10 Wrestling Feuds Where The Bad Guy Won
Lots of Triple H, but it's not ALL about 'The Game'...
Triple H's 2003 feud with Booker T will always be the standard bearer for this particular subject. It's to pro wrestling's detriment that it was forgiven and forgotten so quickly by the company even if fans refused to let the story die.
You remember it, or if you don't, here it is again before a WWE Network documentary presents it as the angle that turned the entire company around for good - Triple H and Ric Flair made remarks that absolutely could and should be construed as racist towards World Heavyweight Championship Number One Contender Booker T,
Trapped within the confines of a period where he beat absolutely everybody, this just felt like one more vanity victory for a man that once had a credible claim to being "That Damn Good" before his insecurity overwhelmed the memories of the time. He didn't get away with murder, but he accused Kane of doing just that. He gave backstage b*llockings about not being able to get over, then ensured that any efforts made to get Rob Van Dam, Bubba Dudley, The Hurricane and others there were undone as soon as they faced him.
Hunter's rationale was something to do waiting to build the guy to take his place, but he didn't half f*cking wait around before finally elevating Batista in 2005. In an effort not to make this list all about those turgid years, let's start with something nearing the end of his run, rather than the flabby middle...
10. Triple H Vs. Sting
Incredible gamesmanship from the man himself here, with a cerebral assassination on par with any of the bodies he took out during his most competitive period.
Over the course of one storyline and match, Triple H managed to abandon months of plot that clearly positioned him as the heel in need of a battering, reframing the war as a last battle of Atlanta (not that one) between WWE and WCW and even managed to go over despite an expressed interest from one-shot-deal Sting to actually do more with the company later that year. In doing so, he commanded 18:36 of the show (not including extended entrances and exits) before returning later for a mammoth angle with The Rock and Ronda Rousey.
How did this even come to be? When Sting tried to stop Triple H's evil Authority group from terrorising WWE of course - a story entirely divorced from the match despite it actually marrying up with 'The Icon's history as a vigilante. He should have learned lessons from the Starrcade '97 omnishambles and stayed in the rafters...
9. Razor Ramon Vs. Randy Savage
This list could be made up of 10 Razor Ramon wins if your writer was to be both a pedant and let out a little more of the New Generation superfan lurking within.
'The Bad Guy' came out on top of enough programmes for this entire article to be one giant troll just to put him over, but he was such a cool customer in his early WWE run that the company had no choice to turn him babyface after less than a year as a top heel-elect.
It was during this time that he sidled up to Ric Flair to make then-WWE Champion Randy Savage's life miserable. It began with the belt itself after Ramon went to ludicrous levels to gift the gold to the 'Nature Boy' before avoiding recompense in a blinding Survivor Series tag team match later.
From there, Ramon got some house show reps in against the company legend to tee him up for a Royal Rumble 1993 headliner against the man that had subdued Flair in the interim. Razor had no luck against an in-form Bret Hart, but had used his abuse of Savage to earn both the spot and (tacitly) the begrudging respect of the audience.
8. Edge Vs. Matt Hardy
WWE would argue that Matt Hardy was given enough of a win with a B-level pay-per-view victory over Edge as well as the fact he returned from a mid-year sacking in the first place. These were crumbs - both of comfort and to feed an audience starving for 'V1.0' to take revenge on his former friend.
'The Rated-R Superstar' and Lita's illicit relationship came to light courtesy of Hardy sharing the story with his online fanbase having discovered it during a period of convalescence, and after the company callously kicked him into touch during the scandal, the heat intensified.
His summer return was the first foreshadowing of the pair's ability to turn the negatives into a creative and commercial positive, but WWE saw the entire thing as a star-making vehicle for Edge rather that a vindication tale for the wronged party. Their SummerSlam match was a borderline burial after Edge targeted the head of his rival, whilst their Raw decider saw Lita rob Matt of his career on the red brand by trapping him as Edge climbed the ladder to reclaim his Money In The Bank briefcase to boot.
