10 Wrestling Swerves That Actually Worked
Kicking everyone square in the candy ass.
Time for a quick multiple choice, one-question quiz.
What makes a good wrestling swerve? Is it A) complete and utter surprise, shock and satisfying pay off afterwards, B) a one-off move just so bookers can scream, "I told you so!", or C) putting Steve Austin in the Alliance because there's a serious lack of star power on the WCW/ECW side?
If you answered A, congratulations. You're not a B+ player like Daniel Bryan, and you've got it right. Any good swerve, even if it was only conceptualised days or hours before, needs to successfully trick the audience's expectations and then deliver some story follow-up that justifies the original decision. This can be difficult, because the temptation is there to pull off swerves without true depth or explanation afterwards.
The best swerves are those that marry unpredictability with good narrative. They should leave fans with a coy smile, and enjoying that moment of astonishment when brain matter collides with vision to establish that they have indeed been hoodwinked.
These are the best examples of swerves that weren't done for the sake of it. Instead, they all had a game plan and ended up being better for that pre-planning. Each one worked a treat...
10. Mark Henry Isn't Ready To Retire (WWE Raw - 17 June 2013)
Everything about Mark Henry's performance on the 17 June 2013 episode of Raw was world class. The pastel pink suit jacket, the crocodile tears, the sad admission to his family that it was time to come home, everything. It was like Henry had saved up all his promo chips and cashed them in for one major payload, and it totally fooled fans.
People genuinely believed Mark was ready to retire, and John Cena played his role of respectful champion brilliantly too. Then, when Henry blasted Cena with his World's Strongest Slam and chastised him for falling into the trap, fans lost their minds. They'd been tricked just the same as Cena had in storyline, and it felt good.
This one would be higher on the list had Henry not started to wind down his career post-feud. Regardless of that incoming career dotage, Henry's 2013 turn was dynamite stuff. It successfully deceived everyone, and it had people high-fiving one another in the stands.
Awesome.
9. Daniel Bryan Cheats To Become Champion (WWE SmackDown - 13 November 2018)
The emotion that accompanied Daniel Bryan's in-ring comeback at WrestleMania 34 was powerful, intense and honest. Fans had been on a rollercoaster journey with the underdog for years, and they (just like him) had refused to accept that he'd never wrestle again. When he finally did and settled back into his career, relief washed over the masses.
Then, Bryan somehow made the crappy 'New' gimmick a winner.
On 13 November 2018, he beat AJ Styles to become the new WWE Champion. What should've been a tear-filled moment was cheapened by Bryan's decision to boot fellow face AJ in the nuts, smile wickedly and gleefully cheat to win. This maniacal drive to rekindle championship glories of old was fantastic, and the heel run reinvigorated Daniel.
Best of all, nobody saw it coming. Fans had accepted a babyface vs. babyface tale because of the quality on hand. Nobody believed for a second that Bryan would turn his back on sentimental vibes to become a devilish preacher who later introduced a title made of hemp.
8. The Twin Referee Conspiracy (WWF The Main Event I)
Back in the WWF's golden era of the mid-to-late-80s, there were few heels as hated as 'Million Dollar Man' Ted DiBiase. His ability to link himself with the towering André The Giant and oppose Hulk Hogan only made him more detestable. Teddy was gonna' use his monstrous compadre to take the richest prize in the game away from Hulk.
Cue The Main Event special on NBC in February 1988.
One month out from WrestleMania IV, DiBiase concocted the most devious of plans to whip Hogan and steal his title. Preposterously, he paid for plastic surgery so a referee could replicate official Dave Hebner and fool everyone into thinking André had won the belt. It was genius, and Ted laughed his ass off when Virgil strapped it round his waist.
The beautiful part to all this was that 'Ref #2' was played by Dave's twin brother Earl. In one move, the WWF had the means to take the strap off Hogan without beating him cleanly, strip DiBiase of a title he never won and crown Randy Savage the new man at 'Mania.
7. Eric Bischoff Is The New Raw GM (WWE Raw - 15 July 2002)
He was back, and better than ever. He'd also grabbed some Just For Men on the way to New Jersey.
On the 15 July 2002 edition of Raw, Vince McMahon shocked the world by revealing that old rival Eric Bischoff would become the new General Manager. According to numerous sources, including Booker T, Jim Ross and others, this came as a complete shock to everyone backstage in WWE.
They hadn't been clued in beforehand, and so many were dumbstruck when the former WCW chief strolled out on stage with McMahon, the announcement was made and these former enemies shared a friendly hug before thousands of slack-jawed fans. It was a real 'hell has frozen over' moment, one of the best in Raw history.
When the GM role was vacated by Ric Flair in June, most probably assumed it'd be filled by someone already in the company. It wasn't. Bisch joined, became one of the best authority figures ever and had a successful three year run.
6. Bret Hart & Steve Austin Trade Places (WWF WrestleMania 13)
Going into WrestleMania 13, change was afoot. In the stands, fans were embracing 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin's menace, and they were starting to grow tired of Bret Hart's goody-two-shoes hero schtick. The era of the anti-hero loomed, and it turned what was already a surefire cracker of a match into a money-making masterclass.
Austin and Hart, natural enemies with opposing views on heroism, switched places simultaneously.
Bret, who had been a babyface since going solo earlier in the decade, suddenly became a jaded, bitter veteran heel. Austin, a snarling pitbull brawler who epitomised the classic villain, turned into an unlikely smash hit as a "good guy". His unwillingness to quit at 'Mania, and Hart's reluctance to relinquish the Sharpshooter, flipped the predicted script.
