10 WWE Backlash Matches That Should Have Happened At WrestleMania
They didn't get it right at WrestleMania, but they definitely did at Backlash.
Everybody knows that Backlash is the pay-per-view of WrestleMania rematches.
Whether it's the former champion getting their revenge, the number one contender having another shot, or just a feud that WWE refuses to let die, you can normally predict the Backlash card a long time before any matches are announced. What you can't predict is how good the event is going to be; that, and when they're going to stick the word WrestleMania in front of it and hope nobody minds...
There have been some laboured Backlashes with obvious endings, designed to let the 'E chug along on its way towards SummerSlam, especially during the first brand split when Raw wouldn't have another PPV until June at the earliest.
The glory days!
In among this endless supply of rematches, like a pearl at the bottom of the ocean, lie a number of incredible matches that have no right being on such a comparatively small show. Legends have returned, brand new champions have been crowned, and future stars have shined on this stage. Even more frustratingly, a number of WrestleMania rematches have been so much better than what WWE gave us at the Show of Shows.
These matches really should have taken place a month earlier, but sometimes WWE won't let you have nice things...
10. Jinder Mahal Vs. Randy Orton - 2017
What a place to start this list...
2017 was the year Goldberg squashed Kevin Owens, Brock Lesnar disappeared from TV with the Universal Championship, and WWE put on a whopping 16 pay-per-views in 12 months. With an absent champion on one brand, you'd think the message in the writers room would be "Let's build up the other belt and make it the top prize." Whoever said belt would've been fired by Vince McMahon, then work would have started.
To cut a long story short, the year started with Randy Orton in the Wyatt Family. The Viper won the Royal Rumble match and Bray Wyatt won the WWE Championship inside the Elimination Chamber; that family knows how to win gimmick matches. A burning Wyatt compound later and the two were face-to-face at WrestleMania 33.
Instead of a grudge match that was six months in the making, fans got the most basic match ever, save for the images of bugs that were projected on the ring. A lot of wrestlers have been blessed with spooky powers, but being able to conjure pictures of insects has to be the worst of the lot.
A month later and Backlash rolled into Chicago. Orton had seen off Wyatt in the House of Horrors at Payback (please don't ask) and now his challenger was... Jinder Mahal.
Whatever you think of this ploy to win over a new market at the expense of a credible development, it made the previous three months pointless. The Modern Day Maharaja had been doing nothing leading into the match, with the Wyatt spooktacular making fans change the channel too. Let's not pretend Orton-Mahal was much better than Orton-Wyatt, but it would've meant so much more to crown a brand new champion at WrestleMania instead of throwing the strap back on the Apex Predator.
9. Chris Benoit Vs. Chris Jericho - 2000
WrestleMania 2000 only had a single one-on-one match on its card. Can you remember what it was? If you said Terri Runnels Vs. The Kat in a Catfight, with Val Venis as the Special Guest Referee, you know how disjointed the first 'Mania of the 21st century was.
It could've been so much better with some quick fixes. This will be revisited later, but for now it's Kurt Angle Vs. Chris Benoit Vs. Chris Jericho for the Intercontinental and European Championships that's being changed. On paper, this sounds like the perfect match for the year 2000, but it went less than 15 minutes and it was just the Chrises pinning each other to take the straps off Angle. Like most of the card, it felt like the entire thing was rushed; there was potential, but they didn't meet expectations.
Later that month, with sports entertainment's only Olympic gold medalist taking on Big Show cosplaying as Hulk Hogan (isn't this meant to be one of the best pay-per-views ever?) WWE put on Benoit Vs. Jericho in a much better match at Backlash. The contest was a true display of technical wrestling, the kind that didn't happen at 'Mania. The feud was far more intense, the crowd was even more into it, and some of the reversals were like nothing Attitude Era fans had seen before.
Sure, it ended in a disqualification (and is difficult/impossible to revisit), but this match was unquestionably better than the Triple Threat earlier in the month. Angle can have a perfect match with anyone; if they'd booked the main event right, he could've even faced the Showster at 'Mania instead.
