10 WWE Stars Who Desperately Need New Gimmicks

These WWE men and women badly need something new before it's too late.

Nikki A.S.H
WWE.com

WWE tends to give up on things rather quickly.

If a character doesn't catch fire and stay that way, then Vince McMahon's whim-led instincts kick in and fresh ideas are doomed to be scrapped from screens ASAP. Fans have witnessed this countless times - it's like both McMahon and his overworked creative team get bored of new toys and so start throwing them away.

Chapter one is rarely a problem. Wrestlers debut gimmicks with a bang, but then the writing staff's complete lack of interest/overall direction becomes clear. That must be so frustrating for the men and women playing these personas, but it's just the way things seem to work in WWE.

There are loads of characters on both Raw and SmackDown who badly require an overhaul soon. Their current gimmicks are either failing terribly or were pretty naff to begin with, but they've all got one thing in common: Vince has blatantly lost much of his early interest (or mild curiosity) in them.

Where do they go from here? Who knows? However, trying something daring might be better than sitting still or doing nothing on weekly TV.

10. T-Bar/Mace

T-Bar Mace
WWE.com

Twin pack attack to start.

Ex-Retribution muscle men T-Bar and Mace are on different brands, for...some reason. The questionable erraticism of WWE's Draft meant that the promotion split them late-last year, but the problem is that they've then proceeded to do absolutely nothing with either man. Seriously, where the f*ck are they?

Surely a switch of scenery should've sparked change for Mace, at least. Both he and the former Dominik Dijakovic need to ditch their old gimmicks as soon as they can and try something new. If they don't, then they're doomed to continue working episodes of Main Event and staring at the lights on bargain bin programming.

Mace showed he had some personality when he worked commentary as Dio Maddin a few years back, and T-Bar has always had in-ring chops stretching back to NXT. WWE should either revert both men back to their prior guises or attempt something fresh.

They just can't go on like this.


9. Apollo Crews

Apollo Crews
WWE.com

The Intercontinental Title was a puzzling death sentence for Apollo Crews' 'Nigerian Prince' gimmick. He introduced that persona to fans in early-2021, and went all in on everything from the hokey accent to enlisting the towering Commander Azeez as his bodyguard. WWE were interested for a cup of coffee.

Apollo's surprise IC Title win came over future WWE Champ Big E at WrestleMania 37. Instead of acting as an encouraging sign that creative cared though, the character peaked. The company lost passion for Crews' gimmick almost overnight, and he all-but-disappeared despite being SmackDown's secondary male champion for 124 miserable days.

Most fans had probs forgotten Apollo was even IC Champ when Shinsuke Nakamura beat him on the 13 August SmackDown, which really says it all. He can't keep beating his head against the wall by continuing to act as phoney royalty, especially when his employer doesn't give a damn about it anymore.

Change is necessary, Mr. Crews.


8. Aliyah

Aliyah WWE Guinness World Record
WWE.com

She's bubbly! She's likeable and energetic! She's...Maria Kanellis updated for the modern generation? Yep, that's what Aliyah's current gimmick seems to be. She's a ditzy, borderline thick type who waltzes through life never knowing when someone is trying to rip the p*ss. Does it work? Nah, not really.

Aliyah's 'happy to be here' approach is probably endearing to some fans, but it's hardly the kind of characterisation that serves long-term sustainability in today's women's division. Compare her to hardened workers like Becky Lynch, Charlotte Flair or Bianca Belair, for example - those women have flash, but they've also got credibility during matches.

SmackDown's newbie doesn't.

Worse, WWE have given up on her already. She only joined the blue brand ranks during last October's Draft, but Aliyah is already struggling to make an impact, and she won't make one until that empty-headed gimmick gets the boot. Honestly, it needs to happen over the next few months for her to have a fighting chance.


7. Xia Li

Xia Li
WWE.com

Meanwhile, Xia Li's 'Great Protector' guise also needs to go.

The idea had promise when WWE began teasing it in late-2021. Li burst onto the scene and was greeted with fanfare when she saved Naomi from Sonya Deville's tyranny, but that led to sod all else. Xia hasn't even worked a televised match since beating Natalya in four minutes on the 25 February episode of SmackDown.

Who, exactly, is she protecting? It's like those writers came up with a catchy nickname, saw potential in the notion that she'd become some Batman-esque saviour for put-upon babyfaces in the women's division, then quickly came to the realisation that they didn't even want that for her.

Li can keep the look. It's eye-catching, and there's no-one else doing that sort of thing on the roster. However, she must be recast upon her return to TV (whenever that might be). This 'Great Protector' concept has been a total failure.


6. Madcap Moss

Madcap Moss Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal 2022
WWE.com

Madcap's jokes were deliberately crummy from the off, but they somehow convinced WWE management that he was worthy of the annual Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal trophy. Perhaps that was a reward for putting his all into jobs for Drew McIntyre during the big Scot's feud vs. Happy Corbin.

Either way, he needs a rethink.

