10 WWE Stars Who Desperately Need New Gimmicks

Sometimes, only a change of gimmick stands between mediocrity and megastardom.

In the world of WWE, personality is everything. Much of a performer’s persona is built around their gimmick, but not everyone is lucky enough to be saddled with a gimmick that makes sense, let alone succeeds. Gimmicks in WWE are just about as hit and miss as it gets, with many performers over the years finding themselves in both categories with the same character. A crazy industry, to say the least.

WWE’s bloated roster means that not every performer gets a chance to shine, but there are plenty of people signed to the company that finds themselves treading water with their current personas. They say ‘a change is as good as a rest’, and in WWE it can be the difference between an underwhelming career and superstardom.

Gimmick changes are part and parcel of the business and history tells us that incredible things can happen when creative commits to a change. The Ringmaster became Stone Cold Steve Austin, Rocky Maivia became The Rock, Fake Diesel became Kane and there are plenty more where they came from. Which current WWE stars need a change of gimmick? Where to begin, where to begin…


10. Carmella

Carmella WWE
WWE.com

You’d have got long odds on Carmella outlasting Enzo Amore and Big Cass in WWE. Long, long odds, but that is exactly what the Princess of Staten Island has done. She is a former Money in the Bank winner (two times, theoretically), a former SmackDown Women’s Champion and also a past winner of the women’s WrestleMania battle royal. To say she has overachieved is quite the understatement.

But right now Carmella is floating around in the ether, doing a whole lot of nothing. She turned face (sort of) in 2019, sparking up a relationship with R-Truth as he spent night and day defending his 24/7 Championship. The two were split up in the shake-up and Carmella is now on SmackDown, filling spots here and there while doing nothing particularly inspiring.

If anything, Carmella is the poster girl for the lack of depth WWE shows when dealing with its females. Those at the top of the card get attention and layers, while everyone below that level is merely shuffled into ‘face’ and ‘heel’ roles, doing a whole lot of nothing. Carmella is never going to be Eddie Guerrero in the ring but there are lots of ways to skin a cat. ‘Vanilla babyface’ is not one of them.


9. Nikki Cross

Nikki Cross
WWE

A former WWE Women’s Tag Team Champion, Nikki Cross is one of a rare breed; a professional wrestler who hasn’t completely floundered on the main roster. Granted, she hasn’t exactly set the world alight, but an argument can be made that her run on the main roster has been more or at least as impressive as her tenure in NXT.

This has come at the expense of anything approaching a character. In NXT Cross was a livewire, a chaotic animal of a performer that somehow managed to be the most insane member of a group called Sanity (okay, SAnitY). She didn’t stop moving for a second, and her wild-eyed glare gained her an army of fans spanning genders and generations. She wasn’t going to main event WrestleMania, but she was an important cog in the machine.

On the main roster, the only personality trait of Nikki Cross is that she ‘is friends with Alexa Bliss’. The pairing will inevitably split up — all teams do — with Bliss the more likely of the two to do the deed. Will Cross then fade into obscurity as a nothing character, or revert back to her chaotic past? The change in personality needs to come soon for the Scot.


8. Johnny Gargano

Johnny Gargano Takeover Punisher
WWE Network

For years, fans have feared the day when Johnny Gargano’s stint in NXT comes to an end and he finds his way to the main roster. The first-ever NXT Grand Slam Champion has become synonymous with the brand, but his general lack of size has many convinced that Vince McMahon will Gargano as little more than feed for the giants. Without being too pessimistic, they may have a point.

Even if Gargano manages to avoid the inevitable and stays on NXT for the foreseeable, the man is in serious need of a freshen-up. Gargano turned heel in costing Tommaso Ciampa the NXT Championship at TakeOver: Portland, but is that going to see him embrace a new character? Gargano has flirted with the dark side in the past, but it didn’t really change too much. He simply went from ‘wrestler who likes comic book heroes’ to ‘wrestler who likes comic book villains’.