Sometimes WWE has to try something and perfect it later. That happened between WrestleMania and Backlash in 2000, more than once...
8. Mankind Vs. Big Show - 1999
Get ready for peak Attitude Era shenanigans.
The start of 1999 was all about Vince McMahon trying to stop "Stone Cold" Steve Austin from becoming WWE Champion again. The Chairman won the Royal Rumble match, then lost his ticket to WrestleMania because of a debuting Big Show not knowing his own strength... shenanigans! When 'Mania XV arrived, Austin 3:16 took on The Rock, with a Special Guest Referee to make sure the match was fair.
It was going to be either Big Show or Mankind; the two faced off on the same 'Mania card to decide. This was 1999, so the match was chaotic. In the end, referee Earl Hebner disqualified Show after he Chokeslammed Foley through a pair of steel chairs, even though both of them had cheated in the match. Why didn't anybody tell Paul Wight the rules of wrestling when they signed him? The World's Largest Athlete did get to knock out Vince McMahon though, the first of many, many, many turns.
The whole match felt like something from an episode of Raw, unlike their rematch at Backlash in a Boiler Room Brawl. This was a proper hardcore contest; tables, ladders, and chairs were used. People were electrocuted, hit with glass, and sprayed with steam. It wouldn't have been a spectacle for the live crowd, but this match was so much better than what their bout at 'Mania: a sideshow to the main event.
If they needed the Special Guest Referee stipulation, they could have had it in this match instead. Big Show's face turn still would have worked; he saved Mankind from Big Boss Man and Test after leaving the boiler room at Backlash anyway. Drafting in this much better match definitely would have improved an up and down WrestleMania XV card.
7. "Stone Cold" Steve Austin Vs. The Rock - 1999
Back to WrestleMania XV again...
In the last entry you read about the mind-boggling storyline that led to "Stone Cold" Steve Austin Vs. The Rock in the main event. This was the first in a trilogy of matches between the two at the Showcase of the Immortals and it's by far their worst encounter. You can ask Austin and he'll tell you the same.
Distracted by issues in his personal life, "Stone Cold" forgot to bring his ring vest and had to walk out in a t-shirt. Things were more convoluted than ever, from Vince McMahon declaring himself the Special Guest Referee, to Commissioner Shawn Michaels sending him packing, to Mankind, Mike Chioda, and Earl Hebner all donning the black and white throughout the match. Austin 3:16 walked out with the belt, but time has been cruel to this contest.
Time hasn't been cruel to their rematch at Backlash. There was still referee nonsense, this time involving Shane McMahon, but these two legends with unquestionable chemistry seemed far more comfortable on their second go. Rocky showed his natural charisma by hijacking commentary and stealing a camera to tease his opponent with; Austin showed why the fans adored him with his brawling style and absolute loathing of the McMahon family.
Everything just clicked, like they'd fine-tuned their 'Mania bout into a far more enjoyable contest. Perhaps they needed to go through the first match to realise what they could do together. Imagine "Stone Cold" being handed the Smoking Skull belt by an irate Vinny Mac at the Granddaddy instead of at Backlash; there's an image to send the crowd home with.
You were so close, WWE...
6. Rhea Ripley Vs. Asuka Vs. Charlotte Flair - 2021
Nobody wanted to see Charlotte Flair added to the Women's Championship match between Becky Lynch and Ronda Rousey at WrestleMania 35, but she should have been in it two years later.
Heading into 'Mania 37, under the thunder in Florida, Rhea Ripley was ready to face Asuka for the Raw Women's Championship. Ripley made her main roster debut just a month before the Grandaddy, challenging the Empress of Tomorrow on her first night on Raw. Sure, she'd had a WrestleMania match before, but she was still a part of the NXT brand at that point.
New Year's Day played Rhea's entrance theme, Brutality, as she made her way to the ring; a telltale sign that WWE was going all-in on their new star. It's hard for Asuka to have a bad match and to be fair to both of them, this was an entertaining contest. WWE was ready to put the strap on Ripley after Asuka had held the division together for the last 231 days.
