10 Wrestlers Who Should Have Stayed Retired

Father time remains undefeated, including against some of these pro wrestling icons...

Ric Flair
WWE

Bret Hart both should and shouldn't have returned to WWE in 2010.

The reality of his departure from the company a little over 13 years earlier had haunted him and his legacy ever since, to such an extent that he made nice for a DVD profile piece just to ensure a planned hatchet job didn't do further damage to yet more incoming generations of fans. It was real to Bret when he worked, and it was just as real now that he couldn't go like he used to.

There was an immense sense of catharsis when he hugged Shawn Michaels in the opening scene of the historic January 4th 2010 edition of Monday Night Raw, and outside of simply the best punches you'd see in wrestling all year when he threw them, that probably should have been that. A Vince McMahon faux-reconciliation kicked off an over-booked WrestleMania build and a badly booked WrestleMania match, and the die was cast on what a post-Stroke 'Hitman' could do beyond the aforementioned flashes of magic with Heath Slater of all people later in the year.

Bret Hart had to come back for so much darkness in his life to disappear, even if his brilliance was always going to best reflected in the archives than in anything brand news. A lot of others had the same stance...

10. Ric Flair

Ric Flair Last Match
wiki

Often considered the greatest professional wrestler of all time in spite of countless personal indiscretions that could and should have realistically tarnished any legacy forever, Ric Flair just can't and won't call time. 

His retirement match at WrestleMania 24 against Shawn Michaels was the perfect send-off - maybe up to that point the best in the history of the entire industry. There was no bigger stage, put on as it was by the market leader in an act of genuine respect and deference to a locker room that mostly idolised 'The Nature Boy'. But Flair's story didn't end there.

He returned to the ring in 2009 - just one year later - to do some Australian house shows with Hulk Hogan before becoming a semi-regular TNA TV act the following year. He was back at it again in 2022 at the age of 73 for a one-shot "Last Match" pay-per-view against Jeff Jarrett and Jay Lethal alongside Andrade, his son-in-law. These matches were a far cry from his heyday, with the latter particularly raising concerns over his health and safety. 

Flair's return did little to enhance his legacy; instead, it left fans worried, nostalgic or just simply depressed thinking of a long-distant time when Flair could live up to his many monikers. 


9. Shawn Michaels

WWE Crown Jewel DX Brothers Of Destruction
WWE.com

As with his aforementioned WrestleMania 24 rival, Shawn Michaels is another name that still crops up when discussing the legitimate greatest to ever do it. 

The conversation might be more divided than it once was thanks to the obvious influences (for better and worse) Michaels' style left on future generations and NXT trainees, but try not to be totally shouted down by the haters - 'HBK' has the CV to match any of the all-timers. And his retirement match against The Undertaker at WrestleMania 26 was a perfect illustration of that. Michaels rode off into the sunset with his head held high.

So high in fact, that he heard the constant calls for a return and defiantly said "No". All until a controversial deal with the Saudi Arabian Sports Authority produced a dollar figure too great for him to turn down. In 2018, Michaels teamed with Triple H against The Undertaker and Kane at the second Saudi show Crown Jewel and played his part in a match that was universally and correctly panned. 

The bout was marred by botches and the undeniable reality that four were brutally past their prime. The return did little more than sully his first send-off, and stain his record with one of his biggest turkeys. 


8. Hulk Hogan

Hulk Hogan TNA X Division
IMPACT Wrestling/TNA

Hulk Hogan is easily the most recognisable name in professional wrestling, and at this point courts infamy as much as he ever did the bright lights of standard issue fame and fortune. But even discounting every gross detail that's emerged about the views he holds beyond promos, his post-full-time wrestling run remains full of misses rather than hits. 

Hogan’s initial farewell from the ring came in the early 2000s following a last WWE Championship-winning run that flattered to deceive. From there, he continued to make sporadic appearances for the market leader, but when that well ran dry, he embarked on a TNA run that was nothing short of a disaster. 

