10 Wrestlers Whose Careers Were Destroyed By A Single Mistake
Botched, bashed and banished from super-stardom to the unemployment line.
A wrestling career can change in a moment. It can bask in the glory of a championship win or drown in a missed move. Often there are political forces at play ensuring that a snapshot in time can live to define.
Randy Orton recently hit the headlines as allegations surfaced about his backstage antics. WWE has thus far remained quiet on the matter. Orton, after all, is a star. He has received a continued push and a high-level feud on TV. Whilst Orton's trunks are seemingly made of Teflon, others are not so lucky. Many WWE employees walk around on eggshells knowing that a trip or slip could cost them their job.
This has always been the case with big stars treated differently. 'Superfly' Jimmy Snuka was accused of murder. McMahon still found a spot on the roster for the charismatic act. Now that WWE believes he has served his time, Hulk Hogan's insidious comments will no doubt be brushed under the carpet.
In the whacky world of professional wrestling, some superstars are given chance after chance. Other lesser known stars are cast out into the wilderness. It depends on marquee value, the lower down the card you are the less forgiving the employer tends to be.
10. Bart Gunn
Viagra on a pole wasn't Vince Russo's only dubious idea. Even in WWE with Vince McMahon as a filter, the odd stinker would seep through. During 1998 the popularity of mixed martial arts was growing in the US and Japan. WWE were eager to cash in on this trend and boost the profile of new signing 'Dr Death' Steve Williams. Russo came up with the Brawl for All tournament. Brawl for All matches would consist of three one minute rounds with points scored for punches and take-downs.
WWE management expected Williams to win the tournament. The grizzled veteran had a reputation as one of wrestling's hard-men, and several lower mid-card performers thrust into the fray as cannon fodder for the star. Enter former tag team champion Bart Gunn who handily defeated Williams via knockout. Bart would go on to defeat self-proclaimed hard-man Bradshaw in the final. The tournament had been a disaster for WWE with several performers picking up injuries.
The winner was ultimately punished by Russo's mistake. At WrestleMania XV Gunn was fed to the super-heavyweight boxer, Butterbean. The former Toughman contestant knocked out the wrestler in a mere 35 seconds. Gunn was released shortly thereafter never to be heard of in WWE again.
9. Daniel Puder
In late 2014 on an episode of SmackDown, Daniel Puder became infamous. Kurt Angle was taking that year's Tough Enough contestants through their paces. Angle started with Chris Nawrocki, taking the youngster down with amateur grappling. The Olympic gold medallist broke the rookie's ribs. Unwilling to suffer a similar fate and more than capable, Puder shot on Angle, locking him in a kimura. Puder had a background in MMA and if not for a quick roll up counter and a fast three-count he may have broken Angle's arm.
Angle and his colleagues were furious backstage. Had the Olympian tapped out to a Tough Enough contestant, he may himself have been on this list. Puder's career was doomed from then on. He would defeat Mike 'The Miz' Mizanin at Armageddon in his only pay-per-view win.
His final pay-per-view appearance was at the Royal Rumble. Eddie Guerrero, Chris Benoit, and 'Hardcore' Holly would play locker-room police. The three took turns chopping the youngster brutally, finally dumping him out of the match and the WWE in short order. Puder would pay for his shoot-style mistake with his WWE career but remains infamous to this day.
8. Rick Bognar
Sometimes the simple act of saying yes is enough to destroy your career. This was the case when Rick Bognar accepted a lucrative looking gig with WWE.
In September 1996 WWE were in dire-straits: WCW was winning the Monday night ratings battle, and Turner's side had also captured two of McMahon's leading acts Scott 'Razor Ramon' Hall and Kevin 'Diesel' Nash. Eager to still capitalise on the characters he had created, a desperate McMahon simply recast the roles.
Jim Ross hyped the duo's arrival on RAW. WCW management was so concerned by these claims that they gave Hall and Nash pay-rises, but Atlanta's fears that two-thirds of the New World Order were going back to McMahon were ill-founded.