From there, Bret had a brilliant final few months in the company as an anti-American whiner, and Austin went from strength-to-strength as the top babyface in the biz. Millions of dollars were made, countless great matches were had and both men were freshened up by the unforeseen dual switch.
5. Triple H & Stephanie McMahon Align (WWF Armageddon 1999)
In typical Attitude era fashion, Stephanie McMahon went from innocent, drugged-up patsy in Triple H's power battle with Vince McMahon to vindictive witch who nuzzled tightly into her new man's chest against her father's wishes. Things all came to a head at Armageddon 1999, but not before quite the story was told.
Triple H had married Steph presumably against her will during a hasty drive-thru ceremony in Las Vegas, and he waited until she was just about to wed Test before dishing the news. That sent Vince into a fit of rage, and it set up a 'No Holds Barred' corker at Armageddon. There, sweet little Stephanie showed her cards.
The McMahon-Helmsley Regime was born.
It barely made sense, but that didn't stop fans from buying into the melodrama, feeling slightly sorry for Vince and showering the happy couple with hate. Stephanie immediately became one of the most over heels in the promotion, and Triple H had a 2000 so strong it rivalled any 12 month period in wrestling ever.
4. Triple H Thinks Daniel Bryan Is A "B+ Player" (WWE SummerSlam 2013)
"You're nothing but a B+ player".
Fans disagreed mightily with those words from Triple H and Stephanie McMahon in the lead-up to WrestleMania XXX. Bryan was their chosen one, not some corporately-selected cash cow who'd tow the party line without protest. He was one of the best wrestlers in the world, maybe even the best.
At SummerSlam 2013, he proved it by working a top main event tussle with John Cena. The crowd in LA popped big when Bryan won cleanly with a running knee strike; they finally had their wish. Bryan was champion, and he'd lead WWE into a bold new era. Kick, wham, Pedigree, pin...Randy f'n Orton cashed in MITB and he ended the night as champ.
Holy. Sh*t. Fans were irate.
The multi-layered story was magnificently laid out though. Triple H's decision to ruin Bryan's moment set wheels in motion towards his eventual triumph at 'Mania XXX the next year. People may have been spitting at the time, but they were positively drooling when Daniel overcame The Authority and their established despotism.
3. The Rock Joins The Corporation (WWF Survivor Series 1998)
If anyone had been able to smell what The Rock was cooking at Survivor Series 1998, then this moment wouldn't have had the same impact. Without any shred of distrust, the WWF's core audience began to enjoy Rocky's heel-ish banter, catchphrases and put-downs. He was becoming loved, and it seemed the company had their new top babyface.
Not quite yet.
The Rock linked up with Vince and Shane McMahon to cruelly swindle Mankind at Survivor Series, steal the WWF Championship and form The Corporation. Vince said it best when he revealed that Rocky wasn't the "People's Champion", he was the "Corporate Champion" and the hand-picked golden boy of the federation.
This worked so well because fans had willingly walked into the ambush. Going into Survivors, it was Mankind who played the role of corporate schmuck, not The Rock. His betrayal of their newfound admiration kicked everyone square in the candy ass.
2. Triple H Turns His Back On A DX Reunion (WWE Raw - 22 July 2002)
At Vengeance 2002, much was made of Triple H's decision. Would he join Eric Bischoff on Raw, or would he work under his storyline ex-wife Stephanie McMahon on SmackDown? Input from old pal Shawn Michaels made the choice easy. Trips was heading to Mondays so he could tear it up D-Generation X style with HBK, baby.
Kick, wham, Pedigree x2.
24 hours after the pay-per-view, Triple H turned on Shawn, spat on any DX reunion notion and sent shockwaves through the audience. This swerve (the idea that crotch-chopping degenerates were on the comeback trail when they weren't) had fans clamouring to see Michaels return to the ring and put his former friend in his place.
That's exactly what happened at SummerSlam, and it was exquisite. HBK, backed by an army of Triple H-hating DX'ers, slowly reintegrated himself to wrestling life and had a 2002-2010 run that arguably bettered his first one. Meanwhile, 'The Game' went on to form Evolution and lift both Randy Orton and Batista to new heights. Win-win.
1. Hulk Hogan Is The Third Man (WCW Bash At The Beach 1996)
"We have seen the end of Hulkamania. Hulk Hogan, you can go to hell..."
Tony Schiavone deserves a medal for that on-the-fly call after Hulk Hogan turned his back on red and yellow to embrace the coming monochrome of the nWo. In a moment that'd make WCW's Bash The Beach 1996 show immortal, Hulk ambled down the aisle to fend off the invading Outsiders, then dropped a leg on Randy Savage to enliven his career.
Garbage came from the stands, fans booed mercilessly and the Hogan/Nash/Hall trio lapped up every bit of it in-ring as they kicked off New World Order domination. It was a swerve from nowhere that changed the industry, and it turned Hogan from fading 80s babyface relic into white hot 90s heel. He doesn't get nearly enough credit for the balls it took to take such a risk.
Despite collapsing under the weight of its own sustained success, 'Hulkamania' still had fans, and it was still making Hogan money when he decided to f*ck his loyal fanbase and go rogue for the first time since the early-80s. As the mysterious "third man", Hulk was in his element.
What other swerves do you recall that actually worked? Let us know down in the comments section below!