10 WWE NXT Superstars You Totally Don't Remember

Good luck remembering any of these WWE developmental projects from NXT's past!

Memo Montenegro WWE NXT
WWE

NXT replaced FCW as WWE's chief in-house developmental project in 2012. At first, fans were confused. NXT had already existed as a reality show-esque paint job for Tough Enough since 2010, so...what was there to be excited about? That'd change once Triple H got his mitts on the third brand and turned it into one of the hottest products in pro wrestling.

At one point, NXT was vastly superior to Raw or SmackDown in terms of blending simple storytelling with satisfying in-ring action. It was early AEW before that was even a thing, in some respects, and people lapped it up. Names like Sasha Banks, Bayley, Seth Rollins, Sami Zayn, Kevin Owens, Johnny Gargano, Tommaso Ciampa and more earned their stripes by delivering what a fanbase hungry for alternatives needed.

They went on to become stars on the main roster, but how about those who didn't? You'll be surprised by some of the names you've completely forgotten about since NXT's peak. Brother tag-teams nobody talks about, first-time champs fans never mention, second-generation hopefuls who didn't cut it - they're all here.

There's a lot of buried NXT history to unearth. Try these wrestlers on for size!

10. Bailey Pierce

Bailey Pierce Ryan Nemeth Seth Rollins WWE NXT
WWE.com

Don't worry, Seth Rollins isn't the focal point of this entry! Check the fella next to him. That's current TNA and ex-AEW man Ryan Nemeth on the left. He scored a WWE developmental deal in 2011, then debuted on an early episode of NXT TV in June 2012. His role? Backstage interviewer extraordinaire.

Nemeth's WWE-ified name was Bailey Pierce. Yep, another one from the developmental name generator there. Pierce asked the easy questions of emerging stars like Rollins, but would find his way into the ring eventually. Like buses, all of his matches came along at once - Pierce worked three bouts on the same set of NXT tapings in May 2013.

Poor lad must've been knackered, but excited.

Dolph Ziggler/Nic Nemeth's brother didn't really get any higher than that in WWE's system though. He was released in late-May (before some of his taped bouts had aired). Ryan was surely hoping he'd turn the announcer job into something bigger. That kinda happened, but only for a cup of coffee.


9. Marcus Louis

Marcus Louis WWE NXT
WWE.com

Marcus Louis found his way into a non-title bout vs. then-NXT Champ Finn Bálor in 2015. That came after several lower-tier storylines that included the guy losing his hair and eyebrows. How's that for sports entertaining? Maybe working Finn was a reward for Louis doing his best with dodgy creative.

Regardless, it didn't elevate him higher up the food chain.

Marcus was released in February 2016. It was somewhat surprising, if only because he'd been such a regular presence on NXT programming just two years prior. Weirdly, and despite how often he was on shows, Louis isn't someone who ever really comes up when people discuss the brand's earliest wave of momentum.

TakeOvers were in full swing by 2015, and had started during Marcus's best year in WWE before that. However, he wouldn't benefit from all that hard work building NXT as a brand fans should pay attention to. Company higher-ups cut him from the roster without much warning.


8. Jake Carter

Jake Carter WWE NXT
WWE.com

For reference, Jake Carter is Vader's son. His real name is Jessie White, but WWE needed to go the name generator route (there's plenty more of that to come in this article!) and trademark their own. Thus, Carter was born. He'd become an early tag-team partner for current SmackDown commentator Corey Graves in FCW.

Jake came along for the ride when FCW changed to NXT in 2012, but he'd be gone by late-2013. WWE bosses at the Performance Center and higher ups couldn't have figured "@itsjake" was going to make the leap to Raw or SmackDown in the future. They'd have kept him around a while longer if they thought he had potential.

Oh well.

Carter's final moment on NXT came with a loss to Tensai. There's something weirdly full circle about that - Tensai, or Matt Bloom, was one of the trainers at the PC who would've coached Jake. Now, during Carter's last night, it was Bloom who sent him packing.


7. Garrett Dylan

Garrett Dylan Damian Sandow WWE NXT
WWE.com

Time for another famous father moment, albeit one outside the wrestling realm.

Former NXT man Garrett Dylan is the son of singer Kris Kristofferson. He was also Scott Dawson/Dax Harwood’s original partner on the third brand, but no-one talks about Garrett in the same breath as future Revival/FTR member Dash Wilder/Cash Wheeler. Dylan was a solid nuts n' bolts wrestler, to be fair.

All of his work on NXT fell between the show's 2012 debut and his 2014 release. Whilst there was definitely some buzz surrounding this revamp from faux-reality show to developmental territory, most of the hype came when main roster WWE stars dipped a toe into what Full Sail had to offer.

In other words, guys like Damian Sandow stopping by grabbed more eyeballs than anything Garrett did. He was a goner by the time NXT blossomed into one of the hottest weekly shows in the biz. Bit of a shame Dylan missed out on all of that.


6. Oliver Grey

Adrian Neville PAC Oliver Grey Dusty Rhodes WWE NXT
WWE.com

Quick! Name the first set of champions in NXT! Seth Rollins was the first top male champ in 2012. Paige followed suit by winning the NXT Women's Title in June 2013. Six months earlier, two Brits were celebrating with Dusty Rhodes as they became the brand's first ever Tag-Team Champions.

They were current AEW man PAC, who was called Adrian Neville, and UK indy star Joel Redman. He was called Oliver Grey in WWE's system, and that win alongside Neville was his finest hour in the industry. Mere months later, Grey suffered a nasty injury and had to be replaced in title matches by Bo Dallas.

