10 Wrestlers Who Turned Down WWE Contracts
Cody Rhodes is jumping right back in, but WWE waters aren't for everybody.
Every prospective pro wrestler, even if they grew up kissing a poster of Sting before bed every night, dreams of someday performing in WWE. Love them or loathe them, there's really no question that, at least in a range of measurable, financial metrics, they're the number one company in town.
Yes, the product may not be the best, the working conditions might often be questionable, and you're twice a year asked to act as court jesters to a Saudi Prince, but there's still the prevalent belief that signing with Vince McMahon means you've made it.
You don't have to like it, mind. A brief spell is enough: being able to bill yourself as a 'former WWE superstar' can set you up on the indy scene for life.
But there are some particularly principled - or particularly greedy, in some cases - pros who, in spite of the undeniable benefits to their bank balances, have said "thanks, but no thanks" to the world's biggest wrestling company. It takes a hell of a lot of courage; opportunities like these might never come around again.
That said, they nearly always do. Carlito's pushing it, mind.
10. Kurt Angle
Olympic gold medalist Kurt Angle might be a WWE Hall of Famer and bonafide professional wrestling legend now, but there was a time when even the thought of entering the industry was totally anathema to his legitimate athletic sensibilities.
Angle's initial flirtations with the business left a sour taste, when, disgusted by a crucifixion angle involving Raven and The Sandman, he walked out on an ECW taping in 1996. As far as he was concerned, wrestling was beneath him - and the Philly incident did little change his tune.
Nor did Vince McMahon's offer of a 10-year WWE contract shortly after his Atlanta triumph. Angle considered his pedigree put him on a pedestal above all the professional fakes, and - medal in tow - told Vince it'd be unrealistic if he lost any matches. "He looked at me like I was crazy," Angle later recalled. McMahon didn't call back, and it'd be two years before Kurt finally put his pomposity to one side.
9. Kota Ibushi
After Kota Ibushi starred in the 2016 Cruiserweight Classic, made an unexpected NXT cameo and even pledged himself for the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic, it seemed a virtual guarantee that the former DDT darling would soon become a permanent fixture in WWE.
Unfortunately, Triple H and co. didn't consider the fact that Ibushi is a man who very much sails by his own wind. WWE engaged in pained negotiations to sign the Japanese independent star to a contact, but were met with constant rejection. When asked by Tokyo Sports in 2016 whether he'd go full-time in WWE, Ibushi finally put the question to rest:
"Zero chance. Absolutely not," he told the paper. "These one-shot deals are an absolute plus for all concerned. If I can be the precedent for this kind of deal, it opens the doors for a lot of Japanese talent in WWE."
The opposite occurred. With the emergence of AEW, WWE started stockpiling talent to lengthy, watertight contracts, guaranteeing they couldn't use their platform as a way to gain exposure and leverage deals elsewhere. Ibushi himself eventually resisted overtures from AEW, signing a 'lifetime contract' with former employers NJPW.
8. AJ Styles
When AJ Styles set the wrestling world alight with his Royal Rumble 2016 debut, it was phenomenal because of the sea-change in WWE philosophy it represented. Here was a man whose entire prestige had been built outwith the company, being promoted opposite de facto top babyface Roman Reigns as a global superstar. In many ways, it was his status as the independent scene's top dog which made him so special.
Things could have been very, very different if not for the peculiarities of fate. Styles was part of WCW's roster when WWE bought the company out in 2001, and although he had evident promise, the Georgian was still an absolute rookie with no cache. His contract wasn't picked up, though a year on, WWE offered him a $500-per-week developmental deal, which'd necessitate a move to Ohio's Heartland Wrestling Association. Whilst it was a fantastic opportunity for the budding star's career, he selflessly rejected it so his wife could continue her college education - though it also helped that his independent dates were already matching the offer.
Later in 2002, a disguisedly bigger opportunity came along. NWA:TNA formed, and Styles was quickly installed as its first breakout stars.
7. Terry Funk
After the roaring success of their retrospective Rise and Fall of ECW DVD in 2004, WWE decided to capitalise on fresh interest in Paul Heyman's hardcore outfit by running, what they planned to be, a one-off special reunion show. Emanating from New York's Hammerstein Ballroom, the homecoming aimed to be as authentic as possible, uniting a throng of ECW originals, including some WWE had hitherto been apprehensive to employ including The Sandman and Sabu.
There was, however, one notable absentee: Terry Funk. The irrepressible 'middle aged and crazy' legend had played a crucial role in helping transform the struggling Eastern Championship Wrestling into the cult renegade group it became, sparing his time and his body for the cause.
Yet, when Heyman came calling in 2005, Funk surprisingly rebuffed him. It wasn't anything personal - well, not against Paul, at least. The hardcore vet had already agreed to work Shane Douglas' Hardcore Homecoming show, and, not wanting to help McMahon exploit the ECW name for profit, saw it as a worthier date.
Until the next year at least. Having seen how faithful the first One Night Stand was, Funk agreed to take part in the sequel.
