10 WWE Stars Who Only Worked One Televised Match
One and done.
WWE has powered through thousands of wrestlers over the years, but not every single one could be a success.
Follow pro wrestling long enough and you'll surely hear the phrase, 'throwing things at the wall to see what might stick'. That's been a Vince McMahon go-to since day one - the boss doesn't always have a nailed-on plan. Sometimes, he just sorta' slings sh*t out there and hopes for the best.
This is never more true than when one analyses all the workers who only worked a handful of matches for the promotion. Even more impressively, the following 10 listed here only managed one televised bout during their fleeting WWE careers. Some disappeared off the face of the earth afterwards, whereas others either went on to become stars elsewhere - or were already respected outside McMahon's insular walls.
There are a few comedic gems in here too, because what good is this sort of subject if you can't go wild with it and make light of the "WWE Superstars" tag? In years to come, people will speak of a list-based article that includes deities, drug dealers, Japanese wrestling legends and scared little boys.
Maybe...
10. Phantasio
It's a kind of magic.
On 28 June 1995, face-painted magician Phantasio worked one solitary TV match on the antiquated Wrestling Challenge show against Tony DeVito. His performance would go on to become internet legend, and not only because he almost killed producer Bruce Prichard by setting fire to the temp Gorilla Position behind the curtain beforehand.
During his match, the wrestling trickster pulled his opponent's underwear clean off (it's not as dirty as it sounds), and used the ensuing confusion to beat him. On commentary, the iconic voice of Gorilla Monsoon desperately tried to sell Phantasio as something special. It was a losing battle, even for the mighty Monsoon.
Phantasio, as Spellbinder, would return for a few house show and dark bouts over the years, but he never wrestled on company television again. The guy behind the paint should definitely take the fact Mantaur and T.L Hopper worked multiple times as an insult.
9. Key
During the lauded Attitude era, the WWF thought nothing of presenting wrestling pimps, porn stars and other adult-themed gimmicks, so it was perhaps only a matter of time before a fully-fledged drug dealer showed up too. Enter Vic Grimes, or 'Key'.
He worked a grand total of three matches for the company, and only one was televised.
After beating Erin O'Grady (Crash Holly) in a cult classic 1998 dark match, Grimes returned in '99 as Key and joined forces with Droz and Prince Albert to smash three unknown jobbers on an episode of Shotgun Saturday Night. It was as memorable as it sounds, and that'd be a wrap on the coke-dealing ways of someone who appeared to be the worst Gangrel cosplay ever.
Later, Grimes joined ECW and worked independents like XPW when Paul Heyman's league went out of business. In 2002, he was notably thrown off scaffolding by a crazed New Jack (who makes no secret about literally wanting to kill Vic).
8. Mil Máscaras
Legendary Mexican masked man Mil Máscaras famously hated the thought of losing on camera, and he even shocked WWF officials with a quick, "no job" declaration before working the 1997 Royal Rumble. That posed quite the problem, because ol' Mil wasn't booked to win the 30-man match.
So, he just eliminated himself to save face. What a guy.
Máscaras, an icon in his homeland, never returned to WWF/WWE television until being inducted into the Hall Of Fame in 2012. During his speech, he refused to job out to the microphone and instead used his booming voice to regale the entire audience with tales of his epic career. OK, that's a joke, but so was Mil's only TV match on Vince McMahon's watch.
Kids watching in '97 must've wondered who the masked wonder with the barrel chest and penchant for no-selling every f*cking thing he could was. He was Mil Máscaras, and he hated to lose even when he was only making a cameo.
7. Priscilla Kelly
Now for something a little more serious.
AEW's own Priscilla Kelly was barely out of her teens when she worked a one-and-done match against recently-released starlet Deonna Purrazzo during the 2018 Mae Young Classic. Her four-minute WWE career must be some sort of record, and it remains the only TV match Kelly has had in the promotion to date.
She's only 22 years old, so there's time yet. If things don't work out for Priscilla in All Elite, then it's possible she'll get another crack at WWE fame somewhere down the road. For now, she's happily hitched to fellow AEW star Darby Allin and looking to carve out a sizeable spot in Tony Khan's female ranks.
If WWE do ever rehire Priscilla, don't expect them to reference her quick loss to Purrazzo much. That spot in the tournament only really happened because the company needed someone to take a hit and pad out the brackets.
6. Nicholas Cone
No, that's not some dodgy Photoshop effort. Yes, it is genuinely a terrified 10-year old child going up against wrestling machine Cesaro at WrestleMania 34. Amazingly, said kid ended up becoming one half of the new Raw Tag-Team Champions.
As Taz once crowed regularly on SmackDown, "Who'd-a-thunk it?".
Nicholas Cone, son of WWE ref John, was handpicked to be Braun Strowman's tag-team partner against The Bar at 'Mania. It was played for laughs, obviously, and was supposed to put over the idea that a monster like Braun didn't need anybody to watch his back. Unfortunately, the bout also succeeded in making Sheamus and Cesaro look like inept fools.
