10 WWE Disasters Rescued With One Tiny Change
Sometimes, WWE just needs to change one small thing and BOOM! The day is saved.
WWE has and always will burn through thousands of ideas.
The promotion is tasked with delivering freshness weekly, or at least the illusion of it; there are only so many variations of the same themes, after all. Regardless, even fans who have been tuning in since before they could tell the time want more, more, more.
It's no surprise that WWE has come up with some stinkers over the decades then. Many of those creative abominations die out quickly, but some...stick around and work out. The survivors? Those are the ones overworked writers or pro wrestlers themselves endeavour to tweak and change into something beautiful.
They pull success from the wreckage, in other words, and they do so in the most ingenious ways. Such changes are rarely sweeping, but they always have a dramatic impact that improves gimmicks immediately. Without those rescue missions, you might not regard any of them as worthy topics at all.
The best thing about all of this is that WWE didn't have to work too hard to turn things around. All they needed was one itsy bitsy, teeny tiny adjustment.
10. New Day Ditch Gospel
Holy f*ck, the original concept for New Day was dire.
Vince McMahon wanted Kofi Kingston, Big E and Xavier Woods to be babyface gospel singers who'd encourage the WWE faithful to get on up out of their seats to clap along. All three wrestlers spotted disaster on the horizon, and they begged McMahon to ditch that plan and just let them do their own thing.
The then-boss eventually relented, and New Day became one of the best trios in company history. Kofi, E and Woods took ownership of the New Day and turned it into a winner. That wouldn't have been the case had they forced some crummy gospel gimmick down everyone's throats.
They still danced, and they still clapped, but New Day did so as heels who were deliberately trying to irritate everybody. They were so entertaining at it that they gained popularity, turned babyface and thrived. All three deserve a medal for fighting back against Vince's awful vision.
9. The Fastest Royal Rumble Ever
Yes, rewatching the 1995 Royal Rumble should come with a public health warning. However, it should also be essential viewing for anybody who moans about WWE's current product. Think that three hour Raw was painful? Check out The Undertaker vs. IRS back in January '95.
The WWF was keenly aware that star power was thin on the ground back then. So, in a bid to mask it, Vinnie Mac decreed that the annual 30-man match should be "the fastest Royal Rumble ever". He dropped the standard (albeit worked) two minute gaps between entrants to just 60 seconds.
That, somehow, made the match zip past even though dudes like Timothy Well and Mantaur were in the thing. Imagine how bad things would've been had folks in Tampa been asked to sit around and wait for dorks like Aldo Montoya, a past-his-prime Dick Murdoch or Kwang to hit the ring.
At least the bout was over in approx 40 minutes.
8. Too Much? Too Cool!
Brian Christopher and Scott Taylor were not over as 'Too Much'.
In fact, the Light-Heavyweight duo entered arenas to silence and came across as the kind of bargain bin tag-team you'd expect to see erm...light up episodes of Shotgun and Superstars every weekend. Then, in mid-1999, Vince Russo suggested they mimic The Hardy Boyz by being the complete opposite of cool.
Christopher and Taylor reinvented themselves as Grandmaster Sexay and Scotty 2 Hotty respectively, and magic was created almost overnight. Fans grew to adore the overt silliness of their outdated 80s dad dancing, and treated the pair like the WWF's very own Beastie Boys.
Suddenly, Too Cool went from slumming it on the 'C' shows to one of the most over acts on the Monday night flagship. Adding Rikishi, and involving him in their goofy dance breaks, was a stroke of genius too. Who knew trying to be uncool could be so awesome?!
7. Mandy Rose Is “Demoted”
Mandy Rose went from flirting with Otis to feuding with Sonya Deville to teaming with Dana Brooke in a going-nowhere-fast women's tag in a heartbeat. That dramatic fall from grace seemed complete when WWE demoted Rose to NXT and tried to repackage her as some world class worker.
That was a bit jarring for fans, but Mandy defied expectations by relishing the challenge and becoming a weekly highlight on the third brand from July 2021 onwards. By October, she'd captured the NXT Women's Title, was leading her own Toxic Attraction faction and refused to let WWE's wobbly 2.0 change negatively affect her.
You've got to admire that effort.
Rose's company career was on course to end in disaster, but she pulled the nose up by putting her head down and working really f*cking hard to improve in-ring. NXT (even with the crap 2.0 branding) was a million times better than teaming with Dana long-term.
6. Jey Uso Sees Through Sami Zayn
Ooft! Some folks won't like this one being included, but here goes.
There were genuine worries that Sami Zayn weaseling his way into The Bloodline would be a mistake for him and for the Roman Reigns-led faction. After all, it wouldn't make sense if the family blindly accepted some conspiracy theorist who had shown himself to be a top class buffoon for years.
