10 WWE Returns Everyone Asked For (Which Ended Up Sucking)

Be careful what you wish for because WWE might just give it to you...

scott steiner
WWE.com

No matter what era or scenario the company finds itself in at that moment in time, next to nothing will stop the wrestling universe from clamouring for a long lost face from the past to make a highly anticipated return to Vince McMahon's playground.

Though the majority of die-hard fans have already figured out precisely how a star should be used, booked, or presented before they've even set foot back through WWE's famous doors, in reality, sometimes things just don't fall into place in quite the way we'd originally hoped they would.

Now, in some cases, father time simply robbed us of a performer's glory years before they had one last chance to perform a victory lap in front of the WWE faithful.

Yet, other seriously talented wrasslers with more than a few in-ring masterclasses still up their sleeves have also left much to be desired after finally making a triumphant return.

From five-star frog stutters to Big Poppa chumps, this bunch of returning faces ultimately found out the hard way that not all comebacks are made equal... and some just straight-up suck...

10. Bret Hart

Bret Hart Vince McMahon
WWE

Make no bones about it, Bret Hart can very much legitimately confess to being "The best there is. The best there was. And the best there ever will be." So, it's just a shame that the middle section of that crowd-popping catchphrase rang most true when it came to his long-awaited return to WWE shores.

Having not set foot in a WWE ring since being infamously screwed a staggering 12 years earlier, The Hitman finally made his presence known on the January 4 edition of Monday Night Raw. Heartfelt burying of the hatchets quickly took place on-screen with both Shawn Michaels and Vince McMahon, only for the latter reconciliation to quickly spiral into a WrestleMania XXVI feud.

Sadly though, the countless theatrics and shenanigans that went into setting up the grudge match we'd been waiting a decade for couldn't mask the fact that this whole scenario was simply 10 years too late. Hart was in no real condition to wrestle anywhere near the match he once did and what could have been a rousing, dare I say, show-stopping comeback, soon devolved into a stale weapons-fest and a lacklustre final in-ring run in general.


9. Trish Stratus

Trish Stratus John Morrison Snooki
WWE.com

From one soul-crushing Canadian comeback to another, and the time Trish Stratus dusted off her wrestling boots for a showcase bout on the Grandest Stage of Them All.

In theory, that statement should elicit fond memories of another milestone moment for the legendary former Women's Champion. But after deciding to get back on the wrestling bike in 2011, Stratus quickly found herself on the losing side in a match against Vickie Guerrero. Sure, said defeat came due to LayCool interference, but it still wasn't the best of starts for the now-fitness master.

Fast forward to 'Mania XXVII, and Trish was lining up alongside John Morrison and Snooki to see off Dolph Ziggler and LayCool in what can best be described as a disappointing use of her talents.

Thankfully, the iconic star would get a chance to redeem herself later down the road with a string of stellar showings in the Women's Royal Rumble, at the Evolution PPV, and during an appropriate career send-off against Charlotte Flair at SummerSlam in 2019. So, the less said about her Snooki spell, the better.


8. Kurt Angle

Kurt Angle
WWE

It's depressingly ironic to realise that the star who once made chanting "You Suck!" one of the most over acts in WWE history, subsequently found his last in-ring run in the company falling into that unwanted classification.

Sadly though, similarly to Bret Hart before him, this was once again a case of pulling the trigger too damn late, with the Olympic hero's body simply battered beyond repair by the time he finally made amends with Vinnie Mac in 2017.

Now, sure, Angle could still offer something when it came to a multi-person car crash situation, notably taking us back down memory lane in his one-time Shield appearance and WrestleMania 34 teaming with Ronda Rousey. But the Wrestling Machine fans had been angling to see collide with the likes of Seth Rollins, AJ Styles, and Roman Reigns inside of a WWE ring just wasn't there anymore and a painfully limp closing stretch between the ropes was emphatically hammered home by a loss to Baron Corbin in his retirement bout at 'Mania 35.

At least we'll always have the memories of HBK and 'Taker classics, Jimmy Crack Corn, and Sexy Kurt.


7. Rob Van Dam

Rob Van Dam
WWE

For a time, ECW legend and former WWE Champion Rob Van Dam was undoubtedly One of a Kind.

However, a solid six years removed from his last stint with the company, that time had evidently passed for the high-flying sensation in 2013-2014. Don't get your writer wrong, RVD could still go to a certain extent, putting on decent showings against the likes of Cesaro and during the 2014 Money in the Bank ladder match.

Yet those clamouring to see the star who many felt was robbed of his time at the top of the mountain reclaim a world title and defend it in five-star bangers against a new set of talents were ultimately left disappointed. Van Dam was quickly ushered into the mid-card and soon decided that his time was worth more to him than it was to the company, as he put it on Twitter, and left.

He'd eventually pop back up later down the road on occasion and via 2021 WWE Hall of Fame induction, but the record will always show that an opportunity was missed to give Mr. Monday Night one last shot at the big time.


6. Kevin Nash

CM Punk, Kevin Nash SummerSlam 2011
WWE.com

Say what you will about Big Sexy and his up and down career inside of the squared circle, but a few months removed from an unexpected appearance in the 2011 Royal Rumble more than a few fans were interested in seeing what the towering former nWo man had left in the tank.

Shedding his Diesel skin during an attack on CM Punk post-SummerSlam victory vs. John Cena, costing him the WWE title in the process, the stage was set for an intriguing battle of the generations; Voice of the Voiceless vs. The Measuring Stick. What could go wrong?

