10 Wrestlers Who Should Replace Shelton Benjamin As SmackDown's New Star

The Gold Standard has fallen, but who should take his place?

MVP WWE United States Champion
WWE.com

Just as quickly as Shelton Benjamin’s return to WWE SmackDown was announced, the former Intercontinental Champion’s dream was snatched away from him. Benjamin took to Twitter over the weekend to announce that he would be unable to make his comeback when WWE’s stringent medical tests revealed he had a torn rotator cuff, forcing the former World’s Greatest Tag Team member into a long, gruelling recovery process.

It’s a big blow for both sides. Benjamin has been wrestling in Japan for years now, and while his exposure to puroresu has helped him develop immensely as an in-ring competitor, his Pro Wrestling NOAH homebase is a million miles away from the WWE Universe’s conscience. This was a fantastic opportunity for an athlete on the wrong side of 40, one that may never arise again.

For WWE, they’re missing out on a talented performer that fans still remember from his previous 8-year run with the company. Widely-regarded as one of the most underused WWE wrestlers in recent memory, Benjamin was always an exciting, eye-catching athlete, and his presence would have added some much-needed beef to SmackDown’s ultra-thin midcard scene.

Benjamin’s injury leaves a big gap to fill, and without a new addition or two, SmackDown will remain a top-heavy, imbalanced show with little that separates the main eventers and enhancement guys. Here are 10 wrestlers who should replace Benjamin as SmackDown’s new star.

10. Ricochet

Prince Puma
Lucha Underground

Widely regarded as the best American high-flier in pro-wrestling today, Ricochet is an ultra-athletic phenom.

Whether performing at home, abroad, or as Lucha Underground’s “Prince Puma”, Ricochet’s stunts and acrobatics have set the indy wrestling scene ablaze in recent years. He’s one of the most attention-grabbing and gif-worthy performers on the planet, and if you don’t believe us, check out his insane NJPW clash with England’s Will Ospreay from earlier in the year.

WWE have reportedly been interested in acquiring Ricochet for quite some time now, and it’s understandable why. Very few wrestlers move with his grace and poise, and Ricochet has mastered the art of high-flying wrestling. He’s far from a one-trick pony, either: Ricochet’s high spots might grab the attention, but he’s also an accomplished mat wrestler who links moves together soundly and logically.

His Lucha Underground contract remains a big issue. Allegedly containing a clause that prevents their employees from appearing on a rival TV show until all their taped performances have aired, this would stop Ricochet from appearing on Raw or SmackDown until 2017. Still, WWE are the biggest company in the business, and if any company can mount a successful legal case against such a restrictive clause, it’s Vince & co.


9. Drew Galloway

Drew Galloway
David James Wilson/ICW

WWE didn’t know what they had on their hands with Drew Galloway.

Going from Vince McMahon’s hand-picked “chosen one” to a comedy rockstar jobber in just a few years, Galloway was green and unseasoned upon debuting, but has developed into an outstanding performer in his own right. His act was stripped back and taken away from him before WWE fans truly got a chance to see what Drew could do, and although he’s deeply-entrenched in TNA’s main event scene at the moment, there’s little doubt Galloway will return to Stamford someday.

SmackDown could use him immediately. A tall, imposing worker who’s great on the mic and no slouch in the ring either, Galloway has been on an absolute tear since his WWE release. Whether working for PWG or Scotland’s ICW, Galloway has never brought anything less than 100% to the table, and his performances have been as impressive as his growth has been staggering.

He’s a complete professional wrestler, and one tailor-made to make an impact on SmackDown.

Would Galloway trust WWE not to make the same mistakes again? That’s the big question. With Triple H’s increased power and the company’s newfound appreciation and acknowledgement of the indies, however, it’s safe to assume that his progress has not gone unnoticed.


8. Jay Lethal

Jay Lethal WCPW
Oli Sandler/Ringside Perspective

Current Ring of Honor Champion Jay Lethal is one of the most highly thought of wrestlers in America, and another man that WWE have had their eyes on for a while. With his ROH contract allegedly expiring at the end of December, it may finally be time for Lethal to make the jump to the biggest stage of them all.

