10 Wrestling Repeats That Just Didn't Work

Lex Luger couldn't hope to be the next coming of Hulk Hogan...

Hulk Hogan Lex Luger.jpg
WWE

Legendary pro wrestling manager Jim Cornette once stated that the industry he loves so much is cyclical. Everything can come back around again given time, almost like there's a soft reset button in wrestling.

Whilst this is true to an extent, things can also come across like pale imitations of what has come before when re-aired and handled poorly.

There's only a finite number of fresh ideas the creative minds can come up with, and once that well has run dry, it's only a matter of time before promotions rehash old concepts. 

Take WWE, for example The Authority storyline, which is simply a complete reprise of the old 'McMahon-Helmsley Regime' gimmick seen during the so-called Attitude Era. 

Even the power players - Triple H and Stephanie McMahon - are the same. The story has long-since run its natural course, but WWE want to squeeze even more mileage out of it. 

The Authority is not an isolated example when it comes to repeat attempts, as there are loads throughout WWE history.

Even companies like WCW and TNA have had their fair share of repeats, and they have rarely worked, either. Let's take a look at some of the worst offenders from all three organisations...

10. Wrestlers Steal The Undertaker's Urn

Cm Punk Undertaker Ashes
WWE.com

Since the passing of William 'Paul Bearer' Moody in 2013, the urn hasn't been part of The Undertaker's act. In truth, the object was rarely part of the gimmick from the late-1990's onwards, once Undertaker morphed into simply existing as a standalone character unlike any other. 

CM Punk was the last wrestler to gain possession of the urn, but he most certainly wasn't the first. 

Back in 1994-1995, members of the 'Million Dollar Corporation' were booked to steal the thing and thus apparently gain some sort of storyline power over The Undertaker. Ted DiBiase instructed the likes of IRS and Kama to get him that urn.

Unfortunately, the story normally fell flat. It also became somewhat comical at times, especially when Kama melted down the urn into a gold chain for himself!

Even armed with the topical passing of Bearer, Punk didn't have much chance with the plot point, because fans had never really shown interest in the idea to begin with.

Worse, some felt offended by the use of Bearer's death for the purposes of promoting a WrestleMania match.


9. TNA Try To Capitalise On Daniel Bryan Success With Eric Young

eric young tna
ImpactWrestling.com

There are those who would have you believe that TNA have never done anything other than ride the coat-tails of WWE. 

That's unfair, and the promotion can boast the original X Division as theirs, as well as helping establish the likes of AJ Styles and Samoa Joe. They have at times been a truly viable alternative for hardcore wrestling enthusiasts looking for something different to the McMahon-led juggernaut.

Then, there have been other occasions when those in charge at the company completely ape what WWE are doing in order to enjoy a little success for themselves. 

The greatest example of this was Eric Young's 2014 TNA World Title win. There's no doubt that this only happened because Daniel Bryan had captured WWE's big belt at WrestleMania XXX.

On April 6, Bryan captured the wrestling world's collective imagination by becoming champion. TNA decided to quickly capitalise on that support by having their own smaller, bearded underdog collect the biggest win of his career.

On April 10, Young defeated Magnus to become the new TNA World Champ. There wasn't as much excitement for this as there had been for Bryan, because the whole thing felt like a cheap rip-off.


8. 'Nature Boy' Buddy Landel

Nature Boy Buddy Landel.jpg
WWE.com

Ric Flair wasn't the first 'Nature Boy' to hit the scene. The original was Buddy Rodgers, but Flair decided he'd use the gimmick for himself. Clearly, he went on to have a lot of success, so he's not exactly applicable for a list looking at repeats that didn't end up working out.

Instead, this slot belongs to Buddy Landel. 

Using the 'Nature Boy' character himself, Landel often came across like a cheap knock-off version of Ric Flair. As harsh as it sounds, by the time he entered the WWF for a brief period in 1995, Landel looked more like a parody of Flair than a genuine individual.