The good news? Jey Uso was booked to shun Sami and question why he was even sniffing around Bloodline business in the first place. That minuscule adjustment to the storyline made something else clear to viewers: Reigns is the one manipulating Zayn, not the other way around.
Segments involving Roman, Sami, both Usos and Solo Sikoa have been a masterclass in character work ever since. Everyone watching knows Zayn is gonna get a kicking from the family at some point - they just don't know when, and neither does he.
Disaster averted.
5. Matt Riddle Finds A Friend
If only Vince McMahon had retired before he could book countless NXT workers into oblivion on the main roster. OK, so maybe that's a bit harsh, but come on - McMahon's mind believed he needed to explain Matt Riddle's barefoot style with some bullsh*t childhood tale about frostbitten feet!
Thrilling stuff.
That unnecessary backstory was absolutely atrocious, and it got Riddle off to a poor start when he started showing up on top-tier programming in 2020. Worse, the NXT standout was starting to burn through the usual bland singles stuff (winning the US Title, losing it, doing nothing else of note etc).
Then, he formed RK-BRO with Randy Orton, and things started to get fun. Simply having someone sigh through Riddle's backstage weirdness breathed new life into his stoner gimmick, and becoming part of a tag with one of WWE's top names saved him from midcard hell.
He's a rare example of somebody who got elevated by a thrown-together tag.
4. NXT Goes Back To Basics
This is super-recent, but it still counts.
Wrestling fans and industry critics alike rolled their eyes when WWE announced that the popular NXT brand was changing to "NXT 2.0" in September 2021. That, not so coincidentally, was around the same time that Triple H took some time off to heal up from a heart scare.
Vince McMahon ditched the traditional black and gold look of the show, and even moved away from the successful 'best of the independents' vibe that Trips had developed for years. The then-boss replaced all of that with a garish colour-splashed aesthetic, and he decided to start booking the place like a raunchier version of FCW.
The nightmare is over. Triple H, free to make his own decisions now that Vince has retired, ditched 2.0 and returned NXT to its roots on 13 September. Fans relate to that style more than McMahon's colour scheme anyway, and it should win back some spotlight for a show most people have started ignoring.
3. Batista Replaces Mark Jindrak
It's important to remember that Batista wasn't some mega-star when he replaced Mark Jindrak in Evolution towards the end of 2002. If anything, ex-WCW man Jindrak had more name value. He just...wasn't a great fit for the group, and that's obvious from even the earliest concept shots of the quartet together.
Triple H, Ric Flair and Randy Orton all look like they belong. Meanwhile, Jindrak looks like someone who just walked into shot and happened to be wearing a swish suit. Something had to change, because this wouldn't do. What good is a killer heel faction (one with main event ambitions) if one member is out of place?
Enter big Dave.
Batista's inclusion was a more natural fit for Evolution, and it stopped WWE from surely making the group a trio shortly after debuting it. Being honest, there was no way a disinterested Jindrak was going to work out alongside top stars like Trips or Flair.
2. Butch Reverts To 'Bruiserweight'
Vince McMahon wanted to pretend that Matt Riddle was able to wrestle barefoot because he'd lost feeling in his feet. The same man figured that nobody could possibly care about a technical marvel like 'Bruiserweight' Pete Dunne'. Nah, they needed to see him throw childish tantrums instead.
He also needed to be called 'Butch'.
Granted, Triple H has kept that name since assuming control of WWE operations, but he's enabled Dunne to revert back to his classic look and actually wrestle some kickass matches. That last bit is important, because it means Butch (WWE-ified name and all) is having more fun out there.
Shockingly, at least to Vince, fans haven't left their seats to get popcorn during his segments either. In fact, Butch has become an even more valuable part of Sheamus' rugged 'Brawling Brutes' gimmick on SmackDown. There are even better things to come for the Brit too, and everybody knows it.
No more tantrums.
1. Becky Lynch Stops Berating Fans
Go back and watch Becky Lynch's post-SummerSlam 2018 promo on the 21 August edition of SmackDown. There, Becky blamed the fans for her behaviour on the pay-per-view and said they were responsible for that attack on Charlotte Flair.
People cheered her anyway, which was problematic.
Becky knew she couldn't continue fighting uphill against rising support, so she stopped ragging on crowds when she had the mic. That smart decision led to the most successful run of her entire career. Lynch turned the heat onto WWE itself, and 'The Man' character was born a few months later.
Lynch subbing out the audience blame game for stoic defiance worked a treat, and it cannot be overstated just how important that was to her push. 'The Man' wouldn't have been anywhere near as rewarding had Becks continued whining like a spoiled brat.
What other WWE disasters were rescued with just one tiny change? For more wrestling, check out 5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Rampage (Sept 16) and 10 Reasons Why Roman Reigns Topped PWI's Top 500 Wrestlers 2022!