had to shift from panic professional mode, using every last resource of skill and mentality to proceed with the broadcast. It was the most impossible, unimaginable position, and he executed it profoundly well.
This one night throws into sharp relief every criticism levelled at the man. His job is impossible, and it was never more impossible on that night.
4. John Cena
WWE was plunged into crisis in the tragic, transformative summer of 2007, in which Chris Benoit murdered his son Daniel and wife Nancy.
The news coverage was widespread and damning; WWE was excoriated for its systemic drug culture and a perceived bid to obscure it via the barely-enforced Wellness Policy implemented in the wake of Eddie Guerrero's 2005 death. The unspeakable tragedy brought WWE's various harrowing, normalised practises into focus. In a dual drive to cleanse its public image and protect its independent contractors, WWE transitioned into its PG Era of broader, childish comedy, chair shots to the back, and the blade ban.
John Cena was the square-jawed, dorky face of it; a man-child permanently resplendent is his own blinding gear, Cena emphasised the cartoonish elements of his act, scrubbed the blood from his face, and accelerated through his corny comeback routine to appeal to a young audience, who loved his Star Wars promos, Peter Engels-adjacent jibes and exaggerated facial expressions. Cena drew big to this audience, and his deeply admirable charity work restored WWE's public image.
He was the future of marketing, but he was not at all insufferable nor disingenuous about it.
3. Sting
The paths taken by the Ultimate Warrior and the man he broke in with, Sting, could not have been more divergent.
Warrior was a complete d*ckhead, Sting a rare wrestling nice guy. Warrior was fundamentally talentless, Sting very skilled with the work ethic to improve. Warrior left the WWF in the sh*t when his erratic whims were not serviced, Sting waded through the sh*t of Jim Herd's putrid WCW as a consummate professional.
Crisis accurately describes much of Herd's tenure, particularly 1992, a period in which WCW was compared to the AWA's late-'80s death throes. WCW house shows were ghost towns, ratings were in the sh*tter, and the creative was atrocious. Sting's popularity however was strangely immune to the horror show, and he was ardently committed to making it work. He voluntarily took an absolute pasting from Vader in this lifeless period, of the sort many of his babyface peers flatly refused, putting himself over as both company man and beloved, gutsy hero. He worked Cactus Jack soon after that programme, too, enduring the most dangerous matches in North America when the megastar babyface of the era had no reason to. As all of North American wrestling entered a recession of sorts, Sting was a vital, awesome reminder of an NWA that hadn't prostituted itself in a strange tribute to the WWF.
Sting was different. They did that, and he does this!
2. Matt Hardy
Is it too reductive to state that TNA/Impact Wrestling has existed in a perpetual state of crisis?
If that is indeed a cynical, blanket reading of a promotion that prior to the arrivals of Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff had secured a sizeable base and offered a compelling alternative often in spite of itself, it was certainly in crisis by 2016: the company had alienated much of its core audience with its hysterically awful booking, and the best in-house talent had left as its TV deals shrunk in revenue and availability.
Matt Hardy's attempts to rebrand himself were often treated with condescension; he had always tried very hard - and think of the word that most always follows - and beyond an inspired acknowledgement of the toxic reception his ROH run was afforded by its fanbase, nothing clicked. But then, very little did at the height of WWE's monopoly.
This changed when Hardy first developed his "Broken Universe", the first glimpses into which drew scorn. It wasn't clear how in on the joke Hardy was, until the punchlines arrived with the force and frequency of a kangaroo jab.
Hardy brought the buzz back to Impact - and his own mainstream career, thought damned by the inexorable improvement of the in-ring standard - with meme-able mispronunciations, outrageous visual gags, and an endless well - or a lake - of absurd creativity.
1. Will Ospreay
Will Ospreay, since pro wrestling has all but shut down, has created both winking respite from this grim present and a life-affirming pitch for its eventual, uncertain future.
In an enterprising bid to provide fans with new, live content, Ospreay helped organise a free show on which he devised the quite brilliant and resourceful idea to wrestle his girlfriend, Bea Priestley, in what was a very good and creative match. In addition to creating safe content in a new world that cannot sustain it - this description does not extend to the chop he unleashed on her chest, f*cking hell - Ospreay listened to CM Punk's musing that a match between them might be of interest, and challenged him to what would be an improbable über-epic at next year's Wrestle Kingdom super-show.
Ospreay had proven himself a benevolent force for good in professional wrestling before this crisis unfolded. He is committed to growing the scene in Australia, thrashing his body in matches most do not see, and of course spearheaded the pre-NXT UK BritWres renaissance.
He loves pro wrestling and refuses to give up on it.