10 Wrestlers Who Regretted Jumping Ship

Sometimes, you don't know what you've got 'til it's gone.

British Bulldog
WWE.com

While the Monday Night War has long since ended, the wrestling world is still divided.

On one side sits WWE, a global juggernaut that has seduced the mainstream consciousness into associating its brand as the genre, a la Kleenex or Xerox. On the other side lie many promotions struggling to claim that No. 2 spot – New Japan, Ring of Honor, Global Force Wrestling, and Lucha Underground. Through much of the 21st century, Global Force/TNA was recognized as the second biggest promotion, even acquiring talent from WWE like Christian and Kurt Angle.

The tide has now turned; WWE’s roster includes TNA’s staples like AJ Styles, Samoa Joe and Bobby Roode. It was a risk for those performers to jump ship, because Vince McMahon has traditionally soured on stars not created by the WWE machine. Many WCW, ECW and TNA performers have been the victim of McMahon’s close-minded view, in which he devalues any achievements not attained under the WWE umbrella. As a result, their characters are overhauled to fit his image, and oftentimes, their careers have suffered. It’s not solely a McMahon trait, though: other promoters have struggled to capitalize on the momentum of popular incoming competitors.

Unfortunately, these wrestlers have learned that the grass isn’t always greener on the other side.

10. Monty Brown

marcus cor von
WWE.com

At one time, the Alpha Male was pegged as the next big thing in pro wrestling. With a pro football background and unlimited charisma, Monty Brown naturally transitioned to the squared circle, where he developed an exciting finisher and fun catchphrase. Brown had all the tools necessary to become TNA’s biggest homegrown star.

However, management fumbled his direction, turning him heel when he should have been Jeff Jarrett’s arch rival. The damage had been done. Brown decided to try WWE when his contract expired.

Debuting on the ECW brand in January 2007, Brown’s name was changed to Marquis Cor Von, as part of WWE’s effort to trademark all characters. Later changed to Marcus, the name strayed from Brown’s simplicity, evoking a sophisticated German or French presence instead. He was thrown into the short-lived New Breed stable, never having the chance to stand on his own.

Six months into his WWE run, he requested time off for family issues and never returned.


9. Raven

Raven - Attitude Era
WWE.com

McMahon had no idea that Johnny Polo reinvented himself since leaving the WWF in 1994, as Raven revealed during a classic Talk Is Jericho appearance.

So the master of psychological warfare, a two-time ECW World Heavyweight Champion, was dead on arrival when he returned to McMahonland in 2000. It was a tragic waste of talent because Raven was perhaps the most innovative character of the nineties, a perpetually pessimistic sociopath tailor-made for the Attitude Era.

Because of McMahon’s understanding of the character, or lack thereof, Raven was relegated to the Hardcore division, smashing fellow directionless ECW castoffs with garbage cans and kendo sticks.

He was treated like a jobber, competing only on secondary shows like Sunday Night Heat, and even becoming an announcer again, before being released in early 2003.


8. Shane Douglas

Shane Douglas had all the momentum in the world, then WWF turned him into Dean Douglas
WWE.com

A decade before Matt Striker educated wrestling fans, there was Dean Douglas.

Accompanied by his trusty chalkboard and “Board of Education” paddle, Douglas would grade fellow wrestlers on their performances, often failing fan favorites. It was a cute concept for the wrong guy – Douglas had already been the ECW World Heavyweight Champion, a cocky jock who referred to himself as “The Franchise.” While he was a legitimate school teacher outside the ring, the audience didn’t recognize him in that subdued role.

His WWF run lasted less than six months, as he became a target of the Kliq. When Douglas was scheduled to win the Intercontinental Championship from Shawn Michaels at In Your House 4, Michaels forfeited the title after being assaulted by a group of Marines the night before.

Although Douglas was awarded the title, he had to immediately defend it against Kliq member Razor Ramon, who defeated him in 11 minutes.


7. Mike Awesome

Mike Awesome That 70s Guy
WWE

Whereas Raven and Douglas were former ECW champions when they jumped ship, Mike Awesome was still the reigning ECW World Heavyweight Champion when he attacked Kevin Nash on Nitro. The wrestling world was shocked as Awesome held the title hostage, refusing to hand the belt back until Paul Heyman paid him his due fees. Although WCW officials never showed Awesome on TV with the title, they consistently referred to him as ECW champion. After he agreed to lose the title to Tazz, a WWE-contracted wrestler, Awesome’s stock plummeted.

His badass aura dissipated due to two gimmick changes: The Fat Chick Thrilla, in which he became infatuated with overweight women, and That ‘70’s Guy, in which he arrived in arenas in a Partridge Family-style bus, wearing colorful leisure suits.

Fans treated the monster like a joke, and Awesome’s career never recovered.


6. Vader

Vader clotheslines Shawn Michaels Raw 1996
WWE.com

Vader’s WWE debut is a microcosm of his entire lackluster run.

After weeks of buildup, the mastodon entered the 1996 Royal Rumble, eliminating four competitors before being tossed out by measly Shawn Michaels. Although he re-entered the match to cause havoc, fans had already been conditioned to see Vader as less than a top star.