Well, Nash not being medically cleared to compete wasn't the best of starts, and that bump in the road led to Punk being flattened by The Game at Night of Champions instead. And when Big Daddy Cool was finally given the all-clear, the CM Ship had sailed, meaning an unwanted sledgehammer/ladder throw-down with ol' pal Trips was booked in an attempt to salvage this ill-thought-out programme.

It did not and a handful of appearances post-Summer of Punk derailment did little to wash away this truly pointless return.


5. Shawn Michaels

Shawn Michaels
WWE

For the longest time, it seemed as though Shawn Michaels was going to comfortably sit as the exception that proved the rule when it came to wrassler's going back on a retirement stipulation.

It didn't matter how hard we screamed for HBK to don the chaps one more time for dream showdowns with the likes of AJ Styles, Seth Rollins, and Finn Balor, this Sexy Boy was happy leaving the superkicks to the next generation.

Then, in a turn of events that just about nobody saw coming, Mr. WrestleMania was finally convinced to tune up the band again by DX pal Triple H (and a boatload of Saudi dollar) in order to see off the Brothers of Destruction at Crown Jewel 2018. And though fans were anxiously hoping for a showing worthy of one of the greatest of all time in this totally-100%-this-is-it retirement showcase, a comedy of errors in the searing heat had other ideas.

Kane's mask doing a runner, Trip's pec trying to escape his person, and Michaels landing flat on his head post-moonsault all highlighted how bad an idea this was all along, and how sometimes it's better to just leave the memories alone.


4. Batista

Batista Del Rio
WWE.com

Thankfully, Dave Bautista was gifted the WWE send-off he most definitely deserved in the wake of a typically gruelling war with The Game on the Grandest Stage in 2019. Yet for a while there, it was looking as though fans' memories of The Animal inside of a squared-circle were forever going to be tarnished by a seriously disappointing spell on the back of a long awaited return in 2014.

Not quite still in the ridiculously impressive shape of old - which was to be expected after taking a few years off to pursue acting - Big Dave was presented as a returning hero, hellbent on reclaiming the top prize at 'Mania. Which would've been fine had it happened a few years earlier, only now the fans already had a star they wanted to see win the big one: Daniel Bryan.

Jump to an ill-advised Royal Rumble win, followed by a forced heel turn in the lead-up to a loss in the 'Mania XXX main event, and it was clear that things just hadn't gone to plan for the legend. The same mistake was not made five years later, however, with Drax slipping straight into full heel mode from the get-go.


3. Mickie James

Mickie James
WWE.com

The words "legend" and "icon" get thrown around a lot in the wrestling world. But, it's not an overstatement to admit that both terms absolutely apply to former Women's Champion Mickie James.

So, you can understand the sheer joy that was felt around the wrestling world when it was revealed that the star would be returning to WWE after a whopping six years away in 2016. An impressive comeback at TakeOver: Toronto reminded everyone what James was still capable of when battling Asuka, and it wasn't long before she was brought back full-time.

Even then, her initial SmackDown showings alongside Alexa Bliss and Becky Lynch were promising enough to suggest the Virginia native had a future further up the card like the days of old. But that was simply just never to be. A few unsuccessful title challenges soon gave way to James slipping into the pack, getting lost in the shuffle for much of her four-year run on the main roster.

If the disrespect shown to her on-screen character wasn't enough, James was then sent her belongings in a trash bag post-release in 2021, leading to the firing of the person responsible - Mark Carrano.


2. Scott Steiner

Triple H Scott Steiner
WWE.com

There's nothing quite like the sound of some ear-piercing sirens reducing an arena full of wrasslin' fans into a swell of deafening emotion. And judging from that aforementioned reaction to a returning Scott Steiner within Madison Square Garden back in 2002, it was safe to assume that WWE had once again captured lightning in a bottle.

They just couldn't hold onto it for very long, unfortunately.

The former WCW World Heavyweight Champion was promptly thrown into a feud with WWE golden boy Triple H over the world title, only to come up short on both occasions and for their Royal Rumble match to be considered the "Worst Worked Match of the Year" by the Wrestling Observer Newsletter.

Things didn't get much better from there, either, as a star who was once frothed over as being one of the most dominant and awe-inspiring stars available to WWE's one-time rivals was soon lumped into a tag team with Test before the two came to blows over Stacey Keibler; because wrestling over the services of a woman was never going to age badly, right?

An injury in 2004 would ultimately be the final nail in the coffin as he was released in August.


1. Goldberg

Goldberg Lesnar Survivor Series 2016
WWE

Not rearing his glorious dome in The Land of the Giants since stinking up MSG with a Beast in 2004, fans had long been salivating over the thought of Bill Goldberg finally coming back to WWE for one last wrecking ball spell.

An announcement that Da Man would be included in the WWE 2K17 video game as a pre-order bonus was the first seed planted. And before long, Goldberg had been lured back onto Monday Night Raw by Paul Heyman, with the humble advocate challenging the star who had been missing for 12 years to face-off against Brock Lesnar at Survivor Series.

A jaw-dropping squash win for the grizzled former WCW man followed, but then WWE got a little trigger happy, didn't they?

A fun Lesnar feud was signed off at 'Mania 33, but the burying of stars like Kevin Owens and The Fiend over the course of a turbulent five-year stint in WWE has left many fans regretting their calls of "GOOOOOOLDBERG" for over a decade.

Admittedly, WWE seem to have cooled off on any more unwanted world title runs for the veteran in recent times, but you get the feeling McMahon is only ever one rotten Raw away from strapping Da Man again.


Watch Next


In this post: 
SCOTT STEINER
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!