10 Wrestlers WWE Dropped The Ball On TWICE
WWE life proved to be a total flop for these wrestlers...more than once!
Succeeding in WWE is hard for multiple reasons. Firstly, you obviously need to be bloody good and connect with the core audience to have any chance of success. Second, workers have often had to battle against Vince McMahon's well-known whims. Triple H is clearly less of a problem there, but even some of his second attempts have been clangers too.
Wrestlers themselves need to take a portion of the blame as well though. McMahon and Triple H would argue that they only provide the platform, so it's really up to the workers to use it properly. That's fair, but...the creative needs to be spot on as well. Blaming a wrestler because they couldn't make two sh*t gimmicks work is hardly fair, for example.
Then, there are those who find themselves totally undermined by writers backstage. Some of Hunter's modern rehires fit in here - they've sailed a beautiful pass overhead into space, only to see WWE creative drop the ball and fail to meet them halfway.
That must be agonising to experience once let alone twice. Sadly, a ton of wrestlers have lived this nightmare over and over!
10. Hit Row
More like Sh*t Row and "Flop Dolla" (credit: Michael Cole), right?!
Seriously though, things are not going well for Top Dolla, Ashante 'Thee' Adonis and B-FAB. They, alongside ex-stablemate Isiah 'Swerve' Scott, gained some traction on NXT before jumping up to WWE's main roster during the 2021 Draft. Things fell apart quickly, and the entire group was released that November.
Scott became AEW's Swerve Strickland and hasn't looked back, but the remaining three members of Hit Row rejoined WWE in August 2022. This second attempt has been a bigger bust than the first; Triple H, like Vince McMahon before him, hasn't been able to find a workable spot for the faction on SmackDown.
Things are so bad that Hit Row top fan-made lists for the worst WWE acts in 2023. Things look bleak for the trio, because they haven't landed whether playing babyface or heel, and Dolla (in particular) hasn't improved in-ring at all.
Hit Row won't get a third chance.
9. Kevin Thorn
Vignettes aired for a counterpoint to the darkness of The Undertaker in 2004. Mordecai was born, and everyone had high hopes he'd be able to grab some of 'Taker's magic and turn it into a lengthy run as WWE's latest supernatural force. Yeah, that didn't happen.
The gimmick lasted three short months before being scrapped.
Kevin Fertig, the dude behind the guise, has been very upfront and honest about his own failings during interviews since. He once opined that trying to copy The Undertaker's slow "zombie" style from 1990-1994 hurt him badly, because that wasn't what people wanted to see in the modern era.
Kev got another crack at it as part of the revived ECW brand in 2006. He became a vampire character named Kevin Thorn, but that ultimately flopped too. Most agree that Fertig had talent, but he just couldn't get any steam behind him in WWE, and so failed multiple times.
8. Bryan Clark
Ask anyone from the 1990s to draw an ideal "WWF Superstar", and they'd probably sketch someone that looked like big Bryan Clark. The dude had God-given muscles for days, and that was handy in an era particularly sensitive to the steroid trial fallout. Clark was introduced in '93 as Adam Bomb.
He was...the survivor of the Three Mile Island nuclear meltdown accident. Yep. Adam had a green tongue just to hammer home the point. It was cartoony, sure, but that shouldn't have been a major problem in the mid-90s. Unfortunately, Bomb didn't work out as a heel or babyface.
A lengthy stint in WCW as Wrath and under his real name seasoned Clark. That's why Vince McMahon was keen to rehire him post-WCW acquisition in 2001, but it was another disaster. Bryan, alongside KroniK partner Brian Adams, worked an infamously terrible match vs. The Undertaker and Kane at Unforgiven 2001 and that was very much that.
Clark once seemed like a top prospect too.
7. Terry Taylor
Speaking of top prospects, it's the "Man Of The Future!".
Before working that guise in WCW, Taylor earned a rep for himself as a damn good pro wrestler. The handsome young grappler was even compared to greats like Ric Flair in some circles, and it looked like he'd go on to bigger and better things when he inked a deal with the WWF in 1988.
That's when sh*t hit the fan. Taylor morphed into the questionable "Red Rooster" character, and was literally instructed to walk around crowing like a farmyard animal. Stranger things have worked in the biz, but this wasn't a neat fit for Terry's traditional feel as a worker.
Following that aforementioned run in Atlanta, Taylor returned to the WWF in '92 as "Terrific" Terry Taylor. It was more up his street, but Vince McMahon failed to put any spotlight on Terry and fans were apathetic at best as a result.
What might've been, eh?
6. Shane Douglas
One Shane Douglas could be forgiven for asking the, "What might've been?" question himself. He worked two stints in the WWF that ranged from mediocre to downright dreadful, and he'd never get that elusive third chance following WCW's demise at the turn of the millennium.
It's kinda weird to look back on Shane's 1990-1991 run in the fed now - it's like watching two distinctly different eras clash by seeing ECW's future 'Franchise' working as a happy-go-lucky, smiling young babyface. Douglas didn't last long here, and ended up being volleyed sideways over to WCW.
