10 Wrestling Feuds With Unexpectedly Ridiculous Stories

There's a reason nobody saw these bizarre wrestling stories coming...

Finn Balor
WWE

Were it not for the stories being told inside and outside of the squared-circle in this routinely insane business known as professional wrestling, there's a solid chance the action of sitting down to watch humans collide with one another in the middle of the ring would be, well, rather dull.

And as with just about any form of storytelling, there has been many an example of expertly weaved tales in the world of pro wrasslin'; the ongoing Elite saga being just one of them. But for every nuanced arc or glorious piece of soap opera drama, there has also been more than a few utterly bizarre developments lodged in the middle of a rivalry.

Sometimes these undeniably ridiculous plot twists in the thick of a wrestling feud can actually provide the odd laugh and even add an unexpected layer of intrigue to a programme. But in most cases they just left you questioning why you dedicated so many hours of your life to watching an industry that once allowed a wrestler to tag team with God.

So, from absolute monsters being dumped into the silliest of circumstances, to the sort of swerves that had to be seen to be believed, you likely didn't find yourself fantasy booking any of these downright bizarre wrestling scenarios in your spare time... and it's not hard to see why.

10. The Rock Slams The British Bulldog In Dog Poo

The rock dog poop British Bulldog
WWE

Back in 1999, The People's Champion was well and truly on the rise. And after a number of WWF Championship victories and ultimately deciding to team with old rival Mankind, The Rock soon found himself suddenly thrust into an odd scenario involving a certain British Bulldog and dog crap.

With Rocky going one-on-one against the legendary performer at that year's No Mercy, The Rock 'n' Sock Connection first had to deal with Davey Boy Smith and his tag partner of Val Venis on the October 11 edition of Raw, though.

So, how did The People's Champion get one over on his upcoming PPV rival? By having Mankind scoop up some backstage dog poop, place it on a board, and eventually Rock Bottom the former Intercontinental Champion onto it post-match, of course.

Far from simply being artificial faeces, this was later revealed to be very much legit "Dog Poop! Dog Poop! Dog Poop!" - as Michael Cole revelled in reminding us - with Davey Boy's daughter later confirming that they "could smell it from so far away" on the night.

As far as go-home angles go, this was some pretty bizarre sh*t and still makes for a surreal watch to this day.


9. Braun Strowman Wins The Tag Titles...With A Kid

Braun Strowman Nicholas Cesaro WrestleMania 34
WWE

WrestleMania 34 likely sits as one of the strangest nights ever to play out in front of nearly 80,000 live human beings.

On top of it playing host to the return of Daniel Bryan, debut of Ronda Rousey, and whatever the hell that Undertaker/John Cena showdown was, the Superdome event also brought with it the long-awaited reveal of precisely who would be teaming alongside Braun Strowman in a Raw Tag Team Championship battle with The Bar.

Instead of the Big Show popping up at the Show of Shows alongside his fellow giant or another, you know, wrestler taking part in the wrestling match, however, The Monster of All Monsters had a better idea.

After stomping around ringside for a spell and ultimately going for a wander through the 'Mania crowd, Strowman felt that a small child by the name of Nicholas was the way to go. And sure enough, both Sheamus and Cesaro were made to look like absolute geeks by the time Strow and his 10-year-old teammate walked out of New Orleans as the new champs.

Adding insult to injury, the youngest champ in WWE history was then forced to relinquish his title with Braun due to "scheduling conflicts"... school, he was going back to school.


8. Abyss Gets Magic Powers From Hulk Hogan's Ring

Abyss Hogan
FlyingElbow.ca

Sticking with monsters finding themselves at the centre of some frankly absurd situations on wrestling television, the consistently peculiar realm known as Total Non-Stop Action boasted one of the oddest stories imaginable back in 2010.

With the once intimidating figure of Abyss being saved from a heel beatdown by none other than a Hulk Hogan who had just arrived in town to shake up the Impact Zone, the performer who had become a shell of his former wrecking ball self was soon gifted The Hulkster's Hall of Fame ring.

Why? Well, simple. It possessed the power to make him a "god of wrestling".

And in the weeks that followed, Abyss not only regained a great deal of confidence and began steamrolling his way through the roster again, but he also started to don red and yellow flickers of Hulkamania all over his gear, too.

