10 WWE Matches That Were Too Epic To Fail (Yet Somehow Still Did)
But, but, but, it was a 'dream match'...
Despite it now feeling like WWE actively go out of their way to set us up for a fall, it is always worth remembering that this is the same company which has produced some of the most important and iconic moments in all of wrestling history.
Through countless eras Vince McMahon's empire has found a way to create magic and has delivered matches that will undoubtedly be studied by the next generation of wrestling fanatics.
Yet, for every jaw-dropping showstopper there will always be a highly anticipated dud waiting right around the corner and this is why it can be a frustrating old life for a fan of the consistently inconsistent world of WWE.
A potentially legendary encounter can fall short of that coveted status for a number of reasons. Stars fluffing their lines on the night, the wrestlers on show not being given the time their feud deserved or even expectations being set unfairly high for an eventual blow-off have all led to fans ultimately feeling disappointed once the bout reached its conclusion.
These ten super fights should've gone down in WWE history as legitimate classics, but they instead just left us wondering how it could all go so wrong.
10. Dean Ambrose Vs Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania 32)
Contrary to popular belief, Brock Lesnar actually quite enjoys being a pro wrestler and he's one of the very best to ever do it on his day.
What often tends to be the problem, however, is getting Lesnar motivated enough to put on the sort of performance we've seen against stars like AJ Styles, Daniel Bryan and The Undertaker since his return in 2012.
When he's not into something, it bloody shows and it did on the night of WrestleMania 32 during his No Holds Barred Street Fight Vs Dean Ambrose.
Ambrose had spent weeks teasing the use of a variety of vicious weapons in their upcoming match - from a barbed wire baseball bat to an actual chainsaw - so fans were rightfully excited about the level of carnage they would surely see go down inside of AT&T Stadium.
Yet, the match never really took off and Ambrose later admitted to 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin that 'Artistically, Brock didn’t want to do anything, if we’re going to be perfectly honest.'
This had the makings to be one of the most creative brawls in 'Mania history, involving two of the company's most over stars at that time. Sadly, all we got was a sh*t ton of suplexes and a severe lack of any real barbed wire or chainsaw chaos.
9. Roman Reigns Vs Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania 34)
Though fans weren't exactly clamouring for a Roman Reigns Universal title run in 2018, the idea of part-time want-away Brock Lesnar holding onto the gold for another six months wasn't an appealing one and it didn't make sense for the company to keep the belt on a star who had his eyes on a UFC return.
So, it was pretty much a forgone conclusion that Lesnar would be conquered on the night and company man Reigns would be walking out as a full time Champion. Which was definitely the lesser of two wrestling evils.
If the pair put on a clash even half as compelling as their last 'Mania battle three years earlier, perhaps Reigns wouldn't end the night celebrating in a sea of boos for a change, too.
Pulling the rug out from under the WWE Universe's feet at the last second, Vince McMahon decided that Lesnar would hold onto his belt for a few more months after 'The Beast Incarnate' chose to sign on for a bit longer.
That probably wouldn't have been too difficult a pill to swallow had the pair's bout not purely consisted of Lesnar's usual array of suplexes and a mind-numbing amount of F-5's.
Reigns eventually wrestled the belt away from Lesnar at that year's SummerSlam in a much more entertaining smash-and-grab match-up. However, their potentially excellent 'Mania 34 main event only succeeded in sending fans home unhappy for the third year in a row.
8. Chris Jericho Vs Edge (WrestleMania XXVI)
The mix of ingredients involved in this wrestling recipe should have guaranteed a WrestleMania main event for the ages.
Chris Jericho was in the midst of arguably his greatest ever run as the despised, cold, suit wearing d*ck iteration of his character and Edge had just returned from a career threatening Achilles tendon injury, winning the 2010 Royal Rumble in his first appearance for over six months.
Jericho had also been mocking his former tag partner on television whilst he was away from the ring and as soon as the 'Rated 'R' Superstar' made his triumphant Rumble winning return it was obvious that he'd want to get his own back on 'Y2J' at 'Mania XXVI.
Yet, even though everything about this programme pointed to another instant classic for the two veteran superstars, when it came down to it their 'Mania collision was just missing something.
