10 WWE & AEW Gimmicks That Belong In A Different Era
In another time and place, these gimmicks could or would have made these stars shine.
A good gimmick can take a mediocre wrestler to the top. Just ask JBL.
A bad gimmick can tank a wrestler in a heartbeat. Unlucky, Karrion Kross.
In the world of professional wrestling, you can have an explosive in-ring game, a phenomenal look and slick promo skills, but it still needs a good gimmick to wrap around it all to bring it to life. That's why we see wrestlers suddenly repackaged with a new name or a new attitude, to try and get them over.
As the years go by, wrestling comes to define itself by its 'eras'. From the Golden Age of the 80's, to the late 90's Attitude Era, there has always been a defining criterion for those years. During the aforementioned Attitude Era, it was the edgier the better, whilst the Ruthless Aggression Era that followed was more steeped in young upstarts.
Either way, each spawned numerous gimmicks, some fondly remembered while others were destined for WrestleCrap. Nowadays, wrestling feels a little more grounded in reality and although a few hokey gimmicks slip through, the majority of wrestlers tend to base their gimmick on the craft.
But there are some that feel like they not only belong to, but would thrive in another era. Gimmicks such as...
10. LA Knight
LA Knight certainly fits the remit of a WWE Superstar.
He is a devilishly handsome man, with a killer physique and has raw charisma that shines through with every promo. In the world of NXT 2.0, he certainly feels more at home than the darker, grittier NXT where he made his debut.
In the ring, he is certainly capable of holding his own, but in the current landscape of the super worker, he feels a little flat at times. When the majority of the roster is capable of explosive, pulse-racing action, there are times were Knight feels a little bit plodding.
However, had LA Knight walked down the ramp at the height of the Ruthless Aggression Era, he would have been a bonafide star. There are serious Mr Kennedy vibes about Knight, where his cocky attitude and wonderful command of the crowd would have seen him certainly involved in the main event picture.
Back then, there were workers such as Vladimir Kozlov and Heidenreich occupying seats near the top of the table and compared to them, Knight would have been a megastar. As it is, he feels a little lost in the current era and will undoubtedly be seen as fodder to the newer generation on NXT 2.0.
9. FTR
Make no mistake about it, FTR are in the conversation for the best tag team in wrestling. It just depends on what you want from your wrestling.
In AEW, where the majority of the teams work a high flying, high octane style, there have been murmurs that that FTR's run in the company has been a little disappointing. Whilst the booking of their dream feud with the Young Bucks was shoddy at the best of times, in the ring, Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler have delivered almost every time.
Yes, their gimmick is a throwback to the older days, but the real guts of their act is that they are tag team specialists who adhere to the art of working as a team. The way they cut the ring in half is surgical and they place more emphasis on winning than entertaining.
Can you just imagine airlifting them out of their current time and dropping them opposite The Hart Foundation in their prime? The matches would have been absolute classics and FTR would have easily built a reputation as the greatest tag team of that era.
Whilst they are still in the conversation today, it's a shame that they are seen more as throwbacks as opposed to pioneers of the art of tag team wrestling.
8. Akira Tozawa
Saying this gimmick would thrive in any era is a bit of a stretch, but how out place does it feel in 2021?
Let's call it what it is: it's a racist gimmick that was devised by powerful old white men who took a look at Akira Tozawa and thought "ninja". It's incredibly problematic and to be totally honest, there is no era where this would be okay.
But considering the amount of trash that made up the majority of the Attitude Era (yes, there was amazing stuff from then but a lot of it was dross), it's not hard to imagine Akira Tozawa running with his gaggle of ninjas during the prime years of the WWE.
Trapped in the 24/7 division hell in 2021, Tozawa would have probably been featured more in the hardcore division then. With his size probably ruling him out of playing an 'evil, foreign ninja' in the Golden Era, the gimmick would still have probably gone down better in the olden days when the world was a lot less politcally correct.
Considering it's hard to really place this gimmick in any era, it's about time the WWE did the right thing and scrapped it and just let Tozawa be himself.
7. The Viking Raiders
Don't the Viking Raiders just scream New Generation?
As War Machine on the indies, Harper and Rowe felt as relevant to the current world of wrestling as any other team. They were legitimate powerhouses who moved like cruiserweights and it wasn't a surprise when WWE came calling.
However, as soon as the creative team realised that these guys appreciate Viking culture, that was it for them. Gone was the intimidating team that ran roughshod over the world and dominated NXT and instead, we got the Viking Experience.
The very memory of that main roster debut is enough to make you puke in your mouth.
Gone was any sense of intimidation driven by their awesome aesthetic and they soon become comedy foil for the Street Profits and have never recovered.
Thrown them into the mix thirty years ago and they would rule the division. Their sheer size would make them perfect for the era and combined with their incredible agility, they could have had the ultimate legacy feud with the likes of Legion of Doom.
Alas - that is confined to video game fantasy matchups and for now, we can mourn what the Viking Raiders should have been as we see what they have become.
6. Abadon
With makeup skills that put most high-budget Hollywood movies to shame, Abadon certainly has a unique look and gimmick. Although it's unclear whether she is a zombie or a zombie aficionado, there is no doubt that Abadon certainly turned heads when she made her AEW debut in March 2020.
Whilst still pretty rough around the edges when it comes to her ring skills, on sheer looks and gimmick alone, Abadon is a talking point whenever she is on screen. Sadly, in 2021, when spooky, supernatural gimmicks seem to be met more with scorn than revere, it isn't always positive. Her "feud" with Hikaru Shida, which consisted of scary, bitey nonsense, fell very flat.
