10 WWE Attitude Era PPV Matches That Are Severely Underrated

The red-headed stepchildren of the Attitude Era.

With so much praise constantly heaped onto the relatively short-lived period of the WWE known affectionately as the Attitude Era, it's difficult to consider anything about it "underrated." And yet, despite the legions of fans (yours truly included) that won't shut up about how wonderful this time period was, there are still a few elements that remain under-appreciated by the masses. For instances, the matches. For some weird reason, the actual wrestling that happened in the Attitude Era has been largely forgotten, save for a few key, epic in-ring duels. The focus tends to shift to the outrageous characters, entertaining promos, and ridiculous(ly delightful) storylines. And that's a real shame, because although it may not have been the peak of technical wrestling in the WWE, the Attitude Era served up what should have been some truly career-defining matches. For whatever reason, though, they were promptly stuffed in the closet and forgotten about.

10. D-Generation X + Savio Vega Vs. Stone Cold, Cactus Jack, Chainsaw Charlie, Owen Hart - No Way Out Of Texas 1998

Let's start things off with some pure, unfiltered bedlam. Has there ever been a more random goddamn bunch of people thrown together for a match? Yet, somehow, some way, they were able to make this pandemonium look so, so good. There's a lot to dissect in this match, but let's start with the roster involved. Why was Savio Vega in a team with DX? He was a last-minute replacement for Shawn Michaels, who'd injured his back and declined to compete in the match. As for the super strange team on the other side, the short answer is that they all had their own beefs with various members of DX. The more fun answer is who cares, any time those four dudes are on the same side it's going to be a wonderful night. The match begins in absolute chaos, with Steve Austin hitting a Lou Thesz press on Billy Gunn while the world around them goes to complete sh*t: everyone's brawling, kitchen utensils are flying, someone's being strangled with a broom handle, and Road Dogg powerbombs Chainsaw Charlie through two chairs. It's a beautiful wreck. Putting aside Royal Rumbles, there may not have ever been so much going on in a single match all at once. Things do eventually clear up and transform into a slightly more "traditional" tag team set-up, but there's still just a ton of weapon smashing and hardcore-style scuffling. It's a great sight to see Stone Cold mixing it up in that way alongside hardcore legends like Mick Foley and Terry Funk, which isn't something that happens often. (Or...ever.) If nothing else, this match proved that disparate wrestlers could unite over an honorable cause, namely taking DX down a few begs. This match probably isn't revered due to its random nature (there was no one else available besides Savio Vega?), but I see this is as a wonderful example of what fun could be had in the Attitude Era when they got a little loose with their own rules.

9. Triple H Vs. The Rock - Fully Loaded 1998

Owed at least in part to the fact that Triple H is widely regarded as one of the most overrated wrestlers to ever step foot in a WWE ring, you'd be hard-pressed to find an avid wrestling fan that would rank a Hunter match in their top 10--or maybe even top 1,000--of all time. And that's fair. Triple H obviously wasn't as technically gifted as the likes of Shawn Michaels or Ricky Steamboat. But he was able to turn it on when he wanted to, delivering an intense (if not necessarily flashy) performance at times. Case in point: his first major feud with The Rock. It pushed him to heights he'd never been before (or possibly since) in terms of sheer exuberance and workmanship in the ring. This was a time when he and The Rock were battling it out for the Intercontinental Championship and trying to prove they could be "the guy" in the company, with Stone Cold Steve Austin suffering a neck injury the year before. Though occasionally given their due for the '98 SummerSlam Ladder Match, it was their 2 out of 3 falls match a month later at Fully Loaded in '98 that stands as a testament to both performers' stamina and storytelling abilities. There was a host of exciting exchanges, including an awesome triple reversal into a DDT halfway through the match, and a good use of the environment outside the ring. Sure, the repeated interference gets a little zany and those 60 second intermissions between falls are momentum killers, but The Rock and Triple H had the crowd eating out of the palm of their hands right until the very end. Really, this match was simply overshadowed by its disappointing finish--the time limit expired just before Triple H pinned Rock for the second time. That was a deflating way to end what was possibly the most solid meeting between two of the top talents in the company.