His story is similar to Galloway’s. Chronically misused as a TNA comedy act, Lethal found new life after returning to ROH, and has really grown into his role as the company’s champion and leading performer. He’s an absolute master of his craft with no obvious weaknesses, and he’s in the prime of his career: the time has never been better for Jay Lethal to jump to WWE, and if the company are smart, they’ll bring him in sooner rather than later.

WWE typically prefer to bring their new signees in through NXT and Full Sail University, but Lethal is more than capable of bypassing this entirely. As a well-travelled ring veteran who wrestles a smart style without sacrificing big spots and excitement, Lethal is the total package, and brings an all-important element of star quality with him.

Bringing him in makes all the sense in the world.


7. John Morrison

John Morrison Tag Team Champion
WWE.com

Just like Shelton Benjamin, John Morrison is a mega-talented multi-time midcard-level WWE champion who has done very well for himself since leaving the company. Whether working as Lucha Underground’s “Johnny Mundo” or going by his birth name (John Hennigan) on the indies, Morrison’s parkour-influenced all-action style continues to win multiple admirers across the globe.

His WWE departure came in 2011 so (like Benjamin) he’s still very much in the memory of all but WWE’s newest set of fans. Had SmackDown shown a vignette for Morrison’s return rather than Benjamin’s, the reaction would’ve likely been the same, as they posted incredibly similar runs throughout their respective WWE tenures. This makes him a natural candidate to fill the void left by the Gold Standard’s unfortunate injury.

Though held back by the same LU contract restrictions as Ricochet, Morrison would be an immediate star on SmackDown’s midcard. He’s the type of worker who goes all-out to entertain the crowd, and while he’s not the best promo guy in the world, Morrison knows how to excite and dazzle between the ropes.

If SmackDown’s midcard is lacking anything, it’s all-out athleticism, which is something Morrison has in spades.


6. Adam Cole

Adam Cole
ROHWrestling.com

Like Jay Lethal before him, Adam Cole is another Ring of Honor megastar whose contract expires at the end of the year. Again, Cole is a well-seasoned indy worker with no obvious holes in his game, and while he’s not quite as tenured as Lethal, it’s highly unlikely that Cole would require significant time at the Performance Center in order to fit in on SmackDown.

The 27-year-old Cole has a knack of making every little thing he does look like the easiest thing in the world. He wrestles with a smoothness and fluidity that’s increasingly hard to come by these days, and he compounds his outstanding technique with a superstar look and limitless charisma.

The cocky, arrogant Cole might be the best microphone worker on the North American indy scene today, and he’d have no trouble grabbing a mic and getting himself over on SmackDown.

Cole is a little undersized at 5’11” and 210lbs, but he’s been one of ROH’s hottest properties for a long time, and he’s still years away from peaking as a wrestler. There are times when his shtick and act can become a little overbearing, but that wouldn’t be an issue with WWE’s regimented approach to writing and storytelling.

Put Adam Cole on the SmackDown roster, and he’d be a major player within months.


5. Shinsuke Nakamura

shinsuke nakamura
WWE.com

Though The King of Strong Style’s forthcoming NXT Title match with Samoa Joe looks set to ground him in developmental for a while longer, there’s no reason he couldn’t work SmackDown at the same time. Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn, and a handful of others did this as they transitioned to the main roster full-time, and given Nakamura’s undeniable talents, there’s no doubt he’s capable of doing the same.

Shinsuke Nakamura will soon outgrow Full Sail. Four months after debuting, he’s already the most popular wrestler on NXT, and well on his way to becoming a major WWE superstar. You only need to listen to live crowds singing along with his entrance theme to understand just how popular the guy is, and his track record suggests that his momentum is only going to continue.

Blessed with an electric charisma reminiscent of Freddie Mercury or Michael Jackson, Nakamura has more presence than anyone else in the company. Your eyes are drawn to him from the moment he steps onto the stage, and he keeps you locked-in with his hard-hitting strong style wrestling techniques.

As one of the best wrestlers on the planet, Nakamura’s call-up will come sooner or later, but WWE could do a lot worse than throwing him into the fray right away.


4. Apollo Crews

Apollo Crews
WWE.com

If you made a list of wrestlers who’ve benefitted most from the 2016 Brand Split thus far, Apollo Crews would be near the top. Lost in a series of directionless feuds after being called-up, Crews doesn’t quite look revitalised on SmackDown, but he’s definitely growing into his skin as a performer.