6. Carlito
Every few months or so, rumours begin doing the rounds that everybody's favourite apple-spitter Carlito is 'set to sign' with WWE, ending an exile from the company beginning 2010.
And every time, it proves utterly bogus. The most recent example came last October, when Savio Vega, operating as some sort of Puerto Rican talent broker, heavily implied Carly Colon was in advanced talks with WWE management over a comeback. We're nearly half a year on, and yet pips still remain un-expectorated on WWE screens.
Although his brother Primo, and cousin Epico, are, somehow, still under WWE's employ, it seems Carlito simply has no interest in the easy money at the Big E - or that easy money isn't big enough. He rejected similar overtures in 2015, with a disagreement on remuneration the apparent dealbreaker. He needs to be mindful that the longer he stays away, the less value his name holds.
5. Will Ospreay
As of 2022, (and with the important caveat that this relates solely to his in-ring work) Will Ospreay remains one of the greatest professional wrestlers on the planet. Would that be the case had he signed with WWE in 2018? His talent may be doubtless, but like his then-social media breaking sparring partner Ricochet, it seems all too likely it would have been painfully repressed.
During an episode of Chris Jericho's Talk is Jericho podcast, the Brit revealed that WWE phoned him up, and immediately began talking business. He was forthcoming with his reply, telling Stamford, "I appreciate it, but I'm quite happy [in NJPW] and love being a part of this."
A gracious response, and one which ensured bridges to the company stayed standing should he wish to cross them in the future. However, unless WWE make wholesale changes to their schedule, that doesn't seem likely any time soon. He further explained to Jericho:
"Those guys are wrestling on Christmas Day and New Year's and that would have killed me. Christmas to me is family and I love being with my family. I don't think I could do it. I really don't."
4. Sting
Sting, a WCW icon and the last great holdout of the Monday Night Wars, finally - courtesy of the savvy mediation of 2K Games - relented on years of refusal to cross over to the other side, at last signing a big-money deal with WWE in 2014.
What had been the sticking point for The Franchise, given the likes of Booker T, Goldberg, and DDP had all agreed to work for their prior rivals - in the latter's case, at the cost of a lucrative stay-at-home contract?
As it happens, precisely that fact. Having seen so many of his former WCW colleagues creatively undermined by the company - he found The Rock's burial of Booker T particularly galling - Sting repeatedly turned down WWE's overtures. Perhaps ironically, he thought his legacy would be better preserved slumming it as the biggest star in TNA.
And what happened when he did eventually buckle? Why, his vigilante angle opposite Triple H was recontextualised as a decade old Monday Night War revival, which Sting, the WCW representative, obviously lost. Perhaps he had a point.
3. Zack Sabre Jr.
As with Kota Ibushi, Zack Sabre Jr's inclusion in WWE's 2016 Cruiserweight Classic had many fans of independent wrestling frothing from the mouth at the prospect of seeing one of the industry's finest technicians exposed to a mainstream audience.
Sadly, as with Ibushi, it didn't happen - despite the best efforts of mate TJP. When asked why he turned down a WWE contract, Sabre had a typically intelligent answer. "It'd be like asking a musician, "Why didn't you sign with the biggest record label?' I'm just concerned with being the best professional wrestler I can me. It was really just a personal choice. This is my path."
It's fair to say, that unless a frankly ludicrous offer comes in, or Sabre is looking for a comfortable retirement way down the line, he won't be alighting on Raw, SmackDown or NXT any time soon.
2. The Elite
Just months before launching AEW, members of The Elite were offered absolutely gigantic opportunities by a panicked WWE, eager to prevent the inevitable.
A king's ransom was presented, which, in addition to a massive financial windfall, would have given them complete creative control in NXT and the main roster, as well as a slot on the Network for weekly show Being The Elite.
Ultimately, they collectively agreed that, whilst the offers were unquestionably magnificent, the risk of going into business for themselves was one worth taking.
Kenny Omega told the Mac Attack podcast that, though working there someday isn't out of the question, he doesn't feel "any less of a performer, any less of a man, or [that he's] had any less of a career" for not having done so. For now, the focus is on providing the best wrestling possible - and he reckons only AEW allows him to do that.
1. Brock Lesnar
Brock Lesnar has a reputation as a mercenary these days, wringing as much out of WWE as possible for the bare minimum of work, but once over, he said boo to all that cash in pursuit of one of his personal sporting dreams.
Back in 2004, Lesnar was fairly fed up with the wrestling lifestyle, and in particular, the hectic travel schedule. Though just two years into his run, and already one of the industry's biggest new stars, Brock decided to jack it all in, and instead embark on a career in professional football.
WWE weren't about to let one of their hottest commodities leave without a fight, however, and furnished Brock with a then astonishing seven-year contract worth approximately £36.5 million. No amount of money could persuade him, and word soon slipped that he was on his way out - leading to the WrestleMania XX farce against the similarly departing Goldberg, during which fans voraciously jeered both men.
A motorcycle accident curtailed Lesnar's NFL ambitions, and he was left to rue those uncollected cheques in the bank. He would not make that mistake when the opportunity arose once more in 2012.