After dominating WCW for the first half of the 1990s, Vader looked lost in the WWF. He failed to defeat Shawn Michaels at SummerSlam, in which HBK publicly scolded the monster for mistiming a move, and then played second banana to Psycho Sid. As injuries piled up and poor booking left the mammoth as “a big, fat piece of sh*t,” Vader left the company in 1998 - another demonstration of WCW stars crumbling in the WWF.


5. Road Warriors

Legion Of Doom
WWE.com

Hawk and Animal made numerous visits to WWE, and none of them were worth it.

When they first jumped from WCW in 1990, McMahon rechristened them the Legion of Doom. They teamed with Ultimate Warrior in several battles against Demolition before winning the WWF Tag Team Championship at SummerSlam 1991. They lost the belts in February in a taped, but never aired match against Money Inc. Then they brought in their old manager Paul Ellering, who WWF fans didn’t know or care about, and a ventriloquist puppet named Rocco. Understandably, Hawk was p*ssed and left.

When they returned, they won the titles again, but lost them to the New Age Outlaws a month later. They evolved into LOD 2000, with a more modern, badass look and Sunny as their valet. Apparently, alcohol and drug issues came with the look, as Hawk’s real-life substance abuse became storyline, creating a wedge between him and Animal.

The nadir of their run came when Hawk faked a suicide jump from the Raw TitanTron - a disgusting angle that has left a foul taste since his untimely passing just a few years later.


4. Davey Boy Smith

Davey Boy Smith
WWE.com

As a result of the Montreal Screwjob, Davey Boy Smith jumped to WCW with Jim Neidhart and Bret Hart. The roster was already bloated with veterans taking TV time away from young talent, and there wasn’t any room nor creative direction for the British Bulldog. He and Neidhart were relegated to WCW Thunder, failing to capture the WCW Tag Team Championship.

Then the injuries began – Smith was sidelined for a month after hurting his knee in April, and then at Fall Brawl 1998, he landed awkwardly on a trapdoor underneath the ring, which nearly paralyzed him. While he was hospitalized for six months, he received a FedEx confirming that his contract had been terminated.

During the recovery process, he became addicted to morphine and painkillers, a lethal combination that ultimately contributed to a fatal heart attack in 2002.


3. Vince Russo

Vince Russo
WWE.com

Vince Russo’s career could be defined as a tale of two cities: the innovative halcyon days of the WWF, and the desperate attempt to recreate them in WCW.

After two years as WWE’s head writer, helping the company achieve unprecedented financial and creative heights, Russo felt burnt out and unappreciated. McMahon added SmackDown to the schedule with no reprieve for his staff. So Russo took his talents (and assistant) to Atlanta to take the helm of the titanic he helped sink.

Unfortunately for the industry, Russo proved more fatal inside the operation than opposed to it. He became an overbearing onscreen character, even winning the WCW World Heavyweight Championship. Entertaining WWE gimmicks like Road Dogg and Chyna were replicated to a lesser degree with Buzzkill and Asya. The illusion of pro wrestling was shattered as performers “went off script” and participated in “shoot fights.” And of course, David Arquette won the World Title.

Although he was hired by WWE and TNA after WCW went out of business, Russo’s supposed genius had been exposed.


2. Chris Harris

Braden Walker
WWE.com

One half of America’s Most Wanted, one of the top tag teams in TNA history, Chris Harris had unlimited potential when breaking out onto his own. After being blinded and betrayed by his ex-partner James Storm, Harris sought revenge as a sympathetic babyface, eventually beating Storm in a Texas Death Match. The Wildcat then drifted in the midcard for the rest of the year before signing with WWE in January 2008.

In hindsight, that was easily the worst decision of his career. Harris debuted on the ECW brand in July as Braden Walker, telling a knock-knock joke to Armando Estrada. He beat Estrada and then beat James Curtis the next month – his only two matches before being released. Harris believes he was simply a message sent to other WWE hopefuls in Dixieland that TNA members best not apply.

His potential evaporated, and he was damaged goods for TNA.


1. Public Enemy

Public Enemy WWE.jpg
WWE.com

Rocco Rock and Johnny Grunge made two mistakes in their career: jumping to WCW rather than the WWF in 1995- and then actually going to the WWF in 1999.

Vinnie Mac holds grudges.

A staple of ECW, Public Enemy partly popularized the hardcore, high-risk, brawling style that the WWF adopted in the Attitude Era. However, they were never recognized for inspiring the style because they were hated by their peers and bosses. They lasted only two months in WWE, as Bradshaw and Farooq took great pleasure in “running them out” of the company. Before a match on Sunday Night Heat, the Public Enemy allegedly asked to change the finish, which infuriated the Acolytes and caused them to mercilessly pummel the ECW originals.

After burning brides in WCW, ECW and the WWF, Public Enemy had no place left to go.


Contributor

Formerly the assistant editor of Wrestledelphia, John has joined the Muthaship at WhatCulture.