Things would surely be better when Shane returned as Dean Douglas in 1995, right? Not really. In fact, things got worse for him. He clashed with members of the 'Kliq' behind the scenes, and stuck out like a sore thumb in the WWF locker room at the time.
Douglas must be considered one of the best all-around workers to never make it in the WWF/WWE.
5. Barry Windham
Well, ain't that a pretty sight?!
A thoroughly miserable Barry Windham donned the camo face paints for as run as "The Stalker" in 1996. That'd be one of three botched ideas he worked during a rotten 1996-1998 run that never satisfied anybody. Things had looked brighter for Baz during his first WWF stint in the mid-80s.
He teamed with Mike Rotunda as The U.S. Express, and they even enjoyed a few runs as WWF Tag-Team Champs. The good times didn't last though, 'cause Windham left to work in Florida for NWA territories before eventually becoming a bigger deal in Jim Crockett Promotions.
If his first WWF run was a classic example of dropping the ball, then his second burst the thing completely. That 'Stalker' persona bombed in front of fans, and gigs alongside Bradshaw as The New Blackjacks and in the rubbish NWA invasion stable tanked too.
Barry, like Shane Douglas, should be viewed as one that got away for the McMahons.
4. Albert
"Aaaaaaalbert! Aaaaaaalbert! Aaaaaaalbert!".
That chant haunted Matt Bloom during his short-lived run as a heel Lord Tensai in 2011. WWE fans trolled the guy, but they were also trolling the company too. Previously, Bloom had worked as Prince Albert (later shortened to Albert) between 1999-2002, and then as A-Train between 2002-2004.
It didn't seem to matter what he was called though. Bloom, who has gone on to carve a niche for himself as one of the most respected trainers in the industry, couldn't rise above the midcard for very long. Either he was missing an important piece of the puzzle, or WWE top brass was too prone to sticking him in comedy situations at the first sign of resistance from live crowds.
Regardless of who's to blame, the Tensai idea was never going to fly in 2011. Go and check out some of Bloom's work in Japan to see the best of him, because it sure didn't come in North America.
3. Karrion Kross
Admittedly, there's time for this to change if everyone gets their act together.
Some might disagree, but this writer thought Karrion Kross was a breath of fresh air during his run on NXT. He worked squashes with the intensity required to make that sort of thing work, then slid neatly into lengthier bouts against the brand's heavy hitters. Plus, his dark, twisted gimmick seemed perfect for WWE's main roster.
It was alarming then to see Vinnie Mac totally botch Kross' in 2021. His revised look was woeful, and Karrion looked humiliated as fans around ringside openly laughed at this Shredder-meets-Mad Max wannabe. Then, to top it all off, Kross was released in November.
Triple H brought him back amidst much fanfare in the summer of 2022, but things have yet to click into place for Karrion. He has Scarlett back by his side on TV, but WWE appears content to fudge his potential all over again.
Fingers crossed things pan out long-term.
2. Bray Wyatt
Lord only knows what comes next for Bray Wyatt.
He burned though a lot of ideas during his first WWE sprint, but things ended on a low note for him and his offshoot 'Fiend' character before being released in July 2021. Wyatt stayed rather quiet after that, and didn't pop up in AEW as expected. Instead, he'd bide his time and return in October 2022.
Pretty much everyone agreed that his timing was excellent. Vince McMahon had retired (which didn't last), and Triple H was calling WWE's creative shots. Surely he'd let Bray soar by encouraging his creativity? Well, eh...yes and no would be the answer to that.
By January 2023, Wyatt was introducing a neon version of his 'Fiend' persona, and it honestly seemed like a giant misstep. Rather than continuing to explore the fragility of his relationship with fans and pro wrestling, WWE painted the broadest strokes over everything and got hammy all over again.
Can Bray's character survive that? It remains to be seen.
1. Scott Steiner
Bruce Prichard once revealed via his podcast that he and Pat Patterson thought Scotty Steiner would be a fine pick to win the 1993 Royal Rumble then headline WrestleMania IX opposite Bret Hart. Vince McMahon vehemently disagreed, pointing out that he'd have to split from Rick to make it work.
McMahon preferred both as a tag-team, so the WWF didn't even get as far as asking The Steiners if they'd be cool with splitting up. What followed was a middle of the road tag run for one of the most exciting duos in wrestling. Then, they lowkey left the company and eventually returned to WCW in 1994.
That was failure number one, but failure number two was next level.
Steiner was a bigger deal when he rejoined WWE in November 2002. The promotion believed they had a ready-made main eventer on their hands, but injuries destroyed Scott's chances. Two calamitous bouts vs. Triple H in early-2003 put any thoughts of top line success to bed.
What a shame.
Which other wrestlers suffered WWE failure twice? For more like this, check out 10 Wrestlers Who NEED To Get Out Of AEW and 10 WWE Stars Who DESPERATELY Need Something New!