It was technically well put together and the story was understandable enough, yet Edge didn't really click with the crowd as a beloved babyface and the pair couldn't quite deliver the drama soaked epic many had hoped for when this grudge match was finally booked into existence.
This wasn't the only highly anticipated super showdown to fall flat on this night, though...
7. Finn Balor Vs Shinsuke Nakamura (Extreme Rules 2019)
The Intercontinental Championship wasn't in the best of positions in 2019.
Just a year earlier the belt was being fought over in the fantastic opening match of 'Mania 34 and stars like Finn Balor, Seth Rollins, The Miz and Dolph Ziggler had been putting it all on the line to prove they were the rightful owner of the storied title.
Yet, here we were in the wake of 'Mania 35 and Balor's 'Demon King' had just done away with Bobby Lashley and Andrade, but the belt now felt about as important as a pre-show match. Which is coincidently where Balor's last IC title defence took place.
That being said, even though it had been banished to the kick-off that didn't dampen our spirits, for we were about to see Finn Balor and Shinsuke Nakamura battle on a WWE PPV for the first time ever at that year's Extreme Rules.
Sadly, they hit all the familiar Balor and Nakamura beats you'd expect, but this ultimately ended up feeling like a 'lite' version of their epic NXT battle a few years earlier.
Nakamura won the contest and then embarked on an even more disappointing 201 day reign as IC Champion.
6. Eddie Guerrero Vs Rey Mysterio (WrestleMania 21)
You'll notice that a lot of the entries on this list all took place at the Showcase of the Immortals. This is probably down to the fact that it's the biggest show of the year, meaning that any match which finds its way onto that card needs to feel like a contest worthy of the legendary stage.
Eddie Guerrero Vs Rey Mysterio looked like exactly the sort of match which was made for 'Mania. Two of the very best performers of their generation - also the WWE Tag Team Champions at the time - battling to find out who was the better wrestler of the two.
Yet, what should have been a high flying, technical masterpiece, eventually devolved into a good-but-not-great encounter between a pair of future Hall of Famers.
Mysterio's mask malfunction didn't help things, but it still just felt like the duo were trying too hard to push for the sort of match they were more than capable of pulling off in their sleep.
Again, it was by no means an awful showcase of what the real life pals had in their lockers, it just wasn't the epic meeting we were waiting for. Thankfully the pair went on to produce one of the most memorable feuds in WWE history in the wake of this underwhelming 'Mania opener.
5. Seth Rollins Vs Dean Ambrose (TLC: Tables, Ladders And Chairs, 2018)
Back in 2018, when Dean Ambrose turned his back on Seth Rollins on the very same night his other Shield brethren Roman Reigns announced to the world he would be leaving WWE to battle leukemia (and the pair had just won the Raw Tag Team titles) the crowd response was understandably nuclear.
Ambrose quickly became public enemy number one in the company and the WWE Universe couldn't wait for Rollins to get his hands on the despicable 'Lunatic'.
However, by the time the pair eventually came to blows over the Intercontinental title at the TLC PPV nearly two months later much of that initial heat had unfortunately died off - thanks to a series of gas mask and inoculation segments. But, surely these two old pals, turned enemies, turned pals again, turned enemies again would deliver a show stealing match and make us care about what should have been the hottest feud in the company.
It wasn't to be and the crowd barely even reacted to this slow paced slog. When Ambrose won the belt, nobody really cared.
In truth, the match had been killed off long before the bell even rang, as WWE had taken a programme which had the potential to be one of the most compelling in modern times and turned it into a lifeless shell of a blood feud. Thankfully, it was mercifully put out of its misery shortly after this damp squib.
4. John Cena Vs Batista (WrestleMania XXVI)
Back to WrestleMania XXVI we go and this time we find ourselves faced with a main event match five years in the making.
John Cena and Batista had both taken the company by storm after winning their first world titles at WrestleMania 21.
They'd both walked into 'Manias as World Champions, beaten a whole host of legends and been the top stars in the company ever since they first cemented themselves as main eventers.