The matches were plodding, the promos lacked the energy and bizarre believability of his heyday, and his physical limitations were painfully evident save for one magic night against Sting at Bound For Glory 2011. Hogan's aura of invincibility was shattered, and each subsequent appearance only further tarnished his once-untouchable legacy. That his presence had actively damaged the company's standing in the industry hung over the run too - he was mostly as terrible a booker as he was a talent. 


7. The Undertaker

The Undertaker Quit
WWE

No matter how successful he gets at pulling YouTube faces for his podcast, The Undertaker’s career will always be synonymous with decades of destruction and dominance in WWE, particularly at WrestleMania, where he built a 21-0 winning streak that surel won't ever be touched. 

His streak-breaking match against Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania XXX could have been the perfect moment to hang up the boots, and per his Network docu-series, it was that fairytale ending he'd always been looking for. However, The Undertaker continued to wrestle, with mostly stinkers to his post-2014 name. 

While there were still flashes of brilliance (The Graveyard Dogs was inspired in concept and execution), there were far more lows. The infamous match against Goldberg at Super ShowDown 2019 was a catastrophe, with both men struggling to perform basic moves, culminating in a match that had fans wincing in discomfort. Another problem - it wasn't the only one from around that time and as an act that was saved almost exclusively for big stages, his shockers were being viewed by the biggest possible audiences.

His final match against AJ Styles at WrestleMania 36 was a fitting end to his run proper, but the years of diminishing performances before it left something of a bittersweet taste.


6. Mick Foley

Mick Foley TNA Title
TNA/IMPACT Wrestling

When Mick Foley stopped and stared back at the life he was walking away from at No Way Out 2000, he looked every bit like he believed he was doing it for the last time.

His autobiography said much the same - he was prepared to call it a day before being offered the right amount of money to do one more favour and go back on his word to main event WrestleMania weeks later. Leaning into just how stupid it looked, he at least accepted that as the real final outing, all until he was teased back to work with the task of elevating Randy Orton to the next level between 2003/04. The cycle repeated two years later with Edge, and just when it honestly seemed like jobs outside the ring were going to define his future, he jumped to TNA and eventually became World Champion.

Not least because of the heights of 2000, 2004 and 2006, the returns were naturally diminished. Getting by on star power and a willingness to get grisly if the stipulation called for it, Foley's TNA run was still a mixed bag at its best, but sadly served as the real end of the line. When that wrapped, all that remained was a 2011 indie date and 2012 Royal Rumble cameo.

Foley himself seemingly wanted a different closing chapter - he openly petitioned for a retirement deathmatch as a 60th birthday present to himself, but doctors stepped into nope it based on his legendarily long list of injuries. 


5. Roddy Piper

Roddy Piper Sean O'Haire
WWE

"Diminished returns" are always the central theme of lists such as these, but Roddy Piper was the sort of performer who never allowed any part of himself to look diminished. That, regrettably, became a big part of the problem with each return he made following his mid-1990s peak.

Realistically, Piper couldn't ever touch the mastery he achieved at any of his iconic peaks between 1983 and 1992, but an alignment-flipped run against Hulk Hogan for WCW in 1996 and 1997 proved that he had box office muscle even if match quality had died on the vine. What tanked the 'Hot Scot' in his latter years was his inability to back up his ever-powerful promos. A microphone maestro right up to his last appearances on screen, few talked as good a game or at least with the sort of machismo Piper exuded.

And then the bell rang.

His 2006 nostalgia run alongside Ric Flair skewed more sad than sweet, as did his well-intentioned face off with Jimmy Snuka at the 2008 Royal Rumble. A legends bout against Chris Jericho at WrestleMania was saved by Ricky Steamboat, not Rowdy Roddy. Nobody cares now and nor should they, but the best days of Piper's final decade were comfortably spent on the stick rather than the mat. 