Johnny Gargano needs a gimmick change, but that isn’t to say that he requires a wholesale overhaul. He doesn’t need to become an actual superhero or start wearing a cape, for example. Sticking with that idea and giving an example of someone that Gargano might take some ideas from, one only has to look at the evolution of PAC from athletic WWE babyface to ultimate bastard villain. If Gargano is going to embrace the darker side of the ledger, he needs to go all the way.


7. Apollo Crews

Apollo Crews
WWE.com

Does Apollo Crews have a gimmick? The former Uhaa Nation is one of the company’s most aesthetically impressive guys, has athleticism for days and a smile that can melt hearts from a thousand feet. Not only that, but he also comes across as a super nice guy. It thus makes perfect sense that he has spent his three years on the main roster losing, losing and losing.

More so than anyone in the entire company, Apollo Crews needs a change. He needs a direction. He needs something to sink his teeth into, something beyond being super handsome and losing wrestling matches. Losing handicap matches against Sheamus almost certainly isn’t the way to go, but that’s WWE creative for you.

A lot of WWE superstars go through a number of gimmicks before settling on one, covering plenty of personality ground before feeling comfortable in their own skin. Apollo? He’s still at the starting line. He’s still the one-dimensional babyface that he was when he came up from NXT during the 2016 draft.

Not everyone gets to be a main event performer in WWE. Not everyone gets to be a larger than life character, a Bray Wyatt, an Undertaker, a Kane. The old ‘be yourself but more’ is generally understood to be the way to go, but that doesn’t guarantee another Stone Cold Steve Austin, another Rock. Over the last three years, it really feels as though Apollo Crews has been himself but dialed down. Something needs to change for the big man before it is too late.


6. Rusev

Rusev WWE
WWE.com

Rusev should be the man in WWE by now. The Bulgarian Brute has it all, everything you need to become a major player in the biggest sports entertainment company on the planet. Few performers in the company can match the man from Plovdiv for charisma, credibility, talent and legitimacy. Rusev has timing, charm, ability, size, everything. His current position on the WWE ladder is an absolute travesty.

It doesn’t help that Rusev continually gets saddled with quite miserable storylines. Fans had only just gotten over the Dolph Ziggler debacle of years prior when the former United States Champion found himself once again losing Lana to a fellow WWE superstar, this time Bobby Lashley. The angle has been atrocious from the get-go and has left Rusev with less personality than at any other time in his run.

In truth, Rusev doesn’t need a total overhaul. He doesn’t need to be repackaged as a sailor or a carpenter or whatever, although he’d almost certainly make those gimmicks work. What Rusev needs is to be injected with life, to amp up his personality and reach new heights in the process. ‘Cucked ex-husband’ is just about as rotten as gimmicks get.


5. Liv Morgan

Liv Morgan
WWE.com

Liv Morgan just received a gimmick change, although that change is yet another example of WWE’s creative team not exactly understanding the idea of subtlety and nuance. Liv returned to WWE TV on the last RAW of 2019, interrupting Lana and Lashley’s wedding and revealing (sort of) a past love affair with the former. The segment was one of the worst seen in WWE in years.

WWE reacted somewhat swiftly to the backlash and the Lana/Liv thing has more or less been dropped entirely, with Liv picking up a couple of wins over the former Mrs. Rusev. Liv now seems to be embarking on a feud (of sorts) with former Riott Squad buddy Ruby Riott, although who knows how long that will last.

There was a time when Liv Morgan was one of the most intriguing future prospects for WWE’s women’s division. The New Jersey-native seemed to be improving every time she got into the ring, and her stint as the playful member of the Riott Squad gave her television experience and laid the groundwork for a future babyface turn. Still only 25, there is plenty of time for Liv to come good, but her current generic character isn’t going to help matters.


4. King Corbin

King Corbin
WWE.com

Why oh why do wrestling companies keep bringing the king gimmick back? The entire concept has largely been a waste of time in the 21st century. King Booker aside, the crown has been more of an albatross than anything else, lumbering those unfortunate enough to wear it with archaic dialogue and one-dimensional character development.