8. Test Vs. Shane McMahon - SummerSlam 1999

There may be a lot of people screaming at their computer screens right now that nothing involving Test could possibly be underrated. But give the guy a break, he was a very capable performer and had the ability to surprise you on occasion. Besides, any match that combined Test and Shane-O-Mac tended to yield mesmerizing results. But no one knew that going into SummerSlam. In fact, this two were about as green as could be, with Test a rookie to the business and Shane more comfortable watching from backstage than performing. To pad out the match and take some of the pressure off their technical naïveté, they made this a street fight and used frequent interference (as with most Attitude Era matches of any variety) from The Mean Street Posse and Vince McMahon's Stooges, Pat Patterson and Gerald Brisco. But Shane and Test both showed some real grit in this match, and there was some tender meat in this weird little stew. Bolstered by the fact that Test was legitimately wrestling "for the love of Stephanie McMahon," (who he would only be allowed to date if he won the match), with each guy taking some fantastic bumps. Shane's overall squirrelly energy and surprising athleticism in this match (check out that corkscrew moonsault) slowly won over the crowd, but nothing in the match endeared him to WWE fans like that elbow drop from the top turnbuckle onto Test and through the Spanish announce table. Shane would later go on a hot streak as WWE's resident rag doll, putting his body on the line in increasingly mortifying ways. But this was a night where he proved he could hang with the boys, and that he was more than a kid with a trust fund and a passing interest in professional wrestling. ...And Test did a good job. Admit it, you guys.

7. Dean Malenko Vs. Scotty 2 Hotty - Backlash 2000

One of them was icy and stoic, a self-described Man of a Thousand Holds, and the other was part of a ridiculously-themed tag team that wore baggy jeans and did "The Worm" as part of his finishing move. Personality-wise, they couldn't possibly be more of an odd couple. But just like Jack Lemmon and Walter Matthau, they created magic together. Yes, there was still a great deal of silliness from Scotty 2 Hotty, but by and large this was just a showcase of two undervalued talents. Malenko went after it with his usual, old-school techniques (seriously, is this guy a lost Brain Busters or what?), working the appendages and using some Ric Flair-esque dirty tricks at every opportunity. This is another match frequently overlooked because it's a strategic slow burner that wouldn't have looked too out of place at a 1990 Pay-Per-View. But they livened things up at all the right times, utilizing some big-time spots (a stellar superplex that should have put a man-sized hole in the ring) to get a few thunderous pops from the crowd. And then there's that ending. Come on, how many endings can you name that match up to the sheer "Oh snap" factor of that reversed superplex into DDT? Brilliant finish.

6. X-Pac Vs. Jeff Jarrett - Summerslam 1998

Both of these guys had a chance to do so much better in the WWE. They were both exciting to watch in the ring--as evidenced by their back-and-forth in this match--but for whatever reason, no one much cared about either of them unless they were directly in their field of vision. Once they were out of sight, even for a second, they super far out of mind. Their encounter at the '98 SummerSlam should be a bona fide classic, though. This was nearly a case of the mid-card guys upstaging the main event, as this was pretty fast and furious from start to finish. Even their failed maneuvers looked flashy. X-Pac was an energetic wild man throughout, while Jarrett shows why he was one of the most well-rounded performers in the company at the time. Though the conceit for this match was pretty silly (it was billed as a hair vs. hair match, with the loser getting their head shaved), the talent rose above the gimmick every minute they were in the ring. They didn't have much in common stylistically, but X-Pac and Double J worked wonders together that night.

5. The Rock Vs. Mankind Vs. Ken Shamrock - Breakdown: In Your House 1998

http://dai.ly/x25uq3u The stakes were very high. This triple threat match, inside a steel cage, would determine the Number 1 Contender for the WWF title. The story was there, all three performers had their stars shooting feverishly upward, and most importantly, they were genuinely engaging characters. (This is probably the first match that showed just how over The Rock was with the crowd.) So why isn't this one regarded as a classic? This match has a delicate blend of athletic maneuvers, tough bumps, and ring psychology that might not play to those who like their cage matches to be brutal and bloody, but there's no denying that it was a well-crafted, finely-tuned bit of wrestling artistry that could stand proudly alongside most of the great matches from that year. And how about that Jimmy Snuka elbow drop from the top of the cage by Mankind? No, it's not exactly his most death-defying leap from a cage (that happened a few months earlier), but the story behind that bump (drawing inspiration from his childhood backyard matches as Dude Love) added to the drama in a different way. And the ending was genuine, edge-of-your-seat stuff. But that's not the only match from this Pay-Per-View that deserves to be remembered a bit more fondly...

4. Owen Hart Vs. Edge - Breakdown: In Your House 1998

https://vimeo.com/104448016 Two native Canadian boys--one a splashy young rookie, the other a seasoned veteran--going head to head in Ontario? This was bound to be an engaging battle, if only because of the locale and the performers' desire to serve up a tasty slice of sports entertainment to their home crowd. Proof (as if we needed it) that Owen Hart could make anyone look like a top tier tactician in the ring, he guides the fresh-faced Edge through a technical clinic, using a mix of classic maneuvers (wristlocks, drop toe holds) and high-flying attacks (hurricanranas, springboard crossbodies) to keep things interesting. The moves were crisp and well-timed, with a steady pace that's hard to find in modern matches. It's a shame that Edge never fully embraced this technical style of wrestling because, despite one early mistake during a backbend, he pretty much nailed it. He also proved he could take a huge bump with relative ease, jumping off the ring skirt and into the arms of Owen Hart for a midair powerslam. The many near falls kept everyone on their toes, as Edge was still undefeated in his young career at the time and could have very easily upset the more experienced Hart. Unfortunately, this match is only really talked about because it first introduced Christian with a quick and mysterious cameo near the end.

