10 WWE Gimmicks I Loved (That Everybody Else Hated)
Screw everyone else, these guys ruled...
WWE.comA successful wrestling gimmick that most fans loved would be guys like "Stone Cold" Steve Austin, The Rock, "The Heartbreak Kid" Shawn Michaels and others of that stature. What about the ones that may have failed for one reason or another, but that you liked even though the character was a failure in a lot of ways? We all have them. These characters could be of interest to you because maybe they're from the same country, maybe they sound like your maybe you just want to like something that's different from how you are. It doesn't matter what the reason is. If you're a fan you're allowed to like who you want and what you want. That's the best thing about being a wrestling fan. Thanks to wrestlingforum.com for the idea. If you read WhatCulture.com regularly then you know we don't do a lot of personal lists, but the editors have afforded me the opportunity because it's such a fun idea. Please feel free to mention any gimmicks that you loved that others didn't like as much. We all have them. Don't be shy! Most of my choices are going to be more recent. There are guys from the 1980s and early 1990s that I remember too, but it's hard to know if they were popular with others or not. At least with the more recent performers I can judge them based on how I know people react to them in the online wrestling community. With that in mind, here are ten gimmicks that I loved that everybody else (or at least a lot of people) seemed to hate.
10. Matt Striker On Commentary
WWE.comCommentators have gimmicks. All of them do. When WWE added Matt Striker to commentary he provided a fresh voice. It was somebody new. Some fans really HATED Matt Striker on commentary in WWE. Not me, especially when he was a heel. It was a role that was actually perfect for a guy like him because he's a lifelong wrestling fan with encyclopedic knowledge of the business that really should have thrived in that role. The powers that be didn't seem to agree and a lot of fans felt like he was a bad fit. It also felt like Jerry Lawler wasn't a big fan of his either. There was a memorable moment that seemed to hurt him at the 2011 Royal Rumble when he said "I'm marking out bro" as Booker T surprisingly returned to WWE. That was frowned upon because the phrase "marking out" is more of an insider or smart wrestling term that shouldn't be used on a wrestling broadcast. It really shouldn't have been a big deal, but it turned out that it was. It was less than a month later when he was taken off commentary. They really could have used a heel color commentator at that point. Striker should have been that guy. Instead, WWE continued to make Michael Cole the heel announcer even though he was supposed to be the play by play guy. Striker could have been great as a commentator in WWE. It's not a popular opinion, but it's my feeling that WWE missed a huge opportunity with him.
9. Jillian Hall As The Bad Singer
WWE.comIf you think about Jillian Hall's career in WWE she deserves to be celebrated for her ability to overcome one of the stupidest gimmicks ever (the woman with the growth on her face) and somehow she managed to completely change things up as the world's worst karaoke singer. It's not like it was the greatest gimmick ever, but she sure put herself out there. She did everything she could to make it work. Hall was always a pretty good in-ring performer. She wasn't one of those girls that got into wrestling as a model that looked lost out there. They trained her in OVW, she came up through WWE's system and when she got her call to the main roster she showed that belonged with the others. They completely missed an opportunity with her too. Instead of keeping her as a heel for the majority of her run as a terrible singer, they could have turned her face by having heel divas mock her for how bad she was only for her to fight back by beating her in matches. Then after those matches she could sing in another woman's face as a way to annoy her. It could have turned her into a more serious wrestler too. Hall should have had a better career in WWE. She's definitely one of the most under-appreciated divas in WWE history.
8. Kevin Thorn & Ariel In ECW
WWE.comIf you forget who Kevin Thorn is you're probably not alone. He was a short-lived vampire character on WWE's ECW brand that was paired with a hot woman named Ariel played by Shelly Martinez. Part of the reason they created the Thorn/Ariel pairing was because ECW was on Syfy and they had asked WWE to create some characters that might cater to the Syfy audience. He was a part of ECW for most of 2006 and into 2007 although he was never given a significant push. If you looked at him as a worker, he was a guy that was capable of having good matches. The problem was that the gimmick was so over the top that fans never really bought into it. Perhaps I merely liked it because I thought Ariel did a great job of looking like a crazy vampire woman. She's easy on the eyes too! When you can have a guy/girl pairing that works that well together you need to capitalize on it, but instead they just faded away.