A pre-Kane Glenn Jacobs would fill Nash's shoes as Diesel. Bognar would become Razor Ramon. The team were introduced by a heel Ross to utter silence; the fans didn't even find this worthy of boos. Despite this reaction, the pair of ringside ringers would take on the WWE Tag Team Champions Owen Hart and 'The British Bulldog' at In Your House 12 in a losing effort.
Thankfully the Royal Rumble would be their final appearance. Glenn Jacobs would be repackaged as Kane. Bognar would pay for this mistake with his career. A trip to Japan would follow but, "Hey Chico", the damage was done.
7. Kevin 'Nailz' Wacholz
SummerSlam '92 was memorable for many reasons. Mainly ‘The British Bulldog’ Davey Boy Smith defeating his brother-in-law Bret ‘The Hitman’ Hart in-front of a rabid Wembley crowd. One match that few remember the event for is Nailz against Virgil, a match that would prove the catalyst for the convict's WWE demise.
Wacholz’s Nailz ex-prisoner character was introduced as a rival for Big Boss Man. The story was that former convict Nailz had been brutalised by the Boss Man whilst in prison. He arrived in WWE in spring '92 attacking the former prison guard. The culmination of their feud came in November at Survivor Series '92 in a dreadful nightstick-on-a-pole match.
It was shortly after this event that performers received their payments for SummerSlam. Wacholz was furious that because his match with Virgil had been cut from the pay-per-view he had not received pay-per-view money for the event. He angrily confronted McMahon, where the two squared off and Walcholz choked Vince. He was fired immediately.
A bitter Wacholz then filed a wrongful termination lawsuit even claiming McMahon had sexually assaulted him. WWE filed a counterclaim and both suits were eventually dropped. Nailz never appeared in WWE again.
6. Monty Brown
Monty Brown had the 'it' factor that WWE looks for in a superstar. Muscular and athletic, Brown had even competed at Super Bowl XXVIII for the Buffalo Bills. Brown was trained to wrestle by Dan 'The Beast' Severn and Sabu, and despite a slow start in TNA, he would go on to make an impact in 2005.
Impressed by his ability, WWE signed Brown in 2006. Renamed ’The Alpha Male’ Marcus Cor Von, Brown made his debut on the ECW brand as part of the short-lived New Breed stable. Brown continued to build his profile in ECW including an appearance at WrestleMania 23. In June 2007 he was defeated by CM Punk in his biggest bout to date, failing to reach the finals of the ill-fated ECW title tournament. Punk’s scheduled final with Chris Benoit never happened. In the wake of the Benoit tragedy, Brown’s exit went unnoticed by many.
Brown asked management for time off due to an unspecified family crisis which was reluctantly granted. Plans to move Brown to RAW were cancelled and he was released from his contract. Asking for time off came with a very high price for Monty Brown. He would retire from wrestling after his WWE release.
5. Billy Jack Haynes
Billy Jack Haynes had been a draw in the NWA Pacific Northwest and was set to be a huge star in WWE. Considered a legitimate tough guy outside of the ring, the soft-spoken grappler commanded respect.
Pushed from day one as a strongman, he was immediately thrown into a high profile feud with ‘Macho Man’ Randy Savage over the Intercontinental Championship. Although he wasn't booked to win the championship, he was at one stage considered as a possible successor as Savage moved up the card.
Haynes went onto a mid-card programme with Hercules Hernandez. Haynes was released by the company in 1988 when he refused to lose a match in Portland, Oregon, and changed the finish. Although his career continued, it would never reach the heights it could have in WWE. He had the look and was an OK worker, but he made the mistake of saying no to McMahon.
Haynes has in recent years become famous on the internet for his bizarre behaviour. Most infamously he made a confession to being involved in a murder which he claimed Bill and Hilary Clinton orchestrated. Such outlandish statements have become the norm for Haynes, ensuring he will remain in the public eye for all the wrong reasons.
4. D'Lo Brown
This is the saddest entry in the list as it actually destroyed two careers in very different ways. During a bout between Darren ‘Droz’ Drozdov and D’Lo Brown in October 1999, Brown dropped Drozdov whilst executing his running power-bomb.