This gimmick, however, would have gone down a storm during the Attitude Era, where nonsense like this was lapped up by roaring crowds. Her in-ring ability wouldn't have been so noticeable either, during a time when women's wrestling wasn't anywhere near as respected as it is today.
Whether it had been WWE, WCW or ECW, she would have undoubtedly found great success and multiple title reigns. Whereas in 2021, it feels like she has already hit her ceiling if she persists with the gimmick.
5. Dirty Dawgs
It might be one of the oldest takes in recent wrestling circles, but Dolph Ziggler really should have had more time at the top. When he broke onto the scene, he was one step ahead of most with his ring work and could carry a promo. Bobby Roode is another one who deserved an awful lot more than the WWE have given him.
As the Dirty Dawgs, they have carved out a nice role as a solid, entertaining tag team that always gives a good match but in today's world, that really isn't enough.
These two, with this gimmick, would have dominated the Ruthless Aggression Era.
Whether as single stars or as their current tag team, both of these men would have been seen as elite, main event wrestlers and during a time when the WWE came crashing out of the Attitude Era with main events like Undertaker vs Hogan in 2002, these two would have been a big deal.
With the Dudleyz leaving and the Hardy's and E&C disbanded, they could have dominated the tag division for the entire era, building Hall of Fame worthy careers as one of the most beloved tandems of the era.
Now, they are rolled out as solid and dependable hands.
Tis a shame.
4. Carmella
Carmella is certainly in the running for the most improved wrestler of the last few years. She deserves all the credit in the world for bringing her ring game up to the level of her character work and she now feels like a credible threat in the WWE women's division.
Her gimmick, however, does not.
WWE, for all their faults, have done a stellar job over the last seven years to elevate women's wrestling to the main event of their shows. The work done by the Four Horsewomen, as well as the likes of Asuka, Alexa Bliss, Ronda Rousey and more recently, Bianca Belair, has helped create respect for the division and built an equal platform for the women to wrestle. Or, as WWE would have it written, Stephanie McMahon saved women's wrestling.
Moving away from the "Diva's Era" of women's wrestling, Carmella's gimmick feels airlifted from any of the era's pre-2014. Obsessed with being the most beautiful of all the women on the roster and feuding with wrestlers she finds ugly, feels out of touch with the modern landscape.
You could easily see this current incarnation of Carmella having a long and fruitless reign with awful Diva's Championship. That probably isn't what she is going for.
3. The Butcher & The Blade
This tag team feels like the one most out of place in AEW.
Deservedly considered the greatest tag team roster in modern wrestling history, it seems surprising and somewhat of a shame that the Butcher and the Blade are part of it. They are a good, solid tag team who play the role of bastard bad guys well and they have a decent look. (Although not too sure about the all white get up at times.)
Whilst they can provide good foil for the quicker, babyface teams, there is a certainly a ceiling for them in AEW and it looks like they have already hit it. Honestly, do you see them jumping to the top of the division? There are many teams above them, with younger, more dynamic teams rapidly approaching them, too.
This gimmick, like the Dirty Dawgs, would have been a roaring success during the Ruthless Aggression Era, considering the title belts at the time were held by the likes of Deuce & Domino and The Basham Brothers. Slotting the Butcher and the Blade into that division would have likely seen them become a pillar of the division as opposed to making up the numbers.
Time isn't on their side, and it doesn't look like AEW creative is, either.
2. Cesaro
Writing this entry is heartbreaking.
In a fair and just world, Cesaro would be a multi-time WWE Heavyweight Champion, with a raft of other accolades that result in a Hall of Fame worthy career. Handsome, naturally charismatic, stronger than most and most importantly, phenomenal in the ring, he has the tools to be the best wrestler in the company.
Apart from one. Cesaro isn't great on the mic.
That's okay, considering the man is from Switzerland and although competent enough, WWE have never gotten behind him in a sustained way due to promo game. His gimmick is that of a super wrestler who can have a great match, and to WWE creative, that just isn't enough.
If you could take Cesaro and drop him into the Ruthless Aggression Era, he would have been a sure fire main event star. Seeing him mix it up with the likes of peak Kurt Angle, Eddie Guerrero, Chris Benoit, Chris Jericho, Shawn Michaels etc. would have produced absolute magic in the ring.
Considering the likes of JBL and The Great Khali held the World Heavyweight Championship during this period, there is no way that Cesaro wouldn't have at least had a few runs with the top title.
It's enough to make you boot up WWE 2k21 and start playing those dream matches. (But don't - that game sucks!)
1. Cody Rhodes
What actually is Cody Rhodes' gimmick?
It seems he doesn't seem to know himself, and considering the obvious indulgence he is allowed from Tony Khan, it's whatever he fancies at the time. He goes from playing a ring general, to trying to be a badass and turning up in a jeep, to then dying his hair black and getting tough. Oh, and he wants to fly the flag and give "ra-ra" America speeches.
It's a really strange time to watch Cody, as the AEW crowd who saw him as a hero, as the man who changed wrestling, are starting to loathe the guy. He isn't getting booed because of great heel work. When he needlessly pinned Malakai Black this past week, the boos that greeted it was clear 'go away' heat.
This wholesome, crowd loving, salt of the earth character that he tries to portray (that doesn't work considering there is a reality show which shows how rich he is) has run its course in AEW. But that would have worked a treat during the Golden Era. At a time where his dad was one of the most beloved babyfaces in the industry, Cody's cheesy, good guy routine where he vanquishes evil in the end, would have gone down a treat.
It worked well for Hulk Hogan. And he loved fighting for America just as much.