Playing a wisecracking sort who purposely goes out of his way to tell dad jokes isn't exactly going to endear someone to pro wrestling fans in 2022. On the plus side, Moss clearly has ability, and his well-muscled look should earn him another chance in WWE circles soon.

Where do they go from here though? The Madcap name was tied to that team with Corbin, and his promo style (those aforementioned crappy one-liners) won't click with fans as a babyface. Moss' future is unclear, but he just cannot keep dressing like a goof and delivering Christmas cracker gags for the rest of 2022.


5. Happy Corbin

Happy Corbin
WWE

Change is also afoot for Madcap's now-ex partner Happy Corbin.

The "Happy" idea worked as a way to spin out of the 'King' Corbin gimmick last year, but it was never going to be the guy's full-time direction. Now, thanks to a split from Moss, Corbs can start looking at what's next for him on SmackDown. Or, maybe he'll get shunted sideways to Raw.

WWE tends to go for that later strategy when they're a bit stuck, so don't be surprised if it happens. Whether he sticks around on FOX or takes his skills to USA, the same is true: "Happy" needs to go and Corbin needs something different.

His 'Happy Lounge' talk show skits have been a painful reminder of everything that's wrong with WWE's TV formatting anyway, and it's not like his matches have offset that creative malaise. A return to playing royalty is out of the question, so it might be time for plain ol' Baron Corbin to launch a comeback.

Buzzing to hear that sweet theme again.


4. Rick Boogs

Rick Boogs Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Shinsuke Nakamura's pal Rick Boogs is a bit of an anomaly on this list. He debuted as an extra in Old Spice ads alongside R-Truth, and showed enough charisma that WWE wanted to take a punt on him - that led to a run as Shin's hype man and, eventually, his tag-team partner.

Then, disaster struck.

Boogs went down with a nasty injury at 'Mania 38 and will be benched for a good while. Not all is lost though. When Ricky boy returns, he can do so with a fresh gimmick that shows a different side to him than the bizarre mix between 1980s rockstar and old-timey strongman he's been working (what would you call his latest gimmick?!).

It's time for Boogs to give Nakamura the boot too. Their duo might've gone on to become SmackDown Tag-Team Champs at some point, but most fans are likely comfortable with never seeing that happen. Rick has potential on his own with a new character to sink his teeth into.


3. The Viking Raiders

Viking Raiders
WWE.com

Yes, the 'Viking Experience' is over.

Not over over, but that's WWE's fault. Their booking for Erik and Ivar has been stop/start for too long, and the only creative direction they have in mind for The Raiders' opponents is to call them smelly. It's a bit sh*t, and it's put the Vikings in a right funk.

The pair's run together as War Machine in ROH, New Japan and on the indy scene was fabulous. Things looked promising on NXT too before the writers on Raw and SmackDown got their grubby mitts on the team. Since then, they've been up and down like Pat McAfee behind the commentary desk (literally - the dude gets fidgety!).

It could be time to try something radically different. Leaving behind their Assassin's Creed: Valhalla routine may be the only way to find out if WWE struggle with the raiding idea or if they don't have a clue how to book Erik and Ivar generally.


2. Ezekiel

Ezekiel Kevin Owens
WWE.com

What a spot WWE put Elias/Ezekiel in the night after WrestleMania 38, eh? The poor lad had to walk out to complete silence and argue that he was, in fact, Elias' younger brother. Meanwhile, Kevin Owens did his best to keep things ticking along. It was poor for Zeke and naff follow up for KO following his match with Steve Austin.

It was also half-hearted from creative.

They must decide what they hope to achieve with all this, "I'm not Elias, honest" malarkey. Is that really the best they have for the revamped star, or was it a last-minute bid to shove him back on telly and pretend that his comeback was shocking enough for the post-'Mania Raw?

Being brutally honest, Ezekiel could be doing with change already. WWE should leave the music man gimmick behind permanently (never mentioning it again) or return to it and lick their wounds. They can't have things both ways, because that won't work.

Also, grow the beard out again. Pretty please?


1. Nikki A.S.H

Nikki A.S.H.
WWE.com

Finally, it's Nikki A.S.H.

The former Nikki Cross did appear revitalised when she strutted out looking like Bananaman last summer. This was clearly something that the Scot had hoped to do for a while, and she put everything into ensuring that WWE's interest wouldn't fade before it properly got started - she deserves credit for that.

Sadly, the bloom is off the rose in 2022. A.S.H has burned through a Raw Women's Title reign and a tag run alongside Rhea Ripley. She's also gone from being cheered to jeered, and pulled the trigger on a heel turn this past January. That's a lot of content for a gimmick that's only existed since June 2021.

The goofy mask and garish outfit will likely go back into storage sooner rather than later. Fingers crossed both Nikki and WWE's writers have something else in mind though. It'd be a catastrophe if she was cast aside, especially when that old SAnitY gimmick is right there.

What other WWE wrestlers badly need new gimmicks/characters? For more wrestling, check out WWE 2K22: 15 Best Female CAWs You Must Download and WWE 2K22: 13 Most WTF CAWs You Need To See!


Watch Next


In this post: 
Nikki A.S.H.
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.