10 WWE Midcard Matches That Stole Major PPVs

Follow THAT!

Sometimes the term "main event" is nothing more than a phrase and a time slot. After all, it's really up to the performers each night to decide which match on the card is going to be considered the true high point. Over the years, the WWE creative team has consistently proven that they have an eye for choosing the right match to highlight as the proclaimed main event. But every once in a while, superstars on the undercard go out and prove them wrong. It's these matches that diehard fans cherish the most, because they're the most unexpected delights. Some of the following non-main events have saved otherwise terrible shows. Others were simply the high point of an already exceptional lineup, going above and beyond to steal the spotlight. In any case, sometimes it's important to rewrite history. And that's what we're going to do here. Let's go back and call out the real main events that didn't get initially get that billing.


10. CM Punk Vs. Daniel Bryan - Over The Limit 2012

This inclusion is just a little bit of a cheat, as the main event for Over the Limit between John Cena and John Laurinaitis was a total joke, but even on an otherwise exciting PPV, it was Punk and Bryan who stood head and shoulders above the other matches. This was the type of methodical (dare I say traditional) match that we rarely get these days, with Punk and Bryan looking like vintage Bret Hart and Mr. Perfect out there. The crowd was incredibly vocal from the opening bell, eating up every near-submission and kick to the face. And this was one of the few instances where a controversial, mildly confusing ending actually worked. If the WWE creative team really knew and loved its audience, they would have figured out a way to get these two back into another feud before their tenures with the company ended.

9. Chris Jericho Vs. Chris Benoit - Royal Rumble 2001

At the height of their careers, Chris Benoit and Chris Jericho were two of the best all-around wrestlers the industry had ever seen. Either of them could get into the ring with the likes of Mark Henry and put on a watchable match. That's talent. So pitting them against each other seems like a natural recipe for success in hindsight and, luckily, WWE remembered how well these guys worked together in WCW and decided to toss them into the ring together with a ladder. Once the Walls of Jericho was locked in on Benoit at the top of the ladder, it was going to be a herculean task trying to one-up this performance. And let's be honest, even the best Royal Rumble isn't going to hold up as well to repeat viewings as Jericho vs. Benoit.

8. Edge Vs. Mick Foley - WrestleMania 22

True, Mick was no stranger to stealing the show. But this is the first time he'd ever upstaged the main event at a WrestleMania. And he managed to steal it even with Mr. WrestleMania, Shawn Michaels on the card. (Though, to be fair, HBK was slightly handicapped in his match by having to carry Vince McMahon.) Even in a packed card at WrestleMania 22, Foley and Edge put together what should be considered a Top 10 match in both of their career retrospectives, which is really saying something considering they have more than 40 years of matches between them. Of course, the most enduring image of the entire night was Edge spearing Foley through a table that had been set ablaze by Lita. The spot set an already bloodied and thumbtacked Edge up for the win and further cemented Foley's legacy as the undisputed King of Hardcore.

7. Razor Ramon Vs. Shawn Michaels - WrestleMania X

Although Bret vs. Owen Hart came pretty damn close to topping this, ultimately the sheer innovation and storytelling excellence edged this one over. Perhaps most impressively, this ladder match wasn't just a spot fest. Instead, the ladder was used merely as a tool to tell the story (and for Michaels to find a new launching pad for his aerial attacks). The novelty of the stipulation was guaranteed to make the match interesting, but it was the dynamics between Scott Hall and Shawn Michaels that pushed it into its rightfully iconic place in the WrestleMania canon. This match was delivered at exactly the right time, too, since the WWE was still in a state of influx. 1994 was the first year WrestleMania didn't feature Hulk Hogan as the company's face, and so the company needed a default star. And while Bret Hart did his best to make the main event against Yokozuna memorable, there simply wasn't much to work with. In a lot of fans' minds, Razor vs. Shawn basically saved WrestleMania.

6. Shawn Michaels Vs. Ric Flair - WrestleMania XXIV

It should be no surprise that Shawn Michaels has ended up on this list multiple times (and we're not done with him yet). HBK earned the nickname Mr. WrestleMania for good reason, somehow managing to one-up himself every time he appeared in the event. Though the majority of matches featured at WrestleMania XXIV were, to put it gently, uninspired, it will always be remembered fondly if only because it was the closing chapter in Ric Flair's astounding career. And there couldn't have been a better choice of guys to send him out the door than Michaels. In a moment that's guaranteed to bring on the tears no matter how many times you watch it, Michaels reluctantly sets up the battered and beaten Flair for the Sweet Chin Music. The look on Michael's face as he primed himself to deliver the career-ending finisher said it all, but it was the heartfelt "I'm sorry, I love you" that showed just how much respect he had for The Nature Boy. The match itself was beautifully executed (as if these guys could ever bring anything but total magic into the ring), but it was the moments immediately following the pinfall that made this so historic, as Flair received a well-deserved standing ovation as he tearfully exited the ring.