7. Chief Morley
WWE.comThe Val Venis character was a very popular midcarder in the late 1990s and into the early 2000s, but once the gimmick lost its steam he became a guy in Right to Censor and later as Chief Morley. His real name is Sean Morley. The "Chief" part applied because he was hired as the Chief of Staff by Eric Bischoff in late 2002. It was a character that should have been very successful for Morley. They could have had him wrestle when Bischoff needed him to and then be an office stooge when the situation called for it, but instead the role he had was inconsistent. He was always a good talker too. If you had somebody in that spot that couldn't talk then it would be pointless, but Morley was always very good at engaging a crowd. He could have been so much more than the "hey ladies" guy. There were plenty of things they could have done with a character like that. In fact, Jonathon Coachman ended up turning into a heel stooge character that could have been Morley, who was a trained wrestler unlike Coach. It was a missed opportunity for Morley.
6. Zack Ryder
WWE.comThis one is weird because Ryder's a current WWE performer, but it's not like he's on TV very often. If you go back to how he was booked in late 2011 when he won the US Title he was getting some of the biggest reactions in WWE. It's not like WWE wanted to push him that hard either. They did it because the fans really believed in him While the Ryder gimmick might have been annoying to some, it was always something that I enjoyed simply because we know that Ryder was a lifelong wrestling fan that was living his dream. He put everything into creating the "Long Island Iced Z" persona, the youtube show that he had that was very successful when it first started and he built a connection with the fans. There were shows that I went to where Ryder was getting one of the biggest pops of the night when he was out there losing in five minutes. It's because he knew how to relate to people. Ryder may not be cool to some fans online because he comes off as annoying, but if you're a fan of wrestling then you can appreciate a guy who puts his heart into it the way Ryder did. He may never get a chance again, which is a damn shame.
5. Prime Time Players
wwe.comThe team of Darren Young and Titus O'Neil should have had a tag team title run before they broke up. It really sucked when O'Neil turned on Young earlier this year, then didn't really do much of anything after. What was the point of it? These two had something as a team that sometimes teams don't always have: chemistry. It's not like they were just thrown together either. Both guys spent time in NXT figuring things out, then they were paired up and it turned out that they really worked well as a team. They were also a team that had a connection with the audience. The "millions of dollars" dance they did was so basic that anybody could do it. Kids in the crowd would do it with them. Even old people did it too. That was their connection as a face team. As heels they were able to get over too. It always seemed like online fans didn't like them or didn't think of them as a team that should have had a bigger role. I felt different. If they were together in WWE right now they would be very serviceable as a face or heel team. Young has a knee injury that is keeping him out of the ring for months, but when he comes back I think WWE should put them back together. It's better than keeping them apart.
4. "Dashing" Cody Rhodes
WWE.comA heel character that tells you that they are better than you, the viewer, isn't a new idea. It's been done in wrestling for dozens of years. That kind of gimmick is never going away. However, when a guy is so full of himself that he wants to give you grooming tips like how to trim nose hair or wash your face then that's taking it to the next level. Those Cody Rhodes "dashing" instructional videos were always hilarious to me. It made you want to punch the guy in the face, which is exactly the kind of reaction a heel should be getting. He still had to develop as a wrestler, but in terms of his persona it worked really well. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oxr2eGdn4Kk It's not like guys want to be told how to look. I have a beard, I don't really care what my hair looks like most of the time and I don't know a damn thing about plucking my eyebrows, but I'm entertained by it when a wrestler is trying to piss people off by talking about those things. He did the "dashing" gimmick for the second half of 2010 and he got into a feud with Rey Mysterio in 2011, but after Rhodes legitimately broke his nose they decided to turn him into more of a freak character that wore a mask. He felt he was no longer dashing anymore. That gimmick sucked. It was a total mistake to dump the "dashing" persona the way they did.