Hardy had at least gotten his professional life back on track, but he was offered little quarter when it came to matters of the heart.
7. Randy Orton Vs. Kofi Kingston
Randy Orton calling Kofi Kingston "STUPID!" during their 2019 feud over the latter's WWE Championship win was the cutest of callbacks to the end of their first rivalry - not least because the story with 'The Viper' ensured that it'd be a long time before a young Kingston ever got near the top strap again.
Kofi was just another midcarder trying really hard to get over in a company gradually losing its grip on how to do just that, but a run of success around Survivor Series time back in 2009 could have been the perfect way to propel him a decade before they actually managed it.
Kingston scored an elimination match victory against Orton then took on 'The Apex Predator' and his Legacy mates as they rather listlessly attempted to run roughshod over Monday Night Raw. A Madison Square Garden leg drop was a genuine Moment(TM) but it proved to be the newcomer's last - Orton beat him clean as a sheet on pay-per-view before the aforementioned IRL b*llocking in a pre-Royal Rumble Raw match parked his push once and for all.
Orton was a sh*thouse throuhgout but it's not like the angle remotely mattered when the company was so keen to cater to his temper either way.
6. Ted DiBiase Vs. Dusty Rhodes
Dusty Rhodes did a phenomenal job of selling show-long heartbreak at SummerSlam 1990 as the grim reality of his situation became all the clearer.
For months, 'The American Dream' had been concerned by the gifts randomly being showered upon his manager and confidant Sweet Sapphire, but the show-long angle revealing her betrayal via Ted Dibiase's millions was portrayed with magnificent pathos. Scouring the building for her all evening before his match with Randy Savage, Rhodes was rendered broken by her absence despite the pair being makeshift at best for the first several months of their union.
Rhodes created stakes in Sapphire selling out then suffered the consequences after the distraction caused defeat at the hands of the Macho King, but Dibaise never got his comeuppance.
Real life interfered with the real-feeling storyline. Rhodes was set to head back to WCW in early-1990, so shifted gears to trying to get his son Dustin some exposure in what limited time he had remaining. The pair were programmed against Dibiase and Virgil to tee up the latter's babyface turn but that was understandably prioritised. The Rhodes Family lost and lost and lost all the way back to Atlanta, with Virgil - ironically named as a rib at Dusty's expense - being the one to take revenge.
5. Sgt Slaughter Vs. Ultimate Warrior
Sgt Slaughter was a complete piece of sh*t around the time of the original Gulf War, or was that Vince McMahon for trying to exploit the situation for his own gains when WrestleMania VII's planned venue suddenly looked a little too large for the Chairman's shrinking organisation to fill.
Chasing the cheapest of heat, former human GI Joe figure Slaughter was brought back as a crazed Saddam Hussein apologist and "Iraqi Sympethiser" as actual human beings died in the desert. Somehow working his way into a shot at the Ultimate Warrior's WWE Championship at January 1991's Royal Rumble, this was supposed to be fantasy fulfillment for fans wanting to watch this catastrophic character get what was coming to him.
Vince McMahon Dennis Nedry.gif
Slaughter was going all the way to the 'Show Of Shows' to be taken down a peg or two by Hulk Hogan. The pair couldn't draw the six figures needed to fill the building (or the Sarge was an at-risk civilian, so said the company), but Warrior was the odd man out beyond his red hot programme with Randy Savage. In a gripping but debilitatingly difficult-to-stomach title clash, he lost his gold thanks to relentless interference from the Macho King, and transitioned immediately into getting his revenge instead of reclaiming his stolen prize.
4. Triple H Vs. Eugene
Back to the 'Cerebral Assassin' for a scheme as needlessly convoluted as the character it sought to victimise, as Hunter's using and abusing of Eugene in 2004 took centre stage over just about every other angle on Monday Night Raw...all to get for programmes that didn't even feature him.