In other words, Hogan's ring was slowly infecting him with those all important vitamins, brother.

It was hilariously dumb. And Abyss quickly found himself being overshadowed by both the former owner of that jewellery and an unretired Ric Flair during the over-the-hill icons' battles.

This truly odd ring-focused angle thankfully came to an end a few months down the road. But it's safe to say this wasn't exactly the most effective way of turning The Monster into "the next John Cena", as The Immortal One once declared.


7. The Ultimate Mirror Mind Games Set Up The Rematch Of The Century

Ultimate Warrior Hulk Hogan Mirror Wcw
WWE

On paper, the rematch of the century between The Immortal Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior should've made for some genuinely blockbuster television for World Championship Wrestling back in 1998.

The iconic pair hadn't locked up in singles action since their epic WrestleMania VI clash a near-decade earlier. But in the company's attempts to recapture lightning in a bottle when it came to the clashing of these titans, someone thought it would be an absolutely terrific idea to add a new layer of supernatural abilities to the already chaotic Warrior character.

And just to really dial up the foolish weirdness, the ghostly appearance/vision of Hogan's giggling adversary haunting him in a mirror backstage was somehow visible to The Hulkster, folks watching at home, and commentators, but not Eric Bischoff who was standing right next to his top guy. Baffling.

However, the best/worst of this disastrous feud was yet to come, brother, as the pair's eventual Halloween Havoc horror show went on to become what many class as one of the worst bouts of all time. An already agonising showing in-between the ropes was soon immortalised for all the wrong reasons thanks to one hell of a botched flash paper spot.

At least we'll always have the surreal visual of The Hulkster accidentally singeing his own eyebrows and moustache on PPV, though, eh?


6. Drew McIntyre Targets Erick Rowan's Spider

Drew McIntyre Erick Rowan Spider
WWE.com

It's often forgot that the last few flickers of normality before the world changed forever in 2020 brought with them one of the oddest wrestling revelations of modern times.

With Erick Rowan spending the latter stages of 2019 walking around with a rather large cage in his possession, trying to figure out what in the holy hell this towering one-time Bludgeon Brother was affectionately conversing with inside of the sacked container actually became a surprisingly fun addition to the weekly slog that was the red show.

The hilariously bizarre sight of a jobber being covered in red liquid courtesy of the being within only added to the surreal intrigue. And then, in an equally odd throwaway backstage skit on March 2, 2020 Rowan suddenly revealed the giant furry (and not at all mechanical) spider within to the "respectful" No Way Jose and his conga-line pals.

And Byron Saxton's cries of "I think it's alive!" would've likely sat as the undisputed highlight of this entire weird character detour, were it not for babyface Drew McIntyre taking a set of steel steps to the creature and its cage a week later to the sound of euphoric cheers.

Nothing puts smiles on faces quite the crushing of a robo-arachnid, am I right?


5. Jason Jordan Is Kurt Angle's Son

Kurt Angle And Jason Jordan
WWE.com

Within a month or so of being brought back into the WWE mix as Monday Night Raw's new General Manager, Kurt Angle was already on the verge of being "ruined" by a series of texts being sent to Corey Graves.

And what was this jaw-dropping, controversial secret that could see Angle lose his family and potentially even destroy his career? It turns out that he was actually the daddy of none other than one-time American Alpha star Jason Jordan... what are the chances, eh?

If all of this felt as though it came a little bit out of the blue and hadn't been really that well thought through, well you won't be too surprised to discover that this was actually designed as little more than a typically horrendous rib from Vince McMahon. The boss learned of the fact Angle had dated a few African-American women in the past and thought it would be hilarious to head in this particular storyline direction.

And while the odd twist didn't exactly lead to instantly captivating storytelling out of the gates, it did eventually seem as though a slow-burning heel turn for Jordan was ultimately setting the stage for a no-doubt entertaining showdown with his "paps" at WrestleMania 35.

Unfortunately, though, a serious neck injury cut down Jordan way too early in his career and that blow-off never came to pass. But it was still a peculiar ride while it lasted, even without a real conclusion.


4. The Street Profits And Viking Raiders Get Competitive...Outside Of The Ring

Street Profits Viking Raiders
WWE.com

In all honesty, you're not exactly short on options when it comes to utterly absurd pandemic era WWE developments.

