10 WWE Legends Who Should Have Retired At WrestleMania

It is obvious that certain wrestling legends should have ended their career at WrestleMania.

The Undertaker WrestleMania
WWE

It is easy to look back in hindsight and plan the perfect pro wrestling retirement when, in reality, the cruel nature of the sport often doesn't let performers choose how they bow out.

For many WWE stars, the final destination will be WrestleMania so they can end their storied careers on top of their game at the 'Grandest Stage of Them All.'

Whilst many wrestlers won't be given the opportunity to go out at the 'Show of Shows,' there have been matches that should have clearly marked the end of certain careers. There have been various bouts, some even with a retirement stipulation attached, that should have been used as a chance for legendary figures to retire from in-ring action for good.

Sadly, many of these icons opted not to end their wrestling careers under the right circumstances and proceeded to have more matches after the right opportunity to retire arose.

In many cases, delaying their retirements didn't harm their legacy too much, but it attached an unnecessary segment at the end of what was an otherwise industry-shaping run in wrestling.

10. Shane McMahon (vs The Undertaker) WrestleMania 32

WWE WrestleMania Shane McMahon
WWE.com

When Shane McMahon made his return to WWE in 2016 fans were actually excited about it, even though it was under the most bizarre circumstances in a match against The Undertaker. His reasons for returning centered around a lockbox that would expose Vince (yikes), so Shane wanted to take control of Raw after seven years away. It was all very contrived nonsense in order to give WrestleMania 32 another match with stars involved.

'The Deadman' was selected as the opponent of the prodigal son with it also being a Hell in a Cell match that if Shane won, would see him seize control of Raw. Vince claimed that if Taker lost he would no longer be allowed to compete at WrestleMania, a threat that may have actually been a good idea had it panned out.

The match itself was fairly bad and slightly outrageous in parts, with Shane flinging himself off the top of the cell in a memorable moment. The 'Boy Wonder' should have probably stopped wrestling for good after losing this match, as fans still felt generally positive about him afterward. That was until he insisted on being a profiled performer in WWE for the next few years, quickly becoming a loathed figure by much of the fanbase.


9. Kane (and The New Age Outlaws Vs The Shield) WrestleMania XXX

Kane WrestleMania 38
WWE

Kane had a very interesting WWE career, not necessarily because it was good or filled with memorable moments but he did manage to stay around for two decades as a distinctly upper-mid-card monster. He won multiple world titles, feuded on and off with his storyline brother The Undertaker, and seemed like a loyal servant to the company in any role he was given.

'The Devil's Favourite Demon' was also a horrendously boring wrestler at times, which is why he was at his best as part of a tandem. He won tag team gold with a number of different partners, including Undertaker, Big Show, The Hurricane, X-Pac, Mankind, and Daniel Bryan as part of Team Hell No.

This is why it would have made sense for Kane to retire in a tag team match opposite the emerging force that was The Shield, as the 'Big Red Machine' could have put over the faction even more. It would have been quite fitting to see him hang up his boots on the same night his former tag partner won the world title and his brother finally lost at WrestleMania.

More importantly, it would have saved the wrestling world from corporate Kane.


8. Mick Foley (vs Edge) WrestleMania 22

Edge Mick Foley Thumbtacks
WWE

There is an argument to be made that Mick Foley should have retired at the turn of the century when he lost a retirement Hell in a Cell match against Triple H at No Way Out 2000. The seminal feud would have been a great way for Cactus Jack to go out on his barbed wire-wrapped sword, but he returned a few weeks later to compete in the main event of WrestleMania 2000.

Afterward, Foley did actually retire for four years before coming back to team with The Rock against Evolution, which would lead to a star-making match for the 'Legend Killer' Randy Orton at Backlash 2004. He would then appear sporadically for WWE over the next few years, but it was clear the 'Hardcore Legend' was physically declining beyond the point of being able to wrestle

Foley's hardcore bout against the 'Rated-R Superstar' Edge at WrestleMania 22 really should have been his last match, as he managed to put in a great performance despite the clear physical struggles he was enduring. The hardcore bout was the last great performance from one of WWE's most important stars, which is worth remembering him for instead of his TNA run.


7. Mr. McMahon (vs Shane McMahon) WrestleMania X-Seven

Vince McMahon Shane McMahon
WWE.com

As recent news has shown, Vince McMahon has absolutely no idea when to leave well enough alone, which makes it unsurprising that he didn't know when to stop performing as an in-ring talent for his own promotion. The biggest heel in wrestling history should have ended his in-ring career at arguably the greatest show ever, as his character had peaked and no longer needed to get physical with other performers.

WrestleMania X-Seven acted as a series finale of sorts for the Attitude Era, which would have been a fitting place to retire the Mr. McMahon character after receiving the comeuppance he deserved from his own family. Instead, Vince would proceed to perform on and off for the next two decades, including a fight with god, an ECW Championship reign, and an awful, silly match against Pat McAffe this past year.

Now that he is back in control of WWE you can not put it past the deranged billionaire that he may get back into the ring, as the 77-year-old has no self-awareness or creative sense anymore.


6. Kurt Angle (and Ronda Rousey Vs Triple H And Stephanie McMahon) WrestleMania 34

Kurt Angle WrestleMania 35 (Placeholder)
WWE.com

Kurt Angle's final run in WWE was marred by the all-time great in-ring performer not being anywhere near his best, and it was clear he had to call it a day as an active wrestler. The Olympic Gold Medalist eventually retired in 2019 when he lost to Baron Corbin at WrestleMania 35, but it was hardly the send-off the legend deserved.

