10 WWE Stars Who Desperately Need New Gimmicks
Stagnation can be terminal in the world of pro wrestling; these superstars need a new lick of paint.
What's that saying? A change is as good as a rest? When in doubt, choose change? Yesterday I was clever so I wanted to change the world, but today I am wise so I am changing myself?
Any and all quotes about change fit the world of professional wrestling, believe it or not. Stagnation is as good as oblivion in this industry. In some ways, it is better to have a bad character than one that simply doesn't register at all.
That isn't true, obviously, as a bad character often leads to that aforementioned oblivion, but there are several men and women on WWE's books today who seem to be floating dangerously close to the abyss with characters and personalities that could do with a little work. What's great today might not be great tomorrow, and if you aren't great tomorrow then you're playing with fire.
Of course, change doesn't have to be wholesale. You don't need to give these individuals second jobs, no matter how delightful the thought of 'Digital marketer T-BAR' is. All that's needed is a lick of paint, a change of outlook, a fresh layer of personality, something to drag them out of the monotony that they are currently flirting with.
Cameron Grimes is a great example of someone who has benefited hugely from a slight tweak to his gimmick; who needs to be next?
10. John Morrison
Can we move on from Miz and Morrison already? John Morrison didn't leave WWE and travel the world making himself a star just to return and be Miz's sidekick, did he? Maybe he did, maybe he didn't, that is his own decision (obviously), but a performer of such ludicrous talents deserves more than playing second-fiddle to The Miz.
It doesn't even need to be white-meat babyface John Morrison, quite the opposite in fact. The WWE Universe deserves a chance to get to know Johnny Mundo, the uber-arrogant heel that Morrison portrayed when Lucha Underground was at its best. Give the fans a one-way ticket to Slamtown already, please.
Either way, Morrison needs a different character to 'Miz's mate'. There have been fun moments but the time has come to try something new, for the benefit of everyone. The ship may have sailed on Morrison being a crossover main event star but that doesn't mean all the boats are out to sea. There is plenty of value in Morrison yet, be it as an eccentric babyface or an understandably cocky heel. Bring Franky Monet over to the main roster and pair them up already.
9. Mandy Rose
Fans might be able to understand when WWE fails to capitalise on certain superstars. Samoa Joe never seemed to fit the WWE mould, no matter how elite his promos and performances were. The same can be said for many stars throughout the company's history, as Vince McMahon and his chosen yes-men continue to strive for that perfect aesthetic for HD TV.
Mandy Rose is just about as perfect aesthetic for HD TV as it gets, yet she still finds herself treading water doing a whole lot of nothing. She's also immensely talented, one of the most improved performers of the last few years. Rewind to the period following WrestleMania 36 and it seemed as though God's Greatest Creation was primed to become a major star on WWE TV. Then, nothing followed by Dana Brooke-partnering purgatory.
As with many names on this list, Mandy Rose doesn't need a dramatic change. She doesn't need to be repackaged as a baker, a bramble picker or a firewoman. She needs something, however, as 'generic blonde female number 5' is currently making a waste of her immense talents and potential.
8. Nikki Cross
Nikki Cross doesn't just need a new gimmick; she needs a gimmick full stop. The diminishing of the former WWE Women's Tag Team Champion is extremely bizarre to say the least. There was once a time when she was one of the few females who seemed to have an appreciable character, albeit a character that didn't have much to it outside of being feral. Wasn't there an entire world to explore there? Why was Nikki in SAnitY at all? In hindsight, what was the reason for that group's existence outside of Eric Young's crazy eyes?
Having had every ounce of character stripped away from her, the previously thrilling Nikki Cross is now as generic as it gets. She hasn't done anything on TV since worrying about Alexa Bliss last year, even though there was obviously more reason for Bliss to be into Bray Wyatt than there was for Cross to follow Eric Young. 'Once Feral' Nikki Cross giving life advice remains one of the silliest parts of last year in pro wrestling.
We're now more than two months removed from Nikki's last TV match and the future doesn't bode particularly well for the Scot. That is a massive shame as she has shown some serious chops over the years. Repackage her and you never know what might happen.
7. Dexter Lumis
They don't come much more gimmicky than Dexter Lumis. The creepy dude with a moustache character has somehow achieved more in NXT than it ever did in TNA, although it must be remembered that the bar was pretty low, to begin with. The problem with it, as per, is that the gimmick is so one-dimensional that its long term prospects don't look too great.
WWE has tried to add a few more dimensions to the guy, be it through his art or romantic dalliance with Indi Hartwell, but each addition has done little more than further ground the stale nature of the gimmick. Truth be told, 'creepy babyface' should never, ever be a thing, and it is a weird indictment of the 21st century that such a thing can come to pass.
One problem Lumis has is that this has pretty much been his gimmick for the best part of a decade now. The guy is plenty talented but the straitjacket nature of the character is seriously limited. There's an idea; have Dexter Lumis carted off in a straitjacket and set about rebuilding from there.
6. Liv Morgan
We've been here before, right? Liv Morgan needs a gimmick change, but if that leads to her interrupting a Lashley/Lana wedding then maybe she's better off treading water in the Riott Squad. A gimmick change is only a good idea if the new gimmick accentuates the qualities that a wrestler has.
And Liv Morgan has plenty of qualities. If you'll forgive the seemingly lazy aesthetic connections, Morgan is very much what WWE management seems to think Alexa Bliss is, just with more bite. Morgan has spent much of her tenure to date working as a heel with major babyface potential, putting on quietly good matches with a variety of opponents. There's no reason to believe that Liv Morgan doesn't have major mainstream potential too, a babyface superstar with crossover appeal.