Baron Corbin’s general lack of development prior to winning the crown gave some hope that it could finally work, that WWE had finally chanced upon someone for whom the title of ‘King’ might be a positive. That may have been the case, but Corbin has now been feuding with Roman Reigns for 14 years and a change is sorely needed.

WWE obviously likes Baron Corbin. It isn’t difficult to see why, and the big man likely deserves a little more respect from disapproving fans. That respect almost certainly isn’t going to come while he reigns as king, a gimmick that has been dead in the water for 20+ years.


3. Mojo Rawley

Mojo Rawley
WWE.com

Contrary to popular opinion, Mojo Rawley is legitimately good at this professional wrestling thing. He is athletic as all hell and carries himself like someone who belongs at this elite level. Mojo also happens to be one of the most underrated promo guys in the company, best shown in a series of phone promos cut during his short post-Hype Bros feud with Zack Ryder.

Despite his obvious talents, Mojo finds himself stuck in WWE limbo, an all too crowded place to be. His Stay Hyped persona is long gone and has been replaced by a darker, moodier Mojo, but that hasn’t really been displayed beyond the man looking in a mirror and occasionally having a shock of blue paint on his face. The attempt at giving Mojo an edge has done nothing but remove any edges that were already there.

Should Mojo revert back to the energetic intensity of his Stay Hyped era? Probably not, but he isn’t exactly fully committed to his current non-persona. A man of Mojo’s talents is perfect for that most American of gimmicks, the jock, the bully, the (American) football player with a cerebral side. The former defensive lineman deserves better than 24/7 title purgatory.


2. Big E.

Big E
WWE.com

Now of course, New Day has been one of WWE’s great successes in recent times. After a rocky start, the trio has gone on to win multiple championships across both shows, with Kofi Kingston’s WWE Championship victory the obvious highlight. Big E. has been an integral part of that success, simultaneously acting as New Day’s muscle and comedic element.

The time has come for a change. Bringing New Day to an end will take nuance and skill, but if done right the company could have a new main event star on their hands in the form of Big E. He has the look, the personality, the skills and the experience to be a legitimate game-changer for the company. When it comes to the former Langston, it really is a matter of when as opposed to if.

The New Day has done fantastic things for Xavier Woods and Kofi Kingston. It legitimised the former, while it made the latter the main event star that he always threatened to be. What has it done for Big E? Multiple tag title runs, sure, and a chance to sharpen his comedic chops. The former NXT Champion is capable of much, much more.


1. Shorty G

Shorty G entrance
WWE

The only way this article could end. Where to begin with the ungodly horror that is Shorty G? It sounds like a joke, it looks like a joke, it must be a joke, but unfortunately for Chad Gable it is not. Or maybe it is? Gable’s current guise is guaranteed to go down in history as one of WWE’s dumbest creative character decisions.

Rewind twelve months back and things were looking much rosier for the former Olympian. 2019 started slowly but Gable soon found himself on a miracle run in the King of the Ring, beating Shelton and Andrade before overcoming Shane McMahon (twice) in the semi-finals. The former American Alpha man came up short against Baron Corbin in the final, but his performances and victories saw an upturn in fortunes for Gable.

That was as good as it got. Gable lost continuously and was made fun of for his height, forcing him to embrace his lack of vertical prowess and take on the Shorty G character. He eschewed traditional wrestling attire in favour of dressing like an actual child, wearing colourful basketball gear with way too much neon. If it looks like a 70-year-old man’s interpretation of what the cool kids are wearing then that is because that is exactly what it is.

Chad Gable is the sort of performer that doesn’t require a lot of creative assistance. He is arguably the best technical wrestler on the roster (and one of the best on the planet) and he has a strange charisma that you can’t teach, not unlike another former Olympian turned WWE superstar. More so than any current gimmick, Shorty G is an indictment of WWE’s creative team.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Big E
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.