When the five-time world champion returned in 2017 he was not being exposed so much in singles action, with a cameo as an impromptu member of The Shield being a particularly memorable highlight. This would extend to a mixed tag showcase alongside the debuting Ronda Rousey against Triple H and Stephanie McMahon at WrestleMania 34, which was a surprise hit that should have ended his career.

The match would lead to a stellar year-long run for the former UFC Champion, who drew comparisons to Angle for how quickly she adapted to the world of professional wrestling. If WWE could book his retirement again it would definitely have been a more fitting way to end the Hall of Famer's illustrious career.


5. Hulk Hogan (vs The Rock) WrestleMania X8

The Rock Hulk Hogan WrestleMania X8
WWE.com

Hulk Hogan had ample time and opportunities to retire, but the mustachioed superstar has been known to be quite an egotistical and controlling person. This is probably why he only ended his in-ring career in 2012, a decade later than he should have done.

'The Hulkster's' return to WWE in 2002 should have concluded his career, after finding a second life as part of the NWO in WCW throughout the late 90s. This comeback lead to a showdown with the most charismatic man in wrestling and Attitude Era megastar, The Rock at WrestleMania 18.

The Rock versus 'Hollywood' Hulk Hogan is perhaps the most anticipated wrestling match of all time as the two biggest stars of their generation faced off in what should have been the latter's last match. Instead, Hogan would win the WWE Championship a month later and appeared on and off in the company for the next few years, continuing to politic and cause drama backstage.

Terry Bollea is one of the most controversial figures in wrestling history, which in no small part contributed to the lackluster end to his undoubtedly important career.


4. Triple H (vs Roman Reigns) WrestleMania 32

WWE Survivor Series 2017 Triple H
WWE.com

Unfortunately, 'The Game' was unable to choose how to end his storied in-ring career, as his severe health problems in 2021 meant that he had to promptly retire. Triple H maybe would have thought he had a few more opportunities to go out on his own terms, with his last official match being in 2019 for a WWE house show in Japan.

He at least got to face off against his former Evolution stablemates Batista and Randy Orton in the same year, which was somewhat nostalgic even if the matches went on for way too long. If given the opportunity to choose again, it is fair to say that the 'Cerebral Assasin' had a number of different matches that could have acted as his final one.

Despite it not being his best match, the significance of his WrestleMania 32 match against Roman Reigns would have been a worthy finishing point for the 'King of Kings.' HHH could have gone out on top of his game, in the main event of WrestleMania as WWE Champion no less, putting over the next generation's biggest star (even if fans weren't ready to embrace Roman just yet).


3. The Rock (vs John Cena) WrestleMania 28

John Cena The Rock
WWE

From Hulk Hogan to John Cena, The Rock managed to have era-defining matches with the biggest stars that preceded and came after him in WWE. Dwayne Johnson had long become a Hollywood A-Lister throughout his seven years away from the ring when he returned in 2011 to set up a 'Once in a Lifetime' matchup against Cena at WrestleMania 28.

The two superstars had a passable matchup that just about managed to live up to the hype of the build, but the fact that Rock won should have raised alarm bells for fans, as there was more to come. At WrestleMania 29, the pair proceeded to have a much worse second match for the WWE title, where Cena got his win back and the 'People's Champion' seemingly retired for good.

The 'Once in a Lifetime' bout should have stuck to its word as their second match a year later was such a diminished return that it was not worth having, or stripping CM Punk of the WWE title for. Hopefully, if The Rock does return for one more match it can leave a better mark than his previous two-match series with John Cena couldn't.


2. Goldberg (vs Brock Lesnar) WrestleMania 33

Goldberg WWE 2003
WWE

Goldberg's comeback run from Survivor Series 2016 to WrestleMania 33 was stellar, which is a shame because it could have served as a great retirement tour if he had called it a day there. Instead, Bill would return numerous times over the past few years in matches that continued to diminish the WCW legend's star power and legacy.

The shocking squash victory over Brock Lesnar in his return match at Survivor Series was tremendous and legitimately one of the most exciting booking decisions WWE made over the past decade. Brock was on top of the wrestling world after ending Undertaker's streak, winning numerous world titles and being the perennial final boss in WWE for all their rising stars.

A rematch at WrestleMania 33 was set for the Universal Championship, where the two behemoths managed to put on an explosive match that far eclipsed their ill-fated WrestleMania 20 bout. It would have been the perfect ending for Goldberg had he not returned for various matches against the likes of Roman Reigns, Bobby Lashley, and The Undertaker, which were all diminished returns and in some cases dangerously worked.


1. The Undertaker (vs Brock Lesnar) WrestleMania 30

WrestleMania 28 Undertaker Mohawk
WWE.com

Undertaker's WrestleMania streak was one of the most important storylines going into the event every year, particularly in the late 2000s when he evolved into an all-time great in-ring performer. His legendary matches against the likes of Edge, Shawn Michaels, Triple H, and CM Punk made the streak seem like the most important thing in all of wrestling.

This is why The Undertaker should have retired as soon as it was over, even though the match against Brock Lesnar when he finally did lose at WrestleMania 30 wasn't his best. 'The Deadman' was knocked loopy early on in the match which made what should have been an all-time great contest against the 'Beast Incarnate,' a bit of a letdown.

What came after was even more disappointing though, as Taker clearly wanted to make good on the match by continuing to perform for years afterward. It was clear that the legend was not in the same place physically or mentally to be able to put in the same performance that he was clearly chasing from his previous matches.

At least 'The Phenom' did finally call it a day after defeating AJ Styles in a Boneyard match during the pandemic, which was enough to finally let The Undertaker character rest in peace.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

I like wrestling a lot and writing about it is fun. Thanks for reading!