A Riptide later and the belt was on the Australian superstar, but the match that solidified her status at the top of the Women's division came at the bizarrely named WrestleMania Backlash. Charlotte Flair returned the night after 'Mania and did what she does best: inserted herself into the title picture. It was completely warranted here though; she made the rematch even better.
With how the Queen has been booked since debuting, there's always a chance that WWE will give her the belt. In the end it was another Riptide that saw off Asuka, but everybody in this match looked strong. Considering they love to make Flair the final boss of the women's division, it's surprising they waited until after WrestleMania to bring her back.
5. Hulk Hogan And Shawn Michaels Vs. Daivari And Muhammad Hassan - 2005
It's wild to think that Hulk Hogan's last match at WrestleMania was against Vince McMahon in 2003.
The Hulkster came and went over the next five years, with matches against Shawn Michaels and Randy Orton happening at SummerSlam and not at the Showcase. Why didn't Hulkamania run wild one last time at the Show of Shows? He was inducted into the Hall of Fame the night before 'Mania 21, then appeared on the night to save Eugene from his ultimate enemy: evil foreign heels. They should've just given him a match; he was already wearing the red and yellow!
The best way to do this would be to move Hulkamania and the Heartbreak Kid Vs. Daivari and Muhammad Hassan from the Backlash card. Not only does WWE love having Americans vanquish foes from the rest of the world, but it was two of the industry's biggest starts teaming up for the first time ever. How wasn't this at a big four pay-per-view? Get rid of the problematic Eugene spot and draft Michaels in, even if it means HBK's match against Kurt Angle from the same year has to go...
The Olympic Hero was living his best life as the wrestling machine a year later in 2006. Take HBK Vs. Vince McMahon off the WrestleMania 22 card (sorry to Pro Wrestling Illustrated, who somehow named this match of the year) and replace it with Michaels-Angle. Sure, the World Heavyweight Championship match would have to just be Rey Mysterio against Randy Orton, but that was the main feud going into the Grandaddy anyway.
It all fits. The more you think about it, the more baffling it is that this match was on a Raw exclusive PPV and didn't even main event. They really dropped the ball.
4. Charlotte Flair Vs. Ronda Rousey - 2022
WWE had been teasing this match for a long time. At Survivor Series in 2018, Charlotte Flair turned heel when she attacked Ronda Rousey in a match for brand supremacy. If only the crowd hadn't cheered her, their rematch might have come a lot sooner. Becky Lynch was becoming "The Man" and plans for Flair-Rousey 2 at WrestleMania 35 had to be shelved.
Eventually, Ronda calmed down and came back to WWE, winning the Royal Rumble match in the least shocking result in history to setup a bout for the ages on the Grandest Stage of Them All. The SmackDown Women's Championship was on the line, but it was still a dud.
Hold after hold after hold ended with a ref bump and, of all the moves in Charlotte's arsenal, ended with a Big Boot. A Big Boot! The story leading into the match wasn't anything to write home about either, as if WWE thought their names were enough to sell the match.
Sometimes WWE shies away from having certain gimmick matches at 'Mania, but switching this washout for their "I Quit" match at WrestleMania Backlash would have made so much of a difference.
Their rematch showed how much of a blood feud this was. They fought in the crowd, hit each other with kendo sticks, and even threw cameras around. It was a contest that showed how much they hated one another. Rousey won after breaking Flair's radial bone with an Arm Bar, making her shout "I quit" to surrender her title.
If WrestleMania is the biggest show of the year, why not crown Ronda as the SmackDown Women's Champion on the Grandest Stage in the best match possible?
3. Randy Orton Vs. Cactus Jack - 2004
The Rock is about to be bumped from the WrestleMania XX card, so brace yourself...
In the 2000s, working with Mick Foley was a blessing. Triple H cemented his place as WWE's top heel after a violent Street Fight and Hell in a Cell match in 2000. By the time 2004 arrived, it was The Game's protege Randy Orton who was causing problems for the Hardcore Legend.