There's nothing wrong with the Riott Squad gimmick, truth be told. Liv and Ruby have excellent chemistry and it is borderline criminal that they haven't had a run with the WWE Women's Tag Team Championships yet. If that title reign isn't happening anytime soon, the time has come for Liv Morgan to regroup and refresh.
5. Braun Strowman
How strange is it that Braun Strowman's first real period of main roster limbo has coincided with his first Universal Championship and a WrestleMania feud with a McMahon? Professional wrestling is a weird, weird world. Just a couple of years ago, the Monster Among Men was seemingly overachieving on the main roster but a number of confusing face and heel turns since have rendered him somewhat toothless.
The time for change is now. Braun Strowman has made a couple of minor changes in recent times, shaving his head and changing up his gear, but it all leads to the same Braun and the excitement has well and truly gone. Feuding with Bray Wyatt and Alexa Bliss all last summer certainly didn't help, but it isn't as if the fault lies only at the feet of those weirdos. Braun hasn't recovered from being dragged into the swamp by his former leader at last year's Horror Show at Extreme Rules.
Braun Strowman is at a crossroads, albeit a crossroads that sees him still hanging around the main event scene on RAW. Is he destined to become the modern Big Show, bouncing from face to heel and back again with no direction to speak of, or will a gimmick change freshen up the Monster Among Men once more?
4. T-BAR
Now that he has been unmasked, the chances of T-BAR getting repackaged have drastically gone up. That said, there's every chance that the former Dominik Dijakovic spends the next few weeks rambling about being freed from the chains of anonymity, doubling down on the disaster that was RETRIBUTION.
Or maybe, just maybe, this immensely talented and athletic big guy can finally get a platform from which he can shine. Give him his name back, tell us why he was seduced by Mustafa Ali and RETRIBUTION in the first place and maybe we'll start to root for the guy. History is filled with naive individuals who fell in with the wrong crowd, were led down bad alleys before finding redemption on the other side. Everyone loves a redemption story.
Let's see that with Dominik Dijakovic. That doesn't mean we need to see the big guy cutting 20-minute promos from a chair in the centre of the ring, he isn't Eddie Guerrero after all, but let's put some flesh on these big bones. The RETRIBUTION misery can be salvaged if it leads to beloved babyface hero Dominik Dijakovic.
3. Ricochet
Oh, Ricochet, what could have been?
Three years into his WWE tenure, the highlight of the former US Champion's WWE career remains a wacky vault out of the ring into the grid of Velveteen Dream. Well, that and being squashed in Saudi Arabia by Brock Lesnar, maybe. Ricochet's athleticism and body control are off the charts, the best in a company full of elite athletes. The problem is that the whole thing just sort of ends there.
If anything is to really happen with Ricochet in WWE, he needs a gimmick that is different to 'flies around and looks shocked a lot'. Why not put him under a mask and see where that goes? That Prince Puma was a pretty cool character, right? WWE loves its merchandise and there are few things cooler than a high-flying dude in a mask. Ricochet doesn't need to go the way of Sin Cara, Kalisto and others, but there's no reason to think he won't catch fire under the hood.
That is exactly what it reads like, an advocation for a total overhaul of the Ricochet character, right down to a different moniker. Give him a mask, a mouthpiece and meaning, and let's see what happens.
2. Tommaso Ciampa
Has Tommaso Ciampa overachieved in WWE? You better believe he has. Any other opinion is flat-out wrong. Ciampa has scratched and clawed his way up the ladder, from getting the piss slapped out of him by Samoa Joe (uncontracted, for the record) to arguably the best NXT Championship in the title's near-decade-long history. Nothing came easy for Ciampa, but the Black Heart always give off the impression that he wouldn't have it any other way.
Ciampa has overachieved but he finds himself in a weird sort of limbo in 2021. What is left for the former one-time NXT Tag Team Champion? The last year has seen Ciampa suffer a couple of serious chastening defeats to Karrion Kross and Walter, thrashings that made the pecking order all the more clear. Other heels are ahead of him and Ciampa's always been at his best when playing the bad guy.
Tommaso Ciampa doesn't need a total overhaul, but he certainly needs a look. There is immense talent in his frame. It would be a shame for Ciampa to find himself pushed out of view at such a relatively young age, injuries notwithstanding. Fans don't need Ciampa to revert to his previous appearance as Muhammad Hassan's lawyer, but a change might do him the world of good.
1. Sami Zayn
Conspiracy theorist Sami Zayn is a great character. Despite the immensely irritating nature of the gimmick, Zayn remains one of the most entertaining performers on WWE TV, and his descent into neurosis and madness has been great fun to watch. The whiny heel who thinks everyone is against him is just about as eternal as bad guy wrestling characters get.
Despite all that, Sami Zayn needs a change. Well, not exactly, he just needs to go back to being the best damn babyface in all of WWE. It has been great fun watching Zayn portray a full-on heel for the first time in his WWE career but not a segment passes without thoughts of what could have been.
WWE missed so many open goals with babyface Zayn that it beggars belief. Where was Intercontinental Champion workhorse babyface Sami Zayn? The world's largest wrestling promotion lucked into a mega-underdog in Daniel Bryan and did everything to stop him from succeeding, a trend that the company went on to perfect with Zayn. How have we not had a WrestleMania end with Zayn holding world championship gold aloft as graffiti falls around him?
Sami Zayn's run as a psychotic heel has been great but can we have babyface Sami Zayn back already?