Much to the chagrin of his Evolution buddies, Triple H played nicey nicey with superfan Eugene and his undiagnosed-but-broad learning difficulty, because the character was over as f*ck and 'The Game' couldn't have any of that. Or, in kayfabe, because he was part of a master plan.
See, said scheme involved Hunter getting in Eugene's head so he'd help him defeat Chris Benoit, but isn't it pretty f*cking stupid to rely on the guy you've already acknowledged as being a little bit slower on the uptake than everybody else? And isn't it equally f*cking stupid to get so infuriated by the plan going awry that you crush and abuse the character to such an extent that the audience doesn't even want the act of revenge anymore and the gimmick is no longer worthy as a headline concern.
Yes to all of the above. This was a pathetic powerplay behind the camera and a pitiful one in front of it.
3. Yokozuna Vs. Lex Luger
Poor Lex Luger.
It's unlikely he asked to have his giant mirror taken off him and replaced with a multi-day electioneering bus tour in 1993, but that's exactly what he received as Vince McMahon waved his d*ck in the dark looking for the next Hulk Hogan.
Luger had been such a 'Total Package' in WCW that his body seemed a natural fit for the old-style WWE, but the man himself wasn't really a fit for the profile of the company's former top hero. As well as not quite having the working chops of 'The Hulkster' when it really counted, he also didn't appear to have the drive - Luger's "Call To Action" campaign was ironically (and rather tragically) a necessary feature of his push rather than just a way to fill television time en route to his first battle with WWE Champion Yokozuna.
He won by countout to keep the feud alive until WrestleMania the following spring, but McMahon's interest died in the interim. By March, the natural order of things called for Bret Hart to be reinstalled as Champion, forcing Luger to lose to Yoko by disqualification to pay the angle off. Both slipped from the pedestal after the fact, but at least the sumo star had a run and reign to his name.
2. The Authority Vs Daniel Bryan
Enough's been written about how WWE managed to get to WrestleMania XXX in spite of the Daniel Bryan story they were trying to tell, but the ability to fake an "ending" in a company without a finish line erases how things actually stalled to a halt for the "Yes!" Movement.
Injuries robbed Bryan of his Championship after just one significant (and sh*t) angle, but the company gamely attempted to keep his feud with the oppressive Authority going via Brie Bella and Stephanie McMahon. So far so good, too - Bella was booked as on McMahon's intellectual level on television, with Stephanie requiring her husband Triple H to subdue Nikki to get the jump on her twin before their SummerSlam clash.
It fell apart with the result of the pay-per-view. Just one more step on that neverending quest for heat, the match served only to take Hunter and Stephanie out of the angle and drop Nikki back in. She turned on her sister for no adequately explored reason, creating a reason for them to fight each other for months until reconciling with similarly little thought.
The Authority had by then moved on to other things, never to be avenged by Bryan or Brie for their relentless misdeeds.
1. Shawn Michaels Vs. Bret Hart
When Vince McMahon screwed Bret Hart at the 1997 Survivor Series, he didn't just take away the pretend prize 'The Hitman' genuinely held dear. He ripped away his love of a family trade.
'The Excellence Of Execution' was partially as good as he was because he respected the game to a fault. He wanted desperately to be the hero he was portrayed as, and upheld a similar reputation amongst his peers thanks to an almost impossible level of professionalism either side of the curtain. Matching his immaculate in-ring game, Shawn Michaels was no such soldier behind the scenes, infamously refusing to put Hart (or just about anybody else) over at a time when paranoia and politics were at an all time high.
Bret wasn't just exercising his contractually obligated right in Montreal - he was enforcing an ethical code, too. He was often prideful to a fault but this wasn't one of those times, nor was it one he was prepared to give Vince McMahon an easy answer for.
Shawn -the on and off screen heel - had been a piece of sh*t, but he was staying put along with the Championship belt. One of the hardest decisions the Chairman had to make was suddenly fairly easy.