10 WWE Castoffs Who Are Killing It In AEW
WWE didn't see the value in these wrestlers, but AEW is getting the most out of them.
WWE releases have been in the news a lot since April 2020, with dozens upon dozens of wrestlers being given their walking papers, and others opting to just not re-sign with Vince McMahon’s sports entertainment juggernaut. This year alone, more than 70 wrestlers have been shown the door, including 18 earlier this month.
These wrestlers have varied in stature within the industry, from young, inexperienced rookies in NXT to veterans or outright franchise superstars. There have been enough free agents floating around to build a new, star-studded promotion twice over.
And while some of the biggest names have unsurprisingly become huge stars in AEW, there are numerous examples of underutilized WWE castoffs who have seen their stock climb ever since becoming All-Elite.
So, while you might be thinking of names like Bryan Danielson, Jon Moxley and Adam Cole, this article will look at some of the guys and gals that WWE seemingly couldn’t figure out how to use effectively, cut loose and then AEW snapped them up and made them instant impact players.
It’s worth noting that guys like Shawn Spears, FTR and Pac just missed this list as guys WWE mismanaged before AEW salvaged them. (We wanted to keep it to 10 and also wanted to highlight a couple of less-obvious choices. Feel free to tweet disagreements on this list @ScottCarlson123.)
With that said, let’s get to it….
10. Serena Deeb
No, we’re not talking about reaching way back into the days of the Straight Edge Society.
WWE actually had their hands on Serena Deeb from 2017-20, bringing her out of semi-retirement to compete in the Mae Young Classic, then kept her on as a coach at the Performance Center. (Keep in mind that Deeb is the same age as Charlotte Flair, so any argument that she might have been older doesn’t hold up.)
Deeb was part of the massive April 2020 cuts after WrestleMania 36 and turned up in AEW that fall. She won the NWA Women’s Championship, which she would defend in AEW periodically. Most recently, she’s turned heel and had a mini-feud with Hikaru Shida.
The fact that WWE viewed her as little more than a coach – even after seeing her during the Mae Young Classic – and didn’t try to coax her back into the ring is an indictment of what WWE values. Imagine if Raw or SmackDown had Serena on their roster the past few years, having solid matches with almost anyone. She would have coached younger superstars through on-the-job training.
9. Ruby Soho
One of the most recent examples of an underutilized wrestler being discarded by WWE and making an immediate impact has to be Ruby Soho (nee Riott).
Well-liked and respected in the industry, Ruby achieved a modicum of success in NXT before being called up to the main roster as leader of a trio called the Riott Squad. The group was little more than enhancement talent for bigger stars, though Ruby did get a Raw Women’s Championship PPV match against Ronda Rousey – where she got obliterated. Injuries and piss-poor booking upon her return made it clear WWE didn’t see a future for Soho. She was cut loose in June.
After changing her name and filming a series of vignettes, Soho made her AEW debut as the joker in the Casino Battle Royal, which she won, at All Out in September. She lost her AEW Women’s Championship match, but she’s remained a featured player on TV and is currently in the tournament to crown the TBS Women’s Champion and could be seen as a likely secondary titleholder.
Already, Ruby has gotten more positive direction in her two months in AEW than she did in the last two years with WWE. From afterthought to championship material. Not too shabby.
8. 2point0
When you talk about WWE castoffs, few duos fit that description better than 2point0, the former Ever-Rise in NXT.
The duo lasted about two years in NXT, toiling away mainly off-camera and not winning a televised match until June 2020. They were bounced from the 2021 Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic in the first round and were released that June.
What no one could have envisioned is that Ever-Rise would be reborn as 2point0 in AEW and immediately interject themselves into a short-lived – and very one-sided – feud with Darby Allin and Sting. Their debut match featured Jeff Parker and Matt Lee joining Daniel Garcia in facing Jon Moxley, Eddie Kingston & Allin. They also had a well-received Texas Tornado match against Allin & Sting.
Most recently, the duo have drawn the ire of Eddie Kingston and Chris Jericho, which should make for some entertaining TV.
Sure, 2point0 are little more than comedy jobbers, but they’ve gotten TV time alongside an icon like Sting, and what’s more important, they’ve been entertaining as hell. Just like that AEW has realized their usefulness and made them an enjoyable part of their programming.
7. Bobby Fish
Who would have seen the oft-injured lesser member of the Undisputed Era becoming someone to be feared in the ring?
Bobby Fish was a founding member of the Undisputed Era and former NXT Tag Team Champion, but he also suffered multiple injuries that took him out of action for stretches. He was released in August as the faction had splintered and NXT prepared to reboot just a couple of months later.
When Fish showed up in AEW to fight Sammy Guevara for the TNT Championship, fans would have been forgiven if they thought this was just a one-off appearance as a flavor of the week challenger. But then Fish signed with the company and had a fantastic bout against Bryan Danielson and a solid match against CM Punk.
Most recently, Fish has reunited with Undisputed Era colleague Adam Cole as something of a mercenary for Cole. Again, for a guy who was regarded as disposable by WWE, that’s quite the turnaround for Fish.
6. Lio Rush
When you talk about coming out of nowhere, you’ve got to mention Lio Rush, who has come on strong in AEW in recent weeks.
