10 WWE Stars Who Survived The Worst Booking Ever
If they can get through this, they can get through anything.
Creative burnout is real, but WWE's overworked writing crew can't hide behind that as the only excuse for some of the nonsense they've penned over the years.
It's one thing to say, 'Sod it', stick someone anonymously under a turkey outfit and call them 'The Gobbledy Gooker', but it's another entirely to take a clearly talented worker and force them to suffer through some of the worst booking in pro wrestling history. It's like creative want to see how talent reacts to adversity or something.
For some reason, WWE's creative minds have believed that questionable construction workers, borderline-white supremacists, cosplay versions of famous characters, creepy stalkers (not who you think), bogus royalty, toilet humour victims and more would all make money - that's what this stuff is all about, right? Making money.
How any of the wrestlers presented here were supposed to prize cash from the pockets of fans whilst peddling this nonsense is anyone's guess. The amazing thing is, they all survived, and some even went on to become World Champions.
Others had already been World Champ when WWE decided to put them through creative hell...
10. William Regal
He's a man - a real man's man.
That was how the WWF presented technical wrestling guru Steven Regal in 1998. The chain wrestling wizard was pushed through the curtain wearing a lumberjack flannel, a plastic hard hat and...wrestling knee pads. He looked like the world's worst CAW from War Zone on PSOne, and it sucked hard.
This was a tumultuous time in Regal's life personally and professionally. Before long, substance abuse issues got the best of him, he was released, and he ended up back in WCW for another forgettable spell. Then, something magical happened. Regal came out of his personal slump, rejoined the WWF and became a success story.
Renamed William, he carved a niche for himself as the promotion's Commissioner and 'Goodwill Ambassador'. By playing a bumbling Englishman who delighted in calling everyone who'd listen a "silly pillock", Regal rescued his career. Better yet, he didn't have to wear that stupid yellow hat.
9. Chavo Guerrero
Chavo Guerrero never really realised his potential in WWE. Sure, he had a fantastic run alongside uncle Eddie as a tag-team, and he did get some shine in the Cruiserweight division, but any longtime WCW mark could tell you he was always capable of so much more after years of up and down booking there.
Not to worry, 'cause Vince McMahon had a solution: Kerwin White.
In 2005, WWE decided to totally repackage their Hispanic star as a golf-playing middle class white dude who denounced his Mexican heritage. It was like Donald Trump's wet dream in wrestling gimmick form, but it was clearly doomed to fail. Nobody wanted Chavo as Kerwin, and fans rejected it from minute one.
After Eddie tragically died a few months later, Chavo returned to his old ways and forgot all about Mr. White. That, despite the sh*tty circumstances, was a step forward. Hell, anything was a step forward following Kerwin, and Chavo managed to work enough good matches that people forgave him.
8. Bray Wyatt
If you've never seen Bray Wyatt introduce Finn Bálor to 'Sister Abigail' on the 2 October 2017 Raw, then go and watch this immediately. Finished? Good, because now you can scratch your head and wonder what the heck WWE's creative team was smoking before pushing this out in front of millions on live TV.
It was embarrassing.
That's saying something for Wyatt; he's been victim to seriously awful booking repeatedly, but draping a torn bed sheet over his head and putting on a creepy old lady voice was a real low point. Christ knows how Bálor managed to keep a straight face throughout this one - to that point, Bray himself deserves a pat on the back for not corpsing.
The good news is that Wyatt's creativity wasn't killed stone dead here. He drifted along doing nothing of note before repackaging himself as a creepy children's TV host with a 'Fiend' for an alter ego. There have been missteps there too, of course, but nothing quite as bad as this.
7. Sheamus
Arguably, 'King' Corbin works. No, it's not ideal, and the phoney royalty gag is wearing thin in 2020, but he's giving it a right good go. Compared to recent predecessors like Wade Barrett and Sheamus, Corbin is doing alright, and he can easily work the gimmick for another few years.
Sheamus couldn't. His run as 'King' was sh*te.
What should've been a career-enhancing tournament win in 2010 ended up being the Irishman's worst nightmare. As soon as he won King Of The Ring, Sheamus was asked to wear the worst Halloween costume in living memory. Honestly, he looked like a total fool dressed up like a B-movie reject and banging on about his ancestors.
Thankfully, even WWE realised that the whole episode was a blight on the guy's run and scrapped it so he could turn face the next summer. Sheamus has gone on to become a respected veteran in company circles, and he deserved a medal for surviving this garbage.
6. Batista
Batista went from carrying a donations box around to headlining WrestleMania in less than three years. That, regardless of what anyone says, is a minor miracle. The 'Deacon' gimmick he played as backup to Reverend D-Von was one of those ideas that should've been binned from the start.
Not only was the character flimsy, but WWE covered up Batista's impressive physique. This was one of the least Vince McMahon things Vinnie Mac has ever done, and he probably regrets sticking a sleeveless suit on Dave and asking him to follow D-Von Dudley around. This wasn't exactly a hot start for the future World Champ.