Landel did capture a number of titles and was a generally good worker, but his main problem lay in the fact that most watching believed Flair to be the real deal, not him. 

Despite having his own bleach blonde locks and a whole host of sequined robes, Buddy Landel just looked like a tribute to Ric Flair rather than a top star in his own right. 


7. Authority Figure Ric Flair Feuds With Steve Austin

Steve Austin Ric Flair Raw 2002
WWE.com

There are few more successful or celebrated feuds in WWE history than Steve Austin vs. Mr. McMahon, so it's not difficult to see why management have sought to replicate that success. 

By 2002, Ric Flair had entered the company and was cast as a majority shareholder on television. He was also the General Manager of Monday Night Raw, something which led creative to a lazy storyline idea.

Looking to recapture the sheer electricity of McMahon vs. Austin, WWE placed Flair in a feud against 'The Rattlesnake'. Instantly, things seemed familiar. Flair was the authority figure, and Austin the fan-favourite renegade.

It was never going to work, since there wasn't enough to differentiate the story from one which had dominated WWE TV for years prior. It was the same old situation as before, only this time it was Flair instead of McMahon trying to put a leash on Austin's anti-hero persona. 

The angle was already fizzling out before Austin lost his patience with management and decided to take a walk in June. Otherwise, there's a good chance his rivalry with Flair would have lingered before dying a death. 


6. WCW Expect New Blood To Recapture NWo Magic

eric bischoff vince russo
WWE.com

By the dawn of the new millennium, WCW had degenerated into a system governed by chaos and a real lack of ingenuity. 

Vince Russo and Eric Bischoff, considered men ideal for the task, were brought back together in the Spring of 2000 to try and turn the sinking ship back into a money-making machine.

Their big idea was to split the roster into 'old guys' and 'young guys', leading to the creation of both the 'Millionaire's Club' and the 'New Blood'. On the surface, the concept was sound enough, but would end up being supremely flawed in execution. It was just too similar to the old story of the New World Order.

Fans had already witnessed a top heel group controlling things on television, and the premise had grown tired. The New Blood didn't stand a chance, it just felt like a watered-down variation of the same ideas people had already lost interest in. 

The Millionaire's Club came across like the nWo Black & White, whereas the supposedly hip and young New Blood mimicked the nWo Wolfpac. Even the colour scheme of the latter faction was the same!


5. Sid Vicious And His Confusing Winning Streak

Sid Vicious WCW
WWE.com

Don't let the WWE propaganda machine fool you, Bill Goldberg was a phenomenon to pro wrestling when he crash-landed in WCW during 1997. 

Looking like a killer, Goldberg became popular within just a few months. His short matches and intense performances gripped people, and the fact he was incredibly over cannot be forgotten.

Embarking on a winning streak that was satisfying and simple for fans to keep track of, Goldberg was the man from 1997-1999. Ironically, in '99, WCW tried to place the same aura around Sid Vicious. Another ultra-intense wrestler, Sid started racking up a winning run of his own.

There was just one problem; it wasn't legitimate. WCW completely undermined themselves by changing the rules surrounding the idea each and every week. 

Sid would even have numbers added to his 'streak' after merely interfering in matches and hitting rivals with his big power moves. The whole thing failed to adhere to the one basic rule determining an idea's success - simple logic.

Once people figured out Sid's winning run was bogus, they stopped caring. Once that happened, the idea was dead in the water.


4. WWE Attempt To Present Convincing Doppelganger Story More Than Once

Fake Kane
WWE.com

Older fans will recall with horror the main event of SummerSlam 1994. Following a red-hot Steel Cage bout between Bret and Owen Hart, The Undertaker - one of the promotion's top creations - fought himself. 

That's right, the main event of the pay-per-view was billed as The Undertaker vs. The Undertaker.

Naturally, Mark Calaway didn't perform suplexes on himself, but instead faced a doppelganger version of his infamous character. Led by Ted DiBiase, Brian Lee donned a 'Taker costume and pretended to be the real 'Deadman'. 