3. Steve Austin Vs. Undertaker - Fully Loaded 1999

Far from the prettiest match on this list, the First Blood match between Stone Cold and Taker was a helluva brawl to watch unfold. The stipulations going into this one were pretty significant at the time: If Austin won, Mr. McMahon was never allowed on WWE television again. But if Undertaker won, Austin would never receive another shot at the WWE Championship. (In hindsight, either possible ending was ludicrous. But at the time both of these things could have very well been legit.) Add to that Undertaker's "personal" quest to make Austin bleed and you've got yourself a pretty dramatic matchup. Even without the storyline build-up, there's a sly sense of drama to a match like this, where the ultimate goal is to bust open your open's face to get the win. Both men are constantly reversing each other's maneuvers and engaging in a lot of near misses, which only builds the anticipation from the crowd, who are clearly chomping at the bit to see it all culminate in a bloody mess. There's been a lot of brawl style matches in WWE history, but this may be the most methodical of them all. That may sound like a given considering The Undertaker was involved, but reigning in someone as occasionally wild and flailing as Stone Cold is no easy feat. Here though, Austin looks every bit as steady as The Dead Man, working him over in an brutally calculated manner. When Undertaker gets tied up in the ropes toward the end of the match, and Stone Cold grabs a steel chair, the pop from the crowd really says all that needs to be said about the tension-building these two pulled off. There are some WTF moments for sure (Shane McMahon and X-Pac and Triple H and The Rock and Vince McMahon all get into the ring at various points), but this match ultimately works so well because of the little things these two titans did to make the melee look so meticulous.

2. The Hardy Boyz Vs. The Dudley Boyz - Royal Rumble 2000

Although it's difficult to say that The Hardy Boyz or The Dudley Boyz ever really got their due in the WWE, they've at least received plenty of recognition for some of their outstanding tag matches with each other (as well as Edge & Christian) over the years. For the most part, anyhow. When discussing this trio of tag teams, what immediately comes to mind is their trifecta of TLC matches (that includes what was originally billed as a Triangle Ladder Match at WrestleMania 16), in which they repeatedly upped the ante of what a person's body could be put through without having to bury a close friend a few days later. And although those are some hellacious, inventive matches, they also unfairly overshadow this Tag Team Table Match from 2000's Royal Rumble. Compared to the Triangle Ladder Match, this is nothing less than a work of art. Whereas the former spent had far too much downtime, eating big chunks out of the clock to set up specific stunts that had no real rationale or escalation, the table match is an example of perfect pacing. At its heart, this was a very clever game of cat and mouse with competitors constantly trying to keep themselves (and their partners) from going through a table at all costs. The only time this match lags a little is at the very end, right before two huge spots, one of which involves Bubba Ray getting smashed with a chair and falling off the balcony and through two tables, and the other features the first of many Jeff Hardy Swanton Bombs through a table. Also, Jeff Hardy deserves an award for how he took that table to the face after jumping off the barricade.

1. Chris Jericho Vs. Chris Benoit - Judgment Day 2000

http://dai.ly/xz51sn There's a pattern growing with the overlooked matches from this era. And it has to do with favoring strategy and ring psychology to flashy aerial maneuvers and random chair shots. Really, any one of Jericho and Benoit's PPV meetings could have gone in this spot, as these two had a series of incredible matches at Backlash, Judgment Day and SummerSlam all in the same year. All of them, unfortunately, are overshadowed by their ladder match at Royal Rumble in 2001. Of the three, the Judgment Day Submission Match wins by a hair if only because of that insane Walls of Jericho overtop the ropes. (Seriously, what in the WHAT?) Also, this submission match was slightly better than the one they had at Backlash, in part because they'd worked out some of the minor kinks they had the first go-round. These two WCW exports were on a mission to get the attention they felt passed them by at their previous company. And although this match may not get the credit it deserves, there's no denying how much chemistry these two had with each other and how efficiently they could execute a match. There's a whole host of crafty submissions sprinkled throughout (...again, that ring ropes Wall of Jericho, you guys!), and there's no part of this match that lacks excitement. Let's be honest: This is only forgotten because WWE wants us to forget everything related to Chris Benoit, right? (Though that sadistic finish with Benoit refusing to release the Crippler Crossface well after the bell is rung is pretty messed up and provides too much of a glimpse into that dude's psyche.)

Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.