3. R-Truth As A Heel
wikipediaThe heel turn of R-Truth came out of nowhere in 2011. It happened after WrestleMania 27 that year. When thinking about the turn, it was hard to know if he'd be successful at it since he was a babyface for so long in WWE. They just had him snap on John Morrison on the loss. Then he drank some water during a match. He even started smoking. It was just so random, but it was such a fresh side of him. Where WWE took a misstep with him was when they had him challenge John Cena for the WWE Title in the main event of Capitol Punishment. It was too soon. They needed some heels for Cena to beat, but it was too soon in his turn for fans to really buy into him as a credible heel. Later in the year, he was in a featured role again along with Miz and that story actually worked well. Then Truth got suspended due to a Wellness Policy violation, so when he came back he was a face. That was a mistake. He's the perfect example of a guy that has been boring as a face for so long, yet he's still in that same role even though he did a much better job as a heel. Maybe WWE feels like they need him as a veteran face to put over the younger heels, but they're wasting his talent by keeping him as the "what's up" guy that rarely does anything of significance anymore. Plus, the whole "Little Jimmy" thing was much more entertaining when he was a crazy heel doing instead of a babyface that was marketable to kids.
2. Drew McIntyre As "The Chosen One"
WWE.comDrew McIntyre should have been a World Heavyweight Champion in WWE. Bold statement? Maybe, but I really think that his "Chosen One" character was built to be a champion and they absolutely dropped the ball with him. It's not like the character was that deep. The reason it really stood out was because WWE Chairman Vince McMahon went on Smackdown and said this guy was going to be a World Champion. They should have followed through on it instead of waiting. Somewhere along the way, WWE lost faith him. Part of it was because of an incident with his wife at the time (WWE diva Tiffany) when they got in an altercation in public that WWE felt embarrassed. People do stupid things once in a while. It shouldn't have killed his push when he was a guy in his mid-20s with a good look that could have been a future main eventer. He spent nearly three years doing nothing or being a part of that 3MB comedy group. It was a complete waste. What's interesting about the "Chosen One" gimmick is that WWE seems to have brought back in a way by making Seth Rollins as a guy handpicked by Triple H. He's young, he's a star on the rise and if everything goes right he'll be a top guy. Rollins is a better overall talent than McIntyre in my opinion, but if they really got behind McIntyre three years ago he would already be in a top position today.
1. "American Badass" Undertaker
WWE.comWhen The Undertaker became more of a "normal guy" as the American Badass that rode a motorcycle to the ring and dressed like a regular person he was amazing. There are loyal Undertaker fans that hate it, though. Apparently WWE hates it too. When they post top 10 Undertaker moments on Youtube they completely ignore that entire period where he was the American Badass biker dude. Former WWE employees have told stories about how Vince McMahon gets mad if anybody brings up that version of the character up because for whatever reason he didn't like it. It's like we're supposed to forget what Undertaker did from mid 2000 to late 2003? That's not easy to do. Plus, it was a great character. If you look at his run when he was in that role there were so many great feuds that he had: Ric Flair, Brock Lesnar, the ladder match with Jeff Hardy and that amazing moment in the Royal Rumble with Maven. As a heel he was unlike anybody in wrestling. It was like watching a 1980s old school heel that was going to have a 30 minute brawl full of blood. It was nothing like the emotionless traditional Undertaker gimmick. Since the character was only around for about three years of The Undertaker's 20+ year career it didn't last too long, but its greatness needs to be remembered. He really did a fantastic job with it and it's a character that I miss whether it's popular to say that or not. A lot of Undertaker fans only want to see him as the Deadman. Anything else is bad. That shouldn't be the case, though. He was terrific in this role.