His WWE career would never recover.

Oliver returned to TV one year later in April 2014, but NXT's creative types had lost interest in him. Grey was subsequently released later that same month. Today, he's the answer to a WWE trivia question more than someone fans fondly remember as a key component in NXT taking brave baby steps.


5. Hugo Knox

Hugo Knox WWE NXT
WWE

The curious case of Hugo Knox follows on neatly, and keeps the UK flag flying.

Knox put pen to paper on a contract in 2013, but he wasn't plucked from obscurity or the independent scene. No, he'd been a professional footballer for teams like Port Vale and Burton Albion before trading playing goalkeeper for pro wrestling. WWE clearly liked his physique and thought Stuart Tomlinson had promise, because they signed him up.

Tomlinson was renamed Knox and debuted on NXT in 2014. He'd only wrestle one match on TV - Hugo teamed with old Heavy Machinery member Tucker to face The Vaudevillains on the 2 March 2016 episode. All of his other bouts were either dark matches before TV tapings or on the road during NXT house shows.

WWE eventually cut Knox loose in 2016, and he returned to playing football. Hugo has done some modelling work on the side to keep himself busy since leaving the company. Will he ever be back? It's doubtful. Was he memorable? Man barely got a chance to be.


4. Dan Matha

Samoa Joe Dan Matha WWE NXT
WWE.com

WWE drafted up a deal for big Dan Matha in late-2015, and he'd report to the Performance Center before hitting the NXT brand in 2016. You probably don't remember him for anything he achieved on the third brand. His claim to fame was getting smashed around the place by a fired up Samoa Joe. Yep, that's it.

Except for his totally random main roster run.

A lot of fans have surely forgotten all about that as well. Matha was handed a spot in 2018's 50-man Greatest Royal Rumble over in Saudi Arabia despite not doing anything of note on NXT. Admittedly, once Vince McMahon had taken a look at him in Saudi, Dan didn’t do anything after that either.

Matha entered the so-called "Greatest" Rumble as #40 and lasted just two minutes before being tossed over the top rope by eventual winner Braun Strowman. After that cameo, Dan went back to working the NXT live event circuit and hoped for another big break.

It didn't come. He left WWE in 2020.


3. Troy McClain

Baron Corbin Troy McClain WWE NXT
WWE.com

Imagine being headhunted by none other than John Cena. That happened to Troy McClain, and he excitedly penned a WWE developmental contract in 2013. The fact McClain had been trained by 'Attitude Era' favourites Rikishi and Gangrel was promising too - surely they made sure he had a good head on his shoulders.

This just in: WWE life isn't for everybody.

Despite the strength of his trainers and a star the size of Cena going to bat for him, Troy couldn't gain a foothold on NXT. His motivational speaker gimmick (that debuted on the 19 April 2013 episode) didn't capture the imaginations of WWE fans, and no amount of support behind the scenes was going to change that.

Gerald Brisco was reportedly high on McClain and thought the promotion's top brass should bend over backwards to help him, but WWE released the rookie in September 2014 instead. Likely disillusioned, McClain worked a few matches on the independent scene before vanishing into thin air.


2. The Ealy Brothers

Gabriel Urial Ealy WWE NXT
WWE.com

Who are the best sibling tag-teams? The Steiners have to be up there, and so do acts like The Hardys, Harlem Heat and The Briscoes. One tandem you won't see grace that list: The Ealy Brothers. Their time in WWE's sun was shorter than most thought it would be. Gabriel and Uriel lasted between 2016-2018.

Both seemed to have all the tools needed to carve out a spot permanently.

Gabriel and Uriel were big, well-muscled workers who had a look one would think WWE loved. Something went wrong though. Uriel was released first, and that derailed Gabe's run too. The Ealy boys disbanded, and they're now considered little more than a footnote in NXT's lore.

Six years is an eternity in wrestling, so you won't hear anybody discussing The Ealy Bros much in 2024 (or after that). They're just another act that couldn't convince WWE they were worth keeping around. Harsh, maybe. True, definitely. The Ealy's are proof nothing is guaranteed.


1. Memo Montenegro

Memo Montenegro WWE NXT
WWE

The same goes for second and third-generation wrestlers too.

Memo Montenegro was the name WWE handed El Hijo de Dos Caras for his tenure between 2012-2013. If you're looking at his picture above (as well as that Dos Caras name) and thinking he looks familiar, then here's the deal: Memo is Alberto Del Rio's brother, not to mention the nephew of Mexican legend Mil Mascaras.

That lineage didn't do much for him on NXT. Montenegro worked two televised matches vs. future New Day members Big E and Xavier Woods, but disappeared from TV and was released in July 2013. Reportedly, it was Dos Caras himself who requested that his contract be torn to shreds. Perhaps he could see that things weren't going well.

Memo lost to E in just 21 seconds, so maybe he was right to be frustrated. Del Rio's name is mud in WWE nowadays anyway, so you won't hear official channels trumpeting Alberto or his family. Montenegro can't exactly be considered collateral damage in that, 'cause he was released long before Del Rio's troubles started, but he's defo one of NXT's forgotten sons.

Can you think of any other NXT stars fans might've forgotten? For more like this, check out 10 Forgotten WWE Authority Figures You Totally Don't Remember and 10 Lockdown Era WWE Superstars You Totally Don't Remember! 


Watch Next


In this post: 
WWE NXT AEW
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.