4. Bill Goldberg

Bill Goldberg
gmsrp.cachefly.net

Bill Goldberg was an unstoppable force in WCW during the late 1990s, to such a degree that even the wretched booking that defined the company's dying days couldn't quieten chants for his name in the years following its closure. That was ultimately the biggest creative crime attached his 2003/04 WWE run - the fans tired of the version of 'Da Man' they were given by the time he exited at WrestleMania XX.

His return to WWE in 2016 was subsequently met with trepidation rather than excitement, but a series with Brock Lesnar changed everything. At long last booked to perfection in his Survivor Series and WrestleMania matches with 'The Beast' his short, sharp, shock of an Undisputed Title reign looked and felt like the perfect way for him to put a bow on his career while exorcising the demons of his first failed run.

Then, frustratingly, on it continued. A disaster against The Undertaker in Saudi Arabia remains the headline, but the Super ShowDown 2019 contest wasn't the only stinker, and fans pounced on the lost magic. Save for a remarkably cool squash win over Dolph Ziggler at SummerSlam later that year as a rehab, his increasingly laboured efforts (and controversial creative decisions such as an easy victory over The Fiend Bray Wyatt ahead of WrestleMania 36) did much to undo the incredible Lesnar one-two punch. 


3. Kurt Angle

Kurt Angle Baron Corbin
WWE.com

Realistically underrated considering how few greatest-of-all-time lists he features in, Kurt Angle was and is a contemporary wrestling icon that has the matches, the promos and the numbers to back up one of the most legendary runs in the history of the industry. It stood to reason then, that - when finished with TNA and a celebrated run on the UK independent scene during its boom - he'd explore one last run in WWE.

What materialised simply couldn't live up to expectations, even if it started magnificently with him subbing for Roman Reigns as one-night member of The Shield. The wear and tear had understandably caught up with the 'Olympic Hero', and it mattered not that fans were willing to forgive the ravages of time - Vince McMahon and others around him weren't.

Kurt's 2019 (and, as of writing, in-ring career) ended with a whimper rather than a bang. He lost to Baron Corbin deep into an over-long WrestleMania in front of a crowd too tired to get up for only-okay action.


2. Kane

Kane Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

Kane mostly always sucked bell-to-bell - name five great singles matches or ten great tag matches from a 20+ year run, you can't - but the more he finally disappeared from view, the more it stung when he returned.

Charmless as a character nearly two full decades into his main roster career, his full time run as The Authority's school trousers-wearing goon stripped him of any remaining aura and/or magical powers that might have continued to carry him even further past his expiry date. The diminished returns from there were such that a move into politics was as welcome for wrestling fans as it was the cranks that follow him on social media.

A walking talking example of WWE simply just doing things, his re-insertion into the main event picture in and around the 2018 Royal Rumble was creatively pathetic. Braun Strowman was no more established as the roster's new monster by beating Kane any more than he was getting drilled in the head for real by Brock Lesnar - and it least those stiff strikes only hurt Strowman rather than everybody having to watch. 


1. Stone Cold Steve Austin

Triple H Stone Cold Steve Austin
WWE

...but only until 2022, when he absolutely nailed it.

'The Texas Rattlesnake' has always been fiercely protective over himself and his legacy; so much so that one of the few times he almost got back in the ring before a glorious WrestleMania 38 contest with Kevin Owens was binned when he smartly elected not to turn up to Taboo Tuesday 2005 and lose to Jonathan Coachman.

Oddly, the defeat wouldn't have felt anywhere near as preposterous then as it would do now. The quiet dignity around Austin's WrestleMania XIX was very him - a clued-in Jim Ross was permitted to speak in glowing terms of his run atop the industry as he departed following a loss to The Rock, but nobody else was any the wiser that this really was it for the 'Toughest S.O.B'. What followed in the months afterwards was anything but dignified.

A parody of himself as the Co-Raw GM and/or "Sheriff" of the show, Austin later said he needed to get away from wrestling for a sustained period to truly get it out of his system. There were other more fan-friendly reasons for him to step away.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.