Orton was deep in his "Legend Killer" gimmick, with Foley in his sights as WrestleMania XX got closer. Unfortunately, the story turned into a nostalgia run when the Rock 'n' Sock Connection reunited to take on Evolution. The contest was just fine. The Rock got a huge pop, but Foley has said that he was disappointed in the match; it ended with an RKO that Mick decided not to sell, sitting up as soon as the bout was over. Bizarre.
Scrub it from the record books and replace it with their Backlash match. You've got to let Foley be Foley; he does it best when he's put in a Hardcore match with an up-and-coming star. Walking out as Cactus Jack, the challenger for the Intercontinental Championship even brought his signature baseball bat wrapped in barbed wire with him. This match showed the world that Randy Orton was here to stay; the sight of tacks sticking out of his back after a missed RKO still makes fans wince.
Plain and simple: they should've done this at WrestleMania. It would have meant so much more for Foley to finally have a good match at the Granddaddy and for the Legend Killer to show a far bigger audience what he was made of.
If they really needed that pop for The Rock, why not have him come and save Foley from Evolution at the end? It's so easy.
2. Randy Orton Vs. Edge - 2020
Edge’s return to the ring in 2020 was absolutely remarkable. The pop when the Alamodome heard “You think you know me” must be in the top 10 of all time; what a shame his first match was behind closed doors.
Everybody knows what happened to the world a few months after the Rated-R Superstar came back to the squared circle, so there’s no need to bring it up here. The show "must go on" and WrestleMania 36 was held over two days with no fans in attendance (except that giant fan on the ceiling) at the Performance Centre. It was a unique pay-per-view to say the least, with matches being filmed and perfected well in advance of broadcast.
Edge’s first feud was with his old Rated-RKO partner Randy Orton. Their match started in the ring, then took them to places in the Performance Centre most fans hadn’t seen before: from the gym, to a warehouse, to the roof of a production truck. This Last Man Standing match was a 5/10; it was long and laboured in all the wrong places.
You guessed it: their rematch at Backlash in June was far better.
Billed as the Greatest Wrestling Match Ever, this carefully constructed contest started with tributes to Howard Finkel and Madison Square Garden. By this point, WWE knew what it was doing with cinematic matches and it showed in almost 45 minutes of action between two wrestlers who knew each other well. It definitely had a lot of editing, some spots were over the top, and it made a mockery of the false finish, but Edge and Orton were able to showcase the best of themselves.
Was it the Greatest Wrestling Match Ever? No. Was it better than their slog at ‘Mania? Definitely.
1. The Rock Vs. Triple H - 2000
One of the best matches of the Attitude Era should have happened at WrestleMania.
The year 2000 started with The Rock winning the Royal Rumble match in a botched finish. Big Show claimed to be the true winner, then won the Brahma Bull's title match at No Way Out as Triple H retired Mick Foley on the same night.
A month later it was all about the McMahons. The Rock was added to the match by Vince after pinning the World's Largest Athlete, then Foley was brought out of retirement by Linda to make it a Fatal Four Way. Stephanie was backing her husband Triple H, while Show had Shane in his corner.
Nobody wanted to see it, but the match main evented 'Mania 2000. The Game became the first heel to leave the Show of Shows as WWE Champion after Vince betrayed The Rock; a lacklustre way to end a disappointing pay-per-view.
WWE righted the wrong a month later at Backlash with a match that would have saved 'Mania 2000 from the scrapheap.
It was The Rock Vs. Triple H one-on-one at last. Pat Patterson and Gerald Brisco got involved, the McMahons were everywhere, and Linda had to intervene with Earl Hebner. The biggest moment was when an injured "Stone Cold" Steve Austin returned to even the odds. It was an iconic moment during a chaotic match that had the crowd on their feet. They don't make them like this anymore.
Putting this match in the main event of WrestleMania 2000 is a no-brainer... so which booker at WWE didn't have a brain when they were putting the card together? Not having that "Stone Cold" pop on the Grandest Stage of Them All might be the biggest oversight in 'Mania history...