Fans weren't convinced, and a combination of uninspiring storytelling and a woefully slow pace made the match tank.

Years later, WWE tried the same thing again. This time, it was Kane who stared in horror at a mirror image of his character. Sadly for those in charge, the doppelgänger Kane was neither as tall nor as frightening as Glenn Jacobs when he first went under the guise in 1997.

This 2006 angle didn't hit the mark, and WWE decided to pull the plug on a situation that wasn't all that original to begin with. They should have learned their lesson the first time.


3. WCW Mimic 'Montreal Screwjob' One Month Later

Sting Hogan Starrcade 1997
WWE.com

The events surrounding the 1997 Survivor Series don't need much introduction. 

Known as the 'Montreal Screwjob', a main event between Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart was halted when Vince McMahon called for the bell to sound. Locked in his own Sharpshooter hold, Bret had been screwed by both his peers and his boss.

A previously-agreed departure to WCW transpired shortly thereafter, and it ended up hampering WCW's biggest match in history. At Starrcade 1997, Sting was set to challenge Hollywood Hogan for the World Title. Anticipation was heavy, because the company had spent the past year building towards the colossal main event.

The whole thing was ruined when Hogan pinned Sting. Announcers claimed that referee Nick Patrick had counted at a faster pace than usual, in essence insinuating that Sting had been 'screwed'. 

Bret Hart then emerged and muttered something over the live mic about a screwjob not happening again and the match was restarted.

It was a poor decision to let what had happened to Bret in another promotion invade WCW's most titanic collision. Sting's subsequent title win felt tainted, chiefly because Patrick's count didn't seem all that fast, but also because of the presence of the 'Montreal Screwjob'.


2. WWE Try To Make Roman Reigns Fit John Cena Mould

Roman Reigns Dean Ambrose Promo
WWE.com

There was a time when John Cena would rap his way through promos, delivering visceral lines and causing audiences to 'ooh' and 'aah'. With the advent of the 'PG Era', his character changed to one much more child-friendly. 

The change prompted Cena's promo style to shift, and he was now more likely to deliver cheesy dialogue that made it difficult for adults to relate to him.

It's one thing to place such a character on John Cena, he's a naturally charismatic guy who can work around most things. It's another to try and replicate the exact same formula with Roman Reigns, and expect people to buy into it.

That's exactly what WWE did in 2015, they turned Reigns into John Cena-lite. Suddenly, his bad !*$% aura of before gave way to an altogether more hokey personality. 

Lines like, 'suffering succotash, son' did not fit in with the look and feel Roman had previously presented.

There was an immediate backlash. Crowds fiercely began booing Reigns, a trend that has continued to this day. What a baffling, not to mention ill-advised, call from those in charge.


1. Lex Luger Cast As The 'Next' Hulk Hogan

Lex Luger Express
WWE

'Hulkamania' was a powerful marketing tool for Vince McMahon in the 1980's. Everyone wanted a piece of Hulk Hogan, he was like a cartoon character come to life, and McMahon loved building his WWF promotion around the character.

Much like all good things, however, the successful run had to come to an end at some point.

That point was with the turn of the 80's into the 90's. After failing to supplant Hogan with The Ultimate Warrior, McMahon briefly allowed the likes of Bret Hart to shine in the main event scene.

Relatively quickly, he changed direction again, likely wanting more of the success he had experienced with Hulk.

The man chosen to lead this new movement was Lex Luger. An expensive, cross-country bus expedition was embarked upon, and Luger was recast as an 'American Hero' akin to how Hogan had previously been presented.

It was difficult to swallow for those who had followed the promotion for years. Lex wasn't as colourful as Hogan in promos and people didn't relate to him the same way. Less than a full year later, the experiment was over and the WWF would move on to putting smaller, more dynamic performers in feature spots.

What other wrestling repeats that didn't work can you think of? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.