As a result, Drozdov was paralysed from the neck down. It was a tragic accident for which Drozdov did not blame Brown. Drozdov later stated in interviews that he was wearing a loose shirt during the match and that he felt that had been partly to blame. Brown, however, took full responsibility saying that he had botched the move, stating it could have happened to "any" wrestler he had been in the ring with that night.
Brown had been one of the most promising talents of the late '90s. From 1997-99 he was a prominent part of the Nation of Domination and his career peaked when he won the European and Intercontinental championship simultaneously. After the accident, Brown confessed he wrestled “differently”, terrified of hurting another colleague.
Although D’Lo Brown would continue to wrestle in WWE and TNA, he was never the same after that night. He would usually be a jobber to the stars or feature in meaningless tag teams. A simple in-ring mistake that could happen to anyone had ruined two promising careers.
3. Muhammad Hassan
Working as Mark Magnus in Ohio Valley Wrestling (OVW) Marc Copani had impressed WWE management. In 2004 he was rewarded with a promotion to WWE television.
Despite being of Italian descent, Copani was repackaged as angry Arab-American Muhammad Hassan. The character would criticise the way Muslims were depicted in the media. Although immensely talented, Muhammad Hassan was unpopular for all the wrong reasons.
During the summer of 2005, WWE planned to push the Hassan character into the main event scene. On the 4 July SmackDown taping it was announced that Hassan would take on The Undertaker at the Great American Bash. Later that night, Hassan summoned five masked villains to attack The Undertaker. The five men were clearly supposed to be terrorists, even choking the ’dead man’ with piano wire.
Just three days later, the London Bombings took place. Thankfully, the controversial footage was cut from the UK broadcast of SmackDown. The tasteless angle became one of the most criticised in WWE history.
The Hassan character was removed from television at the insistence of UPN and Copani was released from his contract in September. It has since been revealed that the original plan was to make Hassan the World Heavyweight Champion. Copani was unlucky he accepted a gimmick that was one of WWE’s most offensive, killing his career in the process.
2. Fred Ottman
It’s fair to say that given his limitations in the ring, Fred Ottman had a decent run in WWE. He initially appeared as Hulk Hogan's babyface ally Tugboat in 1990, before turning heel and aligning himself with Earthquake. Ottman was renamed Typhoon and the pair would capture the WWE World Tag Team Championship as The Natural Disasters. The team would split up when Earthquake left to tour Japan in 1993.
Realising his prospects were limited as a singles competitor in WWE, Ottman opted to join WCW. It was there that he would make the most memorable debut of all time.
His infamous entrance came at Clash of the Champions XXIV during the interview segment, 'A Flair for the Gold'. Just days ahead of the Fall Brawl pay-per-view, Sid Vicious and Harlem Heat demanded to know who Sting and The Bulldogs’ mystery partner would be. Sting bellowed, “our partner will shock the world because he is none other than The Shockmaster!”. It was at that moment that Ottman crashed through the cardboard wall. Few would forget him tripping over and knocking off his glitter-covered Stormtrooper helmet.
Ottman fumbled around to put his headgear back on. He even completed the promo but his WCW career was dead before the helmet had even hit the floor.
1. Paul London
From octogenarians birthing rubber hands to men falling in love with mops, WWE has always been fond of a wacky angle. In June 2007, WWE attempted one of the most baffling in company history. A forlorn Vince left RAW during ”Mr McMahon appreciation night”, and headed to his limousine passing several members of the WWE locker-room on his way. As he stepped into the limousine it exploded.
To add to the insanity, WWE treated McMahon's kayfabe death as a legitimate. The angle would only be dropped in the wake of the very real Benoit murder-suicide. In the aftermath of the aborted angle, one man would receive the chairman's wrath.
During McMahon’s walk to the exploding limousine, the performers he passed were instructed to look concerned for the chairman's sanity. The crowded corridor looked suitably sombre. However, Paul London could be seen grinning like a Cheshire cat. Many have speculated that, frustrated with his push, London deliberately went off script on live TV. Whatever the reason, the high flyer was on borrowed time from then on and was released from his contract in 2008, killing his WWE career with a single smile.