Rush was the definition of a WWE castoff, turned into a manager on the main roster, then demoted back to NXT as a cruiserweight, where he re-established himself, only to be released in April 2020. After toying with retirement, Lio showed up as the joker in the Casino Battle Royal at Double or Nothing in 2021, before finally landing in AEW this fall as Dante Martin’s manager.
But things have really taken off recently with Rush partnering with Martin, and the duo have absolutely wowed fans with their speed and in-ring prowess. (The latest wrinkle with Dante joining Team Taz bodes watching.) Watching Lio perform, it makes you shake your head at how WWE managed to screw this one up.
It’s still early in his tenure with AEW, but Rush could be a long-term success story, finally getting the chance to show off on a big stage rather than being stifled by WWE.
5. Andrade El Idolo
Let’s be clear here: There never was any doubt in Andrade El Idolo’s talent and ability. Most felt like he would be a superstar wherever he landed.
But WWE managed to screw the luchador up so spectacularly that by the time he departed WWE in early 2021, he was little more than an afterthought. The former NXT Champion was famously mishandled on the main roster, and even with a global pandemic where he looked to be a rare bright spot, the company turned his stable into jobbers. His release was actually a welcome sign that maybe he could turn his career around.
Signed by AEW, Andrade’s early days seemed uneven, and you could make the case that he still hasn’t found his footing yet, but the simple fact is that El Idolo has been treated like a big deal, largely protected and put in high-profile matches, rather than trotted out every week to lose to mid-carders.
Importantly, Andrade looks happier there, performing alongside a couple of other fellow WWE castoffs, one of which we’ll get to in a bit…
4. Christian Cage
When Christian returned to the ring for real at Royal Rumble 2021, it felt like it was going to just be a “nice to see you” moment, a cup of coffee to give Captain Charisma one spotlight alongside his best friend Edge after being forced to retire seven years earlier.
But Christian’s performance in the Rumble was better than expected, making it to the final four, and you had to wonder if he might have a late-career renaissance, like Shawn Michaels or Edge. However, WWE wasn’t about to let him get that opportunity, and he was never locked up. So off to AEW Christian Cage went.
In AEW, Cage has been partnered with Jurassic Express, an odd pairing at first that has blossomed into a wonderful collaboration that has seen Christian become one of the very few to defeat Kenny Omega, besting him for the Impact World Championship. The Instant Classic also has racked off a series of solid singles, tag and trios matches since returning to active competition, proving a lot of people wrong that the 47-year-old still has something left in the tank.
More notably, Chrisitan has clearly helped Jungle Boy grow and evolve as a performer during these past few months, as the veteran has served as something of a mentor for the young performer. It really is the best-case scenario and has made the signing of Cage one of AEW’s shrewdest moves.
3. Tay Conti
The inspiration for this list, Tay Conti was little more than an extra body in NXT, a wrestler getting a couple of small spots on weekly TV and little more. She showed flashes here and there, but she never really got the chance to grow.
Released in April 2020 as part of the COVID-19 budget cuts (in a year in which WWE would post record profits), Conti landed in AEW and slowly grew into a solid performer who has turned heads (literally and figuratively) during the past year. Watching her matches now, you can see she’s still in her formative years as a wrestler, but you also can see her confidence growing and her performances improving weekly.
Most recently, Tay competed for the AEW Women’s Championship at Full Gear, coming up short against Britt Baker, but still earning a PPV title shot, which is a far cry from where she was 18 months earlier.
2. Miro
Few wrestlers have showed more skill and talent and been
more popular with fans before being released than the former Rusev. While a lot
of the others on this list were “over” with fans, Rusev managed to elicit
strong reactions despite WWE’s best efforts to keep him down.
Released in April 2020 along with what seems like half the roster, Miro showed up in AEW in September 2020 as a babyface known as the Kip Sabian’s best man. This provided an opportunity for Miro to show his personality, which was often stifled in WWE. Upon turning heel, we got to see the killer fans got to know in his early WWE days, but with a twist: Miro wasn’t a generic foreign heel with a mouthpiece talking for him. He was just a brutal villain who dubbed himself The Redeemer and God’s Favorite Champion.
That persona has been tweaked slightly since Miro lost the TNT Championship, as he seems to be feuding with God him/herself in his promos. But Miro still remains one of AEW’s best assets that hasn’t been fully tapped, and a far cry from the guy who WWE actively tried to tamp down when “Rusev Day” got over with fans.
1. Malakai Black
Probably one of the most infamous WWE releases has to be Aleister Black, who was discarded in June right in the middle of a feud and shortly after returning to the roster with a new character and what seemed like a renewed push.
If you’re looking for an example of corporate WWE stupidly cutting their creative team off at the knees, look no further, as it seemed like one had no idea what the other was doing. Black was another of the former NXT Champions that WWE has managed to screw up and toss aside, fueling the belief that the company simply doesn’t know how to manage its talent.
As part of AEW, Black has maintained the dark and mysterious character he used in WWE, feuding with Cody Rhodes and his associates. It’s obvious AEW views Malakai as a big part of their future plans, as his appearances are well-scripted and prominent.
There’s a pretty good chance Black and a few others on this list will be champions before too long (Miro and Christian Cage already have captured gold), which would only further the legend of AEW polishing up WWE’s discarded pieces.