Lil' Nick would never defend his newly-won prize. It didn't take long for him and Strowman to vacate the titles (thus making a mockery of the decision to even book a title change in the first place), and he retired with a 1-0 record that'd earn serious bragging rights at school.
5. "God"
Ladies and gents, you are officially off the deep end now.
God (or "God", because the religious community would probs be offended by the notion that their almighty jobbed out to Vinnie Mac) was revealed as Shawn Michaels' tag-team partner at Backlash 2006. "God" made "his" way to the ring under spotlights beamed down from heaven, and everyone wondered why WWE had decided to lace their Pepsi Max with hallucinogens.
The 'No Holds Barred' tag match pitted Shawn and the big bearded fella' against Vince and Shane McMahon, and it was every bit as ludicrous as you'd imagine. The only real tragedy is that WWE didn't go further and have either McMahon sell some 'Sweet Chin Music' from "God". Instead, the spotlight hung around on the ring apron and Michaels went solo.
Was this some sort of commentary on having religion in one's corner? Probably. Did it leave everyone scratching their heads and asking why God now had a 0-1 record (one worse than Nicholas Cone, by the way)? Absolutely. Did Vince care?
Not one bit.
4. Bruce Hart
Gods of another kind will have to wait until the next entry. For now, here's the Hart brother Vince McMahon wasn't particularly interested in: Bruce.
At Survivor Series 1993, Brucey baby teamed with Bret, Owen and Keith (who, the announcers couldn't wait to tell the world, was actually a full-time fireman and hadn't wrestled in years) against Shawn Michaels and his knights. It was supposed to be Jerry Lawler, but the 'King' was busy fending off some legal troubles.
Remarkably, Owen was the only sibling eliminated during the match, and his frustrations helped kick off a memorable heel turn on brother Bret at the coming Royal Rumble. Back to Bruce though; he tried to become a full-time member of the roster, and even pitched himself as the bro who'd stab the 'Hitman' in the back by 1994.
Prichard told on his 'Something To Wrestle With' podcast that McMahon wasn't interested, but did let Bruce contribute some more ideas to the company. He wasn't ever going to make it as a wrestler in the company though, and Survivor Series '93 remains his sole TV match.
3. Jushin 'Thunder' Liger
As promised, it's a wrestling God.
It's incredible to think that the legendary Jushin 'Thunder' Liger only worked one solitary match for WWE in the modern era. Technically, he did work a WWF card in 1990 (as part of a co-promotion between WWF, All Japan and New Japan known as the Wrestling Summit), but would never make his way stateside for the company.
That's one thing WCW had over Vince McMahon - they bagged loads of Liger matches between 1991-1999. WWE would have to wait until 2015, and they'd only get one booking out of the former 11-time Junior Heavyweight Champion. That came against Tyler Breeze at the very first NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn.
Predictably, the near-nine minute exhibition wasn't Liger's best showing. It wasn't bad (at all), though he was always better in longer, drawn-out affairs. The atmosphere more than made up for any technical shortcomings though, and turned Liger's one-off WWE booking into a worthwhile pursuit.
2. Cain Velasquez
Someday, Cain Velasquez' brief WWE career will be the answer to a trivia question.
"Which former two-time UFC Heavyweight Champion only wrestled one televised match in WWE?". The answer is, of course, 'Cardio' Cain. After showing up as Rey Mysterio's muscle during the masked icon's feud with Brock Lesnar late-last year, Velasquez was soundly thumped by Brock in a WWE Title match at Crown Jewel.
That Saudi Arabian defeat proved to be Cain's only match of any note in the company. He also worked a tag-team match on the 30 November 2019 house show in Mexico City (with Humberto Carrillo against Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson), but he never worked another TV bout before reportedly being released from contract.
Cain might be the only guy in history to debut amongst so much fanfare, wrestle his first match for the WWE Title and then shuffle out of the promotional sphere without so much as a goodbye. His short stay in WWE was panic booking (they wanted something newsworthy for SmackDown's FOX debut) 101.
1. Buff Bagwell
He's Buff, he's the stuff and Vince McMahon has seen enough.
Buff Bagwell only wrestled one televised match after jumping over to the WWF despite being a major star for years over in rival WCW. His charismatic approach seemed perfect for McMahon's world, but things quickly fell apart after Bagwell's match with Booker T on the 2 July 2001 episode of Raw.
'The Stuff' impressed nobody with his in-ring skills or backstage behaviour. Jim Ross has told several times in interviews and on podcasts how Buff's mother Judy would plague his office with phone calls, and how Bagwell acted like he was above everyone when he really needed to make a good first impression on a new roster.
One week after the Booker match, Buff was released from his WWF deal and sent back into wrestling's wasteland. His short-lived stay in the promotion did nothing for Bagwell's career prospects, and he hasn't been seen in WWE since.
So much for that.
Which other wrestlers only worked one televised WWE match? For more like this, check out 10 Things We Learned From Triple H On WWE’s After The Bell and 10 Things We Learned From VICE’s Dark Side Of The Ring: Dino Bravo!