And while the likes of Randy Orton and The Fiend's never-ending fire/goo wars were... something, and the visual of Seth Rollins popping a masked icon's eye out of his head are definitely up there in terms of unquestionably ridiculous tales told during this period, the competitive battle between The Street Profits and The Viking Raiders in the Performance Center era was every bit as loony.

Instead of having the units battle it out in something as outrageous as a gripping in-ring Best-of-Seven showcase, WWE opted to steer clear of the empty arena setting and dumped the lads into various non-wrestling competitions, including axe-throwing, basketball, and, erm, golf.

But that wasn't even the strangest part of the tag title programme. Not by a long shot.

An all-out backstage brawl erupted between the rivals at Backlash, with the units battling around the parking lot before suddenly uniting as The Viking Profits to take the fight to Akira Tozawa and his team of ninjas instead.

Seven-foot ninjas. Turkey legs. Dumpster monsters. What a time to be a "whatever the hell this was" fan.


3. Shawn Michaels Teams With The Almighty

Shawn Michaels God Backlash
WWE

This being the same person who once pitched to be revealed as the on-screen father of his own daughter's unborn child, the fact Vince McMahon ultimately felt that a feud centred around himself, his son Shane, Shawn Michaels and The Almighty - no, not that one - would go down a treat on WWE television shouldn't come as that much of a surprise.

But that didn't make the sight of The Heartbreak Kid eventually teaming with the spotlight also known as God in a No Holds Barred match at Backlash any less outlandish to behold.

In the lead-up to that planned bout with "The Hipster from Heaven" and HBK, the McMahons also opted to pay an equally problematic visit to a church, with Vince doing his best impression of his son-in-law's entrance with holy water before comparing himself with the man upstairs.

The entire sudden and offensive religious detour was simply a way for the crazy billionaire to fuse Michaels' real-life status as a born-again Christian into the on-screen drama; and an entirely uncomfortable and bizarre one at that.


2. A Revived Demon Stumbles In The Closing Stages

Finn Balor
WWE

In a particularly Extreme case of be careful what you wish for, the long-awaited comeback of not only Finn Bálor to the main roster landscape, but the Demon persona that hadn't been seen in an age could've provided WWE with a much needed new addition at the top of the card.

It didn't, obviously, because this was Vince McMahon in 2021. And instead the call was made to have the former Universal Champion look like a complete and utter idiot on the PLE stage during an eventual showdown with Roman Reigns over the top strap.

After an hilarious mid-match "resurrection" which saw the challenger flail around like a fish attempting to stay alive on dry land, Bálor's theme began to play out as he scaled the top-rope for a title-winning coup de grâce.

Going from enjoyably absurd to just plain perplexing in a matter of moments, though, Bálor soon wound up whacking his nads on the turnbuckle thanks to the top-rope suddenly decided to snap off entirely.

And the most ridiculous part of it all? The company just moved on like nothing had even happened in the wake of The Head of the Table taking advantage of a poorly put together ring.


1. Da Man's Streak Ends Via Da Cattle Prod

Scott Hall Goldberg WCW Starrcade 1998 Cattle Prod
WWE

Trying to land on precisely how to bring one of the most dominant and legendary streaks in wrestling history to an end was always going to be a pretty tall order.

What human alive was realistically going to be able to bring down a force of nature like big bad Goldberg? He'd already ran through everyone from Hulk Hogan to The Giant. So, fans were genuinely invested in what would ultimately be the downfall of Da Man at some point down the road.

All of the fantasy booking in the world wouldn't have resulted in you coming anywhere near close to the finish eventually landed on for bringing The Streak to its dramatic conclusion, however.

Instead of having the wrecking ball finally meet his physical match or an up-and-coming sensation steal a life-changing win against the bald titan, the simply mystifying call was made to have him be cattle prodded by Scott Hall en-route to Kevin Nash picking the bones for the monumental win at Starrcade 1998.

That alone was the sort of laughable twist that ultimately set the stage for WCW's downfall. But the fact this also set the stage for the infamous Finger Poke of Doom cements it firmly as one of the dumbest and most ridiculous conclusions to a once captivating storyline of all time.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Finn Balor
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!