They'd even met once before at SummerSlam 2008 in a match which resulted in a herniated disc and a loss for Cena on the night.
Yet, that was seen as more of an exhibition match, whereas their titanic 'Mania XXVI battle was shaping up to be a bit more personal.
Batista was p*ssed off with the fact that Cena had been pushed as 'the name and face of the WWE' and not him. He'd attacked Cena at every turn - even winning the WWE title from him minutes after Cena had defended it in the Elimination Chamber - and the narrative going into their WWE title showdown centred around Cena not being able to beat Big Dave.
Cena won because of course he did, but a 'Mania match which had been fantasised about for years just didn't live up to the billing in-between the ropes.
This should have been a modern day Rock Vs Austin, but it felt more like two pieces of meat being smashed together for 13 minutes.
3. Daniel Bryan Vs The Miz (Super Showdown, 2018)
When The Miz exploded at Daniel Bryan on an episode of Talking Smack in 2016 any fan would have paid a months rent to see Bryan drag his rival into the middle of a ring and settle their differences there and then.
Yet, Bryan was retired and any hope of him performing in a WWE ring again seemed to be dead and buried.
Or so we thought.
Bryan shocked the world and announced that he'd been medically cleared for action in 2018. This was all well and good, but what was even better was the realisation that Bryan would finally be able to put Miz in his place once and for all.
The pair eventually began feuding in the lead up to SummerSlam. Their eventual match at the 'Biggest Party of the Summer' was good enough, but we knew that there was still more left in both star's tanks.
A decent mixed tag at Hell in a Cell involving the pair's better halves followed, but we would finally get another one-on-one encounter between the pair at Super Showdown in Australia - of all places - with the winner earning a WWE title opportunity.
The match ended in two-and-a-half minutes and that was that.
No epic conclusion.
No furthering of a story which had been captivating fans of SmackDown Live for over two years.
Miz wasn't the only one who felt cheated on the night, as Bryan's small package finished off a match (and feud) which could have been so much more than what we got.
2. Triple H Vs Sting (WrestleMania 31)
Only one former WCW star had managed to stay away from Vince McMahon's company for the duration of their legendary career and 'The Icon' Sting seemed like he was more than happy to go down in history as a WCW/TNA legend.
That was until he showed up at Survivor Series 2014 and attacked 'The Authority's Triple H, kick starting both his WWE career and a feud with the 'King of King's all in one night.
Without missing a beat, McMahon quickly booked this as the WCW Vs WWE war fans had wanted to see over a decade ago and you couldn't help but get caught up in the idea.
We were going to see two of the biggest stars from both legendary company's face-off at WrestleMania, with Sting making his WWE singles debut at the Show of Shows.
However, once it finally got to the match itself fans very quickly realised that we weren't going to get Triple H and Sting from the good ol' days. Instead, we were put through your typical bells and whistles veteran 'Mania match, with DX and the nWo both popping up to add to the 'drama'.
To top things off, Sting lost his WWE debut and shook hands with his conqueror after their greatest hits concert had drawn to a close, reducing a dream match to nothing more than one last WWE slap to the face of WCW.
1. AJ Styles Vs Shinsuke Nakamura (WrestleMania 34)
Touted as a 'dream match' come to life, WWE Champion AJ Styles Vs men's Royal Rumble winner Shinsuke Nakamura on the Grandest Stage of Them All was shaping up to be the greatest rematch in modern history.
The pair put on an absolute clinic in the Tokyo Dome at Wrestle Kingdom 10 two years earlier and now they'd finally have the chance to bring their titanic rivalry to WrestleMania 34 inside of the Superdome in New Orleans.
Yet, despite much of their programme being built around who was the better performer in the ring, when it came to the match itself we didn't really get to see either man let rip like we knew they could.
Instead we got a serviceable world title match which was overshadowed by a shock Nakamura heel turn post Styles' successful defence.
Styles Vs Nakamura for the first time on a WWE stage should have been a larger than life spectacle and reminded us just what calibre of talent the company possessed in their ranks. But, once 'Mania 34 was firmly in the rear view mirror, it became yet another missed opportunity to deliver a match that could have been truly immortalised at the Show of Shows.