His performances over the past few weeks have more than caught the eye, and if he can be the one to finally give the hated Intercontinental Champion The Miz his long-overdue comeuppance, his popularity could explode.

If WWE aren’t going to bring an outside worker in, they could do much worse than push Crews into the role originally intended for Benjamin. Yes, his character work needs refinement, but he’s a thrilling athlete who knows how to entertain between the ropes. If SmackDown can focus on his in-ring abilities rather than his lacklustre charisma, they can make a star of Apollo Crews, even if the upper-midcard is likely his ceiling as a performer.

Crews would make a great Intercontinental Champion. SmackDown’s midcard isn’t as crammed with in-ring standouts as Raw’s, and there’s nobody to overshadow him. Competing against the likes of Miz, Baron Corbin and Kalisto will help Crews build his own identity and really establish himself on the main roster going forward.


3. MVP

MVP Drive By Shelton Benjamin
WWE.com

Hotly-tipped to return as part of the 2016 Brand Split, MVP’s WWE re-emergence has yet to materialise. The man himself has denied any contact with the company, and while it’s best to take wrestlers’ comments on such situations with a pinch of salt, WWE must now see him as one of the most obvious choices to fill the Benjamin role.

MVP’s previous run was fairly productive. He had a nice stint as United States champion, and was presented as a talented, must-see performer from the day he stepped through the door. Things fell off shortly after he’d lost the belt, however, and with MVP finding himself featured less and less prominently, he left WWE in 2010.

An NJPW run followed, before MVP signed for TNA and became one of the company’s lynchpins. A serious knee injury prevented him from reaching his full potential there, but MVP remained one of TNA’s standout performers even when he wasn’t wrestling, further compounding the common opinion that WWE had sold him short by not delivering on a main event push.

Charismatic, brash, and strong in the ring, MVP would be a welcome addition to SmackDown’s midcard. As a former US Champion, he’d be a great guy to help rebuild the Intercontinental division and put over the next wave of younger superstars.


2. Bobby Roode

Bobby Roode NXT
WWE.com

One of the most important, decorated, and celebrated wrestlers in TNA, Bobby Roode has finally arrived in NXT. After making a couple of fleeting appearances in segments at the last two Takeover events, Roode took to the ring last week with a microphone and the most ludicrously brilliant entrance theme in WWE history. His message was clear: I am a megastar, NXT needs me, and I’m here to dominate.

Roode is a near-perfect WWE wrestler. Having worked for TNA for over a decade, he has unparalleled experience working a sports entertainment style, and, most importantly, he knows how to work a television audience. Roode’s workrate is solid, and with his look, intensity and charisma, he has all the tools needed to play a major role not just in NXT, but also on the main roster.

At 39-years-old, WWE may look at cutting Roode’s NXT stint short and calling him up sooner rather than later. He has “top guy” written all over him, and on his best day, Roode is one of the best heels in the business. Throw him on the SmackDown roster and he’d be capable of putting on a good match and compelling feud program with just about anyone else they have.


1. Sami Zayn

Sami Zayn Kevin Owens WWE Battleground
WWE.com

Sami Zayn has struggled since the Brand Split. Having voiced his trepidation at being drafted to Raw, the same show as longtime rival Kevin Owens, the former NXT Champion went on to defeat KO in an instant classic at Battleground, but has laboured ever since. Zayn has eaten two consecutive losses, and wasn’t even featured on this week’s show: amazingly, after the biggest win of his career, WWE Creative appear to have nothing to Zayn on Raw.

The solution? Send him to SmackDown, and make him a star. Zayn will be a WWE main eventer someday - he’s too popular and talented not to be - but for now, he’d be an immediate boon to the blue brand’s upper-midcard, and a great choice to build that particular scene around. Zayn is a proven big match performer, and if he switched to Tuesday nights, he’d likely be the best out-and-out wrestler on Daniel Bryan’s roster. He’d standout from the get-go, regardless of his creative direction.

It remains to be seen whether or not inter-brand roster trades will be a thing, but if they are, sending Zayn to SmackDown makes too much sense. He’s far too good a talent to rot on Raw without direction, and while fans would rather see him competing for the top belt sooner rather than later, there are countless others ahead of him in the pecking order.

Let Sami Zayn rule the roost on SmackDown’s midcard scene for a year or so, and WWE will have a serious star on their hands.


In this post: 
MVP
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.