It wasn't even tepid.
Such a crap religious gimmick could've consigned Batista to the same bargain bin as Luther Reigns, Mason Ryan or Jackson Andrews (if you remember him). Instead, he survived, went on to slot neatly into Evolution and became a bonafide headliner.
5. Steve Austin
You might be asking yourself how being handed Ted DiBiase as manager and the Million Dollar Title could be considered awful. If it was anyone other than Steve Austin, you might be right. Unfortunately for staunch 'New Generation' defenders everywhere, this was a load of old nonsense and should never have happened.
'The Ringmaster' sucked, and Austin knew it.
He had signed with the notoriously over-the-top WWF, and here they were asking him to play a mechanically-sound wrestler between the ropes. Austin was nothing flashy, the announcers claimed, but he knew how to out-wrestle his opponents. That was a death sentence in mid-90s WWF.
Being cast as a boots n' tights journeyman pro did nothing for Austin, so he worked hard to get himself out of the gimmick and into something more satisfying. He'd go on to become the biggest star in the entire industry as 'Stone Cold', thus proving that nobody with that amount of talent should settle for mediocrity.
4. Kane
At least Steve Austin didn't have to cosplay as someone else's gimmick.
Kane wasn't so fortunate. In 1996, he was cast as "Diesel" (the inverted commas are important) even though the real deal had vanished to WCW. Whilst Kevin Nash was smashing it as part of the ultra-cool nWo faction there, poor Glenn Jacobs had to play 'Big Daddy Fool' in the WWF.
Nobody bought it, and things were made even worse by Rick Bognar's attempt at playing Scott Hall's Razor Ramon character. Fans were outraged that the company thought they'd be so stupid to stomach wrestlers playing dress-up, and the resultant apathy for "Razor" and "Diesel" forced the WWF to abandon the project.
That could've been it for Jacobs. He'd already been a fake dentist and a fake Diesel, so there were no guarantees the WWF would have anything else in the pipeline for him. They did - he went on to play Kane, a character so popular it turned Jacobs into a legend.
3. Mark Henry
When Mark Henry embarked on his memorable 'Hall Of Pain' run and bagged the World Heavyweight Title, yours truly shed a metaphorical tear. He'd watched poor Mark struggle through some of the worst ideas ever, including a run as Mae Young's boyfriend and one admission that he'd slept with his own sister.
Wait, what's that?
It's true. Between 1998-1999, the WWF showed Henry fessing up to the fact that he was addicted to sex. Things were so bad that he'd even had coitus with his own flesh and blood the "day before yesterday". Then, Mark went on to reveal he had a thing for the ancient Mae and somehow impregnated her with a human hand.
Going from all that to his bully-boy dominance as World Champ was night and day. Henry finally found his place on the roster as a physically imposing, intense bad ass who loved to throw his weight around and intimidate others. He didn't just survive - he thrived.
2. Natalya
Farting is hilarious.
Just ask Vince McMahon. The WWE boss will bust out his trademark, "Nyuk-nyuk-nyuk" laugh, slap you on the back and agree that toilet humour is where it's at. After all, who doesn't love the social awkwardness that comes with someone who can't hold in gas and releases it during the most inopportune situations?
Natalya, that's who. When grilled about her career someday, Nattie is unlikely to remark that passing wind during backstage skits with Beth Phoenix, Eve Torres, Teddy Long, Hornswoggle and others was a highlight of her run. It's not gonna' be up there with breaking new ground in Saudi Arabia with Lacey Evans or winning titles, let's be honest.
The Canadian's 2012 embarrassment is almost forgotten now. In the eight years since, she's become a mother-like figure of the female ranks and an important cog in the women's movement machine. Working with Natalya is like a WWE rite of passage for many young stars, and it's a role she takes seriously.
Someday, Nattie's book must be called, "From Farting To Hart-ing".
1. Kurt Angle
In 2005, wrestling machine and all-round entertainment wizard Kurt Angle turned into a stalkery sex pest who wanted "beastiality sex" with Booker T's wife Sharmell. The Olympian even alleged to Booker that Sharmell had "fondled my private parts" when he accosted her in the couple's dressing room during a pay-per-view.
Yeah.
This storyline was not a good look for WWE, Angle or anyone else. It was the kind of tale that made fans feel awkward about showing buddies what they'd been watching, and it did nothing to sell Kurt as a heel people should take seriously. The "beastiality" bit, in particular, was all rather unnerving.
How did Angle bounce back from this? By being one of the best pro wrestlers on the planet, really. He left WWE the next year, jumped to TNA and proved all over again why he was such a cherished worker inside the ring. Matches with AJ Styles, Samoa Joe and others showed the best side of Kurt.
He didn't even have to try and shag their wives to prove his alpha male status. Win-win.
What other WWE stars survived seriously rotten booking? For more like this, check out 10 Wrestling Stories That Blurred Reality and 10 Times WWE Tried The Same Failure TWICE!