5. Bret Hart Vs. Steve Austin - WrestleMania 13

Some have called this moment the official launching point of the Attitude Era, since this is the match that really kickstarted Stone Cold's career, but even if some would argue that point, there's no debating that Hart vs. Austin usurped everything else on the card by a mile. It would normally be ridiculous to suggest someone on the undercard stole the show away from an Undertaker main event...until you remember that he and Psycho Sid basically hugged it out for two full minutes in the middle of their match. Passing of the torch insinuations aside, this match showed the darker side of Bret Hart, allowing him to slug it out more than he would typically do, and the end results are brutal. (In the best way, of course.) It was a gutsy display by both performers. It also showed the resiliency and tenacity of Stone Cold in a big way. With his face spewing blood, Bret locks in the Sharpshooter, and spends the next 90 seconds trying to get Stone Cold to tap out. He struggles valiantly, thrashing and screaming, all the while creating one of the most iconic images in WrestleMania history. The storytelling in this match was brilliant, but the execution was even better.

4. Edge & Christian Vs. The Hardy Boyz Vs. The Dudley Boyz - WrestleMania 2000

The Hardys and Edge & Christian had already stolen the show a year earlier in a ladder match at No Mercy 1999, but it was this performance (alongside the Dudleys) that truly proved their legitimacy as show stealers. And this was a Pay-Per-View that pulled out all the stops, with Chris Jericho, Chris Benoit, and Kurt Angle putting on a wrestling clinic for the Intercontinental and European Championship. It also had a 4-way match for the WWE Championship with The Rock, Triple H, Mick Foley, and Big Show that looked great on paper, but panned out pretty poorly. Although the aforementioned No Mercy was a little tighter and better crafted, this triple ladder match featured a whole parade of high-risk spots (highlighted by Jeff Hardy's ridiculous Swanton Bomb from the top of a 20-foot ladder) and had a more memorable finish. Bodies were sacrificed and boundaries pushed to lengths that WWE fans had never before witnessed, turning the 3-way tag battle into one of the most legendary the company ever had.

3. The Undertaker Vs. Mankind - King Of The Ring 1998

So much has been written about this match that it's now taken on a legacy entirely separate from its two performers. But it should be romanticized because, at the end of the day, have you ever seen anything so insanely risky on WWE programming? The first high-risk stunt, with Foley getting chucked off the top of the cell like a rag doll (with an odd sense of what constitutes business casual) was a moment no one would dare recreate today. It was shocking. It was unexpected. It was... quite beautiful, in a strange way. It also featured one of the most recognizable calls in the history of commentary, with J.R.'s assertion that he'd been "broken in half" validating the real concern felt by fans and talent alike. But it was the image of Mick Foley storming back down the ramp after paramedics had attempted to take him to the back for legitimate medical examination that made this one truly legendary. The second big spot, a deadly chokeslam through the top of the cage (which was not supposed to break) made it absurd to think the main event between Kane and Stone Cold was going to be able to follow that.

2. Ricky Steamboat Vs. Randy Savage - WrestleMania III

This match for the Intercontinental Title wasn't just a show stealer, it's one of the most classic performances in WrestleMania history. And while most fans will always remember WrestleMania III as the event that turned Hulk Hogan into a modern-day Hercules, picking up Andre the Giant and slamming him to the mat, they likely forget just how awful that match was otherwise. No, Steamboat vs. Savage is the true defining moment of that event, and it's unfortunate that it's so frequently overshadowed by an exceptionally mediocre climax. For fifteen minutes, they executed a picture-perfect match from start to finish, with absolutely zero filler or flab. Every moment of that performance was meaningful and necessary, and it set a template that's still lovingly emulated by some of today's best superstars. According to various sources (including Ric Flair), Savage's meticulous planning ahead of the match irritated the hell out of Steamboat, who much preferred to "call it in the ring" rather than map out every detail. In the end, though, Savage's method of excessive preparation clearly worked out for the best, as the match remains an intense, gripping exhibition to watch decades later.

1. The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels - WrestleMania XXV

It was The Streak vs. Mr. WrestleMania. Two of the biggest icons in the business going head to head in what was being called an instant classic before the match was even finished. With all due respect to Randy Orton and Triple H, who put on an admirable display in the actual main event, there was no way Orton vs. Hunter (for the 30th time) was going to outshine Undertaker vs. Michaels. Casual fans and diehards can agree that nothing like this WrestleMania matchup had been seen before, nor is it likely to be topped anytime soon. Both performers were in their mid-40s when they met at WrestleMania XXV, but they somehow managed to look like a pair of seasoned twenty-somethings going at it that night. It had all the trappings of a solid Undertaker "Streak Match," including several reversed finishers and near-falls, but it was Michaels' dramatic sells coupled with both performers caution-to-the-wind style that really made this such a captivating bout. The next year, WWE would learn from its mistake and make Taker vs. HBK the main event at WrestleMania XXVI. It turned out as a solid, sentimental showing. (It was Michaels' last match.) But it was simply impossible for them to go out and improve on what they'd done previously. After all...how do you top perfection?

Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.